The Chicago Bears have completed seven training camp practices, including two with pads. Saturday’s session was the longest, lasting over two hours. With these practices now finished, there is enough data and film to evaluate which players are excelling and which are struggling. Unlike recent years, the Bears now have a talented roster, leading to increased competition. This means some players cannot afford to have a poor camp this year. Let’s start by looking at the breakout players so far in the Bears’ training camp.
Tyler Scott
Tyler Scott has been outstanding in his second training camp with Chicago, quickly becoming a favorite target for quarterback Caleb Williams. Despite a challenging rookie year, Scott’s current performance suggests that if he maintains this level of play into the regular season, the Bears will have impressive depth at the wide receiver position.
Caleb Williams evades pressure and delivers a 35-yard TD strike to Tyler Scott.pic.twitter.com/ME3VGavICp
Despite being removed from a drill for hitting the quarterback, Sweat has been performing at a Khalil Mack-like level. He is unstoppable and fully aware of it. If he can avoid making contact with the quarterback, he will be nearly perfect. It’s encouraging to see the second-round price tag for Sweat turning out to be a steal, given his performance.
Matt Eberflus threw Montez Sweat out of a drill today for making contact with Caleb Williams. pic.twitter.com/jCmxAmkOMu
Andrew Billings has been a challenge for the offensive line, causing multiple false starts on his own. He’s had an excellent start at camp.
Khalil Herbert
Herbert faced a lot of pressure with the addition of D’Andre Swift this past offseason. However, he has delivered and demonstrated why he is clearly the No. 2 back in my opinion.
Progress Reports
I will provide progress reports throughout training camp, including updates on players who are not listed in the rising and falling columns. Keep an eye out for those updates.
May 10, 2024; Lake Forest, IL, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams warms up during Chicago Bears rookie minicamp at Halas Hall. Mandatory Credit: David Banks-USA TODAY Sports
Matt Eberflus made a tough decision in January. He knew things had to change on offense if the Chicago Bears were going to take the next step. That required a complete revamp. Justin Fields was traded to Pittsburgh for a conditional 6th round pick. Also, offensive coordinator Luke Getsy and most of his staff were shown the door. Eberflus wanted to find somebody with proven experience who could develop the young quarterback Chicago was now guaranteed to select in the upcoming draft. After a lengthy vetting process, the Bears head coach settled on Shane Waldron.
The 44-year-old had spent the past three seasons with the Seattle Seahawks, producing some impressive offensive output despite a big quarterback transition that saw Russell Wilson traded to Denver. Undeterred, Waldron molded backup Geno Smith into the new starter, sending him to the Pro Bowl in 2022. Yet it wasn’t those successes that led to Eberflus’ decision to hire him. Dan Wiederer of the Chicago Tribune spoke to the head coach about it.
Much of it came from Waldron’s ability to convey information smoothly.
Eberflus interviewed nine candidates for the job but was most drawn to Waldron, who spent the previous three seasons as the Seattle Seahawks coordinator under coach Pete Carroll and four before that on Sean McVay’s Los Angeles Rams staff.
The Bears already are convinced they have felt a natural click between Waldron and Williams, something Eberflus believes has been the result of pairing a passionate teacher and an engaged student with an appetite for football knowledge.
“It’s a great combination,” Eberflus told the Tribune. “When you have an elite teacher like Shane, he’s able to make the complex simple and the irregular regular. And he’s been able to do that with a complex offense. You can really feel that.”
During Waldron’s initial interview with the Bears in Los Angeles, he quickly won over Eberflus with his offensive vision, sharp communication skills and, in Eberflus’ words, “his ability to make things clear and concise in his presentation.”
Some of the best trained Shane Waldron.
He learned under coaching legends such as Bill Belichick, Sean McVay, and Pete Carroll. All three of those men showed they could develop quarterbacks. Waldron took lessons from each of them, forming his own methods of communication. It appears to already be having a positive effect. Caleb Williams has shown flashes of excellent processing and operation from the pocket. Of course, Eberflus’ defense isn’t making that easy. They’ve been giving the offense problems through the first week of training camp.
