Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 993

Chicago Bears Meet With Promising Powerhouse For Second Time

chicago bears
Feb 3, 2024; Mobile, AL, USA; National defensive lineman Keith Randolph Jr of Illinois (88) battles American offensive lineman Layden Robinson of Texas A&M (64) during the second half of the 2024 Senior Bowl football game at Hancock Whitney Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Vasha Hunt-USA TODAY Sports

Recent updates about the Chicago Bears’ draft evaluations suggest they’re paying extra attention to the defensive line. Hardly a surprise when your head coach is a defensive guy and your new defensive coordinator is a line specialist. Shortly after a large contingent attended the pro day of defensive tackle Leonard Taylor of Miami, another name popped up on the radar. This time it is Illinois defensive tackle Keith Randolph, who stated in an interview that he has now met the Bears twice. The first came at the Senior Bowl, and another via a virtual meeting.

Randolph isn’t the same caliber of athlete as teammate Jer’Zhan Newton. That will likely impact how high he goes in the draft. However, that didn’t stop him from making a serious impact. In 2021 and 2022, he had a combined total of nine sacks and 18.5 tackles for a loss. He also had 95 tackles. Randolph is the living embodiment of a worker bee. What he lacks in pure athletic skill he makes up with motor, intelligence, and a not insignificant amount of power. It’s not hard to see why the Bears like him. Justin Melo of The Draft Network was the one who found out about the interest.

“I’ve been meeting with teams virtually through Zoom and whatnot. I recently met with the Cardinals, Seahawks, Bears, and Colts on Zoom. I have a bunch more scheduled as well. I also met with every team at the Senior Bowl.”

The Chicago Bears remain committed to building on strengths.

The defensive line is the key to this scheme functioning properly. Eberflus needs a deep group so he can throw waves of rushers at the quarterback all game long. Adding Montez Sweat and Gervon Dexter were big wins for the team last season. However, they need more. Joseph seems like a great option for a rotational backup at defensive tackle. He can give them the versatility to play nose tackle while also having more pass rush juice than he gets credit for. There is no question that his background as a team captain means he checks the character boxes.

It comes down to where they may want to take him. They only have one pick on Day 3 of the draft. That is in the 4th round. It is unlikely the Chicago Bears would take him before that. GM Ryan Poles is almost certain to try adding more picks via trade at some point during the draft. If he can get one or two in the 5th or 6th round range, that feels like the perfect range for Randolph. There is no doubt he’d be a welcome addition to an already solid locker room.

What To Expect From Garrett Crochet’s Historic Opening Day Start

Mar 9, 2021; Glendale, Arizona, USA; Chicago White Sox pitcher Garrett Crochet against the San Diego Padres during a Spring Training game at Camelback Ranch Glendale. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

On March 28th, Garrett Crochet will do something no White Sox pitcher has done since 1901. Make his first career start on Opening Day.

The White Sox announced on Monday that Crochet will be getting the ball against the Tigers to kick off the 2024 season. He will be head-to-head against fellow southpaw Tarik Skubal. It was a surprising decision from Pedro Grifol and company, considering Crochet is making a jump from the bullpen to the starting rotation. The longest Crochet has pitched in an MLB gamer to this point is three innings, which came on April 25th, 2021 against the Texas Rangers. During that outing, he allowed three hits, no runs, no walks, and struck out one. 

The last time Corchet took the ball to open a game dates back to his college days at the University of Tennessee, where he made 13 starts over three seasons. The last time he threw over four innings came on May 11th, 2019 when he tossed 6.1 innings with six strikeouts against the Florida Gators. 

That’s not to say Crochet can’t handle the pressure. He found himself pitching in the AL Wild Card Series just months after being drafted and struck out both batters he faced. The 24-year-old is also the longest-tenured White Sox player in the starting rotation, despite being the youngest player since Chris Sale in 2013, to be named the Opening Day starter.

Crochet marks just the ninth pitcher in the last 110 years to make his first start on Opening Day and the first since Tanner Scheppers in 2014. Like Crochet, Scheppers began his career as a reliever. Unlike Scheppers, Crochet hopes his career as a starter is a permanent switch. Schepper’s Opening Day start against the Phillies turned out to be the one of just four he would make in his career. Scheppers lasted just four innings allowing seven earned runs. 

