Wednesday, November 18, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 769

It’s Time To Panic About Shane Waldron Says Renowned QB Expert

shane waldron
Sep 22, 2024; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Chicago Bears running back D'Andre Swift (4) is tackled by Indianapolis Colts cornerback Jaylon Jones (40) during the second quarter at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Marc Lebryk-Imagn Images

Caleb Williams did everything he could to lift the Chicago Bears to a victory on Sunday over the Indianapolis Colts. Unfortunately, his three turnovers marred an otherwise encouraging performance with 363 yards and two touchdowns. He also again didn’t get any help from the running game, which failed to even crack 70 yards. Plenty of people have no issue blaming Williams for the loss, which is par for the course. However, one notable former quarterback isn’t buying that noise. The source of the rot traces to Shane Waldron and his overall process as a play caller.

Tim Jenkins played quarterback for both the Los Angeles Rams and Calgary Stampeders. Over the past few years, he has established one of the more renowned quarterback training schools. He also has a YouTube channel where he has become one of the best at reviewing game tapes. Bernstein and Holmes of 670 The Score brought him on their show to ask what he saw from the Colts game. Was Williams the problem? The short answer is no.

It was something far more alarming.

“Transparently, man? I think it, a little bit, with the staff (is) kind of what we got going on. We had some pretty egregious, I think, play-calling issues, but I also think time management issues. Overall handling of the game. About as bad as it can get. Especially when you look at the Colts.

Two weeks ago we were talking about the Chicago Bears offensive line cannot handle when the tackle and the end on the defense twist, right?…And then the Colts, they’ve got like no line movement. So you have to say go into it arguably the worst defensive game plan you could have for the Bears offensive line and we still struggled.

So to me, it’s just like I think maybe it’s time to panic a little bit with the staff.”

Shane Waldron is in a bad place.

This isn’t Seattle, where he sat in a smaller media market masked by a successful head coach like Pete Carroll. Chicago is a top market with ravenous fans, and Matt Eberflus is going into his third season, having yet to produce a winning record. Combine that with the pressure of coaching a #1 overall pick and it is getting easier to understand why Waldron seems overwhelmed. None of the confident scheming he showed in Seattle has been present. The past three weeks have felt like a gross mishmash of Luke Getsy and Matt Nagy.

Now, the good news is that there are 14 games left. The Bears still have time to get things sorted out. Shane Waldron might finally be getting a grasp of his personnel. Cole Kmet and Roschon Johnson saw a lot more action against Indianapolis. If he can somehow provide a jolt to the run game, he might be able to get things on the right track. If he can’t, he, Eberflus, and the rest of the staff may not survive into 2025.

Eloy Jimenez Optioned to Triple-A as Struggles Continue

Aug 31, 2024; Denver, Colorado, USA; Baltimore Orioles designated hitter Eloy Jimenez (72) during the first inning against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field. Mandatory Credit: Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

Eloy Jimenez was once viewed as a potential core piece of a championship-caliber team. Now he is struggling to stay in the major leagues. On Tuesday the Baltimore Orioles announced that Jimenez was optioned to Triple-A Norfolk. It’s a massive fall from grace for the 2020 Silver Slugger Award Winner, who has struggled to find consistent success since. 

Jimenez kicked off the 2024 season with just five home runs in 249 plate appearances with a .642 OPS, his worst in a White Sox uniform. After slashing .240/.297/.345 through 65 games the White Sox traded him to Baltimore. 

But it appears that not even a change of scenery was enough to fix Jimenez. He struck out in 23 of his 100 plate appearances and hit .232 with a .586 OPS and one home run in 33 games. His chase rate, walk rate, and speed all rank near the bottom of the MLB. Jimenez has had some bad luck as well. His 49 percent hard-hit percentage places him in the top ten percent of the league, with little to show for it.  The Orioles used him exclusively at DH, a position Jimenez has previously come out and said he doesn’t like. Unfortunately for the 27-year-old, his resume doesn’t give him much of a choice. 

