Thursday, November 19, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2501

Former Bear Explains Why Matt Nagy Will Fail as Head Coach

matt nagy

It seems the shine is off the apple for Matt Nagy now. After going 12-4 his first year, the young Chicago Bears head coach is under the gun more than ever in 2019. Not only is his team 3-4, but his vaunted offense is also among the worst in the NFL in both yards gained and points scored. Worst of all, his quarterback has regressed badly. Mitch Trubisky looks every bit as lost and ineffective as a passer as he did as a rookie. He still doesn’t read defenses well and even worse has stopped using his legs to make plays.

Plenty of fans have lost their faith in Nagy and it seems some former Bears players have too. One of them is Dennis McKinnon. The longtime wide receiver has never been shy about sharing his opinion about anything related to the team. In fact, he just released a tell-all book called “Silky D Bares All” where he fires a number of shots at former colleagues. This includes accusing Mike Ditka of placing a bet on William Perry to score a TD in the Super Bowl.

His comments didn’t let Nagy off the hook either. He once likened the young coach to Joe Maddon. Someone who is a bit too chummy with his players. So one shouldn’t be surprised that McKinnon didn’t hold back on McNeil & Parkins on 670 The Score when asked for his assessment of the Bears coach.

“Nagy has been exposed. Just because you were in the Andy Reid system in Kansas City and Andy Reid is a genius doesn’t make you a genius because you were on the same coaching staff.”

Matt Nagy offense isn’t fooling anybody to him

McKinnon also called Nagy’s offense nothing but “smoke and mirrors.” He’s not fooling anybody. If he can determine what the Bears offense is doing each snap, then the opposition absolutely can as well. His quarterback not being able to read defenses only makes matters worse. If Nagy wants to salvage this offense he needs to “run the god damn ball” with David Montgomery. The Bears traded up to get this guy. He’s a rookie. He should get fed until he can’t go anymore.

Suffice to say McKinnon is not in the Nagy Fan Club. He doesn’t feel the head coach has the ability to discipline his players enough to correct their ongoing mistakes or adjust the offense properly to conceal how ineffective his quarterback is. Does this mean he will ultimately be a failure? Not necessarily. Nagy has already begun to adjust the offense away from Trubisky and is definitely a leader of men. That was never in question.

Might things be different if he had a slightly more capable quarterback? This is the question that remains unanswered.

REPORT: Two Cubs Coaches Will Leave To Join Joe Maddon With Angels

A few more coaching changes have been confirmed for the Cubs, as 670 The Score’s Bruce Levine has reported that Brian Butterfield and Tim Buss will leave to join Joe Maddon with the Angels.

Butterfield was hired as the Cubs third base coach to begin the 2018 season. Before coming to Chicago he was Boston’s third base coach from 2013-17. Butterfield began his coaching career back in 1979 in college, before joining the Yankees organization. He’s managed in the minors and has coached on five MLB teams since the mid-90s.

While Tim Buss was mostly working behind the scenes with the Cubs as their strength and conditioning coach, he had a great relationship with the players and has one hell of a personality.

Wonder if Buss will leave the speedo behind for the next Cubs strength and conditioning coach.

The Cubs are also reportedly looking to add a veteran bench coach to put next to David Ross and with Butterfield off to Anaheim you could see current bench coach Mark Loretta moved to third base coach in 2020.

Former Blue Jays and Red Sox manager John Farrell is expected to be a candidate to join Ross’ coaching staff next season.

So, the Cubs will have at least a new manager, third base coach, bench coach and strength and conditioning coach in 2020.

And here’s a little more on the change to the strength and conditioning program for the Cubs going forward.

White Sox Free Agents: Who To Re-Sign, Who To Say Goodbye For Good

Jose Abreu, White Sox

On the first day of the offseason for all 30 MLB teams the White Sox made a few roster moves, doing some housekeeping on their 40-man roster and saving $500k by trading away catcher Welington Castillo.

Thursday was also the official start of free agency, as 131 players across the league declared for free agency. That included five White Sox players, headlined by José Abreu.

I’d like to imagine players declare for free agency just like Michael Scott declared for bankruptcy.

Out of the five White Sox players to hit the open market Abreu is really the only one who the team and fans should want to re-sign. After spending the first six years of his MLB career with the White Sox, Abreu has made it pretty clear that he intends to re-sign on the South Side.

Back in August, White Sox owner Jerry Reinsdorf pretty much guaranteed that Abreu would finish his career with the White Sox.

Despite being on pace to put up some of the worst numbers of his career through early August, Abreu finished 2019 strong, hitting 33 home runs and a career best 123 RBIs.