So what can we expect from Crochet? He missed the entire 2022 season with Tommy John surgery. After Michael Kopech missed a year from Tommy John surgery the White Sox threw him in the bullpen for a year in an attempt to build up his workload. Crochet is being thrown straight into the fire. 

Reports during his rehab last season indicated that he looked stronger than ever and his Cactus League results back that up. His work this Spring has earned him a spot in the starting rotation. He has combined for nine scoreless innings in four games with 12 strikeouts and a 0.78 WHIP.

White Sox pitching coach Ehtan Katz broke the news to Corchet that he was getting the Opening Day nod. 

“Heard he had some exciting news for me, thought it was that I just made the rotation,” Crochet told reporters. 

Going from vying for a spot in the rotation to the number one starter is a major leap. It is also a roll of the dice. The White Sox rotation already has a handful of question marks. They need starters who can eat innings to take the stress off a patchwork bullpen that was assembled this offseason. Having a pitcher who hasn’t thrown more than four innings since 2019 is a risky proposition. He will likely be on a pitch limit that hovers around 80 pitches, however, the White Sox have not yet said there will be any limits on how long the hard-throwing left-hander can go.

This spring he has been nothing but efficient on the mound. During his nine innings of Cactus League action, he did not surrender a walk. He will also be facing a Tigers offense that ranked 28th in runs scored last season with a much-improved defense behind him. This improved White Sox defense should allow Crochet to be more aggressive and attack the strike zone. It is also not a bad way to set the tone against a division rival by having a 6 foot 6 pitcher chuck a 100 mph fastball around them during a chilly March afternoon.

Daryl Van Schouwen of the Chicago Sun-Times asked Crochet how many innings he thinks he can last. 

“Kind of the story of my spring is where my feet are,” Crochet responded. “We’ll see when that day comes. If I’m efficient who knows.” 

The White Sox Need To Have This Player On The Opening Day Roster

Sep 24, 2023; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Chicago White Sox catcher Korey Lee (26) scores a run during the fifth inning against the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park. Mandatory Credit: Bob DeChiara-USA TODAY Sports

After letting Yasmani Grandal walk in the offseason, the White Sox found themselves with uncertainty at the catching position in 2024. They acquired Edgar Quero from the Los Angeles Angels in the Lucas Giolito trade, but he was likely not going to be ready until the end of 2024 at the earliest.

This left just Carlos Perez and Korey Lee on the roster to compete for the starting job, pre free agency. But, it seems that Chris Getz did not want to hand the job to either one of them, as he went out and acquired two major league catchers in the offseason. First, he essentially traded nothing to get Max Stassi from the Braves, and then he signed Martin Maldonado to a one year deal worth four million.

These moves clouded Lee’s 2024 season, as it seemed that the two catchers on the roster would be Stassi and Maldy, but this Spring Training could have potentially changed things.

Martin Maldonado has never been known for his bat, as he is a defensive first catcher, but this Spring Training has been abysmal for him with the bat. He is currently 2 for 24 with just one homer. However, he does have a 1.000 fielding percentage and he has caught 2 out of 8 potential base stealers. Overall, just not a great Spring Training for Maldy.

Max Stassi has been a bit better with the bat, as he is 4 for 20, still not great though. He has also been solid with the glove, as he has a 1.000 fielding percentage and he has thrown out 4 out of 14 potential base stealers. Like Maldy, Stassi has been known for being a defensive first catcher, as he has never been an elite hitter.

Neither of these veterans have played as well as Korey Lee this spring. So far Lee is 7 for 20, good for a .350 average. He has added three homers, eight RBIs, and two walks. He has a OBP of .417, a slugging percentage of .900 and a 1.317 OPS. These are very good offensive stats out of the young catcher. However, he has been just as impressive with the glove. He has thrown out 4 out of 14 potential base stealers and has added a 1.000 fielding percentage.

