Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 1038

Draft Insider Reveals Why Ryan Poles Is So Set On Taking His QB Now

ian cunningham

There are two schools of thought surrounding the Chicago Bears quarterback decision this off-season. One section of fans and media believe the team should stick with Justin Fields. Use the resources available to build around him. The other side says it’s time to trade Fields and take the best quarterback at #1 overall. Based on every report from top insiders over the past week, it sounds like GM Ryan Poles is committed to the latter. While he loves the work Fields has put in, an opportunity to reset the QB clock with a player of his choice is too good to pass up.

Except it isn’t always that simple. There could be another reason why he’s choosing such a course now. Good general managers don’t solely focus on a draft class in the current year. They often have an eye on the next two or three draft classes in the future. That includes the quarterbacks. Part of Poles’ decision to take one now might be driven by what he’s seeing in 2025. That is what NFL Network draft insider Daniel Jeremiah stated. By his estimates, next year could be a rough one at the quarterback position.

Ryan Poles understands he can’t delay the decision any longer.

Perhaps if the 2025 class had more options he could be excited about, he’d be willing to entertain the idea of keeping Fields and trading down again. That doesn’t appear to be the case. Shedeur Sanders, Quinn Ewers, and Carson Beck appear to be the top three options going into next year. Maybe one of them takes a big step forward into that elite territory. Yet even if they do, there is no guarantee the Bears would have a high enough pick next year to even have the option of drafting them. Teams don’t get an opportunity to pick first in the draft too often.

One mistake previous Bears GMs made was not pouncing on quarterbacks high in the draft in years past. They passed on Drew Brees in 2001, opting to stick with Jim Miller. In 2005, they felt keeping Rex Grossman was a better bet than taking Aaron Rodgers with the 4th pick. Everybody remembers they almost drafted Joe Montana in 1979 before taking a backup running back instead. Ryan Poles doesn’t want to fall into that same trap of maintaining the status quo. It’s a 3-1 count. He knows a fastball is coming. It is time to take his swing.

ESPN Adds More Smoke To Caleb Williams-Washington Buzz

caleb williams
Nov 11, 2023; Eugene, Oregon, USA; USC Trojans quarterback Caleb Williams (13) celebrates scoring a touchdown in the first half with tight end Carson Tabaracci (84) against the Oregon Ducks at Autzen Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Troy Wayrynen-USA TODAY Sports

Things started getting interesting when the Washington Commanders pulled a surprise, hiring USC quarterbacks coach Kliff Kingsbury as their new offensive coordinator. People began to wonder if this was the beginning step in a plan by their top brass to go after Caleb Williams in the draft. It wasn’t hard to connect the dots. Williams is a D.C. native. New owner Josh Harris has a reputation for targeting players with east coast roots. Minority owner Magic Johnson has deep connections in L.A. All the signs are there.

Dan Graziano of ESPN looked into the situation. From what he’s gathered, two things are apparent. The Kingsbury hire wasn’t solely made for Williams. They believe he is capable of coaching the other top guys like Drake Maye or Jayden Daniels. However, it was also confirmed that their interest in Williams is very real. Enough to where they are more than willing to consider trading up to get him.

The only thing holding them back is whether the Chicago Bears open the door.

I have been cautioned by multiple people not to jump to conclusions about the Commanders’ hire of former USC quarterbacks coach Kliff Kingsbury as it pertains to the Commanders’ interest in USC quarterback Caleb Williams. Yes, there are those in the Commanders organization who are fascinated with the idea of drafting D.C. native Williams, even if that means trading up from No. 2 to No. 1 to get him. But they also recognize that if the Bears are set on taking Williams at No. 1, there might be nothing they can do about that.

The sources I’ve talked to point out that North Carolina’s Drake Maye played in Phil Longo’s offensive system in 2022, which is a version of the Air Raid that Kingsbury knows how to coach. They also point out that LSU’s Jayden Daniels is a mobile quarterback and talented downfield thrower who could mesh well with Kingsbury, who has coached Kyler Murray and Mahomes. I would expect the Commanders to look into what it would take to draft Williams, but I’d caution against thinking they hired Kingsbury based on any belief or certainty that they were going to get him.

Ryan Poles’ evaluation of Caleb Williams will determine everything.

