Monday, November 16, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.

Did Will Venable Win Manager of the Year Because He Was Great, or Because the White Sox Were Supposed to Be Terrible?

-

Will Venable inherited a dumpster fire in Chicago. Just two years after being handed the reins of the White Sox, the 43-year-old has been recognized as one of the best managers in baseball.

After being named Sporting News AL Manager of the Year in October, Venable added the Baseball Writers’ Association of America’s American League Manager of the Year award last week.

The news comes as no surprise. The White Sox were coming off three consecutive 100-loss seasons, including a historically bad 41-121 campaign in 2024, so simply getting the franchise back into contention was going to attract attention.

But here’s a question worth asking: Did Venable win because he was the best manager in the American League, or because nobody expected the White Sox to be any good?

🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.

Both can be true. Venable benefited from the low expectations surrounding the White Sox, but those expectations shouldn’t discredit what he accomplished. If anything, exceeding them by such a significant margin is part of what made his season so impressive.

Entering the season, PECOTA projected the White Sox to win 69 games, finish last in the AL Central, and gave them just a 1.5% chance of reaching the postseason.

Several factors fueled the pessimistic outlook. The starting rotation was thin, significant questions remained about how Munetaka Murakami would adjust to MLB pitching, and much of the White Sox’s young core had yet to prove itself at the major league level.

If the White Sox had won 70 games in 2026, the season likely would have been viewed as a success by both the fan base and front office. The organization reportedly was hesitant to part with some of its top prospects at the trade deadline, largely because it did not anticipate its contention window opening so quickly. 

But being so far ahead of schedule forced Chris Getz’s hand at the trade deadline, prompting him to take a flier on Luis Castillo, while making additional moves to bolster the roster with role players such as Brenton Doyle, Huascar Brazobán and Joey Bart. For that Venable deserves a ton of credit. 

Despite a 6-13 start to the 2026 campaign, the White Sox turned their season around, going 78-65 the rest of the way to finish with 84 wins. That marked the most wins in MLB history by a team coming off three consecutive 100-loss seasons. Chicago also became the first team in MLB history to reach the postseason after losing at least 100 games in each of the two previous seasons.

The turnaround marked a significant milestone for the franchise, which reached the playoffs for just the 12th time in its history. It also more than doubled Chicago’s win total from 2024, when the White Sox won just 41 games in the season before Venable’s arrival.

Much of the turnaround can be traced to the culture Venable established during spring training. From the beginning, he emphasized doing the little things right and finding multiple ways to win. At the same time, he gave his players the freedom to be themselves, allowing their personalities to come through. That balance helped keep the dugout lively and injected energy into a young team, even during the dog days of the season.

More importantly, Venable clearly earned the respect of his players. Regardless of the score, the White Sox continued to play with urgency, running hard down the line and refusing to give away outs, a level of effort that wasn’t always present during Chicago’s last “contention window.” 

Anyone who followed the White Sox throughout the 2026 season had plenty of reasons to grow frustrated with Venable’s frequent use of openers and his reliance on matchup-based decisions.

But while the 2026 roster was far more talented than the previous year’s club, it was far from a complete team. Venable’s creative bullpen management and willingness to lean on platoons and favorable matchups helped mask some of the roster’s biggest flaws. He ranked third in MLB in pinch hitters used per game and fourth in pinch runners, underscoring his willingness to make aggressive, matchup-driven moves throughout the season.

Even after a lackluster trade deadline, Venable continued to find ways to compensate for a starting rotation that lacked depth.

Venable used an opener strategy to help limit the Astros’ offense, with four relievers combining to allow just four hits in a 6-3 Game 1 win while holding Yordan Alvarez to 1-for-8 across the series. He also prioritized late-inning defense by inserting Brenton Doyle in the outfield and manufactured runs through a seventh-inning bunt and an aggressive double steal in Game 2 that set up Chase Meidroth’s decisive three-run homer.