This is a fantastic development for Lee, as last year did not go the way he wanted it. According to Scott Merkin, he made some changes to his swing in the offseason, and it has shown in his performance.

While Spring Training stats aren’t everything, Lee has shown that he deserves an extended look this year. This should be a year for the White Sox to figure out what they have in their younger players. Lee is one of those younger players that deserves an extended look.

At this point, Maldonado and Stassi are veterans that play very good defense behind the plate. Pitchers are known to like them, but they offer little with the bat. The White Sox don’t need to keep both of them on the roster. They should pick between one of the two and let Lee split time with the other.

I’m not sure if that is what the White Sox will do, but they should. But, due to the fact that Lee has minor league options that Stassi and Madly don’t, the decision could be already made. They could keep three catchers, but again, that is very unlikely.

Unfortunately, the likely situation is that Lee will start at AAA and come up due to an injury or continued poor play. Unless Chris Getz shows us he wants the best 26 man roster and does not care about contract status, Lee will start at AAA instead of in the majors where he belongs.

Will New Tax Cut Compromise For Arlington Stadium Deal Bring The Bears To Their New Home?

chicago bears

When Kevin Warren spoke about the plans for building the proposed complex in Arlington Height when he became the Bears’ President, one of the most important issues he wanted clarity on was taxes for the Arlington property. On Monday, village officials announced a new proposal for the team.

The Cook County Tax Assessors Office has attempted to charge the Bears more than $16 Million in taxes for the vacant property, ultimately leading Bears brass to their change of heart. Recently, Keven Warren announced a plan to partially fund a publicly owned domed stadium on the Chicago lakefront. Almost immediately the obnoxious group Friends of the Park voiced their opposition to the plan.

The Arlington Proposal For Tax Cuts Revealed

The Village board certainly did their homework. The plan calls for the team to pay $6.3 Million for the 2023 tax year and $3.6 Million for 2024. An increase of 3-10% based on market conditions over the next three years is built into the plan.

Village Manager Randy Recklaus announced the plan during the village board meeting on Monday, March 18. He brought up tax figures assessed to other Chicago Sports venues in his remarks during the meeting. In 2021, $6.1 million at the United Center in Chicago and $2.7 million at Wrigley Field. He also added the tax bill in 2021 for Sofi Stadium was $8.8 Million, a far cry from the more than $16 Million tax assessors in Cook County tried to charge the Bears for the Arlington property.

Tax Certainty Is What Warren Wanted. Will This Be The Incentive Needed to Move Forward In Arlington Heights?

Five years of tax certainty is what Bears management wanted to move forward with their grand plan to build a sports complex and entertainment center. The plan offered this week does exactly that.

Friends of the Park told the Bears the stadium should not be constructed south of Soldier Field, offering the vacant property further south where the Michael Reese Hospital once stood. One of the concerns FOTP has with the project is reducing the public park area in the Museum District. A spokesman for FOTP dared to call the Waldren Deck a “Park.” The group should ask the City to turn the vacant land at the Michael Reese site into public parkland and keep their noses out of the stadium plans.

If you recall, this is the same group that interfered with the Lucas Museum plans. The Lucas Museum would have brought jobs and much-needed tax revenue to the city. That project bolted to the Los Angeles area after attempting to deal with FOTP.

Arlington Heights Makes Desperate Attempt To Save Chicago Bears Stadium

chicago bears

Things changed fast after Kevin Warren took over as Chicago Bears team president last year. Up until that point, it felt like the organization was on a steady track to build a new stadium on the Arlington Park property in Arlington Heights after a successful purchase. However, the local township and school districts make a defiant stand on property taxes, demanding the Bears pay the value they’d purchased it for. Warren and his people disagreed with that assessment, feeling the previous owners didn’t have to pay anything close to that amount.

Once it became clear the two sides were deadlocked, Warren changed plans. After talking with other suburban locations, he approached Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson about possibly putting the Bears in a new downtown location. Eventually, momentum started to build until a proposal was put forth for a new lakefront stadium in the South Lot near Soldier Field. It appears recent events woke Arlington Heights officials up to the deteriorating situation. According to Dan Petrella of the Chicago Tribune, village official have renewed their efforts to put forth a compromise that would bring the Bears back to the negotiating table.

