Tuesday, November 17, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2821

The Pivotal Play of Bears Win over Rams Was Made by Forgotten Star

eddie goldman

The Chicago Bears defense as a whole was superb on Sunday night against the Los Angeles Rams. Keep in mind this was an offense that had not scored fewer than 23 points this season. No defense had come close to solving the entire puzzle. Then with a little help from the weather and a raucous Soldier Field, the Bears smothered them. In a game with many heroes on that side of the ball though, one stood above the rest: Eddie Goldman.

Normally people would look to guys like Khalil Mack, Akiem Hicks, Kyle Fuller or Eddie Jackson. They even had an excuse in this game. Mack and Hicks both had sacks. Fuller and Jackson both had interceptions at key moments. Fuller to steal the ball back after Mitch Trubisky had thrown one seconds before. Jackson to prevent a crazy Hail Mary touchdown.

However, the most crucial moment of the game belonged to Goldman, their unheralded nose tackle. One of the toughest times for the Bears defense all year has been the second half. People talk about the 4th quarter the most, which is fair, but the start of the 3rd quarter has also been a problem. The week before, after leading 14-10 at halftime, they let the Giants march down the field to score and make it 17-14.

Many feared with the game tied 6-6 it was going to happen again. Not on Goldman’s watch.

Eddie Goldman safety set the tone for the entire Bears’ second half

The Rams had a golden opportunity. They’d kept the game tied after a terrible first half on offense. Now they had the ball to start the second. One good drive for points and they could swipe all the momentum. Things didn’t start well when they were backed up from the start 13-yard line. Then they lost five yards, setting up 2nd and 15. That was when Goldman struck the decisive blow, dropping Jared Goff for a safety.

That play energized both the defense and the crowd. From that point the Rams would fail to score again the rest of the game, Chicago forcing them into submission. It was such a fitting moment for the guy who does all the dirty work for that front with little of the attention from the media.

Not only did Goldman have that huge sack, but he also mauled the entire Rams interior offensive line against the run, holding All-Pro back Todd Gurley to a season-low 28 yards. It’s a reminder that the decision by GM Ryan Pace to lock him up to a new four-year deal this offseason was one of the team’s most underrated moves.

Kris Dunn Returning Tonight For The Chicago Bulls

kris dunn
INDIANAPOLIS, IN - DECEMBER 06: Kris Dunn #32 of the Chicago Bulls is seen during the game against the Indiana Pacers at Bankers Life Fieldhouse on December 6, 2017 in Indianapolis, Indiana. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and or using this photograph, User is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. (Photo by Michael Hickey/Getty Images)

Tonight the Bulls become a little bit more whole again. Starting Point Guard Kris Dunn is returning from a strained MCL injury.

Kris Dunn is entering his third NBA season, second of which is with the Bulls. Kris has only appeared in one game this year. He missed time due to the birth of his first child and in his first game back sustained an injury to his MCL. Cameron Payne took over the starting role and lost the starting role to Ryan Arcidiacono in Dunn’s absence.

With Kris returning hopefully the Bulls can find the consistency they need at the point guard position. This should also help with the defense as Kris is an above average defender and can shut down elite PGs and SGs.

One thing is for sure, Kris coming back drastically improves the starting lineup. With his defense and scoring ability, it takes pressure off of Zach and Lauri. Let’s all hope Kris can stay healthy and help lead this young team in the right direction.

Follow @smbuzzweed On Twitter For Updates On The Chicago White Sox and The Chicago Bulls! You can also hear me on The OutCasts With Buzz and Juice podcast!

Cubs Rumor: Talking About Jurickson Profar Trade With Rangers

The Winter Meetings have arrived and the Cubs need to make moves. Here are the latest rumor surrounding the Cubs.

So, the Cubs need infield depth and there are several players available in free agency, but what’s going on in the trade market? Did somebody say the Texas Rangers?

So, Profar is going to be 26-years-old in February and has two years left of arbitration. How much would the Cubs have to trade in a deal?

Well, here’s what Evan Grant reported. 

While Machado is the prize for teams seeking somebody for the left side of the infield, the Rangers may have a much cheaper model available for merely the price of a couple of pitching prospects: Jurickson Profar.

To be clear, several teams are in the market for another infielder, so the Cubs will be facing some competition if they truly are looking to trade for Profar.