It’s sad to see the once fun-loving player fall off like this. Jimenez had a promising debut season with the White Sox in 2019, leading all AL rookies with 31 home runs. He followed that up by slashing .296/.332/.559 with 14 homers and 41 RBIs during the 55 games he played in 2020. Since then has struggled to stay healthy and his power has evaporated. 

In 2023 Jimenez logged his most games (120) since his rookie year (122).  However, he had 13 fewer home runs, 15 fewer RBIs, and a slugging percentage that dropped from .513 to .441. His barrel percentage and hard-hit percentage also dropped. Jimenez did post a higher batting average but the White Sox were paying him to hit home runs and 18 on the year with just 64 RBIs didn’t cut it. 

In 2023 he had a career-low 9.3 barrel percentage, 26.0 sweet spot percentage, 46.8 hard hit percentage, and a .421 expected slugging percentage. These numbers suggest that Jimenez was having some issues with his timing. 

Jimenez’s sole purpose on the White Sox roster is to produce runs since he has proved to be a liability defensively. Given Jimenez’s well-documented injury history, the White Sox moved him from his primary role in left field to designated hitter. 

Jimenez was vocal about not wanting to be a DH and even tried to win the starting job in right field during Spring Training. Pedro Grifol gave him some opportunities in right field and while the defensive numbers were not nearly as bad as they were when he was in left field they still left a lot to be desired. Jimenez has a career -19 Outs Above Average. In 2023 he had a -1 OAA in right field. To his credit, he did not commit an error in right field. However, his lack of arm strength allowed base runners to advance on balls hit to him at a higher clip than the league average. 

Seeing that his offensive production has taken a dip and he is a liability on defense it is hard to see a very robust market for Jimenez’s services this offseason.

The Caleb Chicago Sports Fans Should Be Worried About is on the Cubs

Sep 23, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Chicago Cubs starting pitcher Caleb Kilian (45) reacts after allowing run during the fifth inning against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

Caleb Williams is going to be fine and actually he’s going to be pretty damn good. So, stop, please stop freaking out, especially if you’re a Bears fan. You’ve seen truly awful QB play, Caleb Williams isn’t that. The Caleb that Chicago fans should be worried about is Caleb Kilian for the Cubs because the 27-year-old made his season debut Monday night and it went just as bad as his other MLB appearances.

We’ve seen this story before with Kilian, who in the past couple of offseasons has shown up to spring training, looked great down in Arizona, and then when he gets a chance against MLB hitters the righty gets crushed. With so many injuries to the pitching staff throughout the season, Kilian could have had a bigger sample size to impress this year, but he was victim to the injury bug himself.

The right-hander didn’t make it back to the mound until July, missing the first half of the season because of a shoulder strain. He put up good numbers at Triple-A, posting a 3.22 ERA in 44.2 innings with 38 strikeouts across 13 appearances with the Iowa Cubs. He had a tough assignment in his first outing with the Cubs this year, facing the Philadelphia Phillies and well, not good.

Kilian allowed five earned runs, (six total) on eight hits, which included a pair of home runs by the Phillies. The Cubs righty also walked four batters and was only able to strike out three in 5.2 innings, Kilian’s longest appearance in the majors.

It’s still an extremely small sample size, 22.1 innings, but man has it been really bad nearly every time Kilian gets an opportunity in the big leagues. While his stuff looks electric facing hitters at Triple-A, and he lights up the radar gun, throwing in the upper 90s with his fastball, Kilian isn’t fooling anyone at the big-league level.

In seven MLB games, hitters are slashing .348/.474/.511, against Kilian. He has an 11.28 ERA, with more walks, 18, than strikeouts, 17.

Can Kilian become a traditional one-inning reliever? Sure. However, his future as being a trusted depth starter who can come up in case of injury to make a few starts just cannot be something the Cubs feel comfortable about at this point.

