Thursday, November 19, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2510

Yu Darvish Finally Gets His Twitter Revenge On Justin Verlander

Back in 2018, Yu Darvish slashed a ball down the right field line at Wrigley Field against the Brewers. An easy double for the Cubs pitcher, who if he was any other position player probably ends up with a triple, but instead this happened.

Astros ace Justin Verlander took the chance to poke some fun at Yu.

Well, 544 days later, Yu finally got a chance to make fun of Verlander and got his revenge on Twitter.

Well done, Yu.

Deon Bush Ranked as Most Likely Chicago Bears Trade Option

deon bush

The Chicago Bears trade market would not exactly appear to be strong this year. Not a surprise since they don’t have a lot of extra draft picks to throw around. Their 1st, 3rd, and 4th round selections in 2020 were shipped away in recent deals for Khalil Mack, Anthony Miller, and David Montgomery. So trading for a player is likely out of the question. If that’s the case, what about maybe trading a player for a little extra draft capital?

There are a few names on the roster that might make some sense in this regard. Leonard Floyd, who has been practically invisible since opening night against Green Bay might be worth something with his contract good through 2020 and teams always looking for outside linebackers who can do a little bit of everything. The same goes for speedy wide receivers, so Taylor Gabriel might be an option. However, Jeff Dickerson of ESPN doesn’t believe the Bears will go that far.

If they do make a move, it would be a minor one. Who does he have in mind? Backup safety Deon Bush.

“In the final year of his rookie contract, Bush has emerged as a solid No. 3 safety behind starters Eddie Jackson and Ha Ha Clinton-Dix. The Bears are pleased with his play; they could look to re-sign him after the season and pair him with Jackson in 2020 (Clinton-Dix is on a one-year deal). But any team in need of safety help would be wise to inquire about Bush, who’s young, productive and inexpensive.”

Chicago Bears trade of Deon Bush makes some sense

There is a logic to this thinking. Bush is young, relatively untainted thanks to his limited time on the field and would be cheap to keep long-term for any team that decided to trade for him. It can be called a low-risk, high-reward sort of move. If they trade for him and he blossoms? Great. If he doesn’t? No big loss. There are a number of teams that might give up a late round pick for somebody like that. Probably in the neighborhood of a 6th.

It would be a preferable move than just letting him leave in free agency next March. Then again, GM Ryan Pace has always been reluctant about letting players he’s drafted move on before he’s left with no choice. Odds are he will choose to hang onto Bush past the deadline in case Clinton-Dix happens to get injured and the Bears would have need of him. Then again Pace has surprised us all before.

Markkanen and White Give Strong Performances In Bulls’ Opener

The Bulls lost a tough one in their 2019-2020 season opener Wednesday evening to a rebuilding Charlotte Hornets team 125-126.

The defense was the main issue for most of the game as the Bulls were late rotating on ball movement especially around the perimeter and the Hornets hit their open shots. However, the Bulls did change that narrative early in the second half and built a ten-point lead with about seven minutes to play in the fourth, but failed to keep it going long enough to earn the victory. The Bulls 126 points allowed was the most all-time in a season opener.

Lauri Markkanen had 35 points (13-25 FG) and 17 rebounds. He was aggressive with the ball from the opening tip, but despite being known for his outside shooting, he was only 1-7 from the arc. Either way, it was still a strong performance in the season opener for the Bulls’ young star.

Rookie point guard Coby White looked impressive in his first professional appearance. He wasn’t afraid to attack the basket or shoot it from deep. White finished the game with 17 points, seven assists, and three rebounds. His seven assists were two more than he had in the entire preseason and things should only get better for him with more playing time.

White’s backcourt co-star Kris Dunn was a defensive agitator all night jumping into pass lanes on defense and attacked the rim when the ball was in his hands.

“I thought Kris Dunn was great tonight,” Head coach Jim Boylen told the media after the game. Dunn had 11 points, four steals, and two assists on 5-7 shooting in 24 minutes of play.

Despite the solid efforts from Markkanen, White, and Dunn, forward Zach LaVine struggled out of the gate converting on just 1 – 7 field goals in the first half. LaVine wasn’t too discouraged, however, and continued to attack in the second half, finishing the game with 16 points, seven assists, six rebounds, and two steals.

