Wednesday, November 18, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 770

PFF Grades from the Colts Game: Breaking Down the Bears Defense

Sep 22, 2024; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Chicago Bears defensive end Montez Sweat (98) brings down Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor (28) on during a game against the Chicago Bears at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Grace Hollars USA TODAY Network via Imagn Images

Each week, Pro Football Focus evaluates every player on every team, offering some of the top football analytics available. This time, we’ll focus on the Bears defensive grades from their loss to the Indianapolis Colts.

Top overall grades

  1. Jack Sanborn, 87.1
  2. Kevin Byard, 83.5
  3. Austin Booker, 78.3
  4. Tremaine Edwards, 69.0
  5. Tyrique Stevenson, 67.1
  6. Jaylon Johnson, 66.3
  7. Chris Williams, 61.6
  8. Jaylon Jones, 60.0
  9. Gervon Dexter Sr, 59.0
  10. Jaquan Brisker, 51.2

Worst overall grades

  1. TJ Edwards, 29.9
  2. Byron Cowart, 42.8
  3. Kyler Gordon, 42.8
  4. Andrew Billings, 45.0
  5. Darrell Taylor, 48.2

Justin Fields Shares Thoughts on Caleb Williams Tough Start in Chicago

justin fields
Sep 15, 2024; Denver, Colorado, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Justin Fields (2) before a game against the Denver Broncos at Empower Field at Mile High. Mandatory Credit: Ron Chenoy-Imagn Images

Regardless of how their careers unfold, quarterbacks Justin Fields and Caleb Williams will always be connected. In March, the Bears traded Fields to the now 3-0 Pittsburgh Steelers. During a recent interview with Fox News Digital, Fields was asked about his expectations for Williams’ performance for the rest of the season. Fields responded with class, showing strong support for the rookie quarterback.

“I think he’s going to be fine.. He’s talented, he has all the talent in the world. They drafted him No. 1 overall for a reason.”

Fields further explained something he’s very familiar with: the struggles in Chicago aren’t solely the quarterback’s responsibility.

“Of course, it’s just not him, but he’s going to get most of the blame just because of the position he’s in. But just as a whole… the guys over there I know.. they want to be better, and I think they’re going to be better.”

Justin Fields took the high road

Fields has always been a stand-up guy, so it’s no surprise to see him sharing these thoughts and showing support for Williams. We’re seeing firsthand how much coaching and organizational structure really matter. Now that Fields is finding success in Pittsburgh, it’s likely just a matter of time before Williams and the Bears follow suit. The key question is whether the current coaching staff can fully unlock Williams’ potential. At the moment, all indications suggest the answer is no.

This Matt Eberflus Quote On Caleb Williams Is A Gigantic Red Flag

matt eberflus
Aug 10, 2024; Orchard Park, New York, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) throws a pass in warm ups with head coach Matt Eberflus looking on before a pre-season game against the Buffalo Bills at Highmark Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark Konezny-USA TODAY Sports

Last Sunday, Caleb Williams was the only good thing about the Chicago Bears offense. He threw for 363 yards and two touchdowns. Unfortunately, the fact he had to throw it 52 times because of a non-existent running game led to three turnovers (two INTs and a strip sack). While some people harped on those mistakes, most watching the game saw a young quarterback showing plenty of progress in less-than-ideal conditions. Conditions which Matt Eberflus has done nothing to improve.

The Bears head coach made wholesale changes to the offense this off-season, firing Luke Getsy in favor of Shane Waldron. He felt that would help pave the way for Williams’ arrival. As it turns out, the bigger problem may have been him all alone. When discussing his young quarterback’s performance, Eberflus was asked about the second interception in which he threw a tight-window pass that hit Rome Odunze in the hands but bounced to a defender instead. Rather than praise Williams for his accuracy, all the head coach could do was lament the turnover.

