Tuesday, November 17, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 705

Montez Sweat Drops F Bomb Describing Locker Room Mood

montez sweat
Sep 29, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears safety Jaquan Brisker (9) celebrates with defensive end Montez Sweat (98) after Brisker sacked Los Angeles Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford (9) during the second half at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears are left in a daze of confusion after what happened the past month. They went into the bye week with loads of momentum and confidence, sitting at 4-2 with a surging offense. A brutal Hail Mary loss in Washington, two blowout defeats, and a blocked game-winning FG against the Packers have sent them reeling to 4-6 and all but out of the playoff picture. Players seem stunned at the turn of events while coaches are grasping at straws, trying to reverse the slow collapse before it’s too late. Montez Sweat has been in the midst of it all.

The star defensive end has had some difficulties this season. Despite playing well, his sack total is stuck at 3.5, and he’s been battling persistent injuries. When asked about his mood and that of the locker room going into a pivotal matchup with Minnesota, Sweat didn’t mince words.

“We’re on, what, a three or four-game losing streak? I’m pretty fucking frustrated.”

Montez Sweat couldn’t have put it better.

It isn’t hard to gauge how the Bears players feel. They know they should be better than their current record suggests. If not for some brutal late-game decision-making, they would be 6-4. Montez Sweat must feel a helpless sense of deja vu. This was his experience, for the most part, in Washington for years. The team would always have enough talent to compete, but they always seemed to get held back by coaching or quarterback problems. His only trip to the playoffs came in 2020 on a team that finished 7-9. He hasn’t even sniffed a Super Bowl. At 28 years old, he knows his number of peak years is dwindling. Setbacks like this have to tug at a man’s love for the game. It will be interesting to see how he and the team respond on Sunday against an 8-2 Vikings team with all the momentum in the world.

Players the Cubs Could Rid Themselves Of Following Next Roster Update

Sep 3, 2023; Cincinnati, Ohio, USA; Chicago Cubs third baseman Nick Madrigal (1) runs after hitting a two-run single against the Cincinnati Reds during the eighth inning at Great American Ball Park. Mandatory Credit: David Kohl-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Cubs have been busy this week, tinkering with their roster, letting go of some players, adding a few more and by Friday night they could end up letting go of another handful of players following the non-tender deadline.

Entering the offseason, the Cubs had 14 players who were arbitration-eligible and would need to be tendered a contract by Nov. 22, if the team wanted to keep them on their 40-man roster. Out of those 14, the guarantees to be tendered are Justin Steele, Isaac Paredes, Mike Tauchman and the newly acquired Eli Morgan.

The Cubs also have to make decisions on right-handed relievers Julian Merryweather, Keegan Thompson, Colten Brewer and Nate Pearson, catcher Matt Thaiss and infielder Nick Madrigal. Six names on the original 14-player list have already been let go by the Cubs this offseason.

Let’s go over the current 40-man roster as of Nov. 21, 2024.

Right-Handed Pitchers
Michael Arias
Javier Assad
Ben Brown
Porter Hodge
Gavin Hollowell 
Caleb Kilian
Julian Merryweather
Tyson Miller
Eli Morgan
Jack Neely
Daniel Palencia
Ethan Roberts
Jameson Taillon
Keegan Thompson
Hayden Wesneski

Left-Handed Pitchers
Shōta Imanaga
Luke Little
Justin Steele
Jordan Wicks
Rob Zastryzny

Catchers
Miguel Amaya
Matt Thaiss

Infielders
Michael Busch
Benjamin Cowles
Nico Hoerner
Nick Madrigal
Miles Mastrobuoni
Matt Mervis
Isaac Paredes
Dansby Swanson
Luis Vazquez

Outfielders
Kevin Alcantara
Cody Bellinger
Owen Caissie
Alexander Canario
Pete Crow-Armstrong
Ian Happ
Seiya Suzuki
Mike Tauchman

So, who should the Cubs non-tender? I really only have strong feelings toward two guys. First, Colten Brewer broke his hand punching the dugout wall at Wrigley Field in 2024 after a bad outing and at this point I don’t see a lot of upside in the 32-year-old reliever.

