On a rainy night in Cleveland, the Chicago White Sox saw their season end with a whimper.
In Game 2 of the ALDS, Gavin Williams set a Cleveland Guardians franchise record with 11 strikeouts in a postseason game. In Game 3, the Chicago White Sox set an MLB record with 19 strikeouts, the most by a team in a nine-inning postseason game. Both records fell in a decisive Game 5 in Cleveland on Saturday night.
The White Sox struck out 21 times at the plate, with Williams accounting for 12 of those punchouts through five innings. In the end, Chicago couldn’t conjure one last moment of magic in a 2-0 loss that brought a frustrating end to a season defined by improbable comebacks and late-game heroics.
Games 2 and 3 were defined by the White Sox’s inability to capitalize on their opportunities. In Game 5, they simply couldn’t generate enough of them. It wasn’t necessarily a matter of a poor approach at the plate, either. Williams was simply better. The man nicknamed “Big Rig” threw 69 percent of his 94 pitches for strikes, overpowering a White Sox lineup that had no answers.
🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.
Over the five-game series, the White Sox struck out 75 times, the most by any team over a 45-inning span in modern MLB history, including both the regular season and postseason.
Unfortunately, two of their three most prolific home run hitters, Munetaka Murakami and Colson Montgomery, failed to make a significant impact at the plate in the series, with Murakami’s Game 2 homer serving as the lone exception.
Murakami went 0-for-4 with four strikeouts. One of those strikeouts came when the White Sox were only one swing away from tying the game after Sam Antonacci dumped a bloop single into right field in the seventh inning. Meanwhile, Montgomery went 0-for-2 with two strikeouts.
Much was made of the White Sox pitching throughout the series, but when the lights were brightest, their ace Sean Burke rose to the occasion. Burke delivered five strong innings, striking out four while issuing no walks to keep Chicago within striking distance.
Burke’s only real blemish came on a two-run homer by José Ramírez, who somehow connected on a pitch just 0.74 feet off the dirt. It was a well-executed offering in a two-strike count, but Ramírez reminded everyone why he’s a future Hall of Famer, turning a pitch most hitters would struggle to do anything with into a game-changing swing.
While it was a tough pill to swallow, being in the ALDS was an accomplishment in itself. Few expected the White Sox to be in there, especially after an 11-1 loss to the Brewers to open the season. The 2026 White Sox were a fun, scrappy, and well-rounded team that transformed the franchise from a laughingstock into a team respected across the league and beloved by the city. From walk-off wins to contributions from unsung heroes, this was a group that defied expectations and gave the South Side something to believe in, and 2026 will go down as one of the most memorable in franchise history because of it.
But it’s hard to shake the thought of what could have been.
It’s easy to point fingers at Will Venable and his reliance on bullpen games, but Venable was backed into a corner with the roster he had to work with. At the end of the day, the players still had to execute, and they didn’t.
Ultimately, the Guardians had the deeper starting rotation, and that proved to be the difference in the series. The White Sox had one starter they fully trusted, while their second-best starter was relegated to mop-up duty out of the bullpen.
The American League was wide open. The path to the World Series had rarely looked more attainable, yet the front office did the bare minimum at the trade deadline.
The thinking behind the Luis Castillo trade was sound, provided additional reinforcements were coming, given his struggles leading up to the trade. Instead, Castillo proved to be the White Sox’s biggest deadline acquisition and didn’t even make the postseason roster. That perfectly encapsulates the shortcomings of the front office’s deadline strategy. The rotation lacked depth, the bullpen was stretched thin, and eventually, the offense couldn’t do enough to cover those shortcomings. For all the magic this team produced, it still needed more help than the front office was willing to provide.
That’s not to discredit Chris Getz for the roster he built. The Garrett Crochet trade yielded three productive contributors to a playoff team, while the addition of Randal Grichuk proved instrumental to the offense. Erick Fedde, Anthony Kay and Sean Newcomb also provided valuable contributions to the pitching staff. But tomorrow is promised to no one, and at times, it felt like the White Sox were content with being a year ahead of schedule rather than seizing an opportunity to go even further.
It will be a long offseason on the South Side. The White Sox proved they belong on this stage in 2026. Now it’s up to the front office to make sure this wasn’t their best chance to go even further.