In 2018, the versatile infielder hit 20 home runs, drove in 70 runs, scored 82 runs, hit 35 doubles and had a .335 OBP. It was his first full year in the big leagues, after missing all of 2014-15 with injuries. His career slash line is at .240/.321/.387. That may not look as appealing in terms of getting another infielder, but if the Cubs are serious about him then it becomes more clear that they want to move on from Addison Russell.

And by the way, Profar’s numbers are slightly better than Russell’s and because of the time missed, you can argue he has more time to develop into a better player than Russell who has been underwhelming offensively. Profar has played 352 MLB games compared to 533 games for Russell.

Yet, as much as you want to hype up Profar and his 2018 season, if the Cubs do indeed make a trade for him, here’s a reminder that the Rangers play in one of the most hitter-friendly parks in baseball. Remember how we all looked at Cole Hamels’ splits before the Cubs got him and he was way better away from Texas? Well, Profar’s numbers on the road in 2018, took a huge dip compared to his home stats.

Profar 2018 home/road splits

Home: .271/.362/.511, 11 home runs, 20 doubles, 123 wRC+
Road: .237/.307/.405, 9 home runs, 15 doubles, 93 wRC+

But hey, those road numbers are still better than what Russell did overall in 2018 with the Cubs.

As far as his versatility, Profar could give Joe Maddon another weapon to use all over the field. He’s made at least 33 starts at all four infield positions and 24 more in left field. In 2018, Profar started 61 games at shortstop, 46 at third base, 20 at first and nine at second.

Anyway, get ready for a whole bunch of more rumors this week.

So, The Cubs Might Just Have A New Number To Retire

No clue why this was announced right before the start of Sunday Night Football, but hey, in case you missed it former Cubs closer Lee Smith has been elected to the Hall Of Fame!

Smith finally got in to the hall thanks to the Today’s Game Era Committee that also elected former White Sox player Harold Baines. Smith got a yes from all 16 voters of the committee.

At the time of his retirement, Smith led all of MLB in career saves and that lasted for 13 seasons until Trevor Hoffman set the new mark for most career saves. Smith now ranks third all-time in saves, behind Hoffman and Mariano Rivera.

Smith pitched the first eight years of his career with the Cubs and there’s no doubt what team he’ll want to represent in the Hall Of Fame.

So, now that Smith will be a Hall Of Famer and will go in as a Cub, does that mean the team will retire his number?

The Cubs currently have five numbers retired for six players and they’re all for Hall Of Famers.

Ernie Banks #14
Fergie Jenkins, Greg Maddux #31
Ryne Sandberg #23
Ron Santo #10
Billy Williams #26

So, is #46 next to be retired at Wrigley Field?

By the way, Pedro Strop who currently wears #46 for the Cubs, is the only reliever in team history to post six straight years of a sub-3 ERA.

Anyway, congrats to Lee Smith!

Fantasy Football Monday: Week 14 Recap

tyreek hill

What a great week of football. But yet, at the same time, what a bizarre week for fantasy football.

The players that you have depended on the entire season to get you to the playoffs absolutely disappeared in Week 14. And yet, somehow, guys like Derrick Henry emerge out of nowhere to give you almost 50 points!

If you have managed to survive, congratulations. If you’re awaiting tonight’s matchup to learn your fate, good luck.

It’s time to recap Sunday’s games and the fantasy takeaways.

1. Adrian Peterson Is Done For Fantasy This Year

As an AP owner in my Dynasty league, this really pains me to write.

AP was turning into an extremely reliable starter week in and week out with Alex Smith at the helm. And then every thing that could go wrong went wrong.

Smith broke his leg and will most likely never play in the NFL again, both starting guards on the offensive line went down with injuries, Colt McCoy breaks his leg and Mark Sanchez has to come in and play QB…then to top it all off, Sanchez sucks and Josh Johnson has to come in and play quarterback for the Washington Redskins.

A huge part of what makes a fantasy running back valuable is opportunity and volume. Talent’s great, but if you aren’t getting the work you’re not going to be useful for fantasy (a.k.a Kenyan Drake).

When your offense literally can’t put together a drive that lasts more than 5 plays for the entire first half, you aren’t going to get the opportunity needed to make an impact.

Josh Johnson is not the solution at quarterback for the Redskins. No one is at this point.

The offense is going to struggle to move the ball and Adrian Peterson needs to be officially moved to the bench if you hadn’t done that already. And it’s a shame.

