Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2421

Bears Mailbag — Would Pat Shurmur Come To Chicago Without Play-Calling Duties?

chicago bears
Dec 2, 2018; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Matt Nagy, left, and New York Giants head coach Pat Shurmur, right, greet each other prior to the game at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Robert Deutsch-USA TODAY Sports

It’s the season of change in the NFL. Teams that didn’t make the postseason have begun to address deficiencies and gaps that they feel, once upgraded, will bring them back to contending for the playoffs in 2020. The Chicago Bears are no exception.

After their season-ending press conference last week (New Year’s Eve), I shared my thoughts on what was said, what was implied, and what might happen next.

Alas, not an hour after I published that article, Adam Hoge of WGN Radio reported that the Bears had fired OC Mark Helfrich, OL coach Harry Hiestand, TE coach Kevin Gilbride, and Assistant ST coach Brock Olivo.

A few days later, the Bears began to address those gaps on the coaching staff. The first hire? Respected OL coach Juan Castillo.

The Bears have plenty of moves left to make, both on the coaching staff (who will be the OC?) and on the personnel side once the legal tampering window opens. It figures to be a wild ride.

With that, I reach into the first offseason Bears Mailbag of 2020. Thanks to everyone who submitted questions. I always appreciate the participation! Follow me on Twitter @DhruvKoul to continue the conversation.

Mailbag

An offensive coordinator has many responsibilities. They help design scheme/plays, they help put together the game plan for each weekly opponent, they prepare the offense for each game, and some of them call plays. Last year, in Chicago, Mark Helfrich had all of the regular OC responsibilities, except for calling plays. That was reserved for Matt Nagy (and it’s a good thing it was — he was largely excellent.)

Pat Shurmur is one of the most respected offensive minds in the game, and has proven success at multiple stops in his career. He was the OC under Chip Kelly in Philadelphia, he helped take Case Keenum and the Vikings to the NFC Championship game (while helping solidify their running game), and masked the atrociousness of Daniel Jones to the point where people think he’s actually a good QB. That’s impressive work.

Shurmur and Matt Nagy have worked together in the past, and an opportunity to work together would certainly appeal to Shurmur. It’s quite possible that Nagy would have to give up play calling for that to happen, and while Nagy is an excellent play designer and good play caller, the opportunity to bring in someone well respected like Shurmur would be a great get for the coaching staff.

As far as the likelihood of him joining the staff, it seems that there’s a better chance than we think. Jeff Hughes of Da Bears Blog indicates that it’s quite a possibility. He has very good information and has broken intriguing stories such as the Harry Hiestand hiring, Mark Helfrich’s hiring, the Juan Castillo hiring, etc. He doesn’t mess around when it comes to information. Bears fans should be optimistic.

If I was a betting man, I would wager that Taylor Gabriel isn’t on the roster next year — either traded or released. He has trade value, so it’s not inconceivable to think the Bears could get a draft pick out of him. But if push comes to shove, I can’t imagine a scenario where he’s back.

He missed a good bit of the season with a concussion, and the Bears didn’t lack playmakers at wide receiver (when Mitch Trubisky could actually get them the ball.) Anthony Miller, Javon Wims, and even Riley Ridley all stepped up at times. Of course, Allen Robinson held down the WR1 fort.

Gabriel did not perform well when he did play this year, routinely dropping catchable balls and showing his visible frustration on the field. It’s clear that he was getting fed up with Trubisky’s poor play this year — that kind of attitude, while understandable, is not acceptable. It’s hard to justify keeping Gabriel another year given the attitude and production regression. So I think he ends up off the roster.

A few of the seemingly obvious cuts (if trades don’t happen) include: Prince Amukamara, Taylor Gabriel, and Bobby Massie (post-June 1 for maximum savings). Kyle Long’s retirement will already save the Bears roughly $8M or so in cap space. The Bears don’t have a lot of cap space to begin with, and these cuts are necessary to give them some breathing room. I wouldn’t be surprised if they agreed to extensions with a few players to reduce 2019 cap hits as well (think Allen Robinson and even Leonard Floyd.) (Eddie Jackson’s extension is already doing the Bears favors in 2020.)

As far as bringing in quarterbacks, my guess is the Bears will bring in at least one veteran to compete with Trubisky, and possibly even draft one (whether it be using a 2nd round pick or a later round pick, depending on how the board falls.)

From a veteran perspective, I like the following names: Tom Brady, Marcus Mariota, Andy Dalton, Ryan Fitzpatrick, and Case Keenum.