“I think it was an aggressive throw, I really do. I think he was open, but again, those windows close in the NFL. The safe option would have been taking the back in the flat in that particular case. We went through the motion and they ended up shifting their coverage over there. So on that particular play — again, aggressive throw. He’s gotta have some wisdom there and discernment in terms of when he needs to make that throw. You never want to take away his aggressiveness, but he has to be really good with the football. That’s his No. 1 job as a quarterback.”

This is precisely why Matt Eberflus is terrible for Williams.

One of the biggest concerns about keeping him as head coach was the knowledge that he sees the game with a defensive mentality. Defensive coaches have a tendency to become overly obsessed with not turning the ball over, which can lead them to instruct their quarterbacks to focus less on scoring points and more on protecting the ball. Lovie Smith was the exact same way. So was John Fox. History shows that is rarely the best way to foster a healthy atmosphere for a young quarterback to grow. Offensive coaches understand that learning to be aggressive is a great way for QBs to build confidence and understand what they can get away with.

Matt Eberflus is proving that he is not the guy for Williams. He believes the Bears can still win the old way. Play great defense, run the football, don’t turn it over. This isn’t 1985. Hell, it’s not even 2005. You don’t win consistently that way in today’s NFL. You need a quarterback who can sling the football. It appears the Bears finally have one who can do that, but the head coach seems hell-bent on neutering him. If you were on the fence about Eberflus before, this is a red flag you cannot overlook.

Jed Hoyer’s Uncanny Response To Counsell’s Cubs Comments

Oct 1, 2022; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Cubs President of baseball operations Jed Hoyer looks on before a baseball game between the Chicago Cubs and Cincinnati Reds at Wrigley Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Cubs sat in their third base dugout on Monday night, watching the Philadelphia Phillies celebrate their division championship after an outclassing of execution. It’s what the expectations and projections called for the Cubs to do in the 2024 season. President of Baseball Operations Jed Hoyer was supposed to open the metaphorical competitive window. Instead, they’ll keep everything closed as frustrations mount and overflow from the clubhouse.

Hoyer has been under fire for the lack of production and star power the roster he constructed provided. As the numbers were crunched, reality sat in. To meet the above expectations, this roster would have to have individual career years simultaneously. Now, Hoyer has to respond to some internal frustrations that are being shared.

Last week, Craig Counsell gave an honest assessment of how he feels the Cubs as an organization is in comparison to the team he abandoned, the Milwaukee Brewers. In short, he said the Cubs should be winning ninety-plus games a year and winning division titles. He also said there is still a hefty, hefty, hefty gap between them and the Brewers that needs to be closed.

Starting pitcher Jameson Taillon echoed Counsell’s thoughts on the floor being a ninety-win season in Chicago. Taillon added that he wants the Cubs and Wrigley Field to be a road trip that other teams fear and do not enjoy. He was calling for a change in narrative.

Jed Hoyer responded to comments about the quest for 90 wins and the gap between the Cubs and the Brewers. He did so in the only way he knew how. He patted himself on the back and said all the same things.

“‘That is the goal,’ Hoyer said. ‘And we talk about a gap, I think that we’ve come a long way. I feel really good about the position we’re in, but there’s still a gap. That last stretch, that’s what we have to make up.'”

Jed Hoyer on the gap between the Cubs and the Brewers, via Maddie Lee of the Chicago Sun Times

Jed Hoyer’s Response To Cubs’ Expectations Doesn’t Help

Via Maddie Lee of the Chicago Sun-Times, Jed Hoyer spoke on manager Craig Counsell’s comments last week about the team needing to consistently win 90 games. Hoyer agreed that should be the goal but patted himself on the back for the strides made in “closing the gap.”

As for winning 90 games a year, Hoyer said they’ll approach the future with the intent of not just winning 90 games one season but building a structure that can handle it consistently. He believes Counsell’s added perspective and competitiveness to the table will help the Cubs “close the gap.”

