Learning from mistakes is a key part of life for everyone, but especially for General Managers of MLB teams. The trade the White Sox pulled off last night falls into that category for Chris Getz. He shipped Luis Castillo and Davis Martin to the Colorado Rockies for two prospects in what can only be described as a pure salary dump move, officially ending one of the worst trade sequences the organization has made in recent memory.
The chain of events that led to this predicament is the worst-case scenario and reflects poorly on Getz’s decision-making. He signed reliever Seranthony Domínguez to a two-year/$20 million contract in January, only to trade him to the Seattle Mariners after 43 mediocre appearances as part of the package for Castillo at the trade deadline. The hope was that Castillo, a three-time All-Star, would provide a boost to the White Sox starting rotation, but there were red flags from the moment the trade was announced.
Castillo performed poorly with the Mariners prior to the trade and many of his metrics were heading in the wrong direction. He was also owed $14 million more for the 2027 season than Domínguez, turning what was already a bad signing into an even bigger financial burden. To make matters worse, the White Sox included catching prospect Boston Smith along with Domínguez. Smith ended up hitting 31 home runs across multiple levels in the White Sox and Mariners farm systems in 2026 and looks to be a potentially useful player heading into the future.
Cutting Losses
To say Castillo was bad with the White Sox would be an understatement. He appeared in nine games total, giving up 29 earned runs across 31 innings with nine home runs allowed. He was ultimately placed on the 15-day injured list with a right shoulder impingement towards the end of the regular season and didn’t pitch in the playoffs. Whether it was an actual injury or just an excuse to get him off the roster, it is undeniable that he didn’t help the team at all. If anything, he actively hurt them because of his poor performance.
🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.
With the White Sox looking to build on their surprising 2026 season, Castillo’s contract was a major eyesore on the books and represented an obstacle moving forward. He was owed more than $22 million for the 2027 campaign, a huge financial commitment for the pitcher he is at this stage of his career. He was also clogging up space on the roster and preventing the White Sox from using that spot on a better pitcher. The trade Getz made last night is an example of admitting a mistake and fixing it before it cost the team additional wins.
Increased Financial Flexibility
The Rockies are taking on Castillo’s entire 2027 salary in this deal and will receive Davis Martin along with Castillo in exchange for doing so. It is a shrewd move by Colorado, a team that has historically struggled to attract quality pitching because of the challenges of pitching in Coors Field, to take on a bad salary to acquire a potential long-term rotation piece in the form of Martin. For the White Sox, parting with Martin in a trade like this isn’t ideal, but getting Castillo’s money off the books now provides them with additional financial flexibility. Those funds will likely be reallocated to the top of the free agent starting pitcher market. Freddy Peralta, Michael King, and Trevor Rogers are all now logical targets for the South Siders as they look to continue improving the starting rotation.
Chris Getz Deserves Credit for Admitting His Failures
The sequence of events that led to this point is unfortunate to say the least. There is no sugarcoating that. The White Sox essentially gave up Boston Smith and four years of Davis Martin for 31 innings of 8.42 ERA ball from Castillo. It’s a substantial price to pay for nothing of value in return. That said, no GM of any sports team is perfect. Mistakes happen, and this trade proves that Getz will not let his ego or the sunk cost fallacy get in the way of building the best possible team. It’s an admirable trait that he can admit his failures, cut his losses, and move on. If he uses the money he freed up by trading Castillo on one of the top pitchers on the free agent market, all will be forgiven.