But hey, maybe there’s a simple fix for Kilian. Could it be as easy as him tipping pitches? Bleacher Nation’s Brett Taylor was all over it during Kilian’s outing Monday night.

Kilian will have one more minor league option in 2025, which could be make it or break it time for the pitcher in the Cubs organization.

White Sox Turbulent Season Gains More National Coverage

Aug 18, 2014; Chicago, IL, USA; The Chicago White Sox logo behind home plate before a game between the Chicago White Sox and the Texas Rangers at U.S Cellular Field. Mandatory Credit: Jon Durr-USA TODAY Sports

A week after the New York Times released an in-depth piece about the root causes that have led up to the White Sox historically bad 2024 season, another national news outlet has decided to join the fun. 

On Tuesday the Wall Street Journal published an article looking into the White Sox failed rebuild attempt. The article rehashes many of the things that have come out about the White Sox this month, including that some people inside the organization felt that Jerry Reinsdorf’s decision to hire Tony La Russa as manager marked the beginning of the end of the team’s contention window. 

Braves starter Reynaldo Lopez was one of the people interviewed for the piece, and the former White Sox right-hander was pretty honest about his experience in the clubhouse. 

“No matter if you have the best players in the clubhouse, if you don’t feel like a unit, you’re not going far,” Lopez said. 

He went on to say that the 2024 season probably “feels like 500 games” for the players still stuck on the White Sox. It is yet another example of current and former members of the organization speaking out.

The White Sox have garnered plenty of headlines on their march to 120 losses. Earlier this month ESPN’s Jeff Passan spent a day inside the White Sox locker room and quoted the White Sox lone All-Star representative Garrett Crochet saying: “It seems like once an inning, we will give up the flare single and then every time that we hit the flare on offense and it’s like, ‘Oh, that one’s falling,’ someone dives and catches it.”

Last week Britt Ghiroli and Ken Rosenthal spoke with nearly 40 current and former members of the organization which revealed a cheap culture that lacked many of the amenities and support systems most other teams have. This included flying on an Airbus A320, the worst plane in the MLB, hiring outside firms to do analytics, not giving players proper scouting reports or offseason plans, and dysfunction in the front office. NBC News also aired a two-minute segment detailing the White Sox losing record. 

It’s the most national media attention the team has received in years but for all the wrong reasons.

Bears Urged To Bring In Old Nemesis To Help Caleb Williams

chicago bears
Green Bay Packers offensive tackle David Bakhtiari (69) blocks Chicago Bears defensive end Yannick Ngakoue (91) during second half of their game on Sunday, Sept. 10, 2023 at Soldier Field in Chicago.

Caleb Williams is under siege to start the 2024 season. Across three games, he has already been sacked 13 times. This isn’t the same situation as Justin Fields, either. Despite his inexperience, the rookie has done a good job of getting the ball out fast. Unfortunately, this cannot overcome the litany of miscues the front five continues suffering. It is evident something is wrong with the offensive line. People are struggling to pinpoint the issue. Many think it is a weak interior, especially at center and right guard. Others believe Braxton Jones has taken a step back at left tackle.

Most agree the coaching hasn’t been good enough.

Whatever the case, ideas are starting to surface about what the Bears can do to help their young quarterback. Multiple scouts working for Bleacher Report agree there is one name they could call who might be able to steady the ship.

Add Now: OT David Bakhtiari

Part of the issue with Caleb Williams to begin the season is the Bears offensive line hasn’t been great in pass protection. Especially with Larry Borom on injured reserve, the front office should look into bringing in Bakhtiari to give the offense a veteran insurance policy to turn to. If healthy, he can help give Williams a little more time to throw when called upon.

Bakhtiari was a two-time All-Pro for the Green Bay Packers between 2013 and 2020. A bad knee injury kept him mostly sidelined over the past three years, though he still looked great when he played.

Bakhtiari can’t help Caleb Williams.

