There had been growing speculation that Chris Getz wanted to add at least one starting pitcher before the impending MLB lockout. On Tuesday, he made it happen, with the Chicago White Sox agreeing to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with right-hander Dustin May.
Starting pitching was one of the White Sox’s top priorities this offseason, and May certainly adds depth. However, with Grant Taylor transitioning from the bullpen to a full-time starting role and Sean Burke, Davis Martin, Luis Castillo and Anthony Kay all expected to return to the rotation, the White Sox needed more than another rotation option. They needed a true front-line starter, and May doesn’t exactly fit that description.
However, he fits the mold of pitchers the White Sox have taken fliers on in the past: former top prospects with power stuff, injury concerns and plenty of untapped potential. The difference is that those fliers typically came through waiver claims or minor league deals, not a $52.5 million commitment.
On the surface, May doesn’t have the track record to justify that kind of investment. He owns a career 4.12 ERA across seven seasons and has surpassed 56 innings in a season just twice. May underwent Tommy John surgery in 2021, forcing him to miss the entire 2022 season, before a flexor tendon tear cut his 2023 campaign short and wiped out his 2024 season. His career walk rate (8.2%) and strikeout rate (22.3%) are also virtually identical to the MLB averages of 8.4% and 22.4%.
🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.
But this signing was less about May’s career numbers and more about his underlying trajectory and the advanced metrics and other factors front offices look at when evaluating players.
May has been healthy the last two seasons and is only 29 years old, which helps ease some of his long-term durability concerns. He also logged 278 innings during that span, including a career-high 145.2 innings in 2026.
His pitching repertoire is also very attractive, with a 96 mph four-seam fastball and sinker combo paired with a 93 mph cutter and low 90s changeup and 86mph sweeper that generated a near 38% strikeout rate.
That arsenal is a big reason May continues to attract interest from teams willing to take a chance on his upside. After signing a one-year deal with the Cardinals in 2026, he struggled out of the gate, posting a 5.65 ERA over his first 10 starts. He was then traded to the Milwaukee Brewers, but the change of scenery did little to turn things around. May finished the regular season with a 4.70 ERA and a .251 expected batting average against.
However, his expected 4.45 ERA and 3.63 FIP in 2026 suggest he has been better than the surface numbers indicate. Now the pressure is on the White Sox pitching lab to help May take the next step, something his four previous clubs were unable to successfully do.
Credit to the White Sox front office for being aggressive, but $52.5 million is a steep price to pay for a pitcher who figures to be a fourth or fifth starter in the rotation. If the White Sox go on to add a bona fide ace like Freddy Peralta or a true front-end starter like Michael King, then this move looks entirely different.
May would join a rotation that already includes Sean Burke, with the possibility of another free-agent addition serving as a front-line starter. Luis Castillo, Davis Martin and Anthony Kay would likely fill out the back end, while up-and-coming arms David Sandlin, Noah Schultz, Tanner McDougal and former top prospect Drew Thorpe would all be in the mix to compete for one of the final spots or provide insurance throughout the season.
However, if May is the lone move to address the concerns surrounding the starting rotation, it is hard to see how the unit shows significant improvement from last season.
Adding another starter is going to be easier said than done. Considering it took more than $50 million to land May, the floor for the starting pitching market has now been set at a price that could make it more difficult for the White Sox to sign a higher-tier pitcher like Trevor Rogers, Michael King, or Freddy Peralta.