From a draft perspective, the Bears could be looking at these names at various points in the draft: Jake Fromm, Shea Patterson, Anthony Gordon, Nate Stanley, and Jordan Love.

The free agent tight end market can be narrowed down to: Hunter Henry, Austin Hooper, and Eric Ebron. While each can bring their own set of skills, it feels like all three will cost more than they’re worth to the Bears. I would imagine the Bears address this position in the draft — perhaps someone like Brycen Hopkins (Purdue) or Cole Kmet (Notre Dame) could be available for Chicago in the second round. They’d be great fits.

Offensive line is another position that I think the Bears will address at some point in the draft, but I’ve always thought that big money (apart from the right QB) should be spent in the trenches. The Bears have big question marks to address in the trenches (RG and EDGE, namely), so I’d imagine the Bears pick one of those positions to pay heavily. I’d imagine the majority of the money goes to EDGE. But a couple free agents that could be interesting to Chicago on the OL are Brandon Scherff and Graham Glasgow.

Nagy is an outstanding head coach. He went 12-4 last year and managed to get this team to 8-8 despite: a 3-5 start, followed by 4-6, and some of the worst QB play this city has seen in some time. It’s a testament to Nagy and the coaching staff that they didn’t let the team completely unravel after the four game losing streak (OAK, NO, LAC, PHI.)

I was going to write something in-depth about how I think Nagy should NOT give up play-calling (I think he’s been absolutely excellent overall.) But I’ll ask you to read this article from Bobby Peters instead. It’s outstanding work and I agree with everything written in there.

Twitter Responses

And now, a few questions and answers posted directly on Twitter…

Recapping Blackhawks’ Prospect Michal Teply’s World Juniors

The Blackhawks 2019 fourth-round pick tallied five assists in five games for the Czech Republic.

With the 2020 IIHF U20 World Junior Championship concluding on Sunday, now is a perfect time to check up on the Chicago Blackhawks 18-year-old prospect, Michal Teply. Teply played wing for the Czech Republic and was their leading scorer to help secure a seventh-place finish.

A quick flashback on Teply’s year, the Havlickuv Brod, CZE native is in his first season of junior hockey with the Winnipeg Ice of the WHL. Teply is averaging just over a point-per-game with 30 points (13G, 17A) in 29 games, which ranks third on the team.

Game 1- 12/26/19 vs. Russia

Teply opened the World Juniors with a strong showing, as he registered three primary assists in the Czech Republic’s 4-3 victory over Russia. The 6-foot-3, 192-pound forward failed to record a shot on goal but was heavily involved in his team’s success. Teply skated with the first line alongside Matej Pekar (Sabres) and Jan Jenik (Coyotes).

The Czech Republic opened the scoring on the powerplay as Teply set up Simon Kubicek at the point for a power-play goal.

Teply recorded his second primary assist on a quick play in transition, and then picked up a third on the eventual game-winning goal late in the second period.

Not only did Teply excel offensively, but he did his part on the Czech Republic’s penalty kill as well.

The only negative takeaway from the opening contest for Teply was his lack of coverage on the Russian’s third goal to tie the score.

Game 2- 12/28/19 vs. Germany

After an impressive first showing, Teply remained on the Czech Republic’s top line with Pekar and Jenik against the Germans. The right-handed winger finished with 0 points and four shots on goal in 22:29 in the 4-3 loss.

Teply’s best chance of the game came in the third period on a near-breakaway opportunity. He was able to fire a shot on net, but it was stopped by the German netminder’s blocker.

Game 3- 12/30/19 vs. USA

Unlike the first two games, Teply skated with the Czech Republic’s second line in the 4-3 OT loss to the United States. He recorded his fourth assist of the tournament, while also leading both teams with six shots on goal in 22:27.

Teply’s assist came on Libor Zabransky’s power-play goal to give the Czech a 2-1 lead late in the first period.

Teply also helped set up the game-tying goal in the third period to force overtime but was not credited with an assist.

The Czech Republic ended up losing in overtime, which was because of Teply’s lackluster defense. He got caught puck watching and left his man, Alex Turcotte (Kings), wide-open to set up Cole Caufield (Canadiens) for the game-winner.

Game 4- 12/31/19 vs. Canada

Teply picked up his fifth assist of the World Juniors on the Czech Republic’s opening goal to make it 4-1 Canada. He moved the puck to Simon Kubicek at the point, and Vojtech Strondala tapped home the rebound in front for a power-play goal.

Teply finished the game with two shots on goal and a -1 rating in 18:25.