That hasn’t deterred anybody. Shane Waldron knew it would be a process from the beginning. Installing a new offense is difficult. He found that out in Seattle three years ago. Even with a proven star like Wilson, there were consistency issues the team had to work through over the course of the season. By the end of it, things were clicking. Seattle scored 30 points or more in four of their final six games. Waldron must stay the course and keep teaching his players. The more he harps on the details, the likelier it is they will stick.
Jan 1, 2024; Pasadena, CA, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide head coach Nick Saban looks before the game against the Michigan Wolverines in the 2024 Rose Bowl college football playoff semifinal game at Rose Bowl. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports
One thing you can say about Matt Eberflus is that he’s not a man stuck in his ways. While he may employ a defensive scheme some would consider dated, he’s found ways to update it over the years to make it continually viable. He always keeps an open mind to new ideas, and that is why he has found success in the NFL. However, his toughest task is still ahead. His job rests on whether or not he can help Caleb Williams develop into a legitimate franchise quarterback.
The Chicago Bears head coach has followed a good process. He hired a proven offensive coordinator in Shane Waldron. He and GM Ryan Poles worked all off-season to acquire offensive assets like Keenan Allen, D’Andre Swift, and Rome Odunze. Nobody can say Eberflus shortchanged the efforts to help his young quarterback. Still, he knows more goes into this than that. So, he decided to reach out to a familiar face: legendary Alabama head coach Nick Saban. Eberflus played under him briefly at Toledo years ago.
The Bears coach invited up to Halas Hall to watch practice and chat.
“I texted him right after he retired and I said anytime you want to come up and visit coach, please do. He did that. He came up and visiting and spent about two and a half hours together. Basically our conversations were on leadership of the football team and really his process and his cadence and rhythm of working with a quarterback, you know, with Tua (Tagovailoa), with Jalen (Hurts), and what was his experience during that time during the camp phase of it and also during the season.
“I gleaned a lot of information and a lot of wisdom from him and it was great to see him. He’s been a mentor of mine for a long time.”
Matt Eberflus knows the wealth of experience Saban brings.
After all, contrary to popular myth, the man knows what to do and what not to do regarding quarterbacks. Before his epic ascent at Alabama, he made a run at the NFL with the Miami Dolphins in 2006. The team needed a quarterback. He was famously part of the decision to pass on free agent Drew Brees in favor of Daunte Culpepper. Brees went on to a Hall of Fame career in New Orleans. Culpepper was haunted by injuries, and Saban never went anywhere in Miami. Those lessons helped his approach in Tuscaloosa, where he recruited event Pro Bowlers Jalen Hurts and Tua Tagovailoa. He also turned Bryce Young into a Heisman winner.
Keep in mind that Saban isn’t some offensive genius. He was a defensive coordinator for years before entering the head coaching ranks. He was in the same spot Matt Eberflus was once upon a time. If anybody can offer tips on how to handle Williams, it’s him. One can only hope the Bears head coach took them to heart and will be able to implement them into his plans. Try to imagine what Williams would’ve looked like under Saban’s direction. That would’ve been unfair.
Patience is a limited resource in all lines of work, but that is especially true in the NFL. Teams won’t wait for you. If you’re wasting their time and resources, they will dump you for somebody who can actually help them. The Chicago Bears signed guard Nate Davis last year in hopes he could shore up the offensive line. What followed was him missing most of training camp and several games last season due to various health and off-the-field issues. Things haven’t gotten much better.
Davis missed both OTAs and minicamps with another health problem. Then, after one padded practice on Friday, he left the second on Saturday with another undisclosed strain. Head coach Matt Eberflus spoke to the media about after practice. He said Davis was day-to-day, indicating the injury should be minor. However, with Davis, you never know. Either way, Eberflus didn’t seem overly pleased about this ongoing issue. It sounds like he and the organization are reaching a breaking point.