Chicago swept Houston before pushing Cleveland to the brink in the ALDS, taking the first two games on the road before the Guardians rallied to win the series in five games. The postseason run was another indication of how far the franchise had come under Venable, even if it came after the award voting had already taken place.

Still, Venable wasn’t the only manager with a compelling case.

Kevin Cash, who finished second in the voting, has a strong argument of his own. Tampa Bay entered the season with relatively modest expectations after missing the playoffs in consecutive years. FanGraphs projected the Rays to finish 79-83, giving them just a 25.2% chance of reaching the postseason and a 4.3% chance of winning the AL East.

Instead, Tampa Bay finished 98-64, won the division by 4 1/2 games and secured the American League’s top postseason seed. The Rays finished with the best record in the league despite not entering the season as a projected contender.

Cash deserves credit for getting the most out of a roster that operated with one of the lowest payrolls in baseball. Tampa Bay leaned further into small-ball tactics and found ways to squeeze production out of its lineup. The two-time AL Manager of the Year also continued to evolve his approach, helping establish a culture in which players could get the most out of their abilities.

Cash’s candidacy is important because it shows that exceeding expectations wasn’t exclusive to Chicago. The Rays were also projected to finish below .500, yet they wound up with the best record in the American League. Cash received 12 first-place votes compared to Venable’s 15, making the final result a relatively close decision. 

But was anyone really surprised that the Rays were in the mix? Tampa Bay has a track record of outperforming expectations and doing more with less. The Rays have earned a reputation as one of baseball’s savviest organizations, using analytics to remain competitive despite limited resources. The White Sox, on the other hand, have long been viewed as one of the worst-run franchises in the sport

Venable has been part of the brain trust, helping the White Sox modernize their baseball operations, as evident by some of the creative ways he deployed his pitching staff, and for that he deserves slightly more credit this season. 

Then there is Chad Tracy, who was thrust into an entirely different challenge in Boston. Tracy was managing Triple-A Worcester when the Red Sox unexpectedly fired Alex Cora in April and promoted him to the major league job.

Boston was 32-46 on June 25, carrying the worst winning percentage in the American League. From that point forward, the Red Sox went on a 32-5 run that completely changed the trajectory of their season. Boston ultimately went 77-58 under Tracy, including a 55-29 mark over its final 84 games, to secure a postseason appearance that seemed unlikely just months earlier.

Tracy had an advantage in knowing many of the players from his time managing Worcester, but he still had to earn their respect in a much more demanding role. He brought stability to a team that had just experienced a major organizational shake-up and helped guide it back into contention.

All three managers had compelling cases. Cash led the American League’s best regular-season team despite modest expectations. Tracy helped rescue a season that appeared to be slipping away after a midseason managerial change. And Venable took a franchise coming off three consecutive 100-loss seasons and guided it back to the postseason.

Ultimately, Venable received 15 first-place votes and 111 points, edging Cash’s 98 points. He became just the sixth White Sox manager to win the award and the first since Ozzie Guillén in 2005.

There will always be debate over whether Manager of the Year recognizes the best manager or the person who most dramatically exceeds expectations. In Venable’s case, those two things aren’t mutually exclusive.

Yes, the White Sox were expected to be terrible. That undoubtedly helped frame the narrative surrounding his candidacy. But expectations don’t win games, establish a clubhouse culture, or compensate for roster deficiencies. Venable still had to do the work, and he consistently found ways to get more out of his team than anyone anticipated.

He deserves credit for that — not an asterisk.

Mitchell Kaminski
Mitchell Kaminski
I’m a Bradley University Sports Communication graduate with five years covering the Chicago White Sox and experience broadcasting for ESPN-partnered Bradley Athletics. I’ve worked as a radio play-by-play announcer in Missouri and currently serve as a TV reporter for ABC 17 News in Columbia.

Chicago SportsNEWS
Recommended for you

← More Chicago White Sox News & Rumors | SportsMockery Home