This all sounds great and promising. But there are two loud, apparent problems with the talk already being received from Jed Hoyer. First, it’s all been heard before. The Cubs have not made the playoffs in a full season since 2018. They’ve not one a playoff game since 2017. Nothing has changed.

Second, this “gap” being referenced was created by Jed Hoyer. He’s giving himself credit for attempting to fill a hole he dug himself.

There’s still a week of baseball for the Cubs and then a month of playoffs for the league. November seems so far away. However, hopes of this offseason being different on the North Side of Chicago are already dwindling.

New Cole Kmet Comments Hint At Discontent In Bears Locker Room

cole kmet
Chicago Bears tight end Cole Kmet (85) celebrates a touchdown Sunday, Sept. 22, 2024, during a game against the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.

Matt Eberflus and his coaching staff managed to stop the bleeding before things got too bad last year. However, 2023 didn’t come with high expectations. That was different this year. The Chicago Bears had loaded up on front-line talent for their offense. They took Caleb Williams #1 overall. Eberflus even overhauled most of his offensive staff, opting to bring in the more experienced Shane Waldron. Veteran players like Cole Kmet were assured that things would be better. This team was ready to win.

Three weeks into the season, Chicago is 1-2, and their offense might actually be worse than it was last season. They’re averaging less than 13 points per game and have the third-worst rushing attack in the league. It has been a sequence characterized by plentiful mistakes and highly suspect play calling. The 21-16 loss in Indianapolis might have been a breaking point for some. Teven Jenkins and Coleman Shelton had already hinted at concerns with the coaching they were given.

Add Kmet to that list.

Cole Kmet is struggling to hide his anger.

He’s made it clear his window actually to win something isn’t limitless. There are maybe five good years left for him. The Bears can’t keep wasting them with all of these self-inflicted wounds. He already had to endure the end of the Matt Nagy era. Now it is Matt Eberflus and his underwhelming stint. Kmet is a professional. He is doing his best not to say anything inflammatory. No question it is proving difficult. Eberflus promised the Waldron hire would change things. Instead, it’s more of the same.

The fact Cole Kmet and others are already grumbling about the coaching is a bad sign. These guys know this team is way too talented to be 1-2 and probably should be 0-3 if not for that crazy comeback against Tennessee. When a team underachieves, that points to a coaching problem. Unless Eberflus can right the ship again, things will only get worse from here.

White Sox Claim Interesting Reliever Off Waivers From Yankees

May 2, 2024; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; New York Yankees relief pitcher Ron Marinaccio (97) delivers a fifth inning pitch against the New York Yankees at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. Mandatory Credit: James A. Pittman-USA TODAY Sports

The saying “one man’s trash is another man’s treasure” applies to the pitiful White Sox. The team claimed reliever Ron Marinaccio off waivers from the New York Yankees this afternoon and optioned him to AA Birmingham. While it seems like a relatively insignificant move in the scheme of things, claiming the 29-year-old right-handed reliever is a savvy move for a White Sox ballclub looking for all the help they can get.

Marinaccio’s Strong MLB Track Record

Marinaccio has a fairly strong MLB track record. In 101 games over three big league seasons, he carries a respectable 3.22 ERA, 1.19 WHIP, and 10.8 K/9. Marinaccio has struck out 28.2% of the MLB hitters he has faced while holding them to a .184 batting average against. He was a productive member of the Yankees bullpen for several years.

Gradual Decline

Marinaccio’s numbers have slipped recently, especially from his 2022 rookie campaign which was the best season of his MLB career. His K% has dropped from 30.9% to 25.3% from 2022 to 2024, while opposing hitters’ exit velocity has increased from 84.5 MPH to 89.2 MPH over the same span. His whiff% has also decreased from 33.2% to 27.9% from 2022 to 2024. Relief pitchers are volatile, and Marinaccio is proof of that. He went from being a productive reliever to somewhat shaky over a short period. His drop in performance helps explain why the win-now Yankees were willing to part ways with him.