2. Patrick Mahomes Deserves The MVP Award

I was very hesitant to start Patrick Mahomes this week.

Let me be clear, this had nothing to do with his talent. Nothing at all. But it had everything to do with the matchup and who he was going up against.

Somehow, despite being knocked around like a piñata, Mahomes came through with some amazing throws and finished with a solid fantasy day.

I’m done doubting. No matter the matchup, no matter who he has playing around him or anything else that I can come up with…Mahomes is an absolute every week starter and deserves to be the NFL MVP at the end of the year.

If you have him in a Dynasty league, congratulations. You’re going to have a QB1 for the next 10+ years.

3. Chris Godwin Had No Chance

After DeSean Jackson was ruled out for a second week in a row due to his thumb injury, Godwin looked like a great play in what was a projected shootout against New Orleans.

Yeah, it didn’t go that way.

Godwin finished with 1 catch for 13 yards.

The most infuriating part? He had 10 targets.

Any time that a WR finishes with 10 targets, it’s usually safe to assume that they had a good fantasy day…but not in Godwin’s case.

The bright side of this is that he’s a focal point of the offense and this is most certainly an outlier. However, for it to come in round 1 of the fantasy playoffs is not what you want to have happen.

If Jackson misses next week again, you should feel confident in rolling Godwin back out there in your starting lineups. Things are bound to turn around at some point.

4. Jared Goff Destroyed Your Team

51% of fantasy football players in Yahoo leagues started Jared Goff. Depending on your scoring format, Goff may have actually lost you points last night.

Goff finished the game against the elite Bears defense with throwing for 180 yards, 0 touchdowns and 4 interceptions.

It has to be one of the worst fantasy playoff performances in recent history. And if you started him, I hope that you were able to have Amari Cooper on your team to counteract the awfulness.

Moving forward though, Goff has some very good matchups to end the season against Philadelphia, Arizona and San Francisco (Week 17). If you survived, you can roll him back out there with confidence. None of those defenses come anywhere close to what he just saw in Chicago.

5. Tyreek Hill Might Miss Some Time

Speaking to Peter King of Football Morning in America, Tyreek Hill said the injury to his heel is bad.

Typically, a player will sugarcoat an injury and say that they plan to play this upcoming week, etc. But when a player comes out after the game and uses that language, it’s typically not good for next week’s outlook.

If you got into the next round of the playoffs on the back of Hill’s dominant performance, you might need to adjust and be ready to have a backup plan in place. The Chiefs play the Chargers on Thursday Night Football, so it’s a quick turnaround.

With a player that’s come out and expressed how bad his injury is and how short of a week this is before their next game, I highly doubt Cheetah will play in Week 15.

(Chris Conley is intriguing if he’s still out there on your waiver wire.)

There’s your five takeaways from yesterday’s games! If you have any fantasy football questions, feel free to ask over on Twitter @KyleYNFL.

Here’s What The Latest Kyle Schwarber Trade Rumor Means

All right, so everyone’s been trying to trade Kyle Schwarber since 2016, and back then you had a pretty good idea that this front office simply wasn’t in the business of shipping him out of Chicago. I mean, they said no to the Yankees for Andrew Miller and that’s when Miller was the most dominant reliever in the game. Anyway, he certainly hasn’t produced up to the expectations that the Cubs and fans placed on him, but Schwarber has still been more than decent. That being said, the Cubs will always value him higher than most teams, which is why the latest trade rumor involving Schwarber isn’t much of a surprise.

Schwarber just had a 3.2 fWAR season and yet there are plenty of fans who can’t wait to get rid of him. And there are obviously teams hoping to buy low on him, but again, Theo Epstein isn’t selling low.

So yeah, when Bob Nightengale says that the Cubs have said “not available” in trade talks with teams asking for the left fielder, it’s more, “we don’t want your shitty offer for Schwarber.”

It just doesn’t make any sense for the Cubs to trade Schwarber, who again despite his “bad” season was still one of the most productive offensive players on the team. For a roster that needs to improve offensively, trading away a guy who gets on base at a solid rate and hits for power doesn’t add up unless the players coming back in a deal blow the Cubs away.

Of course, there’s the possibility that a Schwarber trade can happen, but that would mean other moves would have to proceed it. Like, big moves to add to the outfield.

Anyway, the Winter Meetings in Las Vegas have started and you should expect some action from the Cubs this week. Definitely expect a trade by the end of the week. But Kyle Schwarber? Doubt it and if he is dealt that’s going to be a huge move for the Cubs.