The Bulls still have a lot to learn from their season-opening loss and Boylen touched on that in the post-game press conference.

“I thought we battled back down sixteen in the second quarter. We had a good talk at half time and we scored 40 in the third and got ourselves back in the game.” Boylen explained when asked about his team’s overall performance.

“We were kind of in mud early and I didn’t think defensively we had the edge we needed early, and then we kind of picked it up and grew as the game went on. And then we gotta do a better job of executing down the stretch.”

As disappointing of a loss as it was, this is a very talented and athletic Bulls roster and it’s just the first game of the year. Hopefully, they do a better job of executing late when they take on the Memphis Grizzlies on Friday.

Mitch Trubisky is Conducting a Severe Case of Self-Sabotage

mitch trubisky

This isn’t the Mitch Trubisky we came to know last year. Despite Matt Nagy insisting that the young quarterback had made strides in understanding the offense, it feels like he’s taken a giant step back. There are plenty of concerns to cover such as his slow field vision, constantly inaccurate passing, and often erratic decision-making. Yet the most baffling thing that people can’t understand is the disappearance of his running ability.

Through his first four full games last season, Trubisky ran the ball himself 17 times for 117 yards and a touchdown. So far in 2019, he’s run it just five times for 21 yards. How can this be? It’s not like he suffered an injury or got old overnight. He runs with the same speed he did last year. Yet he hasn’t done it much. Trubisky explained that defenses are working hard to spy on him more this year and keep him in the pocket, yet that shouldn’t create such a drastic decline in production.

Teams spy Russell Wilson all the time and he still has 178 yards and three touchdowns already this season. It’s something else at play here. Part of it is a seeming change in mindset as Trubisky explained during his most recent press conference.

“I’m trying to be a pass-first guy. Running when it’s open. It hasn’t been there. So just keep looking for it but doing my job as a passer first.”

According to that, it seems he’s got it in his head that he needs to focus on throwing the ball and avoid running unless absolutely necessary. He makes it seem like the opportunities haven’t been. There’s one problem though.

They have.

Mitch Trubisky is way too focused on throwing the ball

One can understand what Trubisky is trying to accomplish. He wants to morph himself into a better pocket passer. So it seems like he’s forcing himself to avoid running and find the open receivers. While that is the ultimate end game for any quarterback, the fact is this move has caused Trubisky to rob the offense of one of its biggest weapons. Teams spy him because they fear his legs.

By refusing to use them more often, he’s playing right into their hands. It’s not like there haven’t been opportunities either. Here’s one in the opener against Green Bay. After stepping up in the pocket to avoid pressure, he has a wide open lane to his right and easily could’ve beaten the closest defender to the edge. Instead he throws it back across his body for what should’ve been an interception.

Here’s another against New Orleans. Trubisky runs a bootleg off play action. Taylor Gabriel carries the defensive back deep, leaving just one Saints defender against three Bears blockers. If he recognizes the right side of the field is completely bare, he picks up the first down with ease and maybe more. Nope. Just throws into triple coverage instead.

It’s these sorts of decisions that are hurting the offense more than helping Trubisky get better. Sure, running the ball a lot didn’t advance his prowess as a passer but it did lead to a lot more positive plays. It also helped to open up the running game. Defenses no longer fear him running, and this has allowed them to crash down on the backs more often, limited positive plays. Spies or no spies, Trubisky has to start utilizing one of his best physical tools before the team loses faith in him completely.

Chicago Bears Viewed as Prime Trade Spot for Kenyan Drake

chicago bears

The Chicago Bears aren’t seen as one of the teams who will be aggressive at the upcoming trade deadline on October 29th. Part of that is due to their lack of assets to trade with and the other is there doesn’t seem like a quick fix for their current problems out there anywhere. Not unless they can somehow pry a starting quarterback from another team which is unlikely. This hasn’t stopped people from pondering moves they could make.

Marc Sessler of NFL.com believes there might be help out there for them. Somebody who can give their struggling offense a nice jolt. None other than Kenyan Drake. The Miami Dolphins, who remain winless, are in firesale mode and have already sold off several players including Laremy Tunsil and Kenny Stills. Most believe that Drake will have his turn shortly. The 25-year old is viewed as one of the more versatile running backs in the league, able to pop big plays on the ground and through the air.