Reasons For Optimism

Despite some concerning trends, there are reasons to believe that Marinaccio can turn things around. His 10.1 BB% this season is the lowest of his career, and his four-seam fastball has a 5-run value this season, according to Baseball Savant. It has been an effective pitch throughout his MLB career, and 2024 is no exception. His sweeper also grades out the best by run value this season than it ever has before. The big difference between his most productive days and now is the decline of his changeup. Opposing hitters are batting .367 against that pitch this season compared to just .141 in his 2022 rookie season. Perhaps the White Sox see a tweak they can make that will get his changeup effectiveness back to where it used to be.

Potential Long-Term Bullpen Piece

Marinaccio’s contract is another appealing aspect of this waiver claim. He has not yet reached arbitration and will not become a free agent until after the 2028 season. Should he get back on track, Marinaccio could be a long-term fixture in the White Sox bullpen and potentially even a trade chip down the line. While the season is almost over, Marinaccio will undoubtedly be a factor in the team’s bullpen competition in 2025 spring training. The bullpen has to be rebuilt almost entirely from scratch, and Marinaccio’s past MLB success could give him a leg up on the competition.

Precedence For Such A Move

Current White Sox reliever Gus Varland was in a similar situation as Marinaccio. He was part of a roster crunch on a win-now Dodgers team earlier this season, which led him to being designated for assignment and claimed by Chicago in early August. Varland has been one of the White Sox’s best relievers since he got here, and it is not inconceivable to think Marinaccio could be on a similar trajectory following his departure from the Yankees.

Final Word

Whether Ron Marinaccio becomes a fixture in the White Sox bullpen or not, these are the moves the team should be making right now. There is no risk in a waiver claim like this, but there is quite a bit of upside if he can turn things around again. Chris Getz has received much criticism for how this season has gone, but he has the right idea with these waiver claims.

NFL Exec Openly Says Matt Eberflus Is Holding The Bears Back

matt eberflus
Aug 22, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Matt Eberflus at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-USA TODAY Sports

When Ryan Poles took over as GM, he knew what he wanted as a head coach. During his brief playing career in 2008, he got to experience Lovie Smith and his influence on the Chicago Bears. Given the former head coach’s success during his stint with the team, Poles felt he needed to find somebody with similar convictions and teaching philosophies. It didn’t take long to recognize Matt Eberflus embodied those ideals. Everything from his H.I.T.S principle to his demand for accountability lined up.

Unfortunately, this isn’t the same era Smith thrived in. Defense still meant something in the 2000s. Rules allowed teams to control games on that side of the ball. It isn’t this way anymore. You need a productive passing attack to function in today’s NFL. That was the big fear with Eberflus. That he would run into the same problems Smith did at cultivating that position. The past 37 games have done nothing to assuage those fears. Mike Sando of The Athletic spoke to an exec from another team who stated unequivocally that Eberflus is holding the team back.

“The media gets excited, the personnel people get excited and people expect that guy to come in and just tear it up,” a former head coach said. “They did a good job putting people around him. I do not think the offensive line is very good.”

And that is the No. 1 issue, but in a division featuring LaFleur, O’Connell and the Lions’ Ben Johnson at the offensive play-calling controls, the Bears are the obvious outlier.

“The Bears’ problems, in my opinion, start with the offensive line and the construction of it,” an evaluator said. “Then it’s Waldron, especially when you look at the other coordinators in the division. He is clearly fourth. The head coach is fourth. Right now, the quarterback is surviving on his own.”

Matt Eberflus is failing his primary mission this season.

That was ensuring he could put an environment around incoming quarterback Caleb Williams that would help the rookie thrive. Instead, it has been the exact opposite. The Bears are 30th in rushing and have allowed 13 sacks through three games. They also have two dropped passes that would’ve been touchdowns. This is the same sloppy operation that bedeviled the Bears last year despite replacing offensive coordinators. It is time to start accepting that Eberflus deserves more ownership of this.