Whether it works remains to be seen.

Arlington Heights village officials have proposed a compromise over the Chicago Bears’ property tax for the site of a potential domed stadium in the suburb that would significantly cut the team’s tax bill.

In an effort to break the impasse between the Bears and local school districts over the property tax bill on the former Arlington International Racecourse site, the village proposed an agreement to accept the Cook County Board of Review’s assessed value of $124.7 million for the 2023 and 2024 tax years.

The property would be assessed at the 25% commercial rate for half of 2023 and the 10% vacant property rate for the other half, resulting in a total tax liability of $6.3 million, according to Arlington Heights’ Feb. 27 proposal, which the village released publicly late Monday after an open records request by the Tribune…

…Village Manager Randy Recklaus disclosed the proposal Monday night at the village board meeting. He also shared a slide that showed 2021 property tax bills at other developed sites, including $2.7 million for Wrigley Field, $6.1 million for the United Center, and $4.5 million for the vacant but built-out and comparably-sized Sears campus in Hoffman Estates.

In a letter to the team and the school districts, Recklaus wrote that the offer would achieve the team’s goal of reducing its costs this year and next while allowing the school districts increased assessments in future years before a long-term tax deal is negotiated.

The Chicago Bears suddenly hold negotiating leverage.

While nothing is set in stone, it sounds like they’re building serious momentum towards a new lakefront stadium. The biggest challenge is overcoming opposition from Friends Of The Parks, an advocacy group built to protect the local environment from excess building. This isn’t a surprise. The group is against any idea of new lakefront projects, and the Chicago Park District, who own Soldier Field, are notorious for resistance to any sort of renovations. It is what started this whole mess in the first place.

Some have felt that this entire flirtation by Warren with the city was a negotiation tactic to force Arlington Heights officials to lower their demands. If so, it seems to be working. The city believes it now runs the risk of that entire 326-acre property staying vacant, which would do nothing for the local economy. They must find a way to bring the Chicago Bears back to the table. This proposal seems to be their strongest attempt yet to get something worked out. Now it comes down to how committed Warren is to staying downtown.

Bidding A Complicated Farewell to Justin Fields

justin fields
Jan 7, 2024; Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields (1) during warmups prior to the game against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Hanisch-USA TODAY Sports

I’ll say this: Processing the Justin Fields departure has been quite a mixed bag of thoughts and emotions. Those of you who know me and follow my Twitter coverage of the Bears (and occasional rants and sarcastic bouts) know that I was one of the few folks who didn’t jump up and down with excitement the night the Chicago Bears traded up to select Justin Fields.

While the physical talent was undeniable and intrigued the hopeful fan in me, his process of playing the quarterback position at Ohio State didn’t elicit confidence in the analyst in me. I never bought in to the hype before the draft.

Yet when the news came in that Fields was the pick, the excitement from my friends and Bears fandom as a whole was something I hadn’t seen since the Jay Cutler trade. It was euphoria — everywhere. For me, though, the conflicting emotions were difficult to balance. On one hand, I wanted nothing more than to buy into the excitement. This is sports – it’s supposed to be fun! But on the other hand, I just didn’t feel this was going to end well. How do you celebrate when you think you just have to gut it out for a few years until the next swing at QB?

I remember posting this in the offseason after Fields’ tough rookie year that had a few moments of promise sprinkled in:

Knowing what you know about Bears Twitter and their love for Fields (especially back in early 2022), how do you think this went?

Take a look at the replies and the quote tweets. It’s a fun (?) rabbit hole.

But I understood the vitriol towards me at the time – here’s a guy (ode to Cris Collinsworth) who is arguably the most unique physical talent the NFL has ever seen, with a new regime coming in to take over and unlock him. Fans were excited and defending their QB. Hell, I wanted nothing more than to be wrong!

But as 2022 and 2023 went on, it was clearer and clearer that Fields was basically an incredible hhighlight reel and a massive blooper reel all in one. There was too much variance in his play to be sustainable. And after three years, that simply wasn’t acceptable. Chicago had to go another direction.