If he feels the USC standout is the best QB in this class and nobody else is close, then nothing Washington does matters. Chicago will stay put at #1 and take him. However, if they think Maye and Daniels are close to the same level, then swapping places with the Commanders in exchange for a significant package of draft picks might sound appealing. Nobody has a firm grasp on the pecking order of this class. Some think Williams is the best option by a significant margin. Others think Maye is the better, more NFL-capable prospect. Daniels is gaining some steam thanks to his Heisman-winning season.

Caleb Williams also may try to control how this goes. If he is against the idea of coming to Chicago, as some rumors have suggested, he could try to discourage the Bears from drafting him by tanking drills or avoiding meetings. Most don’t believe that is true, but it is something to consider. One can safely assume Washington will place phone calls to Halas Hall in the near future if they haven’t already. Other teams are bound to do the same. Poles has all the cards. What he does with them will be the story of the next three months.

Chicago Bears Reportedly Preparing A Push For Star Free Agent

chicago bears
Nov 6, 2022; Landover, Maryland, USA; Minnesota Vikings linebacker Danielle Hunter (99) sacks Washington Commanders quarterback Taylor Heinicke (4) during the second half at FedExField. Mandatory Credit: Brad Mills-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears have a chance to make this a critical off-season over the next three months. GM Ryan Poles has around $40 million in salary cap space with the ability to free up another $20 million with ease. He also has two picks in the top 10 of the upcoming 2024 draft. That gives him an opportunity to add some serious juice to this roster, enough to make it a potential playoff contender. As everybody knows, what they do in free agency will dictate their decisions in the draft. Some have expressed skepticism the Bears will take a big swing of any kind.

Based on what Jeremy Fowler of ESPN is hearing, that might be an unwise stance to take. They apparently have eyes for at least one big name set to hit the market.

“The sense I get here in Vegas is that Danielle Hunter will be hard for the Vikings to keep. He will have a very strong market, he turned 29 in October, and several teams had interest at the trade deadline. Chicago could look to add a pass-rusher to complement Montez Sweat in free agency and is very high on Hunter. The Jacksonville Jaguars are another team to watch, though they have to figure out Josh Allen’s future.”

The idea of pairing a four-time Pro Bowler like Hunter with Montez Sweat is hard to ignore. Despite not yet turning 30, the Vikings star already has 87.5 sacks. His 16.5 sacks in 2023 was a career-best. Current projections have him commanding around a three-year contract worth $65-66 million. The Bears would basically be renting him for most of their projected 1st round quarterback’s rookie contract.

This isn’t the first time the Chicago Bears were connected to Hunter.

Back in late November, Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune mentioned him as a name to watch once the off-season began. Biggs is the most well-connected insider close to the organization. When he mentions names, it is rarely by accident. There is a strong possibility he was hearing things about Hunter even back then. It makes sense. The Bears need another pass rusher. Hunter is a beast. They have the necessary cap space to meet his asking price. It is a move that would also crystallize their draft plans.

GM Ryan Poles would be free to use most 1st round picks on the offensive side of the ball. One would be for a quarterback, while the other could go to a wide receiver or offensive tackle. It’s a good plan since both positions are considered loaded in this class. The offense would get a much-needed infusion of blue-chip talent, setting this team up to be well-balanced going into 2024. It wouldn’t be the first time top pass rushers left one NFC North team for another. Julius Peppers left the Chicago Bears for Green Bay in 2014. Alan Page went from Minnesota to Chicago in 1978.

Players often like to stay in the same division. Hunter would be far from the first.

Confirmation Teams Are Reportedly Lining Up For A Run At Justin Fields

justin fields
Dec 17, 2023; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields (1) throws the ball against the Cleveland Browns during the first quarter at Cleveland Browns Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Scott Galvin-USA TODAY Sports

People weren’t ready to believe Justin Fields would command a lot of interest on the trade market this off-season. It seems they were mistaken. Thus far, two prominent insiders (Adam Schefter and Tom Pelissero) have suggested the Chicago Bears are virtually guaranteed a 2nd round pick for the quarterback and might be able to secure a 1st rounder if enough teams are involved. It sounds unbelievable until you remember Sam Darnold netted the Jets 2nd, 5th, and 6th round picks. Fields is a better player than him.

Now, you can add Ian Rapoport to that list. The NFL Network insider provided a significant update on the Bears’ situation. According to his sources, the team seems intent on staying put at #1 overall, barring a “crazy” offer from another team. That means they aim to take a quarterback and will trade Fields, who apparently could be in high demand.