Sessler thinks he would solve the Bears’ running game woes.

“Buy running back Kenyan Drake. Seven carries a game ain’t gonna cut it. Paced by David Montgomery and Tarik Cohen, the Bears’ 28th-ranked running game needs a reinvention. Enter Drake, whom Miami has been dangling as trade bait for a while now. Over the last two weeks, Mark Walton has earned more touches than the former third-rounder. A move to the Windy City won’t take a Miami miracle. Potential compensation: 2020 seventh-round pick and 2021 third-round pick.”

Kenyan Drake won’t solve the Chicago Bears running game

Sessler is not wrong in that Drake is a talented offensive player who was wasted for far too long in Miami. At the same time, his addition would not solve the Bears’ overall issues with the ground game. They already have enough talent in the backfield with David Montgomery and Tarik Cohen. Their problems lay with two underlying issues. The subpar blocking of the offensive line and the inability of the head coach Matt Nagy to make a steady commitment to running the ball.

Odds are adding Drake to the mix would only result in him getting stuck in a log jam with those other two for the limited touches already going around. This is more about a philosophy shift. The Bears need to make a greater effort to balancing the offense and truly approach each game with the mindset that they’re going to run the football and dare other teams to stop them. Besides, they’ve already given up too many valuable future draft picks in previous trades. They need to keep the few they still have.

Bears Mailbag — What Stopped Working On Defense?

akiem hicks

The Chicago Bears suffered a disastrous loss to the New Orleans Saints on Sunday at Soldier Field. At home, facing a team without its Hall of Fame QB, top RB, and top TE, and getting their own starting QB back from injury, the Bears completely unraveled in the second half, getting dominated by Sean Payton & Co. while dropping to 3-3.

The offense, by far this season’s biggest concern, was awful. Mitch Trubisky looked lost, displaying poor judgment, slow field vision, sloppy footwork, and an overall inability to do anything right. Before garbage time, Trubisky was 14/27 for 84 yards. Eighty-four yards on twenty-seven attempts through three quarters. Those aren’t typos. And the running game crashed and burned, too — the Bears finished with 17 total yards on seven carries, and they lost two fumbles.

Yes, it looked every bit as bad as those stats say.

With a banged up 2-5 Los Angeles Chargers team coming to town next week, the Bears are absolutely desperate for a win. The NFC North is slipping away from them and they are buried in a tough NFC Wild Card race at the moment. They need a win in the worst way. If they get to 4-3 (and 2-2 at home), there’s still hope for the remainder of the season. If they drop to 3-4 (and 1-3 at home) … imagine the reaction in Chicago.

With that, let’s reach into this week’s Bears Mailbag. Thank you to everyone who submitted questions; I always appreciate the participation. Follow me on Twitter @DhruvKoul to continue the conversation.

Mailbag

There are a few issues. First, the loss of Akiem Hicks is big for this defensive front. His importance in the running game can’t be overstated. The Bears miss him a lot.

Second, nobody is stepping up opposite Khalil Mack when teams scheme him out of the play. Leonard Floyd has been non-existent, Aaron Lynch hasn’t done much, and the blitzes aren’t getting home at the moment.

Third, Roquan Smith indeed looks a bit lost at the moment on the field. Out of respect for his situation, I won’t comment on what might be happening, but it might be good for the Bears to put in Nick Kwiatkoski on Sunday against the Chargers. Smith isn’t getting home on blitzes (like Chuck Pagano would’ve counted on) and is looking timid on the field. Kwiatkoski could be an upgrade while Smith sorts his situation out.

Fourth, the coverage in the secondary is confounding. Pagano has allowed Kyle Fuller to play off (his preferred method), but the game plan to give that much room (without help) to Michael Thomas against the Saints was indefensible. They need to play tighter than they are, especially with the pass rush not getting home.

Finally, you do need to credit Oakland and New Orleans. Their offensive lines are dominant and physically pushed around the Bears’ front. And Jon Gruden and Sean Payton coached brilliantly on offense. Sometimes, you just tip your cap.