Game 5- 1/2/20 vs. Sweden

The Czech Republic was shutout 5-0 against Sweden, so Teply obviously failed to record a point. Teply’s final stat line credited him with two shots on goal and a -2 rating in 16:24.

Teply’s best chance of the game came on a 2-on-1 rush that was stopped by Swedish goaltender Hugo Alnefelt.

Teply finished the World Juniors with five points (all assists) to lead the Czech Republic in scoring. The Blackhawks’ prospect was named one of the team’s best three players of the tournament by the coaches.

For more Blackhawks news and updates, follow the author (@JackBushman2) on Twitter. Make sure to check out the author’s podcast, Talkin’ Hawkey, which can be found on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Twitter (@TalkinHawkey).

Jay Cutler Once Delivered A Trash Talk Fatality on Willie Young

jay cutler

These days most Chicago Bears fans have fond memories of defensive end Willie Young. One could argue he was one of the best free agents the team signed in the 2010s. Not so much because he became a star but more because they got great production out of him for relatively cheap. Basically 24 sacks for $9 million. However, he wasn’t always a friend of this team. For four years to start his NFL career, he was busy trying to sack Jay Cutler with the Detroit Lions.

According to former wide receiver Earl Bennett, it wasn’t so much Young’s play that first drew the Bears’ attention during those years. It was his mouth. The defensive end was apparently quite the trash talker. He didn’t fear yapping every single play. It was here that Bennett told an incredible story of how the normally reserved Cutler decided he’d heard enough from Young and absolutely scorched him with a reply.

“Willie Young was in his second year with the Detroit Lions when he began talking trash to Cutler. After a bad first start we took the field and Young was yapping, at that point in his career we were all trying to figure out who the yapper even was. Cutler asked us in the huddle who is number 79? No one knew.

We break the huddle and get to the line of scrimmage and 79 is still yapping. Before the play was called you hear Cutler say ‘Hey 79, could you turn around so we can know who you are because we are fucking clueless you no name.’ A subtle, but yet dagger remark.”

Jay Cutler was and always has been a low key savage

This story only adds to the legend of Cutler at this point. He’s had a reputation going back years for being able to deliver some sharp barbs at both opponents and teammates when the situation called for it. The game in reference was a showdown in Detroit in 2011. The Bears quarterback had a solid outing with 249 yards and a touchdown. However, Young had the final say in a 24-13 Lions victory. He wasn’t allowed to bask in that glory for too long though.

A few weeks later the Bears got their revenge, humiliating Detroit 37-13 at Soldier Field. So it’s clear both sides had their opportunities to gloat. If nothing else, this relationship no doubt led to Young developing a weird fondness for Cutler, resulting in his decision to join the Bears a few years later. Either that or got tired of taking the quarterback’s ruthless insults.

This Charles Leno Music Video is All Sorts of Savage

charles leno

Charles Leno Jr. has endured one of the wildest career swings a Chicago Bears left tackle has ever had. In 2018, he delivered his best season with a Pro Bowl nod and career-low six penalties surrendered along with being one of their best run blockers. He was also reliable in pass protection. It seems everything changed rapidly for him this year. Not only did he commit the fourth-most penalties of any player in the NFL with 13, his pass protection was leaky all year long.

One person who was on Leno’s case that entire time was Phil Ottochian, a member of the popular Bears Barroom Radio Network. He produced a weekly YouTube video series called “The Tape Never Lies” covering every Bears game of 2019. One of his constant punching bags was Leno for repeated mistakes that cost the team valuable opportunities. The animosity reached such an extent that Ottochian and his colleagues created a music video about the Bears left tackle.

Suffice to say? It’s not exactly kind.

2-Year-Old Girl Struck By Foul Ball During Cubs-Astros Game Has Permanent Brain Damage

Sadly there’s another terrible update about the toddler who was struck by a foul ball during a Cubs-Astros game during the 2019 season. Back in June the family’s lawyer said the two-year-old girl suffered a skull fracture along with other brain trauma.

This week, attorney Richard Mithoff said the young girl has permanent brain damage.

Via the Houston Chronicle.

Attorney Richard Mithoff, who represents the child’s family, said the girl continues to receive anti-seizure medication more than seven months after she was struck by a line drive off the bat of Chicago Cubs player Albert Almora at Minute Maid Park.
“She (the child) has an injury to a part of the brain, and it is permanent,” Mithoff said. “She remains subject to seizures and is on medication and will be, perhaps, for the rest of her life. That may or may not be resolved.”

The brain damage has affected the child’s central nervous system the same way a stroke would.