As for Nick Madrigal, do the Cubs really need him around anymore? The 27-year-old has been a bust since the Cubs traded for him in the summer of 2021, posting a combined 0.8 fWAR in parts of three seasons on the north side. He battled through leg issues in his first couple years in a Cubs uniform and then after struggling at the plate in 2024, Madrigal was demoted to Triple-A, where he unfortunately suffered a broken hand in June, ending his season.

Madrigal is projected to earn a salary just shy of $2 million in 2025, and if you look at the list of infielders already on the 40-man roster, coupled with the fact that the Cubs will need to add Matt Shaw once he’s ready to join the squad in 2025, then there’s really no need for Madrigal.

I think Nate Pearson will be back after his showing in the final couple months after being acquired from the Toronto Blue Jays in July. I’d be disappointed if Keegan Thompson wasn’t tendered following his rebound in 2024. As for Julian Merryweather, I think that’s 100% determined by his health. You saw his capabilities when healthy during the 2023 season, but this past year was a disaster that ended with the reliever needing knee surgery, which came after he had already missed most of the season with a rib fracture.

I initially thought Merryweather would return at the beginning of the offseason, but now I’m not so sure, especially with the addition of Morgan.

As for catcher Matt Thaiss, he falls into the category of potentially being non-tendered, but with the understanding that he’ll re-sign with the Cubs on a minor league deal. We’ll see how the tender deadline plays out, as the Cubs have to make their decisions final by Friday night.

Free Agents Cubs Should Still Target Following Trade for Catcher

Jul 11, 2024; San Francisco, California, USA; Toronto Blue Jays catcher Danny Jansen (9) walks to the dugout after the game against the San Francisco Giants at Oracle Park. Mandatory Credit: Sergio Estrada-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Cubs traded for backup catcher Matt Thaiss earlier this week and while he could end up being an option on the major league roster it would be prudent of the organization to continue their pursuit at improving the catcher position. Luckily, we don’t have to guess if that’s what they will do and while there’s never a guarantee that they’ll accomplish their goal the Cubs are reportedly still focused on upgrading at catcher following the Thaiss trade.

Thaiss, 29, was DFA’d by the Los Angeles Angels last week and then the Cubs sent over some cash to LA to acquire the backstop. Despite a decent 0.6 bWAR in less than 200 plate appearances in 2024, Thaiss should only be viewed as a depth option and according to The Athletic’s Sahadev Sharma, the Cubs won’t stop their pursuit to upgrade the catcher position with him.

Via The Athletic.

The same should be said about the Cubs’ catching situation after they acquired Matt Thaiss from the Los Angeles Angels for cash Wednesday. The Cubs saw an opportunity to grab Thaiss — the Angels have Logan O’Hoppe as their starter and just signed Travis d’Arnaud — at a low cost and pounced. But they will continue to look to upgrade the spot.

Miguel Amaya, who did bounce back in a big way during the second half of the 2024 season, is the other catcher on the current 40-man roster. Top catching prospect Moises Ballesteros made it up to Triple-A this past season, but question marks surrounding the young player’s skills behind the plate remain, so the Cubs probably aren’t in a rush to promote Ballesteros early in 2025.

So, let’s take a look at the catchers who are still available in free agency and the catchers who have already been signed.

Catchers Off the Board

Travis d’Arnaud: 2 years, $12 million – signed with Angels
Austin Hedges: 1 year, $4 million – re-signed with Guardians
Jacob Stalling: 1 year, $2.5 million (2026 option) re-signed with Rockies

Out of the three prominent catchers that have signed early on in the offseason the biggest missed target by the Cubs appears to be 35-year-old Travis d’Arnaud. Seemed like an ideal fit to pair up with Miguel Amaya, but now he’ll be the mentor for Logan O’Hoppe with the Angels. The Cubs had previously been connected to d’Arnaud in free agent rumors.

Top Free Agent Catchers Available

Danny Jansen
Carson Kelly
Kyle Higashioka
Gary Sánchez
Yasmani Grandal
Elias Díaz 
James McCann

There are more free agent catchers available, but the list above only includes the ones who had a positive WAR during the 2024 season. Yeah, not exactly a strong market this offseason at catcher.