I wouldn’t say it’s been figured out, per se. There is a blueprint to beating the Bears’ defense, which includes quick passes to render the pass rush useless and making the Bears tackle well. And while the last two weeks have had moments of that, there have been other issues at play. The Oakland Raiders just straight up physically dominated the Bears’ defensive front with their elite offensive line. Losing Akiem Hicks hurt the defense a lot, but there’s not much you can do when you’re getting blown off the line of scrimmage. Jon Gruden and Derek Carr used that to their advantage to sell play action passes well and find open receivers.

Similarly, New Orleans’ offensive line routinely bullied the defensive front — it was magnified because the Bears were missing Hicks again, and the Saints schemed Khalil Mack out of the game without anyone else on the Bears’ front (Leonard Floyd, Aaron Lynch, etc.) stepping up to make plays.

There have been miscommunication issues and crazy coverage cushions employed on defense the last two games, and the Bears have things they can clean up. It’s up to Chuck Pagano to find the answers there, and for the players to execute better.


I do think there could be some value in handing off play calling duties in order to spark the offense a bit. Of course, this question was rendered redundant because Matt Nagy said in his press conference today that he’ll continue to call plays (at least for Sunday’s game against the Chargers). But if they fail to move the ball well enough on Sunday, I think he should seriously consider it.

My vote would honestly go to Dave Ragone. Brad Childress is an offensive consultant but it’s not clear how much influence he’s had in the scheme or play development. I’m not sure he’d know enough of the details to call the right plays. And I’m not happy with any of Mark Helfrich’s influences on the offense right now. The Oregon level stuff isn’t working at the moment. If the Bears had Marcus Mariota at QB, I could understand it and perhaps even vouch for Helfrich to call plays. But it isn’t working.

Mitch Trubisky trusts Ragone, and Ragone had a pretty successful audition in preseason calling plays in a limited manner. He’s young and can grow into the role, if needed. But I suppose we’ll cross that bridge when we get there.

There’s a lot of hate circulating for Matt Nagy right now. And while there is validity to *some* of the points made (namely related to the running game), Nagy is still doing an excellent job scheming receivers open. If you watch the tape, there are countless occasions where Mitch Trubisky fails to find an open receiver because he failed to get off of his first read. The Packers and Saints games were chock full of these instances. It’s infuriating, because the coach is doing his job — it’s up to the quarterback to make the throws.

There are arguments that the offense is too complex for many of the players, something that concerns me quite a bit — not about the offense, but about the players. Nagy has publicly stated twice now that he’s had to scale back the offense to get the players comfortable with what they’re trying to execute. It’s only a matter of time before defenses recognize the same personnel groupings, formations, motions, etc. being recycled because this is all that the Bears are comfortable running. And yet, receivers are still open!

I’d like for the Bears to be a bit more aggressive in their run schemes — ditch the motions and trickery and just line up and run the ball down the throat of the defense. That would be fun, and probably best for this offensive line and the running backs. But in the passing game? People are open. Frequently. Make the damn throw, Mitch.

There could be some legs to this. Interestingly, there are reports out of Philadelphia saying some players are murmuring that Doug Pederson’s offense is also too complex. Pederson, of course, is another Andy Reid disciple. And that team has been together for a while and won a Super Bowl together. It’s interesting, for sure.

But at the end of the day, even plays they’re executing in practice aren’t translating to the games. After the Saints game, Nagy said that Trubisky’s wide open miss to Taylor Gabriel was a throw he hit over and over in practice. But he missed it on the field when it counted.

What concerns me is Mitch is the one struggling the most. Yes, he has to keep track of *everything* because he’s the quarterback. Anthony Miller has certainly struggled at times, getting lined up in the wrong spot or running the wrong route. But when you go back and watch the tape, receivers are open. The scheme is working (in the passing game) and receivers are getting open — the quarterback has to find them and make the throws. If Mitch hits the wide open throws to Gabriel and Miller that he missed against New Orleans, we’re probably talking about an entirely different game and result.