Bryce Harper Warming Up To The White Sox

Cue up the clamor and chaos, Bryce Harper is reportedly “warming up to the White Sox” as reported by NBC Sports Vinnie Duber and WBBM’s George Ofman.

It’s more of the same speculation, and I for one am getting tired of writing these stories. And if I’m tired of the rumor mill, I can only imagine how exhausted Sox fans are. The second half of Ofman’s tweet is key to signing Harper: He will sign with the organization that offers him the most money.

This idea can be hashed out in several ways, whether by average annual value or largest total value. It’s been reported that Harper wants to eclipse Giancarlo Stanton‘s $325-million benchmark set a few seasons ago, but if the money is greater for a few fewer years He might be willing to ditch history for a higher paycheck.

But there is more to this story than just dollars and cents. Bob Nightengale of USA Today Sports noted that Harper’s decision will be a family affair and his wife, Kayla has been privy to the pitches from several clubs already. Some of those pitches have lasted longer than 10 hours, and Scott Boras (Harper’s celebrity agent known for his “binders”) compiled a 181-page leviathan of a rebuttal to clubs searching for bargains.

Rick Hahn offered his perspective on how difficult these decisions are for players.

“You have to understand these guys are professionals and they understand deep nuances about each individual franchise,” the White Sox general manager said on a conference call last week. “And from a macro standpoint, the idea of potentially being part of a winner in Chicago has very broad appeal. From a nuanced standpoint, the chance to be part of the White Sox organization based upon what our future looks like, futures that these players are familiar with and understand having either seen personally some of these young players play or video or talked to other players about them, it’s something that they buy into.

“There’s an allure not just to winning in this city. But there’s an allure of being part of building something that’s potentially sustainable and potentially great. Where we were in Year 2 of a rebuild I don’t think really plays a huge role in the decision-making process of what a player is buying into in terms of the long-term future.”

Don’t expect hasty and irrational moves from the White Sox to simply rubber-stamp a deal with Harper or Manny Machado. Hahn explained on Sunday at the Winter Meetings that they won’t “scurry” around looking for deals to make just for the sake of making deals. But the fact that Harper is reportedly “warming up to the White Sox” appears to be a good sign for the South Siders.

New Team Interested In Trading For Jose Abreu

Jose Abreu, White Sox

Executives at the Winter Meetings haven’t even had their cheese danish at the continental breakfast in Las Vegas yet and the White Sox are already fielding interest on Jose Abreu. Besides the Dodgers, who have long had eyes for Abreu, the Astros are now reportedly kicking the tires on the 32-year-old slugger.

Given the return Paul Goldschmidt netted for the Diamondbacks, Abreu would command a similar price. The Dodgers are prospect-wealthy, especially in the outfield, but my gut tells me L.A. will be hesitant to separate from Alex Verdugo or Cody Bellinger. Factoring in Abreu’s pending free agency after the 2019 season and it’s easy to conclude that Abreu’s value is diminished by his lone season of control.

But…after the Cardinals paid a steep price for Goldschmidt, there is hope for a surprising return. Dealing away Carson Kelly and Luke Weaver at first seemed a steep price for one season of Goldschmidt, but Ken Rosenthal reported that many rival executives felt the Dbacks were fleeced in the deal. Kelly is a heralded yet unproven major-league player with a negative WAR in limited action over three seasons with St. Louis. He’s 24 years old and may have worn out his welcome with the Cardinals, so a change of scenery might serve him well. Weaver has been equally frustrating to Cards fans and falls into the same bucket at Kelly in terms of a fresh start. So, depending on who you ask it seemed like a fair deal given the term limits on Goldschmidt.

Jose Abreu #79 of the Chicago White Sox hits a three run home runin the 7th inning against the Kansas City Royals at Guaranteed Rate Field on August 17, 2018 in Chicago, Illinois.
(Aug. 16, 2018 – Source: Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images North America)

The prospect swap for Goldschmidt weighs heavily on a potential trade for Abreu. Both Goldschmidt and Pito are among the top-5 one-baggers in the game under an expiring term. Abreu is set to receive nearly $16 million in salary this season, so he’s not exactly a bargain. But the blogosphere deals in hypotheticals and we’ve got nothing better to do than hurl ideas against the wall on what the Astros might give up for Abreu, at least until Rick Hahn finishes his cheese danish.