“Availability is everything, right? You have to be available to practice and you’ve got to be capable of doing hard better during training camp. That’s all part of preparing for the first part of the season — to callous yourself. That’s your individual responsibility to the football team and when you’re not out there, guess what? That doesn’t happen.”
Nate Davis is not on a team afraid to cut bait.
GM Ryan Poles has already shown he is more than willing to move on from mistakes. Trading Chase Claypool less than a season after acquiring him should tell you that. Cutting Davis would only net the Bears $600,000 in cap space, but that wouldn’t be the point. It’d free up a roster spot for somebody else who can actually help the team win rather than constantly wasting their resources on the training room table. Undoubtedly, the team is likely questioning his mental and physical toughness behind closed doors.
Fans certainly are. They’ve already grown tired of him. Nate Davis wasn’t even that good when he did play last year. He struggled with inconsistency. If that is who he is, then what’s the point of continuing this farce any longer? Thanks to their trade for Ryan Bates, the Bears have an experienced right guard on the roster. It might not be the perfect solution, but at least Bates acts like he cares. Eberflus sent Davis a message. Either he heeds it and works hard to stay on the field or he’ll soon find himself unemployed.
Jun 14, 2023; Los Angeles, California, USA; Chicago White Sox starting pitcher Mike Clevinger (52) goes to the dugout after suffering an apparent injury against the Los Angeles Dodgers/ during the fifth inning at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Gary A. Vasquez-USA TODAY Sports
Mike Clevinger may have thrown his last pitch in a White Sox uniform. On Saturday multiple reports indicated that Clevinger is expected to undergo disc replacement surgery in his neck on August 1st. As a result, he will miss the remainder of the season.
Clevinger only threw 16 innings in the big leagues this season and was already behind the eight ball after remaining unsigned in free agency until April 4th. He owned a 0-3 record in four starts with a 6.75 ERA and 15 strikeouts. During that stretch, he posted a -0.2 WAR, 11.5% walk rate, 35.2% ground ball rate, and a .295 expected batting average against him. Those numbers were not going to draw any suitors at the trade deadline so there really wasn’t much use for Clevinger on the roster anyway.
The 33-year-old right-hander was placed on the 15-day injured list in May. Clevinger tossed four innings of one-run ball in a rehab start for Triple-A Charlotte on July 14 and was scheduled to make another one on July 23 before being pulled due to neck stiffness.
At the time White Sox manager Pedro Grifol said that the team planned to reevaluate him. The decision to shut down Clevinger for the season is best for both parties. It allows Clevinger extra time to recover before hitting free agency
Clevinger is already not well-liked by the majority of the fan base. He doesn’t figure to be a member of the team once they shift into their next “contention window” and if he was healthy he would be blocking a spot in the rotation that a younger arm could use in the minor leagues.
During his two seasons in Chicago, he owned a 9-12 record, 4.09 ERA, and averaged 7.6 strikeouts per nine innings.
Apr 14, 2024; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Nate Pearson (24) reacts after a win over the Colorado Rockies at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports
Right-handed pitcher Nate Pearson is officially with the Chicago Cubs. The former first round pick of the Toronto Blue Jays in 2017 was traded to the Cubs Saturday for a pair of prospects. Pearson, 27, will be in the bullpen for Saturday night’s game against the Kansas City Royals. To make room on the active roster the Cubs designated right-handed pitcher Jesus Tinoco for assignment.
Tinoco, 29, was recently acquired by the Cubs in a deal with the Texas Rangers. The right-hander made two appearances with the Cubs and did not allow a run in four innings, surrendering just three hits, while striking out three and walking none.
Infielder Josh Rivera and outfielder Yohendrick Piñango were sent to the Blue Jays in exchange for Pearson.
The #Cubs today acquired RHP Nate Pearson from the Toronto Blue Jays for INF Josh Rivera and OF Yohendrick Piñango.