Mitch Trubisky Seemed Pissed Off at Latest Bears Presser

mitch trubisky

Mitch Trubisky is a nice kid. He’s always presented that type of personality from the day he was drafted. An easy-going smile. Patient with questions. Willing to sign every autograph he can. However, at the most recent press conference with the Chicago Bears media on Wednesday, something was different. While he still answered questions like normal, his replies were a lot curter. A lot shorter and more forceful.

While one must be careful to read too much into body language and facial expressions, it was clear enough the 25-year old quarterback was not happy. Quite the opposite. He seemed angry. Was it with having to talk to the media or more with himself over the fact his team is 3-3 and in danger of letting a promising season slip away? Knowing how competitive the young man is, it’s probably more towards the latter. That and the fact he’s probably well aware of the dangerous territory he is getting into.

If he puts on too many more performances like last Sunday, his hold on the starting job could slip away. This might explain why he was unusually candid about his play. Specifically one regarding a run-pass option in the second half where he took a bad sack from Cameron Jordan rather than just handing the ball off.

“I made a bad decision. (Cam Jordan) does do a good job with (making it look like he’s crashing the RB) but it would have been an easy handoff read. I was doing too much with my eyes on that. I never try to look at the running back and then do a free axis out route. So that was just bad by me. Should’ve been a handoff.”

Mitch Trubisky better use that anger while he still can

There is no getting around reality. Trubisky is on a timeline right now and it’s getting shorter. Ten games remain in the season. The Bears are 3-3 and on the outside looking in of a stacked NFC playoff race. They need to start putting some wins together. With the defense banged up, it falls on him to drag the offense out of its prolonged slump. Being pissed off has helped him in the past. He was clearly angry during the game against Washington a few weeks ago and threw three touchdowns. Maybe this is the secret to his success.

Then again maybe the anger is pointless.

One thing is for sure. It can’t possibly make him play worse. Trubisky has played scared to this point. It feels like he’s trying to do too much. He’s trying to be the hero on every play instead of just going out there and taking what the defense gives him. This is why he’s missing open receivers, seeing things that aren’t there, and lacks any sort of rhythm. Who knows. Maybe being pissed off and in fear of his job might be the thing that flips the switch.

David Ross Loves Bunts, Defensive Shifts And More On His Managerial Philosophies

Some Cubs fans are acting like David Ross wasn’t already tabbed as a future manager while he was still playing. He was regarded as a player who had a great feel for the game, learning from hall of fame managers and players during his 15-year career behind the plate and on the bench. Seriously, you all jizz yourselves over catchers making great managers, but because David Ross danced on TV he’s all of a sudden soft and not qualified?

Anyway, The Athletic’s Patrick Mooney summarized my overall thoughts on Ross’ hiring.

So yeah, the modern MLB manager isn’t 100% calling the shots, but that doesn’t mean Ross will be a glorified cheerleader in the dugout. He has his own views, some may align with the front office, while others may not.

During his last MLB season in 2016, Ross was interviewed by David Laurila from Fangraphs. In the article Ross discussed how he’d manage different aspects of the game when he’d be the guy in charge.

Well, that’ll begin in 2020 and here’s a preview of what to expect from Ross as Cubs manager. This was from three years ago, so it is possible Ross’ perspective has changed on a few things.

One of the biggest things that stood out to me is that Ross is all in on defensive shifts.

Via Fangraphs.

“I like shifting. I believe in it. Anything where the numbers show you have a better chance of getting someone out, you do it. I actually don’t think the outfield gets shifted enough. I think it should be moved way more than it is. When I’m behind the plate calling a game, I know that certain guys can’t drive the ball to the opposite field against certain guys I’m catching.
“Those things are constantly being tweaked. I have a couple of ideas about shifting guys who bunt. I’ve come up with a few secrets, although I don’t want to divulge them yet. A lot of pure pull hitters are slow, and there are some things you can do to mess with them.
“I don’t care if 
Albert Pujols hits a ground ball to the right side of the infield for a base hit. If a pure power hitter like that wants to hit a 10-hopper the other way, that’s fine with me. When guys are changing their approach from what they do best, because of how you aligned your infield, it’s usually a positive.
“I’m a big believer in defense in general. When you don’t give teams extra outs… look at St. Louis and how they play clean baseball. That’s winning baseball, the cleanness of how they make the plays you’re supposed to. And when you hit the ball hard and someone runs it down in the gap, that’s demoralizing. Same thing with shifting. If someone hits a rocket right where you’re shifted, and takes a hit away from you, it demoralizes them.”