The 32-year-old made $16 million in 2019, a raise from the $13 million he earned in 2018.

As far as Ross Detwiler, Hector Santiago, Jon Jay and Ivan Nova, goodbye! The White Sox have plenty of money to spend this offseason and that should include making big upgrades to their pitching staff and outfield. No need for placeholders anymore, especially if the White Sox are serious about contending in 2020.

Sportsbook Felt So Bad For People Who Bet On Mitch Trubisky To Win MVP That They’re Refunding Bettors

chicago bears

Back in the summer, when Bears fans could still be optimistic about the team being Super Bowl contenders, people all across the country were betting on Mitch Trubisky to win MVP. His odds were as low as 200-1 to 100-1. Basically, for every dollar you bet you’d get $200 or $100 back depending on where you placed your bet on Trubisky to win MVP.

Now, seven games into the season Trubisky’s MVP odds have dramatically fallen, comparable to other quarterbacks who are currently benched. Sadly, the odds are probably 10 times better that Trubisky is benched this season than him winning the MVP award.

One sportsbook feels so bad for people who bet on Trubisky to win MVP that they’re refunding money.

Hey, at least someone has some pity for Bears fans. I mean, it had to have been mostly Bears fans betting on Trubisky.

Why Ryan Pace Shouldn’t Be Judged Solely By the Trubisky Pick

ryan pace

Let’s just get this out of the way. Ryan Pace messed up. He had a chance to finally end the Chicago Bears’ ongoing curse at quarterback in 2017 and he blew it. He had his choice of three notable quarterbacks and somehow managed to pick the wrong one in Mitch Trubisky. While he continues to flounder, Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson thrive. Seeing this unfold before the eyes, it’s hard for a lot of Bears fans to forgive him. Pace gave up four picks including the #2 overall for Trubisky.

He blew it.

That is a major stain on his reputation. To say nothing of his other 1st round misfires like Kevin White and to a lesser extent Leonard Floyd. Some believe this is enough to warrant Pace losing his job. Why should the team trust him to get the quarterback position right after missing so spectacularly? It’s a fair point, but also a dangerous way of thinking. This will be an attempt to explain that in spite of his missteps, he’s still a good GM and one deserving of another shot.

Ryan Pace continues to prove he can draft well

Most of the focus has remained on Trubisky. That’s no surprise. However, amidst the headaches he and Floyd are causing, plenty of other Pace draft picks have begun to assert themselves in recent weeks. Top 2019 pick David Montgomery delivered his best game of the year against the Chargers with 135 rushing yards and a touchdown. Anthony Miller has 12 catches for 183 yards in the past three games.

Roquan Smith was all over the field last week, making seven tackles in just 40 total snaps. Even Bilal Nichols, on his first game back from injury against the Saints had a tackle for a loss and a quarterback hit. This is proof enough that they haven’t suddenly stopped being good players.

The same goes for Pace’s free agent moves. Allen Robinson is a star at wide receiver, on track for over 1,000 yards this season. Cordarrelle Patterson is averaging a ridiculous 32.1 yards per kick return with a touchdown. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix has two interceptions including a pick-six. Buster Skrine has filled the slot corner job very well. Taylor Gabriel had a great game in Washington and has been open a lot.

It’s not like Pace is making nothing but wrong decisions.

This is still a good football team with a lot of talent on the roster. The problem is so much of it is overshadowed by two of his three biggest draft picks. As anybody knows, missing on a quarterback can set an organization back years. This is often why a lot of GMs lose their jobs. Does Pace warrant the same treatment? No. He’s proven he can run an organization well and find talented players.

The question is whether he can deliver on another attempt at quarterback. History does show this is not impossible. Jim Finks, the best in Bears history, missed horrifically at QB when he traded a 1st round pick for Mike Phipps back in 1978. Undeterred he awaited his next opportunity and it came in 1982 when he secured Jim McMahon. That worked out pretty well.

Pace has done enough to deserve that same courtesy.

Starling Marte, A Great Solution To Cubs’ CF Problem

The Pittsburgh Pirates don’t have a GM right now, but the writing is on the wall. They’re going to rebuild. Since Jake Arrieta slashed any championship aspirations by the Pirates in 2015, Pittsburgh has only been above .500 once and hasn’t returned to the postseason.

After the 2019 season, the Pirates fired manager Clint Hurdle and earlier this week GM Neal Huntington was dismissed as well. The Pirates also parted ways with team president Frank Coonelly earlier in October.

So, the Pirates are expected to start over and while they will have almost every player available this offseason there’s one guy who is a perfect fit for the Cubs.