To make room on the 40-man roster, RHP Jesús Tinoco has been designated for assignment. pic.twitter.com/eCUj8KBIze
The 27-year-old pitcher certainly has the stuff of a good pitcher, but Pearson has not had much success at the major league level despite the talent in his right arm. He’s been hit hard this year, allowing 45 hits in 40 innings, but his 28% strikeout rate is definitely intriguing for the Cubs.
The Cubs are hoping that Pearson simply needs a change of scenery to unlock his talent because he does have good stuff.
Nate Pearson is a fun arm because Stuff+ says "oh yeah" and the results say "oh no."
Shapes are plus, command is fine for a reliever, he gets hit, and I'm not confident why.
There’s also the idea that he’s been in the same org since he was drafted in 2017, he’s been hurt a lot and not really improved outside of a pretty obvious usage change this year to lean on slider more this year.
Pearson has struck out 130 batters in 115.2 innings in the majors. The righty is under team control through the 2026 season.
(Previous Update)
The Chicago Cubs have traded for former top-10 MLB prospect Nate Pearson from the Toronto Blue Jays. Pearson, a right-handed pitcher, hasn’t lived up those lofty expectations yet in the majors and now he’s off to the Cubs.
ESPN’s Jesse Rogers broke the news first on Saturday.
The Toronto Blue Jays are trading reliever Nate Pearson to the Cubs, sources tell @JeffPassan and me.
The 27-year-old pitcher has struggled out of the bullpen with the Blue Jays in 2024, posting a 5.63 ERA and 1.55 WHIP in 41 appearances. Overall in his career, the right-hander has a 5.21 ERA in 115.2 innings.
Heading into the 2020 season, Pearson was regarded as one of the best prospects in the game. He was ranked as high as No. 7 according to Baseball America and was ranked 8th in MLB Pipeline’s top-100 prospects list. The right-hander made his MLB debut during the 2020 season as the No. 1 prospect in the Blue Jays farm system.
Meanwhile, the Cubs are sending outfield prospect Yohendrick Piñango to the Blue Jays in the deal.
Cubs trade LF Yohendrick Pinango in the deal, per sources. 22 years old and in AA. Would need to be added to the 40-man this winter by Toronto to protect from the Rule 5 draft. https://t.co/guqbgb9GI0
Piñango has slashed .223/.316/.345, with a 99 wRC+ in 225 plate appearances at Double-A this season. The left-handed hitter began the 2024 season at Advanced A-Ball, where he was great, posting a 194 wRC+ in 29 games. The outfielder is currently ranked No. 29 in the Cubs minor league system according to MLB Pipeline.
Shortstop Josh Rivera is also headed to the Blue Jays.
Return is double-A infielder Josh Rivera and outfielder Yohendrick Pinango, sources tell me and @ArdenZwelling
Rivera, a third round pick by the Cubs in 2023, has not been able to hit at Double-A in 2024. The right-handed batter is only hitting .169 in 253 plate appearances and has recorded a 67 wRC+ in 68 games.
Pearson, who was the 28th overall pick by the Blue Jays in the 2017 MLB Draft, has unfortunately had some injuries throughout his career. Still, with a fastball that averages nearly 98mph, the Cubs are certainly hoping that they can fix Pearson. They recently had success with Julian Merryweather, who was also with the Blue Jays and couldn’t get consistent results in Toronto.
And get this, there’s this unique connection now that Pearson is joining the Cubs organization.
— Ben Nicholson-Smith (@bnicholsonsmith) July 27, 2024
So, with the Cubs expected to trade away a few of their own relievers, Pearson will now have the opportunity to prove himself in Chicago during the final two months of the 2024 season. The Cubs can evaluate whether or now they can truly fix Pearson and then plan accordingly in the offseason. The pitcher still has a few years left of team control if the Cubs decide to keep him on the 40-man roster after this year.