Or he can’t do it unless he’s willing to switch positions. He has been a left tackle his entire career. At 32 years old, it seems unlikely he would change. That means the Bears would have to bench Jones to bring him in. There is no way GM Ryan Poles would consider such an idea. Replacing a young blocker who still shows signs of improvement for an older player with a knee issue that hasn’t seen him play since last September is bad business. Now, would Bakhtiari be willing to move to left guard? That might change things.

Plugging him there would allow the Bears to shift Teven Jenkins over to right guard, where most feel he is a better fit. That would put their two best pass protectors on Caleb Williams blind side and their two best run blockers on the right side. It’s not the perfect solution, but it would be an improvement. There is no doubt Bakhtiari’s veteran presence might help settle things down. The big question is that knee. It feels like it may never be 100%. Besides, would he return to join a team that is 1-2? Unlikely.

Caleb Williams Shows Leadership By Challenging Bears Coaching Staff

Aug 22, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) on the sidelines against the Kansas City Chiefs during the game at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Denny Medley-USA TODAY Sports

Rookie quarterback Caleb Williams showed a fiery spirit reminiscent of former Bears quarterback Jay Cutler. Like Cutler, Williams isn’t shy about expressing his thoughts, even during games. In the recent Bears vs. Colts matchup, on a crucial 3rd and 4 play, he missed a deep throw to Rome, who had beaten his defender down the left sideline. As Williams left the field, he appeared frustrated and was seen looking at the Bears coaches, asking, “What are we doing?”

Caleb makes a valid point here. While he could have connected on a deep pass to Rome for a big completion, it raises the question: why attempt deep shots on a critical third-and-short situation? We’ve already seen too many questionable play calls in just three games. Williams fire and passion are crucial for his success, especially as he navigates a coaching staff that seems to be failing him. By speaking up, he forces them to improve or their tenure in Chicago will come a end.

It’s rare for a rookie quarterback to have the confidence to do this, which highlights Williams competitiveness and desire to win now. On the very next drive, the Bears scored a touchdown. It’s important to balance these kinds of interactions, but this one was necessary and seemed to energize the offense against Indianapolis. However, it proved to be to late to complete yet another comeback win.

Why Bears Fans Should Be Excited About Rome Odunze: A Potential Star in the Making

As the season rolls on, it is clear the Chicago Bears have a lot left to do as they continue their rebuild under head coach Matt Eberflus and general manager Ryan Poles. The team is in search of young playmakers who can help elevate their offense; the former Washington Huskies wide receiver Rome Odunze, standing at 6-foot-3 and possessing a unique blend of size, speed, and athleticism, is quickly emerging as one of the most exciting wide receivers in the NFL.

Here’s why Bears fans should be thrilled about Rome Odunze already wearing navy and orange.

1. A Perfect Fit for Caleb Williams

One of the biggest reasons Bears fans should be excited about Odunze is how well his skill set complements quarterback Caleb Williams. Williams, the Bears’ new franchise QB, thrives on deep passes and making plays outside the pocket. Having a dynamic receiver like Odunze—who excels at stretching the field and making tough catches—will allow Williams to fully showcase his talent.

Odunze has the speed to get behind defenses, the hands to come down with contested catches, and the football IQ to find open spaces in the secondary. This pairing has the potential to be one of the most electric QB-WR duos in the NFL.

2. Size and Versatility

At 6-foot-3, Odunze brings much-needed size to the Bears’ receiving corps. His combination of size and speed makes him a threat at all levels of the field, particularly in the red zone, where the Bears have struggled in the past. Whether it’s jump balls in the end zone or using his physicality on slant routes, Odunze’s versatility gives Caleb Williams a reliable target in crucial situations.

Odunze’s presence will also open things up for other players, like DJ Moore and Keenan Allen, who can now benefit from the attention Odunze commands from opposing defenses. This creates a more balanced and unpredictable offensive attack.