What made this even more difficult was how genuinely likeable Fields was. The reports of his work in the Chicagoland community, his interactions with fans at training camp and at games, his dedication to honing his craft, and not a single negative thing about him off the field. His teammates loved him. Everyone loved him. He was almost everything you could want at the QB position.

Almost.

But fans – incredible as they are – still had Fields’ back. I remember the unbelievable scene on New Year’s Eve against Atlanta. Fields had one of the best performances of his career at a snowy Soldier Field. With the possibility of this being his last ever home game in Chicago, the fans united to chant “We want Fields!” loudly — a clear message to Ryan Poles, Kevin Warren, and Bears ownership. Despite having the #1 overall pick for the second straight year, fans wanted to see it through with Fields.

And even though I was thoroughly done with Fields on the football field, a small part of me wanted to see a redemption story here in Chicago. I remember when I was officially 100% out on Mitch Trubisky – after Week 1 of the 2019 season. I couldn’t wait for his tenure to be over. But with Fields… it remained difficult to root for.

Alas, after a total rollercoaster three years in Chicago, the Bears did finally cut bait over this past weekend, sending Fields to Pittsburgh for a conditional 2025 6th-round pick. The fact that teams weren’t falling over themselves to trade for him wasn’t surprising to me. But the Bears DID find a trade partner and officially paved the way for their next quarterback. A good day for the Chicago Bears – even though it doesn’t feel like a celebration just yet.

I’m excited for the next guy to come in here and take over a team that looks primed to compete in the NFC. Caleb Williams is the presumptive #1 pick. Drake Maye (my favorite QB prospect in this draft) remains a possibility if the Bears trade back to #2 to recoup some draft capital. But in either prospect, the Bears will enter 2024 with a higher floor than what Fields offered (and higher ceiling, at this point). The future is now.

But I wholeheartedly wish Fields well in Pittsburgh and wherever he ends up getting another opportunity (if he does). Hopefully he does. As someone who remains unconvinced about his abilities as a QB, I’ll always root for him and his success. He is absolutely exciting and is still must-see TV. Especially now that it’s for another team.

Blackhawks Looking To Lock In Another Long-Term Defenseman With Recent Move

Oct 10, 2023; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Chicago Blackhawks defenseman Wyatt Kaiser (44) clears the puck ahead of Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby (87) during the third period at the PPG Paints Arena. Chicago won 4-2. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

A few weeks ago, I wrote about the pleasant surprise that has been Alex Vlasic this season – and about how he won’t be the last one through the pipeline. As the “next Alex Vlasic”, defenseman Wyatt Kaiser has been just one year behind his star counterpart for the past several seasons.

On Monday, the Blackhawks announced Kaiser would be joining Vlasic and the rest of the big-league club, recalling him from the Rockford IceHogs. It won’t be Kaiser’s first stint in the NHL this year, as he played in 23 games in Chicago before being sent down earlier this season. But like Vlasic, being with the team for most of the home stretch of the season could be a major indicator of his future with the team.

Last season, Vlasic was recalled to the NHL on March 28, playing in six games before returning to Rockford for the AHL playoffs. With 14 games remaining in Chicago’s regular season and the IceHogs likely positioned for another playoff run, it should come as no surprise if the team does the same with Kaiser. Plus, with veteran defenseman Connor Murphy still on injured reserve with a week-to-week label, Kaiser will have every opportunity to show he belongs in the NHL.

Comparing Kaiser to Vlasic and expecting the former to live up to what the latter has already done is a tall order, as Vlasic has already become one of the best statistical defensemen in the league – he’s more than sound defensively at 22 years old. But Kaiser has been just one step behind his counterpart for the last several years, from their drafts being one year apart to each spending three years in the NCAA one season apart. That trend now continues with Kaiser potentially staying on the big-league roster for most of the remainder of the season. If he makes the jump to the NHL full-time at the start of next year, who’s to say he won’t have similar success?