It’s crazy how a few months can completely change the perception of a player because back in May and June Cubs fans, myself included, were pounding the table and demanding a trade for Elias Diaz. The Colorado Rockies ended up holding onto him through the trade deadline and then released him in the middle of August.

Diaz had an .800 OPS entering July, but then fell off the face of the Earth in the next six weeks leading to his release. He was eventually picked up by the San Diego Padres, but only got 21 at-bats in September and now the 34-year-old isn’t getting much buzz from the Cubs or any other catcher-needy team in free agency.

Danny Jansen and Carson Kelly have been linked to the Cubs this offseason and frankly both seem like they could fit in nicely with the club. Out of the two, Jansen has the better track record offensively, despite coming off a down year at the plate for him, and Kelly has generally graded out as the better defender, although not by a big margin.

Jansen is seen as a top-50 free agent this offseason with a contract projection of 2 years for $20 million on MLBTR and 2 years for $16 million over at Fangraphs.

Out of the two, Jansen obviously provides the higher upside offensively, but if the Cubs are looking for value, then Kyle Higashioka might end up being a viable option.

Pure speculation here, but if the Cubs don’t want to extend themselves financially for a catcher who will most likely be in a time-share with Amaya in 2025, then a one-year deal for the 34-year-old veteran could be right down their alley. Higashioka hit 17 home runs in 2024 for the San Diego Padres, posting a 105 wRC+ in 263 plate appearances. He has excellent framing skills and double-digit home runs in each of the last four years during his time with the New York Yankees and Padres.

From 2021-24, Higashioka has a combined 5.2 fWAR. During that same time period Kelly’s at 4.2 fWAR. For reference, Jansen, despite a low 0.5 fWAR in 2024, has a 6.6 fWAR in the past four seasons.

Long story short, the Cubs need to keep exploring their options at catcher and whether it’s one of those guys in free agency or via trade, they still need to improve the position this offseason. Let’s hope they do.

Jonathan Toews Finally Shares Rare Update On Recovery Journey

Apr 13, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Blackhawks center Jonathan Toews (19) is honored after the game against the Philadelphia Flyers. He played his last game as a Blackhawk, at United Center. Mandatory Credit: David Banks-USA TODAY Sports

When it comes to retirement, some hockey legends stay in the spotlight to a certain degree while others seem to vanish from the public scene altogether. While Blackhawks legend Jonathan Toews hasn’t officially retired, he hasn’t been seen at the United Center since his last game on the ice there and has rarely been seen in public in general.

This week, we finally got an important update on the status of the Blackhawks’ greatest captain and his road to recovery. Toews shared via Instagram that the reason he hasn’t been seen at all during this NHL season is because he hasn’t even been in the same hemisphere.

The fact that Toews has been trying alternative medicine thousands of miles away is an update that many fans didn’t exactly see coming. The important takeaway – he’s “happy to say things are trending.” Toews’ issues went far beyond the possibility of him playing again, and he’s been privately working through those things since his last game in Chicago in April.

The Blackhawks’ longest-tenured captain led the team to three Stanley Cups in an incredible 15-year career. His decline began in the pandemic-shortened 2020-21 season, when he missed the entire season due to what he later revealed was chronic inflammatory response syndrome. His health deteriorated again at the beginning of 2023, leaving the team and saying “it has reached the point where I had no choice but to step back and concentrate on getting healthy.” Then, last August, he announced that he wouldn’t be retiring from the league. Instead, he planned to sit out the 2023-24 season and obviously hasn’t been seen since.

While we would all love to see Toews back on the ice, especially in a Blackhawks sweater, it’s beginning to look like that’s not happening. However, according to Toews’ post, he’s improving in a much more important area – his own well-being. As long as his health can get back to normal and he can get back to enjoying himself, that should be enough for Blackhawks fans everywhere.

Thomas Brown’s Message To Bears After Green Bay Loss Will Shock You

thomas brown
Nov 17, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears offensive coordinator Thomas Brown looks on before the game against the Green Bay Packers at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-Imagn Images

If there’s one positive takeaway from the Bears’ past two weeks, it’s that Thomas Brown might genuinely be the right guy—at least for the rest of this season. Since Shane Waldron’s firing, Brown has stepped up as offensive coordinator and hasn’t looked back. He’s the complete opposite of not only Waldron but also current Bears head coach Matt Eberflus.