“If Chicago does decide to take the former Heisman Trophy winner in Williams, they would almost certainly trade Justin Fields to the highest bidder in what should be an active and fertile market. Fields, who hit his stride in the second half of this season and should command considerable interest, received plenty of support this week from teammates (DJ Moore is one example) with hopes of him sticking in Chicago.”

It sounds like several teams are ready and willing to take a gamble on Fields, hoping the progress he showed this past season can continue.

Justin Fields will get another opportunity.

He’s done enough to earn that. While he never quite blossomed as a passer in his three years with the Bears, nobody can ever question his effort. He put in all the work necessary to be great. There were flashes this past season, but he never found the consistency needed to be a high-level quarterback in this league. If Chicago didn’t hold the #1 pick, there is a strong likelihood they would keep him for another year. Yet they do, and it appears Poles intends to take advantage of it this time.

The lingering question is which teams out there might make a run at Justin Fields. Atlanta, Las Vegas, and Pittsburgh feel like the most obvious ones to watch. Each has clear voids at the position and isn’t in the best spot to draft one. Washington, New England, Minnesota, Denver, and Tampa Bay could all be involved too. If just three of those listed teams convinced themselves Fields is the best option, it would create a bidding war the Bears are looking for. That should enable Poles to secure the trade package he wants.

Drake Maye Scouting Report: Jay Cutler – The Revenge

drake maye
Oct 28, 2023; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels quarterback Drake Maye (10) throws a pass against the Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets in the first half at Bobby Dodd Stadium at Hyundai Field. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports

As is often the case, this is more than a one-quarterback draft class for the Chicago Bears. While Caleb Williams might get most of the hype at the moment, there could be legitimate threats to his chances of being the #1 pick in the draft. GM Ryan Poles owes it to the Chicago Bears to do every bit of homework possible on all the quarterbacks. If he doesn’t and one of them becomes the next great player, he will have followed in a long line of general managers who cut corners when they shouldn’t have. Drake Maye is up next.

Everybody knows the story here—a quarterback who wears #10 and played at North Carolina. Bears fans have traumatic flashbacks to the Mitch Trubisky era. It is difficult not to make comparisons. However, the saying goes, you must scout the player, not the helmet. So, let’s take a look at what Maye brings to the table.

Is Drake Maye a Ryan Poles guy? Let’s find out.

Strengths:

  • One of the best arms in the draft. He can drive the ball with velocity at all levels of the field and fit it into the tightest windows that most QBs can’t.
  • Prototypical size. If you drew the ideal quarterback on a canvas, it would look like him with his 6’5, 230 lbs frame. He has the build necessary for the NFL.
  • Utterly fearless. Isn’t afraid to stick his nose in there when running the ball and will attack defenses constantly, trusting in his ability.
  • While it’s not what he is known for, Maye can make plays with his legs. He had over 1200 career rushing yards and 16 touchdowns on the ground.
  • Comfortable in the pocket. Understands how to operate on timing and rhythm, reading the field until he finds the open man.

This play is a good summation of Maye’s strengths. Georgia Tech brings a delayed blitz and a rusher gets free for a clean shot at him. Maye doesn’t panic, trusting his feet. He reads the play perfectly, firing an absolute dot to his receiver over the middle for a 35-yard touchdown. Those are the kinds of throws NFL quarterbacks are expected to make.

  • Was productive and got eight wins from a supporting cast that was frankly not that good. He has that ability to elevate the players around him.
  • Release is a bit wonky but it’s quick enough to get the ball out fast when pressure is bearing down.
  • Has a moxie to him. Led some impressive comebacks late in the 4th quarter between 2022 and 2023. He always seemed to play his best in rivalry games.

Weaknesses:

  • Accuracy can be a bit streaky at times. There are stretches where the guy can’t miss but then his ball placement will go all over the place.
  • Has a lot of gunslinger in him. Shows a bad tendency to attack windows he shouldn’t and will throw it into dense coverages when he’s feeling rushed.
  • Struggles to read more complex coverages. If opponents disguise looks against them, he tends to get too easily confused.
  • Still carries too many hitches in his drops. Also tends to pump fake a lot. He gets away with it in college, but that won’t fly at the pro level.
  • Known for having a somewhat stoic personality. While not a bad guy, there are some questions about his ability to lead.
  • Can’t hide from the basketball school stigma. No UNC quarterback has ever had a successful career in the NFL to this point.

