Friday, November 13, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 169

NFL Execs Are Hammering Buffalo Over The DJ Moore Trade – Here’s Why

dj moore
Nov 28, 2024; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Chicago Bears wide receiver DJ Moore (2) heads upfield after catching a pass against the Detroit Lions in the fourth quarter at Ford Field. Mandatory Credit: Lon Horwedel-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears made a folk hero out of DJ Moore last season. Granted, the wide receiver did most of the worst with two of the most meaningful catches in franchise history, but their media machine took care of the rest. Despite playing only three seasons with the team, he will be remembered more fondly than names like Alshon Jeffery and Brandon Marshall, even though the latter two were more productive. That is what happens when you slay the Green Bay Packers demon with two mighty killing blows.

Sadly, the story doesn’t have a happy ending. The tax man came calling. Chicago had serious salary cap problems and had to find ways to address them. One of the few they had that didn’t involve restructuring contracts was unloading Moore, who counted $28.5 million against the books. With Luther Burden and Rome Odunze in place, it was a tough sacrifice the Bears were willing to make, trading Moore to the Buffalo Bills for a 2nd round pick. While the deal made sense on paper, some NFL executives told Mike Sando of The Athletic that Buffalo got fleeced.

“D.J. Moore was gonna get cut, and they gave up a second-round pick to get him,” one exec said. “They gave up a second-round pick and $40 million (in guarantees). What is going on?”

As one agent noted, getting free agents to choose Buffalo over other NFL cities can be tricky. Recent history could be another factor, as former coach Sean McDermott complained about personnel, especially at wide receiver. Moore played under new coach Joe Brady in Carolina. No one can say the Bills did not get the receiver Brady sought.

“D.J. Moore has two years of regression now,” another exec said. “He is a non-traditional receiver that wins with size and yards after the catch. I still feel they needed someone that could win down the field. Moore can do that — he did it to beat Green Bay. But I feel like his strength is on the underneath catch-and-run stuff, which they already have with (Khalil) Shakir.”

The Bills badly need DJ Moore to excel.

In most cases, that sort of trade should’ve probably gone for a 4th round pick. Moore’s sagging production and hefty contract made it so. However, Buffalo needed a playmaker more than ever. Somebody who could make things happen in big games. They saw what Moore did in crucial moments all season for the Bears. They were willing to overpay somewhat to get that guy on their roster. Now, Josh Allen may finally have someone who can step up in the playoffs, which has been a constant issue for years.

One also must not discount head coach Joe Brady. He worked with Moore in Carolina for two seasons. They know each other well. If anybody understands how to get the most from the veteran receiver, it would be him. As in most cases like this, nobody will mention the price tag if the player delivers. Moore cracking 1,000 yards and making some big catches in the playoffs will make that 2nd round pick look like a bargain. It is up to Chicago to make full use of it as they continue retooling their roster.

Moore deserves the benefit of the doubt.

What happened in Chicago wasn’t entirely his fault. After an outstanding 2023 season, the team switched quarterbacks in 2024 to a rookie, Caleb Williams. That goes without mentioning the disastrous Shane Waldron situation at offensive coordinator. Then last year, Ben Johnson arrived with a new offense that was predicated on featuring the tight end position a lot more. DJ Moore did the best he could with the targets he got. It is worth mentioning that if he had gotten his usual 130 targets, he would’ve cracked 1,000 yards.

Maybe Buffalo overpaid, but that doesn’t mean their offense isn’t better with Moore involved. He gives them options they didn’t really have last year. The idea that the Bears would’ve cut him if they hadn’t found a trade partner is untrue. Team brass insisted they didn’t really want to move on from Moore. Business issues merely made it necessary. Don’t be surprised if in a few years this trade will be looked at as a win-win for both teams.

“Steal of the Offseason” — Tom Thayer Drops Bold Take On Bears’ Jedrick Wills Signing

tom thayer
Oct 13, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Cleveland Browns offensive tackle Jedrick Wills Jr. (71) against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears didn’t spend heavily in free agency this year, but they were active across multiple areas. That was particularly true on the offensive line. It started with trading for veteran center Garrett Bradbury from New England. Drew Dalman had just retired, and the team needed a reliable option in the middle. Next came some decisions at left tackle. Unsurprisingly, the Bears opted to bring back Braxton Jones. He knows the system, has starting experience, and can be a solid hand when healthy. The much bigger surprise was the arrival of Jedrick Wills, the former 10th overall pick in 2020. It was a move met with a shrug of the shoulders at first. Tom Thayer liked the move only because it improved team depth.