Brown has demonstrated accountability in a short period, a stark contrast to Eberflus, who often doubles or even triples down when questioned about controversial decisions. While it’s still early, Brown seems to have a solid grasp of dealing with the media and commands respect in the Bears’ locker room. It’s no surprise his name appeared on recent list of up-and-coming NFL head coaching candidates, alongside names like Ben Johnson. Brown’s rise appears imminent.

During his weekly press conference, Brown shared a notable moment from his message to the team after a better offensive performance. It was a much-needed spark for a unit that had been stagnant for nearly a month, highlighting Brown’s growing impact on the team.

“There are no atta-boys in this game. We play the game to win, and we came up short.”

For the second week in a row, Thomas Brown has brought a noticeably different vibe and energy during his press conferences. However, my favorite moment wasn’t about any of those topics. Instead, it was when Brown spoke about tailoring his play calling to fit his players:

“It doesn’t matter what I’m comfortable with, I don’t play. I can always adapt and adjust.”

It’s clear that the players are buying into Brown. As for what this means for his future, it’s still too early to tell. However, the Bears should keep a close eye on the Brown over the final seven games. He could make a strong case to be the leader of the team moving forward and help develop rookie QB Caleb Williams into the player the Bears believe he can be. But for now, it’s time to focus on Minnesota.

More Details Surface On Why Caleb Williams Got Fed Up With Waldron

caleb williams
Sep 29, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) and offensive coordinator Shane Waldron chat during the first half against the Los Angeles Rams at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images

Caleb Williams apoligized to the locker room before the Green Bay Packers game. He held himself responsible for getting offensive coordinator Shane Waldron fired due to poor play. That is what he wanted to happen. However, don’t be fooled. The Chicago Bears rookie quarterback had serious issues with his former play-caller. Part of it was the non-sensical way he strung plays together or his inability to command the room as a leader. That put even more pressure on Williams to pick up the slack.

Yet one of the biggest sticking points might not be what you’d expect. It wasn’t so much a conflict of personalities as it was an inability of Waldron to operate at a high enough speed. Often Williams would have to wait extra seconds for the coordinator to get a play call in. That would force the offense to break the huddle late, leaving the quarterback little time to assess things at the line of scrimmage. Jori Epstein of Yahoo Sports discovered this when discussing the differences with Thomas Brown taking over.

The biggest was his ability to get calls in quickly.

In his first game receiving play-calls from Brown, Williams completed 20% more passes than any of his past three outings. The 2024 first overall draft pick registered his quickest release time yet, at 2.42 seconds on average, and he applied Brown’s principles to escape with his fewest pressured snaps (in raw numbers and percentage) of his career…

…When he returned to the field, decompressing time was over. Play-calls seemed to arrive immediately.

“Super fast, as soon as a play happened,” Williams said. “Thomas was right on the headset giving me the play and then from there, he just strung plays together pretty well.”

Brown continued to repeat calls in case game-day cacophony overpowered his first delivery.

Williams would listen until the play clock hit roughly 30 seconds, then gather teammates in the huddle from about 30 to 25. He broke the huddle around 20 seconds.

“And now you can use all your different cadences,” Williams said. “Mixing it up so the D-line can’t get a jump on the snap.”

Caleb Williams didn’t feel Waldron was helping.

It probably felt like the coordinator was sabotaging him more than anything. Retaining the massive amounts of information to run a professional offense is already difficult. Doing so with precious few seconds left on the play clock is almost impossible. No wonder Williams often looked overwhelmed. He was trying to process information at speeds that even 10-year vets would’ve struggled with. No wonder they had constant protection breakdowns and pre-snap penalties. There was always a sense of being rushed.

Brown seemed to recognize the issue immediately upon taking over. That is why his first order of business was moving to the booth. He wanted to give Caleb Williams more space and also have a great view of the field. This enabled him to identify what the defense was doing and have plays ready to counter. Once one play was over, he would fire the next one into the huddle. That helped settle Williams down. Calm and confidence lead to better rhythm, and better rhythm leads to better execution.