Pro comparison: Jay Cutler

Like Maye, Cutler built his reputation at a primarily basketball school (Vanderbilt) and spent most of his college career carrying mediocre rosters. He wasn’t great at reading coverages, could get reckless with the ball, was streaky, and had a standoffish personality. Cutler also had a tremendous arm, elite toughness, athleticism, and could put together some dazzling performances. It was always about consistency with him. That is Maye in a nutshell. If he finds consistency, he will be great.

Projection: Top 10

Unless he completely fumbles the ball in interviews, Drake Maye will be a top 10 pick. His caliber of talent is rare. Teams have taken risks that high on guys with far less proven track records. See Josh Allen. If the Cutler comparison holds, the Bears are sure to be interested. Jay was a Pro Bowl player when he played in a Shanahan-style offense with the Denver Broncos. Matt Eberflus and Shane Waldron might see something similar unfolding with Maye at the helm.

Rome Odunze Shares Honest Assessment On Justin Fields And Caleb Williams

rome odunze
Jan 8, 2024; Houston, TX, USA; Washington Huskies wide receiver Rome Odunze (1) warms up before playing against the Michigan Wolverines in the 2024 College Football Playoff national championship game at NRG Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

It’s widely understood that the Chicago Bears are likely aiming to draft a wide receiver given the depth at that position in this year’s draft. Marvin Harrison Jr. from Ohio State is considered the top prospect, but LSU’s Malik Nabers and Washington’s Rome Odunze are also highly regarded. Some even argue that Nabers or Odunze could be on par with, or possibly even superior to, Harrison. During a recent interview on Radio Row with NBC Sports Chicago, Odunze shared his thoughts on both Justin Fields and Caleb Williams. He particularly emphasized Fields mobility and commended his ability to evade pressure and create opportunities for the Bears with his legs.

They’ve got a great quarterback in Justin Fields. I think he’s a baller. I think they’ve got some weapons. But I think they could add me, and [I could] be another asset for them.”

Rome went on to discuss his favorite aspects of Caleb Williams game.

“He’s a special player. He can deliver it inside the pocket. I even saw it firsthand, his ability to get outside the pocket and make people miss and make plays. His awareness to be able to look downfield and be able to make some of the throws he makes — man, it’s incredible to watch. He’s a special player. It would be exciting to play with him.”

Rome Odunze is a great fit no matter the quarterback.

Rome Odunze is exceptionally talented, and his perspectives on Justin Fields and Caleb Williams are fascinating. Rumors are circulating that the Bears might choose a quarterback at number 1. So if Odunze remains available at the 9th pick, it seems he could potentially team up with Caleb Williams for the Bears.

Chicago Bears moving on from Justin Fields for Caleb Williams?

In this week’s episode of the BFR Podcast, hosts Dave and Ficky are joined by Chicago Sports Talk legend David Kaplan. They discuss the Bears quarterback dilemma, Devin Hester’s Hall of Fame status, and much more. You can listen to the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your preferred podcast platform. The episode is also available on YouTube.

Ian Rapoport Reveals Chicago Bears “Crazy” Asking Price For #1 Pick

chicago bears

GM Ryan Poles was almost immediately open to trading the #1 overall pick last year. His path forward seemed obvious at the time. The Chicago Bears wanted to further explore what they had with quarterback Justin Fields. Trading the pick would net them a large haul of draft picks, with which they could continue upgrading a rebuilding roster. The decision looks like a big success. The deal netted them wide receiver D.J. Moore, tackle Darnell Wright, cornerback Tyrique Stevenson, the #1 pick in the 2024 draft, and a 2nd in 2025.

One would think Poles might be eager to duplicate the process again this year. After all, Fields did show some improvement down the stretch this season. There are several QB-desperate teams in the top 10. One would think the return for dealing the pick would be huge. However, Ian Rapoport of NFL Network provided an update on that subject with the Super Bowl almost upon us. From what he’s hearing, the Bears are determined to stay put at #1 this time unless somebody makes an offer they can’t possibly turn down.

“If someone is going to pry the No. 1 overall selection away from the Bears, they are going to have to pay — and pay a lot.