Starling Marte.

Center field has turned out to be a tough position to fill for the Cubs since Dexter Fowler signed with the Cardinals after 2016. Albert Almora Jr. hasn’t been the answer, and while Ian Happ might be an OK option, the Cubs are focused on diversifying their offense and he could very well be a player who’s traded away this offseason.

When you take a look at the free agent market there aren’t many good options that would drastically upgrade the Cubs. The best available center fielder is Japanese free agent Shogo Akiyama, who the Cubs have reportedly been scouting.

However, if the Cubs come up empty in free agency, then Jason Heyward will once again be slotted in at center. That is unless the Cubs can work out a trade with the Pirates for Marte.

There are plenty of reasons the Cubs should be interested in a deal for the 31-year-old center field. Marte plays solid defense, runs the bases well, has struck out less than 19% in the last three seasons and has a career 116 wRC+. The right-handed hitter has two more years of control at $11.5 million in 2020 and $12.5 million in 2021.

In 2019, Marte slashed .295/.342/.503, with 23 home runs, 31 doubles and six triples. He’d be a big upgrade to the Cubs’ outfield and it’s easy to see why they could be interested.

MLB.com reporter Matt Kelly has also brought up the Cubs as a team that might be interested in pursuing a trade for Marte.

Via MLB.com.

But the closing of the Pirates’ most competitive window in decades brings an opportunity to invest in their next window. Specifically: Now might be the time to shop center fielder Starling Marte.

Cubs: Chicago began benching Albert Almora Jr. down the stretch, signaling it might not believe that his bat will catch up to his glove. The Cubs are still near the top of their competitive bell curve, and have several current big leaguers (Almora, David Bote, Ian Happ and Addison Russell, to name a few) who could yield a decent return for Pittsburgh.

Ahh, the offseason is officially here. Let the speculation and rumors power us through the winter.

Ben Zobrist…Back To The Cubs In 2020?

PHOTO: Chicago Tribune

Ben Zobrist spent most of the 2019 season away from baseball, dealing with family issues and it’s fair to say that most fans assumed the 38-year-old would call it a career after playing in 14 MLB seasons. The switch-hitting, two-time World Series winner is now a free agent, but it doesn’t sound like Zobrist is ready to retire just yet.

If Zobrist does indeed plan on continuing his playing days in 2020, should the Cubs try and re-sign him?

As always, it’s about the money, but for Zobrist it may also depend where he’s closest to his children.

In 2019, Zobrist only appeared in 47 games for the Cubs, slashed .260/.358/.313, with one home run all season. I know what you’re thinking. He’s not getting any younger and his versatility on defense isn’t necessarily a plus anymore. Time to move on.

However, Zobrist still makes contact, knows the strike zone as well as anyone else and he’s just one season removed from having a .378 OBP. It shouldn’t cost the Cubs or any team more than a few million dollars to sign him in the offseason. For a veteran hitter who still gets on base? I think it’s worth it.

We’re not talking about Zobrist being the starting second baseman, but as a bench guy? Seems like a low-risk move for the Cubs. But we’re a long way from things actually happening, so stay tuned.

REPORT: Ex-Red Sox Manager Will Be Candidate To Join Cubs Coaching Staff

David Ross officially became the newest Cubs manager on Monday and although there weren’t any groundbreaking takeaways from his introductory press conference we did learn that the team wants a veteran coach next to the first-time manager.

By all accounts Ross will be the one deciding who’s on his coaching staff in 2020 and the biggest change will most likely be the bench coach. Mark Loretta, who was an assistant for nearly a decade in the Padres’ front office, spent 2019 as Joe Maddon’s bench coach. It was Loretta’s first MLB coaching job.

The Cubs want some more experience in the dugout and it’s not really that difficult to make connections on who may be considered to join the coaching staff next season. I wrote about John Farrell, Fredi González and Jim Riggleman being good options, as they’ve all crossed paths with Ross during his playing career.

And guess what? Ex-Red Sox manager John Farrell is expected to be a candidate to join the Cubs this offseason.

Farrell managed the Red Sox from 2013-17 and was a part of Boston’s coaching staff from 2007-10, when Theo Epstein was still there. Farrell also managed the Blue Jays for a couple seasons and has spent the past two years working in the Reds’ scouting department.

Bruce Levine also said that at this point it’s unclear if Will Venable and Brian Butterfield will come back as Cubs coaches next year. Levine also mentioned Fredi González and Jim Riggleman as potential options for the Cubs.