Cubs Desperately Want to Unload $30 Million Player

Apr 21, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Cubs center fielder Cody Bellinger (24) looks at the Los Angeles Dodgers dugout after hitting a home run during the third inning at Wrigley Field. Mandatory Credit: David Banks-USA TODAY Sports

There are actually two separate reports coming from The Athletic overnight that point to desperation from the Cubs and their desire to trade Cody Bellinger this offseason. Ah lovely, more depressing Cubs rumors.

First, national baseball insider Ken Rosenthal relayed the thoughts of executives around the league, who believe the Cubs aren’t just taking calls, they want to trade Bellinger. However, as Rosenthal makes a point to bring up, is it even likely that the Cubs can find any suitors for Bellinger, who will earn a base salary of $27.5 million in 2025, plus has an additional $5 million buyout waiting for him if he wants it for 2026.

Via The Athletic.

While rival executives say the Chicago Cubs want to trade first baseman/outfielder Cody Bellinger, they also note the difficulty the team likely will face pulling off such a move.

Bellinger, 29, secured a remaining guarantee of $32.5 million — $27.5 million in salary, $5 million in potential buyout — by choosing to remain with the Cubs rather than opt out. Execs often say there is no such thing as a bad one-year deal, but Bellinger wouldn’t necessarily be a one-year commitment; he can sacrifice the buyout and opt in for another $27.5 million in 2026.

Don’t get me wrong, I’ve already written how it could be beneficial if Bellinger had opted out following the 2024 season, but he didn’t and right now it doesn’t really make a ton of sense. For starters, while Bellinger’s numbers declined this past season, he still turned in a fine year, 109 wRC+, 2.2 fWAR, gave the Cubs flexibility on their roster by filling in at first base and right field, which also allowed Seiya Suzuki to excel in the DH role.

Plus, if you look ahead to the 2025 season, while Bellinger may no longer be a $30 million player, he’s great insurance to have on your squad in case something goes wrong with Pete Crow-Armstrong in center field or Michael Busch at first. Sure, those two rookies had promising campaigns in 2024, but it’s never a bad thing to have an established veteran with a good track record like Bellinger on your squad to give you quality depth in case of emergency.

And also, Bellinger could be good again, possibly repeating his 2023 season, which would be fantastic.

I know the big argument here is that you could open up a spot on the roster for a prospect, maybe Kevin Alcantara or Owen Caissie, but there’s just no way the Cubs can enter 2025 expecting either of those players to become immediate difference-makers in the lineup. And honestly as much as we all seem to love Matt Shaw’s potential, his success isn’t a guarantee either.

The other big problem with this Bellinger trade rumor is that if he is moved, the Cubs aren’t actually going to get much in return. At least, that’s the perception right now. Below, Rosenthal’s final thought on Bellinger’s market.

But the $32.5 million Bellinger is guaranteed would mitigate the return in some fashion. The Cubs might need to take back an inflated contract, or accept marginal prospects in a deal.

Meanwhile, Cubs beat reporter Sahadev Sharma also wrote about Bellinger as a trade candidate this winter and again the former MVP’s current value just isn’t the same anymore around the league. But maybe there is one glimmer of hope when discussing a potential Bellinger trade which is the market can’t really be determined right now because the interested teams for him are waiting to see where Juan Soto goes.

So who knows, maybe other teams get desperate later on in the offseason and Bellinger’s value does increase.

With a price tag of $32.5 million, what the Cubs can get for Bellinger remains unclear. There has been interest in Bellinger on the trade market since the summer of 2023. The value of a potential return has certainly dipped since that point when he was performing at an All-Star level.

But the reality is the teams that are likely interested in Bellinger are the ones who are in on Juan Soto. So gauging his market currently is difficult. There are other outfield options on the free-agent market, like Anthony Santander and Tyler O’Neill. But any team that values defense and is looking for a short-term solution in the outfield and upside on offense may be calling the Cubs once Soto signs.

So, on the surface this still doesn’t make a ton of sense to me. We’re talking present day. Bellinger’s value doesn’t seem high and if he’s traded are the Cubs are actually going to save much money to use on another impactful hitter?