Chicago would need a historic haul of draft picks and overall compensation to move off the first pick of the 2024 NFL Draft, sources say. In the words of one source, it would have to be “crazy.”

That indicates the Bears, who received the pick in a mammoth trade last offseason with the Panthers, are more likely than not to make the pick and land their new franchise QB.”

The Chicago Bears seem intent on starting over at quarterback.

Everything points in that direction. While Fields did improve, it wasn’t enough to justify picking up an expensive 5th-year option. Conversely, the Bears could start over on a rookie contract with any of the quarterbacks in this class. By all reports, it features a lot of talent. The heavy favorite to go #1 is USC’s Caleb Williams, whom many compare to Patrick Mahomes. If not him, there is also Heisman winner Jayden Daniels from LSU and rocket-armed Drake Maye from North Carolina. They could even pull a shocker by taking reigning national champion J.J. McCarthy of Michigan.

As to what would constitute a “historic” haul, the closest example one might have would be in 2012. Washington traded their 6th overall pick, a 2nd round pick, a 1st in 2013, and a 1st in 2014 to the St. Louis Rams for the #2 pick. That is likely the ballpark teams are looking at. It would likely be even higher since the Chicago Bears hold the #1 pick. Is there any team desperate enough to pay that price? If we’re going by pure desperation, the New York Giants (#6), Atlanta Falcons (#8), and Las Vegas Raiders (#13) might fit the bill best.

Washington and New England can’t be dismissed because they may have QBs they really like. All things considered, it sounds like Poles is determined to stay put this time.

Cole Kmet Revealed When Matt Eberflus Began Winning Over Lock Room

matt eberflus
Jan 7, 2024; Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Matt Eberflus looks on during the third quarter against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears made a difficult choice this off-season. Despite several notable head coaching candidates being available, they elected to keep Matt Eberflus for a third season. The logic was understandable. He’d overcome an ugly start to improve the team’s record from three wins in 2022 to seven in 2023. It felt like the Bears were playing some of their best football down the stretch. Continuity often counts for something in this league. GM Ryan Poles and team president Kevin Warren felt the best thing to do was keep him in charge. By the sound of things, players in the locker room liked the decision. Cole Kmet was among them.

He and others became big believers in Eberflus over the course of this past season. Much of it had to do with his consistent message, preaching teamwork, hard work, and effort. If everybody does their job, you win football games. It took some time to get people on the same page, but the results started cropping up in the second half of the season. Kmet revealed that things really began to turn around once Eberflus took over as the defensive playcaller. He started earning a lot more respect once that happened.

Cole Kmet confirmed what others have said.

It’s incredible how things played out. Eberflus didn’t start the year calling the plays. He never had any plans to. However, Alan Williams struggled so much and then mysteriously resigned from the team in September. The head coach had no choice but to step into the role. After an adjustment period, the defense embarked on a remarkable turnaround that saw them play as one of the NFL’s best in November and December. Now, with Eric Washington’s arrival to help as the new defensive coordinator, it feels like the staff is much stronger than before.

Excitement is already building for Cole Kmet and others in the locker room. They felt the team had tapped into something last year. They started learning how to win. With some tweaks to the roster this off-season and hopefully more cohesion with the offensive scheme, the Bears have a chance to make some noise this fall. That will be made easier if Eberflus keeps the defense on track. Based on his track record since 2018, that is a relatively safe bet.

Caleb Williams Might Be The New Jalen Carter For Ryan Poles

caleb williams

More than two months remain to go before the NFL draft. Yet it sure sounds like everybody believes the Chicago Bears have made up their minds about their plans. Every notable insider, from Adam Schefter to Tom Pelissero, has indicated from what they’ve heard that most people around the league think GM Ryan Poles will stay put at #1 overall and select a quarterback. Caleb Williams is the heavy favorite to be that choice. It makes sense. He’s been the projected top pick in this draft for two years. He’s drawing comparisons to Patrick Mahomes. Everything points in that direction.

That in itself should give people pause. Let’s remember who is running the show. Poles may come across as straightforward in interviews, but his ability to enact subterfuge isn’t talked about enough. His best disinformation campaign took place last year. Leading up to the 2023 draft, everybody was convinced the Bears would take Georgia defensive tackle Jalen Carter. Projections had him falling to #9, and all the buzz around the league was that he wouldn’t get past Chicago.