Joe Maddon Wants Everyone To Know That He Didn’t Want To Be Back With The Cubs Either

CHICAGO, IL - NOVEMBER 04: Manager Joe Maddon of the Chicago Cubs holds the World Series trophy during the Chicago Cubs victory celebration in Grant Park on November 4, 2016 in Chicago, Illinois. The Cubs won their first World Series championship in 108 years after defeating the Cleveland Indians 8-7 in Game 7. (Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)

So, after the Cubs let everyone know that Joe Maddon wasn’t going to return as the manager in 2020, both sides painted the breakup as a mutual decision. A win-win for both sides. Yet, in a recent interview with Marc Topkin of the Tampa Bay Times, Maddon wanted to make it pretty clear that the decision not to return to Chicago was as much his choice as it was the Cubs.

Via the Tampa Bay Times.

“I didn’t know how the end of the season with the Cubs was going to work out either. Everyone thinks they knew, but they didn’t, and I didn’t either. When it got down to the last couple days it was really obvious to both sides. I didn’t want to be back either. It was more of a bilateral than a unilateral decision.’’

And it’s not like things ended on bad terms between Maddon and the Cubs front office. Despite the failures of the past two seasons, Theo Epstein had nothing but praise for the future hall of fame manager. However, maybe the recent comments about the Cubs wanting more accountability from their new manager got under the skin of Maddon, who shrugged off those comments, but still sounds a tiny bit bitter of how things ended.

But again, it’s mostly all love from Maddon, who dreams of a World Series matchup between his Angels and the Cubs and he’s more than elated about David Ross being the new manager on the North Side.

On the Cubs hiring David Ross to replace him, and all the current talk of needed accountability:
“I love that David’s there. I spoke with him the night before his press conference and we had a great conversation. All these other semantics and descriptions, I don’t necessarily agree with all that. We’ll see how it all works out. But I’m really into David being really successful.”

So, as the 2019 MLB season is officially over, a new era has begun with the Cubs and for many of the players that means a different manager for the first time in their big league careers. Maddon said he received a lot of messages from Cubs players following the season.

“I love a lot of the players there. I’ve got more thought- provoking, tear-provoking outreach from some (Cubs players) at the end of this season than I’ve ever gotten before.’’

You can read the full interview here, where Maddon also talks about his restaurant in Chicago. Apparently, it’s not doing as well as his other locations.

A Final Goodbye To The 2019 Cubs By Remembering Guys You Forgot Played For Them

I was thinking about this a few days after the regular season ended and despite having a pretty decent memory I completely forgot about some of these guys playing for the 2019 Cubs. Even when I did remember Carlos González, I couldn’t even correctly remember one of his two biggest plays with the Cubs.

Indeed, CarGo did play in 15 games for the Cubs in June and his very first highlight was this nice catch against the Angels.

Unfortunately, he wasn’t the spark the Cubs were hoping for as the former All-Star only hit .175 in 40 at-bats before he was let go at the end of June.

And hey, remember when catcher Martin Maldonado was with the Cubs for two weeks in July? He was acquired after Willson Contreras went down with a foot injury, but only played in four games. Maldonado’s mostly going to be remember for being traded to the Astros for Tony Kemp that allowed the Cubs to have enough money in their budget to trade for Nick Castellanos. Thanks for the memories, Martin.

Poor Mark Zagunis. He was a surprise addition to the Cubs Opening Day roster and he was even in the starting lineup in the first game of the year against the Rangers. However, after a disastrous game playing in the outfield against the Braves in early April, Zagunis was relegated to a bench role and only started one more game until the Cubs sent him back to Triple-A in late May. He went 9-for-36 at the plate, briefly called up in August for one game before being sent back down to the minors.

I was going to include Taylor Davis in here, but man, who can forget his grand slam against the Cardinals.

Back in spring training I had high hopes for right-hander Tony Barnette. But he dealt with an injury and slowly worked his way back and was called up in June. Yet, the right-hander only pitched in two games and in July he was placed on the restricted list as he was mulling over his future playing career.

Barnette wasn’t the only forgettable free agent reliever for the 2019 Cubs. Left-hander Xavier Cedeno was brought in to be a solid lefty out of the bullpen, but he also dealt with injuries and only threw two innings in five appearances.

And a few more guys.

  • Brad Brach was the Cubs big offseason free agent signing for the bullpen. 6.13 ERA in 39.2 innings. DFA’d in August. LMAO
  • Randy Rosario….sigh.
  • Allen Webster looked really good in the minors and then was bad with the Cubs.
  • Jim Adduci was the Cubs starting right fielder on May 27 against the Astros. He was up for a week and never heard of again. No, you don’t remember Jim Adduci.