Sharma ended his article in The Athletic emphasizing how pitching remains the Cubs’ top priority this offseason, which got me thinking about a potential trade idea with Bellinger. Oh don’t worry, you’ll hate it and I don’t love it either, but when doing this exercise I took Rosenthal’s words into consideration about the Cubs needing to take on an inflated contract and came up with this.

Cubs trade Cody Bellinger to the Arizona Diamondbacks for Jordan Montgomery.

The Diamondbacks are also desperate to shed Montgomery from their 2025 payroll following his brutal 2024 season. The left-handed starting pitcher is owed $22.5 million in 2025 and will be a free agent after that season. Arizona would get Bellinger to take over first base with Christian Walker currently testing the free-agent market and the Cubs net about $10 million in savings.

On the other hand, you’re the fucking Chicago Cubs, go out and sign Max Fried.

But again, even in that scenario the Cubs now need to replace Bellinger’s bat when the team already needs to add more reliability in their lineup with Bellinger still on the team.

There’s really only one route where a Bellinger trade makes sense and that’s pairing him up with one of the team’s top prospects and trading them for a star like Vladimir Guerrero Jr., who the Cubs would then have to agree to a big contract extension to make it worth it.

I don’t know. Trading Bellinger now does not seem like an ideal outcome because at this point how can you count on the Cubs making the necessary moves afterward to make the team better in 2025. Sure, there’s a path, but it’s not very clear at the moment and Jed Hoyer’s the one driving.

Bears Kingmaker Trace Armstrong Has One Connection You Better Not Ignore

trace armstrong
USC Trojans quarterback Caleb Williams talks with USC Trojans head coach Lincoln Riley during the first half of the game against No. 6 Oregon Ducks on Saturday, Nov. 11, 2023, at Autzen Stadium in Eugene, Ore.

The past six years of Chicago Bears football can be directly traced to one man’s decisions. No, it’s not George McCaskey. Well, technically, it is, but there is another who has worked the puppet strings like a master. That is Trace Armstrong. The former Bears defensive end has become one of football’s most powerful coaching agents. Chicago knows this better than any team. He is the one who handed them their last two head coaches, Matt Nagy and Matt Eberflus.

Plenty of Bears fans are stressed out that Armstrong will strike again after Eberflus gets fired this offseason. The name haunting their dreams is Mike McCarthy, the embattled head coach of the Dallas Cowboys who is also on the cusp of being fired. However, he isn’t the one you should pay attention to. Matt Zamek of Trojan Wire revealed why in 2021.

“Trace Armstrong, the agent for both Lincoln Riley and Brian Kelly, played this coaching carousel like a fiddle. He got what he wanted for each of his high-profile clients. He engineered two deals without real precedent in college football history. He just became one of the most powerful people in college sports, joining college football superagent Jimmy Sexton.

Trace Armstrong has made himself a figure athletic directors will want to talk to when they have a coaching vacancy. Few people thought anyone could pull off a Lincoln Riley-to-USC deal. Trace Armstrong did.”

Trace Armstrong has the perfect ammo to hoodwink the Bears again.

It is reasonable to assume that Chicago will enter the 2025 coaching market looking for somebody who can maximize quarterback Caleb Williams. That means someone who both believes in the former #1 pick and someone he would buy into. Lincoln Riley coached Williams for three years at Oklahoma and USC. The two have a strong relationship. Riley even called Williams before the Packers game to offer advice. There is little question the quarterback would probably jump at the chance to reunite with his former coach. Rumors of Riley jumping to the NFL have persisted for years.

Given the rumblings of discontent at USC over his lackluster 5-5 season, it might be the perfect time for him to bolt. Trace Armstrong would almost certainly push for him to replace Eberflus in Chicago. While Riley might be considered an offensive wizard, his track record as a head coach is underwhelming. He’s never once made a national championship game despite a preposterous run of quarterbacks like Baker Mayfield, Jalen Hurts, Kyler Murray, and Williams. His reputation for building quality staffs is also rough. His defenses have routinely been among college football’s worst. He has also never worked in the NFL, meaning the chances of him connecting with a professional locker room are long.

This is the likely result if the Bears try the Armstrong route again.