It’s unclear what the future holds for Kaiser, but one thing is certain: if his teammate’s past performance is any indication, the next few games are crucial for the 21-year-old. He’ll have to prove he belongs at the game’s highest level but has the perfect opportunity to do so with a month to go. If he’s able to turn into anything close to what Vlasic has, the Blackhawks’ blue line could be set for years to come.

Adam Schefter Hints Bears Go Unexpected Route At 9th Pick

ryan poles

The Chicago Bears have made their plans for the #1 pick in the draft clear. After trading Justin Fields, they will obviously take their quarterback of choice at that spot. The only uncertainty left is who it will be. Most agree Caleb Williams is the favorite, but it’s not set in stone. Either way, the decision is made. What GM Ryan Poles will do with the 9th pick remains uncertain at this stage. After watching how free agency unfolded, it appears the plans aren’t difficult to surmise. Or at least that was the case until Adam Schefter spoke up.

Following the addition of Keenan Allen via trade from the Chargers, it feels like the only spot remaining on the roster that is a glaring need is edge rusher. They have Montez Sweat, but nobody viable to play across from him. Taking one at #9 feels like the obvious decision, pairing him with a young, athletic, and inexpensive talent. They could also double down at wide receiver since it’s such a strong class. Allen will be 32 this year, don’t forget.

Schefter suggests they may go in a different direction.

Adam Schefter hints the Bears might not be totally set on Braxton Jones.

The former 5th round pick was a surprise hit as a rookie in 2022 and played well last season. However, he missed time due to a neck injury. There are also lingering concerns about his ability to handle power rushers. More than anything, what may drive this decision is the presence of a strong offensive tackle class. JC Latham, Joe Alt, and Olu Fashanu are all viewed as possible Pro Bowl-caliber left tackle. The fact Alt gets compared to Eric Fisher, the former Pro Bowler in Kansas City whom Poles helped draft, can’t be ignored.

If Adam Schefter is correct, it’s hard to blame the Bears for thinking this way. The key to long-term success for a young quarterback is two factors: his weapons and his protection. Adding Allen addressed the former. If they’re not convinced about Jones’ long-term viability, then taking a tackle at #9 would help solidify the latter. Having two top 10 picks as the bookends of your offensive line is never a bad thing. Chicago did something similar with Keith Van Horne and Jimbo Covert in the 1980s. That worked out pretty well.

Everything comes down to who is available at #9. There is a real possibility every tackle will still be on the board as other teams focus on the quarterbacks, wide receivers, and pass rushers.

Chicago Bears Arrived In Force To Watch Top Draft Interior Pass Rusher

chicago bears
Sep 23, 2023; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Miami Hurricanes defensive lineman Leonard Taylor III (56) celebrates his sack in the second half against the Temple Owls at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Andy Lewis-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears may only have four picks in the upcoming draft, but that could easily change. GM Ryan Poles and head coach Matt Eberflus need to make sure they’re informed on every prospect possible, especially at positions of need. One of them is the defensive line. While adding Montez Sweat was a huge win for the team, they still have question marks at both the second edge rush spot and the three-technique interior pass rusher. Both Yannick Ingakoue and Justin Jones left as free agents. Replacing them must be a priority.

It appears the Bears understand this and are operating with a sense of urgency. One notable player seems to be in their sights. Tony Pauline of Sportskeedia reported that no fewer than six team representatives were present at the Miami Hurricanes pro day. While it is where two of the draft’s top safeties reside, it is also home to one of its top interior pass rushers. That is Leonard Taylor, who has similar dimensions and capability to former 3rd round pick Zacch Pickens. It isn’t hard to understand their apparent interest.

The Chicago Bears must figure out who Taylor is.

He was terrific in 2022, notching three sacks and 10.5 tackles for a loss in 12 games for the Hurricanes. However, he regressed last year with only one sack and 3.5 tackles for a loss. Did he lose his interior drive or was it something else? It’s worth noting Taylor had to play for two different head coaches and three different defensive coordinators in his time with Miami. Developing can be difficult in those circumstances. When he had the chance to work with Charlie Strong in 2022, a proven defensive mind with a strong track record on the defensive front, he thrived.