More defensive shifting would be a major strategic change for the Cubs under Ross compared to Joe Maddon’s teams. From 2016-19, the Cubs ranked in the bottom three in shifting, finishing last in 2017 and 2019. The Astros have shifted more than any other team in baseball since the start of 2016.

For fans who love small ball, David Ross is here to put a smile on your face.

“I’m probably one of the few guys left who likes the sacrifice bunt. I wouldn’t always use it, but there are scenarios where I like it. For instance, if I have a runner on second with nobody out in a close game, I like moving him to third. If the best way to do that is with a bunt, I’m willing to do that.
“A lot of the time, I’ll want to let my guys fire away. But I’ll also want to be a well-rounded team. I want to be able to play small ball if need be. There comes a time when having that aspect in your game is important. Some people believe in not sacrificing until you need it, but that might mean asking someone to bunt who hasn’t done it all year.”

Hey, so remember how Joe Maddon kept starting Albert Almora Jr. even though it was pretty obvious that Almora was struggling and had no business being in the lineup. But fine, at least Almora wasn’t at the top of the lineup. NOPE! Maddon made things worse by continuing to bat Almora at leadoff despite being one of the worst hitters in the league since last summer.

Simply put, Maddon wasn’t placing his best hitters at the top of the order, instead opting to give the most at-bats to one of the worst hitters on the roster.

Hopefully Ross sticks with this novel concept on lineup construction.

“Overall, I think you need to put your best hitters near the top of the lineup, and your worse hitters near the bottom. You want your best hitters to get more at-bats.”

THANK YOU! It’s really not that complicated.

Ross also talked about wanting speed at the top of the order. That’ll be one giant question mark the Cubs have to solve this offseason, as their leadoff hitters were a disaster in 2019 and there hasn’t been much stability at that spot since 2016.

Those were things that stood out to me, but there’s plenty more for you to check out, including Ross’ thoughts on managing a bullpen, pitch counts, in-game adjustments, working alongside the front office to make game decisions and more. It really gives you a good sense of what type of manager Ross will be and he even shares a few of Maddon’s qualities as a manager.

OK, here’s the last thing that stood out for me.

“I think it’s important for a manager to keep things relaxed and to be the same guy every day. Be cool, calm, and don’t let adverse situations affect you. Make the same moves in the heat of battle. That way, as a player, you know what to expect.”

Ross also believes in a clubhouse policing itself, with veterans leading the way. That’s very much in line with Maddon’s way of handling things in the clubhouse when he was managing the Cubs.

But again, it’s not like Ross isn’t a red ass.

Seriously, if Ross didn’t appear on Dancing With The Stars, you’d be saying he has the fire and passion the Cubs need.

Matt Nagy Makes His Decision on the Play Calling Issue

matt nagy

The sudden downturn of the Chicago Bears offense this season has raised serious questions. Namely its inability to run the ball or have any sort of identity. They ran it just seven times against New Orleans last Sunday, a franchise record low. Matt Nagy has insisted several times that he understands the team has to run the ball more. Yet he continues to fail in this venture. This is why the buzz has increased of late that it might be in his and the team’s best interests if he handed play calling duties to someone else.

Sometimes a head coach can handle both jobs of running a game and calling plays. Other times they can’t. Relieving Nagy of his duties as a play caller would allow him to focus on managing the game and motivating the players. Two things he’s really good at. The problem would be who does he hand the play sheet over to? The most obvious choice is offensive coordinator Mark Helfrich but he’s not a great option since he’s never done something like that in his coaching career.

Offensive consultant Brad Childress has but his ties to the system can best be called limited since he was away from the team for a long period in the several months dabbling in the AAF. That would just leave quarterbacks coach Dave Ragone who also has never called played. With these options on the table, it’s little surprise Nagy stepped in front of the media on Wednesday and announced he will continue to call plays himself.