Cole Kmet Calls Out Green Bay For Cheating

cole kmet
Nov 3, 2024; Glendale, Arizona, USA; Chicago Bears tight end Cole Kmet (85) against the Arizona Cardinals at State Farm Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears suffered another heartbreaking loss last week to their rival, the Green Bay Packers. The game ended with a potential game-winning field goal attempt by the Bears, which was blocked. However, controversy arose after many pointed out that the Packers appeared to commit a penalty during the play. Specifically, they hit Bears long snapper Scott Daly while his head was down after the snap, a clear penalty in the NFL rulebook.

This controversial play has been analyzed extensively on sports shows and podcasts throughout the week. The Bears even submitted the play to the NFL for review, but no decision has been made yet. Unfortunately, even if the NFL acknowledges the mistake, the Bears won’t get a chance to replay the down or change the outcome. At most, the league might admit the error, which is rare in such situations.

Bears tight end Cole Kmet discussed the incident on his podcast, The 85 with Cole Kmet, stating that he firmly believes the Packers committed a penalty and that it was obvious.

“I thought they hit Scott (Daly) pretty blatantly there on that play which you cannot do. We will see what the league comes back with and what they say.”

Regardless of which side you’re on regarding the Bears vs. Packers’ last play of the game, it’s rare to see such calls made at the end of a game. Referees usually hesitate to call penalties like these in those final moments. Similar to pass interference calls on Hail Mary passes. You just aren’t getting that call. However, it’s clear that in this instance, the Packers benefited from the refs’ restraint. That’s often how it goes in the NFL. Sometimes, luck plays a big role in games, and unfortunately for the Bears, they’ve found themselves on the losing side of most outcomes this season.

Sounds Like Ryan Poles Isn’t As Safe As Many Think

ryan poles
Aug 17, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears general manager Ryan Poles plays catch on the sideline before the game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears have some tough questions to answer before the end of the season. It looks like they already have one regarding head coach Matt Eberflus. He was given a third season after improving on his first-year record in 2022. However, after a 4-2 start, the team has collapsed to 4-6, highlighted by two more ugly 4th quarter implosions. It feels like a near certainty that he will be fired at the end of the season. The other question left unanswered is whether Ryan Poles will join him.

The Bears GM sits at an awkward crossroads. He’s done a nice job assembling a talented roster and seems to have finally secured a viable quarterback in Caleb Williams. At the same time, he has some ugly misses (Chase Claypool and Nate Davis) and made the mistake of doubling down on keeping Eberflus this year. Many believe he should be held just as accountable for his failures. Others think if Ryan Pace got a second chance, he will, too. Albert Breer of the MMQB weighed in on the situation. By the sound of it, everything hinges on whether Bears brass feel they can lure a top coach with him in charge.

Would Ryan Poles get another shot with a new head coach? I think he has a good relationship with Warren, but I’d imagine that’ll come down to what the Bears are shooting for in their next coach. Detroit Lions offensive coordinator Ben Johnson, for example, will be very picky in the jobs he’d entertain. Former Tennessee Titans coach Mike Vrabel was already in a place where ownership and front-office politics got in the way, so I’d guess he’d want things set up a certain way, too.

So, how does Warren value the job Poles has done (and I do think he’s done a good job)? That’ll be the question, as I see it.

Ryan Poles is in a difficult position.

He’s done just enough with the roster to make you think he has it pointed in the right direction. The defense is good. The arsenal of weapons on offense is talented. His young quarterback has shown flashes of brilliance. However, his offensive line is still a significant problem, and the coaching staff he helped put together is a train wreck. If the Bears were to hire a new coach, many would have reason to believe the GM is on the hot seat were Poles to stay in charge. That means he could be fired if they have a losing season in the first year. Then, the next GM comes in and may wish to bring in a coach they selected.

It is the exact sort of mess this franchise has made for itself going back over a decade. It happened with Jerry Angelo and Dick Jauron and again with Phil Emery and Lovie Smith. Top coaching candidates may not want to walk into a situation lacking long-term stability. This means the Bears would have to hope Ryan Poles can still land a good head coach from a smaller pool of names, or they must fire him and start fresh at both top spots. Both options bring uncertainty, which is why nothing has been decided yet.