The Chicago Bears might actually be perfect for him. He’d get to work with Eric Washington, one of the best defensive line experts in the NFL. The new defensive coordinator has a stellar track record developing young defensive tackles. He proved it with Henry Melton during his first stint in Chicago, Kawann Short in Carolina, and Ed Oliver in Buffalo. If anybody can get the most out of Taylor’s potential, it’s him. He’s 6’3, 300 lbs, has 34-inch arms, and showcases more than enough quickness and power for the NFL level.

Whether the Bears can get him outside the first two rounds will be the question.

White Sox Top Pitching Prospects Vying For Opening Day Roster

It is no secret that Nick Nastrini and Drew Thorpe are two of the White Sox best pitching prospects. They have several things in common: they were both acquired by the White Sox within the last year, both are right-handed, both have incredible facial hair, both are near MLB-ready, and both will likely be in the White Sox starting rotation for years to come. The big question the organization must answer is whether or not they will make the opening day roster. The decision of whether or not these pair of young right-handed pitchers will make the team will impact not only the White Sox for this season but potentially years down the line.

Spring Training Stats

Nastrini has had a fantastic spring thus far. In 11 innings, he has 11 strikeouts with an 0.82 ERA and 0.82 WHIP. Thorpe pitched very well with the Padres earlier this spring, though he did not fare well in his White Sox debut this afternoon. It is fair to chalk up that performance to nerves. There is no doubt that Nastrini would open the season in the big league starting rotation if the criteria were based on spring training stats, talent, and needs on the MLB roster. The same argument also applies to Thorpe, despite his rough performance today. The White Sox are dearly lacking quality starting pitchers, and both Nastrini and Thorpe are unequivocally two of the better rotation options in the organization at the moment. However, the decision of whether or not they will make the team is not that cut and dry.

Lack Of Experience

Both pitchers are relatively inexperienced. Nastrini only has four career starts at the AAA level, while Thorpe has none. The inexperience of these pitchers might play a role in whether or not they make the opening day roster, especially in the case of Thorpe. The White Sox may decide to keep them in the minors to start the season for more seasoning and development, which is reasonable. 

Service Time Considerations

Service time is another factor in the equation. Should the White Sox keep Nastrini and Thorpe in the minor leagues for a few weeks to open the season, the team could gain another year of control of their services. These service time manipulation tactics are not new. Arguably, the most notable example is when the Cubs decided to keep Kris Bryant in the minors to open the 2015 season to gain the extra year of team control, even though he had a monster spring and was good enough to make the opening day roster. The Cubs’ decision to use service time manipulation on Bryant was controversial and criticized by many, but they did it regardless.

Given the inexperience of both Nastrini and Thorpe and Jerry Reinsdorf’s reluctance to pay quality pitchers in free agency, keeping both of them in the minors to open the season might be a sound strategy. It would be nowhere near as controversial as the Cubs’ handling of Bryant. Nastrini is likely more MLB-ready than Thorpe, but both pitchers are on a similar trajectory regarding their timelines. Gaining an extra year of control for both these pitchers could benefit the White Sox in the future when the team will hopefully be better, and each pitcher is in their prime.

Positive Outlook

Asked about his chances of making the opening day roster after his start yesterday, Nastrini replied: “Ultimately, whatever the organization feels like they need to do and gives them the best chance to win, I’m going to buy into that.” Thorpe echoed similar sentiments. After his trade to the White Sox, he stated: “I’ve been told I’m in the race for a spot, and I couldn’t be hungrier to earn that spot. So I’m pumped.” Both players have an optimistic outlook, regardless if they make the team out of spring training.

Future Studs

If the White Sox will win anything over the next handful of seasons, Nastrini and Thorpe will likely be at the forefront of those efforts. Whether or not they make the opening day roster is a key storyline to follow for the rest of the spring. My educated guess is that Nastrini will make the opening day roster while Thorpe will not. In any case, both pitchers will be in Chicago sooner rather than later. The White Sox decision as to whether or not they will break camp with the team will give insight into how they view the 2024 season and the trajectory of the team moving forward.