What’s it worth to you?

Phil Rogers tossed out the following names to get the ball rolling on Abreu discussions.

J.B. Bukauskas – the Astros’ No. 8 prospect – immediately jumps off the page as a player the White Sox would be interested in. He’s another right-hander in an already one-sided rotation for the Sox, but he has pushed his way to Double-A in just two seasons and could be poised to make a jump to the big leagues in 2019. Bukauskas finished the season with a 2.14 earned run average in 59 innings of work. His season was delayed after a car accident at Spring Training that slipped a disk in the thoracic region of his spine, but he seems to have recovered nicely.

Seth Beer is another name that will get Sox fans heart pumping, although his star has faded as the novelty of a Jake Burger, (Seth) Beer combo evaporated over the past two years. Beer played well in his debut season posting a .304 batting average and an .885 OPS at three levels of A-ball. He also smacked 12 home runs, displaying the power potential scouts have hailed him with.

The problem with Bukauskas and Beer, and what makes them legitimate players to consider in this type of deal, is that they are one-trick ponies. Bukauskas profiles as a late-inning reliever or closer while Beer is a lumbering first baseman without much added value. If Beer doesn’t hit and hit well, he’s bench player that bounces around the majors. For Bukauskas, it’s a question of where he profiles. The Astros believe he can remain a starter, but with the White Sox stable of flamethrowing starters, Bukauskas might be a bullpen option.

But let’s get real. There’s no way the White Sox will trade Jose Abreu for anything less than both Beer and Bukauskas as well as one other role player. In fact, my gut tells me the White Sox will extend Abreu before making a deal. Maybe Abreu’s agent won’t let that happen, but with the talent around the league at that position at quite a high level, Abreu would be wise to cut a long-term deal to take him into the golden years of his career.

Seeds of Bears Defense Smothering Rams Started on Flight Home from NY

chicago bears defense

The Chicago Bears defense was unveiling a form it hasn’t had in a long time. There’s nothing like watching that navy blue flying around Soldier Field on a cold night in December. It gave one memories of that great even back in 2005 when Brian Urlacher and his crew shut down the mighty Michael Vick at the peak of his powers. Smothering the Rams as they did, there’s no longer question this defense is for real.

The numbers prove that. They held the Los Angeles Rams, the #1 offense in football, to six points. It was the lowest total of the Sean McVay era. Todd Gurley ran for a season-low 28 yards and did not score a touchdown. Jared Goff threw a career-high four interceptions. It was a clinic of defensive football against a team that had scored 54 points less than a month ago.

Head coach Matt Nagy admitted even he was surprised by how great the defense was and couldn’t say enough about their effort. So how in the world did it happen? According to Albert Breer of the MMQB, the seeds for this domination were actually planted a week earlier following the crushing loss in New York to the Giants.

Giants loss motivated Chicago Bears defense to crush mighty Rams

Everybody remembers what happened the week before. The Bears defense went into the game against a 3-8 Giants team that looked soft on paper. They could do their thing and take care of business. Except they forgot this is the NFL and it doesn’t always work like that. After a strong first half, things went wrong in the second. Saquon Barkley got going on the ground, finishing with 125 yards and New York scored 17 points.

It was a humiliating sequence. One that Nagy said they were starting to address even before getting back to Chicago.

So … could Nagy see this coming? Sort of. The coach was curious all week about how the players would manage a heart-breaking loss to the Giants the previous Sunday. He saw them handle it on the flight home from Jersey with a “we got this” ownership that he’d witnessed after previous losses. He also got a good week of practice out of them. But it wasn’t until Saturday night at the team hotel that he really knew.

“You know what it was? I noticed a looseness, and a calmness, which I thought was really neat,” Nagy said. “Going into a game like this, where you get flexed, and it’s against one of the best teams in the NFL, we haven’t been in that situation before. So for them to react the way that they did—I could feel it out on the field, they felt confident, they felt good playing together.”

One of the common aspects of good units is they play pissed off after having a bad game. In 1985, after allowing 38 points to the Dolphins in their only the loss of the season, the Bears defense allowed just 43 total in their remaining six games including the playoffs. After giving up 338 yards and 23 points last week, this Bears defense responded by allowing 214 yards and six points to the best offense in the NFL. That’s beyond impressive.