3. Instant Impact in the Bears’ Rebuild

For a team in the midst of a rebuild, drafting a player like Odunze signals that the Bears are serious about giving Caleb Williams the tools to succeed. Odunze’s combination of raw talent and polish means that he can contribute immediately. He’s not just a developmental prospect; he’s a player who can make plays from Day 1.

Odunze’s ability to stretch the field, move the chains on third downs, and be a reliable target in the red zone will be key in taking the Bears’ offense to the next level. As the Bears look to grow their young core, Odunze’s immediate impact will be crucial in helping Chicago become more competitive in the NFC North.

4. Helping Connor Bedard and the Overall Culture of Chicago Sports

Though this might seem like a side note, the excitement around Odunze’s arrival also reflects the broader resurgence of Chicago sports. From the Bears’ recent draft picks to the arrival of hockey phenom Connor Bedard on the Chicago Blackhawks, the Windy City is becoming a hotbed of young talent across the board.

In many ways, Odunze’s arrival is part of this larger culture shift toward rebuilding and revitalizing Chicago’s sports landscape. Having players like Odunze can help rejuvenate the fanbase and instill a winning mentality, both for the Bears and for Chicago sports in general.

5. Polished Skills and High Football IQ

Odunze is not just an athletic freak—he’s a polished route-runner with a deep understanding of the game. His football IQ allows him to adjust on the fly, find soft spots in coverage, and create separation with his route-running technique. This level of polish is rare for young receivers, which is why Odunze was such a valuable draft pick for the Bears.

In addition to his route-running, Odunze has excellent hands and the ability to make difficult, contested catches in traffic. Whether it’s third-and-long or a crucial red-zone possession, Odunze has shown that he can be trusted to come down with the football when the game is on the line.

6. Building Chemistry with Caleb Williams

Odunze’s arrival gives Caleb Williams a receiver who can grow alongside him. Both players are young and loaded with potential, which means they have the opportunity to develop a long-term partnership. As they work together and build chemistry on the field, it’s likely that Williams and Odunze will develop a connection that can fuel the Bears’ offense for years to come.

For a team that’s been starved for offensive firepower, the chance to see this duo develop is something Bears fans should be excited about. A young, talented quarterback paired with an explosive, versatile receiver like Odunze could be the key to unlocking a potent, modern offense that the Bears have lacked for years.

Conclusion

Rome Odunze’s addition to the Bears’ roster is exactly the kind of move that should get Chicago fans excited. With his size, speed, polished skill set, and ability to make an immediate impact, Odunze is the perfect weapon for Caleb Williams as the Bears continue their rebuild. Together, they could form the backbone of an offense that will be competitive for years to come.

For a franchise looking to turn the corner, Odunze represents both the present and future of the Bears’ offense. His arrival brings hope to a team that has long needed a reliable No. 1 receiver, and his development alongside Williams has the potential to elevate the Bears to new heights. Bears fans, get ready—Odunze is the real deal.

Five Reasons Bears Fans Should Be Concerned About Caleb Williams

Indianapolis Colts defensive tackle Taven Bryan (96) takes down Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) on Sunday, Sept. 22, 2024, during a game against the Chicago Bears at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.

As the Chicago Bears’ 2024 season unfolds, fans are already starting to feel the weight of unmet expectations surrounding their highly-touted rookie quarterback, Caleb Williams. Drafted first overall, Williams was seen as the savior for a franchise in desperate need of stability at the most important position. However, through the first three games, there are growing concerns that the same systemic issues that plagued previous quarterbacks are beginning to affect Williams as well. Here are five reasons why Bears fans should be concerned about Caleb Williams.

1. A Leaky Offensive Line

The Bears’ offensive line has been a consistent weak point for several seasons, and unfortunately, it appears not much has changed. Williams has been sacked 13 times in just three games, a staggering number that highlights the lack of protection he’s receiving. The pressure is coming from all sides, and while some of the sacks can be attributed to Williams holding onto the ball too long, the line’s inability to give him adequate time to go through his progressions is a major red flag. A young quarterback under constant duress can quickly develop bad habits, leading to more turnovers and stalled drives.