Jun 5, 2024; Lake Forest, IL, USA; Chicago Bears defensive end Montez Sweat (98) looks on during the team's minicamp at Halas Hall. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports
The Chicago Bears defense has owned the first two padded practices of training camp. While this isn’t a surprise, much of it is thanks to the presence of Montez Sweat. The Pro Bowl defensive end has picked up right where he left off last season, giving Bears tackles fits with his consistent, dominating pass rusher. Unfortunately, such relentlessness appears to have gotten him in trouble. One ironclad rule of camp is defenders are not allowed to touch the quarterback. Ever. The reason is obvious. A single mishap could lead to an injury, and an injury leads to a season of Tyson Bagent or Brett Rypien.
That would explain why head coach Matt Eberflus was incensed when Sweat struck Williams’ arm during an 11-on-11 team period. It was the second time in back-to-back days the defensive end committed this act. As a result, Eberflus kicked him out of the drill, lecturing him that such recklessness could lead to an injury that sinks the team’s entire season before it begins. While it is great to see Sweat doing so well in every drill, he must learn to control himself until he gets to face actual opposing quarterbacks.
Montez Sweat is at least one thing Bears fans don’t have to worry about.
He’s already in midseason form, so the pass rush should be viable for the defense as long as he’s healthy. The bigger concern is the offensive line. They haven’t had the best start to training camp. Not only has Williams been under lots of pressure, but they’ve also committed too many pre-snap penalties. This is likely a byproduct of installing a new system under offensive coordinator Shane Waldron. That and an uncertain situation at the center position between Ryan Bates and Coleman Shelton.
Still, there is a long way to go. The offense has more than a month to iron out the kinks, which should be enough time. Meanwhile, Montez Sweat can continue wreaking havoc on the practice field until actual games start being played. The big question is whether anybody else can match his effectiveness. Gervon Dexter has the best shot after what many believe was a great summer getting in shape. This front four could be a lot better than people think come September.
May 23, 2024; Lake Forest, IL, USA; Chicago Bears defensive tackle Andrew Billings (97) warms up during organized team activities at Halas Hall Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports
The second day of pads was a forgettable one for the Chicago Bears offense. Caleb Williams threw two interceptions during 7-on-7 drills, and he wasn’t the only one. The defense seemed a step ahead of everything they tried. Nowhere was that clearer than up front. Montez Sweat continues dominating team drills while Gervon Dexter and DeMarcus Walker get their turns causing problems. However, the biggest thorn in the offense’s side on Saturday wasn’t any of them. It was defensive tackle Andrew Billings.
Only it wasn’t for the reason people would think. A persistent issue the offense keeps having is pre-snap penalties, particularly false starts. Some of that is various cadences, which Williams isn’t used to. Another part is thanks to Billings. According to multiple reports, he has a habit of shouting, “Move!” right before the snap. This caused a lot of confusion with the Bears offensive line, leading to premature jumps. The guys never seemed to find a solution for it.
Andre Billings' voice is a weapon for the defense. Just Billings yelling out "Move" before the snap has caused back-to-back false starts.
The offense has committed at least five pre-snap penalties today.
Andrew Billings doing this is a blessing in disguise.
While it may frustrate fans who want to see the offense click better, these are the kinds of things they must get used to. Head coach Matt Eberflus said a big talking point going forward is focus and finish. Part of the issue for the Bears is their ongoing uncertainty along the interior offensive line. They’ve been rotating centers since camp began, holding a competition between Ryan Bates and Coleman Shelton. Nate Davis saw fit to complicate things further by missing yet another practice with an undisclosed injury.
Now that Andrew Billings knows he can cause confusion with this tactic, he will use it daily until the offense shows they can handle it. That is a good thing. The more you practice against something, the less it should affect you. Eberflus stated that this is what a training camp is for. The Bears offense is learning a brand new scheme. Things were never going to click right away. Still, they have to get things cleaned up. Protecting Williams remains their top priority.