Controversy Boils Over Baines’ Ascension To MLB Hall Of Fame

Harold Baines of the Chicago White Sox looks on during an MLB game at Comiskey Park in Chicago, Illinois. Baines played for the White Sox from 1980-1989-1993, 1996-1997 and 2000-2001. (Jan. 4, 2011 - Source: Ron Vesely/Getty Images North America)

After news of Harold Baines and Lee Smith‘s election to the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame, many stat-heads and number-crunchers took to social media lambasting the decision. Unknown immediately after the decision, the Baseball Writers Association of America had not provided the victory to the pair. Instead, the Veteran’s Committee had opened the door for Baines and Smith to join the hallowed halls.

Smith seemed to be an acceptable choice by the new baseball literati, but Baines was a downright outrage.

Aaron Gleeman is Editor-in-Chief of Baseball Prospectus and he sure slammed Baines getting backdoored into the Hall. There were others from the new guard of analysis that echoed Gleeman’s consternation.

Rob Neyer is the commissioner of the West Coast League, a wood-bat summer league for college players, similar to the historic Cape Cod Baseball League. He has also written a few books, which used to mean something. There are plenty of these leagues scattered around the country from Alaska to South Carolina, and the West Coast League is NOT the Cape Cod league. With that aside, Neyer had some strong words on Baines induction. In fact, after his tweet slipped through a gauntlet of dissenters he continued defending his take by asking where the hard evidence existed for Baines induction?

There’s no denying that Baines is a fringy candidate for the Hall of Fame. His career WAR is 38.7, far below the average hall member. The Veteran’s Committee is designed to reward players that impacted the game in ways incalculable by sabermetrics and modern measures of excellence. Era committees comprise the 16-member panel where they consider several factors in making a decision.

The Eras Committees, formerly known as the Veterans Committee, consider retired Major League Baseball players no longer eligible for election by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA), along with managers, umpires and executives, whose greatest contributions to the game were realized in one of three eras. Committees meet at the MLB Winter Meetings.

The Eras Committee has been a part of the Hall of Fame voting process since the first class of electees in 1936, with the first Eras Committee electees coming in 1937. In all its forms, the Eras Committee has elected 165 individuals (96 major leaguers, 28 executives, 22 managers, 10 umpires and nine Negro Leaguers) to the Hall of Fame.

Each era is composed of 16 members and given and assigned two classes for induction every five years. The Modern Baseball era (1970-1987) subcommittee constructed this year’s ballot. To be elected, candidates must secure 75 percent of the vote, and the committee must limit their consideration to the following criteria.

(A) Eligible candidates must be selected from managers, umpires, executives and players, who meet the following criteria related to their classification:

• Players who played in at least 10 major league seasons, who are not on Major League Baseball’s ineligible list, and have been retired for 15 or more seasons;
• Managers and umpires with 10 or more years in baseball and retired for at least five years. Candidates who are 65 years or older are eligible six months following retirement;
• Executives retired for at least five years. Active executives 70 years or older are eligible for consideration regardless of the position they hold in an organization, and regardless of whether their body of work has been completed.

(B) Those whose careers entailed involvement in multiple categories will be considered for their overall contribution to the game of Baseball; however, the specific category in which these individuals shall be considered will be determined by the role in which they were most prominent. In those instances when a candidate is prominent as both a player and as a manager, executive or umpire, the BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee shall determine that individual’s category as a player, as a manager or as an umpire or as an executive/pioneer. Those designated as players must fulfill the requirements of (A).

(C) Any person designated by the Office of the Commissioner of Major League Baseball as ineligible shall not be an eligible candidate.

Objectivity has no place in these considerations. Although Baseball Reference and Fangraphs have tried to reach back into history and quantitatively compare players from different eras against themselves, these committees unapologetically ignore the fancy statistics that are so popular today. Yes, these are old men who spent decades in and around the game that value the “eyeball test” over objective measurements. That’s not to say they don’t toss around statistics and earnestly weigh one player against another, but I’m near certain that most of these guys are more comfortable with a paper ledger as opposed to Excel spreadsheets.

This is an old and tired debate in baseball. BBWAA voters have started revealing their ballots and in some cases, offering lengthy rationales for each choice. The steroid-era has ripped a tear in the fabric of old-school ideas of success and excellence in baseball. Statistically speaking, Barry Bonds is a Hall-of-Famer, but what about his integrity? What about Alex Rodriguez‘s flagrant use of PEDs followed by vicious threats and lawsuits? These are the thorny issues the denizens of baseball must ponder.