Many people weren’t happy about the hire in 2022 because they felt he would be another good defensive coordinator who wouldn’t know how to foster an environment of growth on the offensive side. Try as he might, their predictions remain true. Though Williams is improving each week, it hasn’t been because he is getting plenty of help from the coaching. It’s almost been in spite of it. Poles gave Matt Eberflus a reprieve despite calls to fire him this past off-season. He is slowly wasting his golden opportunity.

The Bears Found A Solution For Caleb Williams But Refuse To Use It

caleb williams
Sep 22, 2024; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) hands the ball to Chicago Bears running back D'Andre Swift (4) on during a game against the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Grace Hollars USA TODAY Network via Imagn Images

One thing has become apparent through the first three weeks of the 2024 season. The Chicago Bears offense is still a mess, but for once, the quarterback isn’t one of the primary reasons why. Quite the contrary. Caleb Williams has been the only one able to generate actual scoring drives. It hasn’t been perfect. He’s thrown four interceptions over the past two weeks. Turnovers are something you can’t have. However, when your offense also boasts one of the worst rushing attacks in the league, one has to be more understanding of the situation.

What really makes Bears fans irate is that the coaching staff hasn’t done enough to help him. They don’t seem to have any answers on making life easier for the rookie. Well, in actuality, they do have a solution. Unfortunately, they seem dead set against implementing it. Over the past two weeks, Williams has thrown 11 passes from under center. He is 7-of-11 for 125 yards in those situations. His only blemish is an interception on Sunday that hit Rome Odunze in the hands.

It is plainly evident that the quarterback hits chunk plays far more often when working under center. So, of course, the Bears only implement it a few times per game.

For Caleb Williams, it can’t be about what is familiar.

The primary reason for the overabundance of shotgun plays is that the quarterback ran them at USC. Chicago probably wants to ensure he’s comfortable. The problem is that this offensive line is incapable of blocking those formations consistently. One of the benefits of playing under center is it helps the quarterback establish better timing with his receivers. His drops should line up with how they run their routes, allowing him to know when and where they will be. It is also much more effective in play action situations, making it difficult for defenses to read fakes.

Speaking of rushing, excluding end-arounds to wide receivers, the Bears ran the ball 16 times for 50 yards from under center against Indianapolis. While this is only 3.12 yards per carry, it’s way better than the 10 runs for 13 yards they had out of shotgun. Running under center at least allows the offensive line to go forward. That, in turn, will give Caleb Williams more play-fake opportunities. Under center might be considered an outdated approach to some. Who cares? It is the Bears’ responsibility to help their young quarterback.

Blackhawks Reveal Shocking Defensive Changes, Jumble Opening Night Pairings

Feb 9, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Blackhawks defenseman Alex Vlasic (72) celebrates his goal with teammates against the New York Rangers during the first period at the United Center. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-USA TODAY Sports

Throughout this summer, the Blackhawks’ defensive unit was somewhat unpredictable, as no one knew how the newcomers would fit in with the somewhat limited existing talent on the roster. The blue line was an afterthought in general, with much of the focus of the media being on the completely overhauled offensive group.

While no one could predict how the Blackhawks would fill out its defensive group, one part that was a near certainty was a top pairing of Alex Vlasic and Seth Jones. The two spent almost all season together last year and were just about the only successful part of that woeful blue line group.

At Monday’s training camp practice, Chicago made it clear that might not be the case again this season. The Blackhawks shockingly switched up their defensive pairings Monday, and the changes are more than just an experiment – they’ll be in effect to open the season next month.

At first glance, this lineup is simply experimental. After all, that defensive grouping is pretty far from what everyone projected throughout the summer. However, Jones spoke with Tab Bamford of Bleacher Nation afterward and confirmed that he and Vlasic would be split up by the coaching staff. He also said he would indeed be starting the season with free-agent acquisition Alec Martinez, and the two have been predominantly working together in practice.