Doctors and the child’s parents say other results of the injury include staring spells, periods of unresponsiveness, night terrors and frequent headaches.
Mithoff said doctors have been unable to determine if the child, who turned 2 years old in May, has cognitive deficits as a result of the brain injury and skull fracture. She was struck in the back of the head while sitting in her grandfather’s lap along the third-base line in the ballpark’s lower bowl.

Beginning this season all 30 MLB ballparks will have extended netting, with seven teams installing the protective netting all the way to the foul poles.

The Cubs have still not announced their specific plans for their extended netting at Wrigley Field for the 2020 season.

Who The Hell Is Brendon Clark?

Brendon Clark Notre Dame

As Notre Dame’s sophomore quarterback Phil Jurkovec has entered his name into the transfer portal, the question becomes, who the hell is Brendon Clark?

Jurkovec made the decision to transfer. So now, the Fighting Irish are left with signal caller Ian Book at the helm.

As long as Book stays healthy, there should be no issues but if he does not the Irish will have only two options on the roster.

One of them, an incoming freshmen named Drew Pyne who is riding a hot performance at the All-America Football showcase – the other is a currently finishing his freshmen season at Notre Dame.

Three Star / Pro-Style QB – Class of 2019

Clark is a state champion quarterback who played at Manchester High School, about 30 minutes southwest of Richmond, VA.

He compiled over 3,000 total yards and threw for 35 touchdowns to one interception in his 6A state championship run. On the ground he added another 17 touchdowns for a total of 52 touchdowns in his senior season. Pretty impressive.

Clark was only given three stars, but still ranked in the Top 15 players from the 2018 Virginia state class across ESPN, Rivals and 247sports and was rated between the 19th-21st PRO style quarterback nationally.

Pro Comparison?

At just under 6’2″ – Clark reminds me of Jacksonville Jaguars QB Gardner Minshew. He just has that sort of look to him, does he not?

Minshew was also a three star prospect and bounced around before finally landing at Washington State.

Minshew was from Brandon, MS.

Close enough.

NFL Exec Sees Marcus Mariota Signing With the Bears

marcus mariota
Aug 17, 2019; Nashville, TN, USA; Tennessee Titans quarterback Marcus Mariota (8) attempts a pass during the first half against the New England Patriots at Nissan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

The list of possible veteran quarterbacks the Chicago Bears could target in 2020 free agency is larger than usual. In addition to the usual journeyman types like Case Keenum, there will be a number of possible aging former stars such as Eli Manning, Philip Rivers, and even Tom Brady. Then there will be the former 1st round picks who haven’t quite lived up to the hype. This crowd involves Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota.

Mariota might be the most interesting of that group. He was benched midway through this past season in favor of Ryan Tannehill who proceeded to take the Tennessee Titans into the playoffs. Mariota’s run with the team is one long story of sadness, plagued with multiple coaching changes, inadequate offensive weapons and a general lack of direction. By the time the team started to get good, it was too late.

Now Mariota will be searching for a new opportunity elsewhere this March. According to Jeremy Fowler of ESPN, one executive believes Chicago makes all the sense in the world for him.

“I could see Chicago [for Mariota],” one exec said. “Ryan Pace wants to stick with Mitch [Trubisky], and this way Mariota can start games but isn’t a total replacement, leaving room for Trubisky to regain his confidence and play well.”

Marcus Mariota to the Bears is quite a debate

Make no mistake. The idea of Mariota coming to the Bears has been discussed at length and a lot of people are on the fence about it. Why would the team want to bring in a guy with a lot of the same concerns as Mitch Trubisky? Well, the price will certainly be appealing. Mariota will be cheap to get in comparison to other options. He might even take a discount if he feels he’s getting a legitimate shot to compete for the starting job.

The Bears do run an offensive system that is similar to what made him a success in college with lots of spread concepts and run-pass option. There is also the fact that Pace was enamored with Mariota back in 2015, sending out feelers to trade up to get him in the 1st round. Ultimately it didn’t happen. This would give the GM a second chance to do what he wanted to all those years ago.

On the flip side, it’s important to note that Trubisky and Mariota share the same agent. So both of them competing for the same job on the same roster would be a conflict of interest. So there is an argument for both sides. Mariota has a career 89.6 passer rating in 63 games. This with four different offensive coordinators and three different head coaches. Have we seen the real quarterback or somebody who’s been clearly mismanaged?

Maybe that is what the Bears will want to find out.

