The Chicago White Sox made headlines Tuesday by signing right-hander Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million deal.
At first glance, the move appeared to be an attempt to add depth to the starting rotation. But given May’s 4.82 ERA over the last few seasons and his extensive injury history, he projects more as a back-end starter than a legitimate front-line option.
The White Sox already have several arms who could fill that role, with Davis Martin, Luis Castillo and Anthony Kay all expected to return to the rotation. Grant Taylor is also transitioning from the bullpen to a starting role, while David Sandlin, Noah Schultz, Tanner McDougal, Shane Smith and former top prospect Drew Thorpe are all candidates to compete for the remaining spots.
In theory, the May signing makes plenty of sense if the White Sox can follow it up by adding a more traditional front-line starter like Freddy Peralta. But if May is their only significant addition to the rotation, it’s difficult to see how the group represents a substantial upgrade over what they already had.
🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.
The bigger issue is the financial commitment. At $52.5 million, May’s contract is a sizable investment for a pitcher with his track record, and it could raise the asking price for other free-agent starters. The White Sox are also committing significant money to May and Castillo, two pitchers expected to occupy rotation spots despite underwhelming seasons and plenty of question marks.
While that logic holds true for a traditional baseball team that relies on five established starters, the White Sox showed last season that their approach to managing a pitching staff is anything but conventional.
White Sox relievers combined for 766 innings last season, the most in MLB. A major reason for that workload was the team’s heavy reliance on an opener strategy. By the time the postseason arrived, Sean Burke was essentially the only true starter the White Sox could consistently trust.
While some fans found the constant use of openers frustrating, the results speak for themselves. Chicago used an opener 21 times during the regular season, posting a 12-9 record in those games. The strategy helped compensate for a rotation that consistently struggled to work deep into games while creating more favorable matchups for some of the team’s back-end starters when they entered.
With so many pitchers capable of filling hybrid starter/long-reliever roles, the White Sox could continue to experiment with a similar approach. They could stretch out younger arms like Noah Schultz and David Sandlin while using piggyback arrangements to get through games. If several pitchers can consistently provide four innings every fifth day, Chicago may not need five traditional starters. Instead, the team could rely on three established options and use the remaining rotation spots — potentially even three of them — for openers or piggyback combinations involving pitchers like Luis Castillo, Anthony Kay, Davis Martin and Grant Taylor.
The biggest obstacle is getting those pitchers on board. Both Kay and Castillo indicated last season that they weren’t particularly fond of the opener strategy or, in Castillo’s case in Seattle, the idea of piggybacking with another starter. Still, neither consistently worked deep into games last season, leaving some questions about how best to deploy them.
That’s where May could provide additional value. Even if he isn’t a true front-line starter, his ability to take on a more traditional starting role gives the White Sox greater flexibility with the rest of the staff. It could allow them to mix and match their other rotation candidates, move some arms into bulk-relief roles, and experiment with openers without putting quite as much pressure on the back end of the rotation.