Mike Greenberg (ESPN)

“I do. I think he’s going to be there. I’m telling you what the buzz is everywhere here. All of the buzz is that Jalen Carter is going nine to Chicago.”

Matt Miller (ESPN)

“The best intel I have on the Bears? I’ve heard defensive tackle Jalen Carter (Georgia) won’t fall past their pick at No. 9.”

Dane Brugler (The Athletic)

Bill Zimmerman (Windy City Gridiron)

Polled NFL execs/scouts (ESPN)

“When asked to predict Carter’s landing spot, more than 10 scouts and execs polled believed he would be drafted at No. 5 (Seattle Seahawks) or No. 9 (Chicago Bears).”

Then, the draft arrived. Carter fell to #9 as predicted. To the shock of many, Chicago traded that spot to Philadelphia in exchange for the #10 pick and a 4th round pick in 2024. It had all been a misdirection meant to steer people away from Poles’ actual target: Tennessee offensive tackle Darnell Wright.

Poles might be actively feeding the Caleb Williams rumors.

The question many have is why? Answering that is simple. If teams around the league think the Bears are fully prepared to draft Williams at #1, it means they will have to make more extensive trade offers to convince them otherwise. Poles had the Eagles so spooked about Carter that they offered a 4th round pick for basically nothing. Imagine what he might get from QB-desperate teams for what they consider one of the best quarterback prospects to come out of college football in years.

Now, let’s be clear. The Bears may indeed plan to select Caleb Williams #1 overall. However, let’s also remember it is February. The Bears haven’t even met with the top quarterback prospects yet. There is no way they would have made a determination on such a course this early. Not without ensuring Williams had the mental faculties they were seeking in that position. For the smoke to be this thick so early in the process, it is hard not to feel like Poles is the one orchestrating it.

So, About That JJ McCarthy Bears Theory? It May Actually Be Heating Up

chicago bears
Nov 4, 2023; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Michigan Wolverines quarterback J.J. McCarthy (9) looks to pass in the first half against the Purdue Boilermakers at Michigan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

A few days ago, I wrote an article detailing a little conspiracy theory I had about the Chicago Bears’ plans at quarterback. The seed was planted a couple of months ago when Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune, the most prominent team insider, posted his first article about the quarterbacks in the 2024 draft. Yet it wasn’t about Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, or Jayden Daniels. It was about JJ McCarthy of Michigan. I couldn’t help but wonder if Biggs might’ve heard some things. Like maybe the Bears like him a lot. It felt like a reach at the time, so I let it go.

Things have changed. Benjamin Allbright of KOA Colorado is one of the most accurate national insiders in the business. He delivered a surprising update that definitely added fuel to the conspiracy fires on McCarthy.

In the previous article, I illustrated why McCarthy felt like a Ryan Poles guy. He’s tough, efficient, accurate, makes good decisions, is an outstanding leader, and seems to bring his game up a level in big moments. Poles said he needs somebody who can handle playing in a passionate city like Chicago. McCarthy was born in La Grange Park, just 20 minutes outside downtown. If anybody would understand the people of Chicago, it would be him. Poles loves adding local products to the roster.

JJ McCarthy would be a gamble but a calculated one.

The primary issue evaluators have with him isn’t his mental makeup or even his talent. He’s 6’3, has good mobility, consistent accuracy, and a strong enough arm to make most throws. The problem is Michigan was a run-first offense. They didn’t let him throw a lot. Across two seasons as a starter, McCarthy threw only 654 passes. He might require a slightly longer adjustment period for the NFL before he’s ready. So if the Bears wanted to, say, keep Justin Fields for another year, then drafting McCarthy would make sense.

It is a move that would allow Poles to do both things he wants to: trade down from #1 and take a quarterback. He could deal that pick to either the Commanders (#2) or Patriots (#3) so they can get their QB of choice. Then he can select Ohio State wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr., whom many see as the best prospect in the class. Once done, Poles can turn around and take JJ McCarthy with the 9th pick or move up a few spots to get him. This way, the Bears feed all their masters.

  1. They likely get a future 1st rounder and more for moving down
  2. They get the best wide receiver in the class
  3. Fields remains the starter for 2024, improving their odds of competing for the playoffs
  4. They have what they feel is their long-term answer at quarterback

Yes, it’s a stretch in several areas. Even so, a lot about it makes sense.