Another pairing that has been working well together in training camp is the combination of Wyatt Kaiser and veteran Connor Murphy. I didn’t have Kaiser sneaking into the lineup but projected him as a potential seventh defenseman. With how comfortable the two have looked together, it looks like that will be the bottom line in Chicago to start the season.

In Kaiser’s place I had initially projected Kevin Korchinski. The big 20-year-old was one of the players to watch in this training camp. He was forced into an NHL role last season because he wasn’t old enough to spend time in the AHL, but now that he’s old enough, he may be sent down to develop a bit more. However, he’s spent quite a bit of time with Louis Crevier so far, who was one of the lowlights of a terrible Blackhawks team last season. With all the new talent being brought to Chicago, there’s no chance the team uses Crevier again. That’s a pretty indicative sign that Korchinski is headed to Rockford.

So who’s left? In between those two lines are Vlasic and TJ Brodie, who could make up a great tandem this season. Vlasic put on one of the best performances of any defensive defenseman in the league last year, so I’d like to see him get as much ice time as possible. Brodie could probably keep pace on this potential top line; he’s an aging veteran but was strong in 78 games in Toronto last season. Even if Vlasic and Brodie make up a second pairing, the top two will be essentially interchangeable, which is a great problem to have.

As a refresher, here’s what the Blackhawks’ defensive pairings could look like in the season opener. If Jones’s comments are accurate, this lineup should be fairly firm, with only minor changes expected over the next few weeks.

Seth Jones – Alec Martinez
Alex Vlasic – TJ Brodie
Wyatt Kaiser – Connor Murphy
Isaak Phillips

NFL Scout Drops Shane Waldron Quote That Is Positively Damning

shane waldron

Something has felt off with the Chicago Bears’ offense ever since the season began. Nobody can pinpoint what is going on with Shane Waldron. He was supposed to bring a credible scheme with him from Seattle. Instead, the Bears are off to one of their worst starts in recent franchise history, which is saying something. It would be one thing if they couldn’t throw the ball. That is par for the course. They have a rookie quarterback and an unreliable offensive line. However, the fact they may have the worst rushing attack in the entire NFL is not something anyone saw coming.

This system was supposed to be different from Luke Getsy’s. It was supposed to be better. That has not been the case. Sure, it is early in the season, and it can sometimes take time to absorb a new system. However, that doesn’t seem to have stopped teams like New Orleans, who just hired Klint Kubiak, from leading the league in points scored. What stands out the most is how out of sorts, undisciplined, and sloppy the entire operation looks. Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune asked around the league about it. One answer he got back might be the most damning quote one could imagine.

Talking to scouts around the league, they don’t feel a lot has changed in the Bears’ ground game in moving to coordinator Shane Waldron from Luke Getsy.

“Hired a guy for the exact same offense as the previous guy,” one scout noted.

Shane Waldron being Getsy 2.0 is such a Bears outcome.

In truth, that comment hurts a lot because of its accuracy. Waldron is far too in love with screens, specifically of the wide receiver variety. He gets too cute with his play calling and never seems able to get his players in a rhythm. Worst of all, they both lean on young quarterbacks to make magic happen rather than doing more to make their lives easier. The fact they also seem to hit the same beats in their press conferences about teaching players better and not worrying about a specific identity on offense only magnifies the issue.

Matt Eberflus wanted to separate himself from Getsy because he felt the offense wasn’t progressing as hoped. Yet he never seemed willing to stray too far from the type of coordinator he preferred, both in personality and philosophy. It is horribly fitting that Shane Waldron is turning out to be another Getsy. Perhaps Eberflus’ influence on the entire operation plays a part. Either way, it is evident something is rotten with the entire structure from top to bottom.