2. Questionable Coaching Decisions

Head coach Matt Eberflus and offensive coordinator Shane Waldron have come under fire for their questionable play-calling and overall game management. Many fans and analysts have pointed out that the Bears’ offensive scheme lacks creativity and fails to put Williams in a position to succeed. The coaching staff’s inability to adjust to opposing defenses and their reluctance to tailor the game plan to Williams’ strengths could stunt his development. When a team’s coaching staff is considered among the worst in the division, it’s hard to have confidence that they will get the best out of their quarterback.

“I threw (the ball) 52 times? Jeez.” Caleb Williams on the number of pass attempts he had in Week 3.

3. The Weight of Franchise Expectations

One of the most significant concerns for Bears fans is the immense pressure placed on Caleb Williams to be the savior of a franchise that has been searching for a true franchise quarterback for decades. Drafted first overall, Williams arrived in Chicago with sky-high expectations, and the burden of being the face of the franchise at such a young age can be overwhelming. The intense media scrutiny, coupled with the passionate and often impatient fan base, means that every mistake Williams makes will be magnified.

This pressure can hinder a young quarterback’s development, especially if the team isn’t performing well around him. We’ve seen it happen before—highly touted prospects struggle under the weight of expectations, and their confidence takes a hit. If Williams begins to feel the pressure mounting, it could lead to rushed decisions on the field, second-guessing himself, and ultimately stunted growth.

The Bears’ long history of quarterback woes only exacerbates this issue, as Williams is constantly being compared to past failures and is expected to succeed where others have failed. Without proper support from the organization—both on and off the field—there’s a real risk that the expectations could become too much for Williams to bear, potentially derailing his career before it even gets started.

4. Early Comparisons to Other Rookies

The emergence of other rookie quarterbacks like Jayden Daniels, who had a historic performance in Week 3 for the Washington Commanders, has led to unfair comparisons. While it’s still early, these comparisons can create unnecessary pressure on Williams. If Daniels or other rookie QBs continue to outperform Williams, the narrative could shift, leading to doubts about whether the Bears made the right choice in drafting him. Such doubts could undermine Williams’ confidence and further complicate his transition to the NFL.

5. The Shadow of Justin Fields

Perhaps the most concerning factor is the success of former Bears quarterback Justin Fields with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Fields currently leads the NFL in fourth-quarter passer rating, a far cry from his struggles in Chicago. This success raises questions about whether the Bears’ problems lie more with their coaching staff and organizational structure than with their quarterbacks. If Fields continues to thrive while Williams struggles, it could spark frustration among fans and lead to a loss of faith in the current regime’s ability to develop a franchise quarterback.

In conclusion, while Caleb Williams has shown flashes of his immense potential, the early signs are troubling. A weak offensive line, questionable coaching, franchise weight, unfair comparisons, and the shadow of Justin Fields’ success all contribute to a growing sense of concern. If the Bears don’t address these issues quickly, they risk repeating the same mistakes that have kept them from finding a true franchise quarterback for years.

Heat On Chris Morgan Reportedly Skyrocketing As O-Line Struggles Persist

chris morgan
Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) jumps over Indianapolis Colts linebacker Zaire Franklin (44) while evading tackle Sunday, Sept. 22, 2024, during a game at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.

The Chicago Bears offensive line’s performance through the first three weeks has been nothing short of baffling. Keep in mind that this unit paved the way for the #2 rushing attack in the NFL last season. They also showed legitimate progress in pass protection. Coming into 2024, they even had continuity. Four of the five starters from last year were returning. Everybody expected at least something similar to last season. Instead, what they’ve gotten is the third-worst rushing attack in football, 13 sacks allowed in three games, and a comedy of mental errors. As a result, many have called out offensive line coach Chris Morgan.