Matt Nagy will have to dig himself out of this mess

The frustrating part about all of this is that Nagy has actually had a number of instances where he called excellent games offensively. He got guys open, ran the ball consistently and just had defenses on their heels. For whatever reason, it seems like he’s lost something. Like he doesn’t quite trust himself. He’s leaning too heavily on certain formations and play designs too often and opponents are finding it easier and easier to counter what he’s trying to do.

The lack of balance is playing a huge part. Not to mention the lack of discipline from the players themselves. The best thing for him to do moving forward is to put his foot down and scrap whatever craft schemes they were trying to cook up this summer. Get back to what was working in 2018. It may not have always been pretty, but it got the job done. This coming Sunday against a pretty good defense in the Los Angeles Chargers will reveal a lot about what’s to come.

Does Ryan Pace Deserve a 2nd Crack at QB? History Offers a Warning

chicago bears

Mitch Trubisky isn’t dead yet but it certainly feels like he’s on life support. Unsurprisingly, this has led to a ton of backlash on GM Ryan Pace. For all the good things the man has done rebuilding the Chicago Bears into a talented team, his trade up in 2017 to grab Trubisky over the likes of Deshaun Watson and Patrick Mahomes is fast becoming one of the most colossal misfires in recent history. There is no doubt in many minds that Trubisky could be done after this season.

This raises a highly important question.

If the Bears do indeed chase after another potential franchise quarterback, does Pace deserve to be the guy that leads that search? Most GMs don’t survive beyond whiffing on a highly drafted quarterback but some have. In order to answer this question, it might be best to evaluate how many of those men did with their second opportunity. Were they able to adjust their evaluations and score a hit on the next try or did they stick to the original script?

Here is what I found.

Ryan Pace would be in very rare company if he hit the second time

Looking back over several 1st round busts since 1990, I was able to pinpoint six different GM/personnel guys who made those picks and were eventually given another chance, either with the original teams they worked for or new ones who gave them a second crack at the job. Here is how things played out.

Bill Tobin (Bears 1987-1992, Lions 2001-2002)

Jim Harbaugh

  • 26th overall, 1987
  • 77.6 career passer rating
  • 66-74 record

Joey Harrington

  • 3rd overall, 2002
  • 69.4 career passer rating
  • 26-50 record
Charley Casserly (Redskins 1989-1999, Texans 2002-2005)

Heath Shuler

  • 3rd overall, 1994
  • 54.3 career passer rating
  • 8-14 record

David Carr

  • 1st overall, 2002
  • 74.9 career passer rating
  • 23-56 record
Tom Flores (Seahawks 1989-1994)

Dan McGwire

  • 16th overall, 1991
  • 57.3 career passer rating
  • 2-3 record

Rick Mirer

  • 2nd overall, 1993
  • 63.5 career passer rating
  • 24-44 record
Vinny Cerrato (Redskins 2000-2009)

Patrick Ramsey

  • 32nd overall, 2002
  • 74.9 career passer rating
  • 10-14 record

Jason Campbell

  • 25th overall, 2005
  • 81.7 career passer rating
  • 32-47 record
Ozzie Newsome (Ravens 1996-2018)

Kyle Boller

  • 19th overall, 2003
  • 69.5 career passer rating
  • 20-27 record

Joe Flacco

  • 18th overall, 2008
  • 84.2 career passer rating
  • 98-72 record
Rick Spielman (Vikings 2006-present)

Christian Ponder

  • 12th overall, 2011
  • 75.9 career passer rating
  • 14-21-1 record

Teddy Bridgewater

  • 32nd overall, 2014
  • 88.3 career passer rating
  • 22-12 record

All told, the evidence isn’t the most inspiring. Of the six general managers listed, four of them outright missed on their second chance, sometimes with an even worse quarterback than before. Only Newsome and Spielman managed to improve from their first blown opportunities. Flacco never became a star in Baltimore but he did win them a Super Bowl. Bridgewater went to a Pro Bowl in Minnesota before tragically suffering that horrific knee injury in 2016 that almost ended his career.

Suffice to say if the Bears do decide to move on from Trubisky in the near future, they’ll be taking a considerable risk if they let Pace be the man to determine who the next quarterback will be. The one thing he’d have going for him the second time around is Matt Nagy being in his ear. That added expertise could be of considerable benefit.

Then again Tom Flores was an actual quarterback himself and that didn’t help much.