May 22, 2024; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk (30) and pitcher Nate Pearson (24) celebrate a win over the Chicago White Sox at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports
The Chicago Cubs have traded for former top-10 MLB prospect Nate Pearson from the Toronto Blue Jays. Pearson, a right-handed pitcher, hasn’t lived up those lofty expectations yet in the majors and now he’s off to the Cubs.
ESPN’s Jesse Rogers broke the news first on Saturday.
The Toronto Blue Jays are trading reliever Nate Pearson to the Cubs, sources tell @JeffPassan and me.
The 27-year-old pitcher has struggled out of the bullpen with the Blue Jays in 2024, posting a 5.63 ERA and 1.55 WHIP in 41 appearances. Overall in his career, the right-hander has a 5.21 ERA in 115.2 innings.
Heading into the 2020 season, Pearson was regarded as one of the best prospects in the game. He was ranked as high as No. 7 according to Baseball America and was ranked 8th in MLB Pipeline’s top-100 prospects list. The right-hander made his MLB debut during the 2020 season as the No. 1 prospect in the Blue Jays farm system.
Meanwhile, the Cubs are sending outfield prospect Yohendrick Piñango to the Blue Jays in the deal.
Cubs trade LF Yohendrick Pinango in the deal, per sources. 22 years old and in AA. Would need to be added to the 40-man this winter by Toronto to protect from the Rule 5 draft. https://t.co/guqbgb9GI0
Piñango has slashed .223/.316/.345, with a 99 wRC+ in 225 plate appearances at Double-A this season. The left-handed hitter began the 2024 season at Advanced A-Ball, where he was great, posting a 194 wRC+ in 29 games. The outfielder is currently ranked No. 29 in the Cubs minor league system according to MLB Pipeline.
Shortstop Josh Rivera is also headed to the Blue Jays.
Return is double-A infielder Josh Rivera and outfielder Yohendrick Pinango, sources tell me and @ArdenZwelling
Rivera, a third round pick by the Cubs in 2023, has not been able to hit at Double-A in 2024. The right-handed batter is only hitting .169 in 253 plate appearances and has recorded a 67 wRC+ in 68 games.
Pearson, who was the 28th overall pick by the Blue Jays in the 2017 MLB Draft, has unfortunately had some injuries throughout his career. Still, with a fastball that averages nearly 98mph, the Cubs are certainly hoping that they can fix Pearson. They recently had success with Julian Merryweather, who was also with the Blue Jays and couldn’t get consistent results in Toronto.
And get this, there’s this unique connection now that Pearson is joining the Cubs organization.
— Ben Nicholson-Smith (@bnicholsonsmith) July 27, 2024
So, with the Cubs expected to trade away a few of their own relievers, Pearson will now have the opportunity to prove himself in Chicago during the final two months of the 2024 season. The Cubs can evaluate whether or now they can truly fix Pearson and then plan accordingly in the offseason. The pitcher still has a few years left of team control if the Cubs decide to keep him on the 40-man roster after this year.
The Bears have completed day 7 of their training camp, marking the second day with pads on. However, there’s a concerning development: guard Nate Davis, who has had a rocky start in Chicago, participated fully in all training camp practices until Saturday. On Saturday’s padded practice, Davis didn’t take part in team drills, though he was present with his helmet on. Instead, the Bears tried Ryan Bates at guard and Coleman Shelton at center. Davis also skipped 1-on-1 drills but rejoined the offensive linemen afterward and was seen on the sidelines with the trainers.
The Bears’ offensive line has been a major concern, with several false starts (7 unofficially on Saturday alone) and constant pressure on almost every snap. While it’s still early in the camp, the defense seems to be well ahead of the offense, a recurring theme in many Bears’ training camps. Despite the offense’s efforts, the first two days of padded practice have highlighted the gap between the two units. The situation with Nate Davis only adds to the uncertainty surrounding the offensive line.
Update from Matt Eberflus on Nate Davis
After Saturday’s practice, Matt Eberflus spoke to the media and mentioned that Nate Davis has a strain he’s dealing with. The team is being very cautious with this type of injury. Davis is currently listed as day-to-day.