He was one of the few holdovers from last year. Head coach Matt Eberflus felt Morgan had done enough to prove he could develop young guys to play at a high level. The stunning regression of guys like Darnell Wright and Braxton Jones over the past three weeks has many second-guessing that assessment, including inside Halas Hall. A source informed SM that there is a “s**t ton” of heat on Morgan for the constant mistakes. The feeling is there is way too much talent in that group to be playing this poorly.

Chris Morgan feels like a potential scapegoat.

There is something much deeper going on with the Bears offense. There is no way things should’ve devolved this fast. Morgan didn’t just suddenly become a bad coach, right? The only difference from last year is Waldron. Maybe he isn’t the great teacher Eberflus made him out to be. A good teacher never lets his students make so many mistakes. Maybe he and Morgan don’t have great chemistry together due to unfamiliarity and differing opinions. Remember, Morgan is also the team’s run game coordinator.

Either way, if this keeps up, something is going to change. Ryan Poles made that clear before the Colts game. He stated talent is not the issue. It is the fundamentals and discipline. That falls on the coaching. Chris Morgan is the man with those guys more often than anybody. If they aren’t performing, he must shoulder responsibility. It hasn’t gotten to a point where jobs are on the line yet. That said, any goodwill from last year has evaporated.

Kyle Schwarber Gives Jed Hoyer, Cubs A Painful Reminder

Sep 10, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Phillies designated hitter Kyle Schwarber (12) celebrates his home run during the first inning against the Tampa Bay Rays at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

Kyle Schwarber was one of the most unlikely heroes of the Chicago Cubs 2016 World Series team. After a catastrophic injury that ended his season in the first week of play, he fought back in rehab to be able to play in the Cubs’ first Fall Classic appearance in 70 years. Jed Hoyer and the Cubs gave up on him a few years later. He probably remembers.

After 2016, consecutive seasons of a batting average in the low .200s, an increasing number of strikeouts, and below-average fielding gave Hoyer and the Cubs pause on keeping Schwarber on the Cubs after the 2020 season. They opted not to extend a qualifying offer to Schwarber for 2021, which would have been valued at $8 million. Instead, Schwarber was granted free agency while the Cubs continued pinching for pennies.

After spending time in Washington and helping the Red Sox make a playoff push in 2021, Schwarber signed with the Philadelphia Phillies. He’s been there since, helping them make two deep playoff runs. Now that they’ve clinched their division, they’re poised to do it again.

Kyle Schwarber has had a remarkable 2024. He is building on his MLB record of most leadoff home runs in a season. Schwarber hit one against the Cubs on Monday with Jed Hoyer in attendance, reminding Hoyer he is worth way more than the $8 million they passed on him for.

Kyle Schwarber Continues To Thrive While Jed Hoyer, Cubs Still Searching For Answers

Last night’s home run was Kyle Schwarber’s 37th of the season. He also surpassed 100 runs batted in for the second consecutive year. He’s the first Phillies player to do that since Ryan Howard did it from 2006-2011. It’s also his second consecutive season with 100 walks and 100 runs.

Granted, the Cubs let Schwarber go before the designated hitter was a thing in the National League permanently, feeling Ian Happ was their best option in left field. And, to be fair, Happ is a top-five left fielder in baseball today. But losing Schwarber’s offense is something that will haunt the Cubs until they can find what they gave up on. Also, the last time the Cubs had a player reach 100 RBIs was in 2018, when Javier Báez and Anthony Rizzo both reached the century mark.

Kyle Schwarber would lead the Cubs in all four categories above this year. He’d also lead the team in OPS. His contributions probably could have made a difference in the win/loss column for the Cubs, too. But the Cubs like him walk for nothing in return. He’ll continue to battle for a championship in Philadelphia while a cold, harsh winter begins early for Jed Hoyer and the Cubs in Chicago.