Notre Dame QB Enters Transfer Portal

To the surprise of some, it was reported earlier today that Phil Jurkovec has entered the transfer portal.

The news comes just a few days after fifth year eligible quarterback Ian Book announced his return to Notre Dame for the 2020 season.

Whether it was Book’s return, or the quarterback pipeline outlook for Notre Dame, there was enough pressure to push Jurkovec to transfer.

See: Who The Hell Is Phil Jurkovec?

The Irish will return Book and Brendon Clark for 2020, and welcome Pyne.

 

Javier Báez Is The Best Defensive Infielder In MLB According To New Metric

Stats, stats and even more stats. If you don’t like stats, then I’m not sure why you pay attention to baseball and if you’re a Cubs fan this is the only reliable defensive stat to go by until the end of time. Why? Well, it finally categorized Javier Báez as the best defensive infielder in MLB, which we all know is correct.

No, it’s not tags above replacement, but Statcast has a new defensive metric to measure just how good infielders are by tracking every single play they make and then assigning every play a score. Here’s what the Outs Above Average stat is based on.

Via MLB.com.

  • How far the fielder has to go to reach the ball (“the intercept point”)
  • How much time he has to get there
  • How far he then is from the base the runner is heading to
  • On force plays, how fast the batter is, on average

For example, this play below was considered to have a mere 10% chance of being converted into an out, since Carlos Correa had just 1.5 seconds to move 12 feet, then had to get the ball 147 feet to first base before Aaron Judge, who possesses above-average sprint speed (28.2 ft/sec), could get there. He did, so he adds +.90 towards his seasonal total of +9; if he’d missed it, it would have cost him just -.10.

And because Statcast tracks where a player is standing at all times regardless what position he is being listed as, OAA has the ability to determine things that other defensive metrics like DRS and UZR cannot.

As useful and effective as they’ve been over the years, DRS and UZR use either the eye test via video scouting or zone-based systems. The Statcast technology allows us to know exactly where each fielder stands, which is helpful in a baseball world where shifting and out-of-position defenders are commonplace.
What that means is that every tracked play is accounted for, regardless of if the third baseman is standing in his regular spot or at shortstop or in short right field. It allows you to know exactly “how far” and “how much time,” regardless of shifts.

So, in 2019, Báez led all of MLB infielders with a +19 OAA. You can see the leaderboard here.

You can take a more detailed look at Báez’s defensive breakdown here. These new metrics are spectacular because you get to see just how good a guy is going to his left, right, backing up or coming in on a ball. There are also graphics that show how much defensive value a player has based on where they begin on a play.

So yeah, a new intricate defensive metric and there’s also one for outfielders too!

Someone Is Lying About Nick Castellanos And The Rangers Which Is Good For The Cubs

This is peak free agency because we all know most of this stuff doesn’t mean shit, but we love to talk about it every day. Agents use reporters to spread their message and teams use other reporters to spread whatever they want to the public. And right now someone is definitely lying about Nick Castellanos and the Rangers.

So, during the past two weeks reports have pointed to the Rangers emerging as a finalist to sign Castellanos. Most recently, MLB.com’s Jon Morosi reported on Monday that Castellanos met with the Rangers and felt great about them. Jon Heyman also said this week that the Rangers are the most likely destination for Castellanos.

HOWEVA!

On Tuesday, a new report came out in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, saying that the Rangers do have some interest in Castellanos, but a source from the team said the Morosi report was false.

Via the Star-Telegram.

A club official rebuked a Money report that the Rangers met with free-agent outfielder Nick Castellanos and are a finalist to sign him. According to the official, the Rangers have not met with him, have not made him an offer and are not going to move Joey Gallo from right field to first base to accommodate Castellanos.

I mean, maybe the Rangers are lying, but c’mon, this screams of Scott Boras trying to inflate the market for his client. “Oh, not getting good enough offers, let’s say this team is being aggressive and that we love them to draw some other offers.”

If that’s the case, then Castellanos’ market hasn’t developed this offseason as he’d liked. Kind of obvious, as most of the top free agents have already signed. This just gives the Cubs exactly what they need if they really do want to re-sign Castellanos and that’s time.

As long as Castellanos doesn’t sign, the Cubs can figure out how to shed payroll or do whatever possible to find a fit for the right-handed hitter on their team, as their top priority for 2020 seems to be to stay under the luxury tax. But it’s kind of obvious that Castellanos still hasn’t found a big deal from other teams and we know that he’d prefer to stay with the Cubs.

Soooooooo, we wait. The more time that passes the better the chance the Cubs figure out how to get Castellanos back.