However, it sounds like the former Bears guard has changed his stance in the past three weeks. He appeared on Kap & J. Hood for ESPN 1000 to discuss the team’s new-look line. Thayer openly stated that Wills could be the steal of the offseason, provided he is healthy after missing most of the past two seasons due to a unique knee injury. It is such that the longtime analyst even believes it isn’t necessary for the Bears to draft an offensive tackle early.

Tom Thayer usually can be trusted with his takes.

After all, he was one of the first to praise the Bears when they drafted Jones in 2022. He stated early on that the rookie tackle should be considered a real threat to start. He loved the Darnell Wright pick a year later and knew immediately what sort of impact Joe Thuney would have when the Bears traded for him. The point is, Thayer knows capable offensive linemen when he sees them. It appears he went back and reviewed the tape of Wills since the signing first happened. Apparently, he came away more encouraged than he thought.

Talent was never the issue with Wills. He was the 10th overall pick for a reason. Draft experts loved his mix of size and athleticism, believing he had all the tools of a future Pro Bowler. Things started pretty well in Cleveland, helping the Browns make the playoffs as a rookie. His second year was solid as well. Then things took a turn in 2022. The team had shifted from Baker Mayfield to Deshaun Watson following the blockbuster trade, resulting in a significant scheme shift. Wills didn’t take to it well, and then injuries struck a year later.

What matters is what the Bears think.

They signed him for a reason. They must think Wills has the capacity to play. Head coach Ben Johnson has always had a sharp eye for talent. The medicals must’ve checked out as well, or the Bears wouldn’t have finalized the deal. That leaves questions about Wills’ motivation. Analysts in Cleveland expressed concerns about the young tackle’s passion for the game, which began to show after his first couple of years. Is Johnson confident he can fix that, or does he believe Wills was unfairly criticized for what was a tough situation?

It’s one of those possibilities, or the Bears merely see him as a cheap flier for training camp. We’ll get a clearer picture on that during the draft. If the team doesn’t select an offensive tackle in the first two rounds, that will be a signal they’re willing to give Wills an honest shot. He’s always had the ability. Maybe this offense is a better fit for him than what he had to play with the Browns. Dan Roushar is one of the best in the business. If the Bears’ offensive line coach can reignite Wills, nobody can. Tom Thayer has that level of trust.

Hammond Mayor Thomas McDermott Guarantees Bears Are Going To Indiana

george mccaskey
Dec 26, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears chairman George McCaskey walks into Soldier Field prior to a game between the Chicago Bears and Seattle Seahawks. Mandatory Credit: Talia Sprague-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears remain deadlocked on their new stadium situation. Illinois government officials have hemmed and hawed on the issue for months despite insisting there’s been real progress. The first attempt to get a vote passed on the PILOT megaprojects bill didn’t even reach the starting line in March. Now, team president Kevin Warren has set a hard deadline of May 31st (when the legislature adjourns) for when the Bears will decide whether to stay in Arlington Heights or shift to Indiana. If you ask Thomas McDermott, though, that decision was made a long time ago.

He is the mayor of Hammond, Indiana. Most believe that is the preferred building site if the Bears were to cross state lines. Warren basically confirmed as much when he stated the township offers 340 acres of land, which is larger than the 326 acres they purchased in Arlington Heights. McDermott has already been preparing as if the Bears’ coming over is a forgone conclusion. He even told Doug Ross of the Chicago Tribune that he believes it is exactly that. The franchise merely hasn’t come out and said it yet.

McDermott is convinced the Bears are choosing Hammond over Arlington Heights.

“The Bears had already made their mind up before most of the public found out about it,” he said.

Thomas McDermott isn’t crazy for saying that.

Let’s just look at the situation from a business perspective. Illinois has been resisting this endeavor from the beginning. Getting help with infrastructure was like pulling teeth, and the state remains like the Spartans at Thermopylae when it comes to property tax assistance. This doesn’t even account for many in the government who are trying to get the Bears to pay off the remainder of the Soldier Field debt ($400 million), even though they paid their share long ago. It is not negotiable.

You’re already seeing top brass prepare fans for the possibility. Just look at George McCaskey’s comments about it during his meeting with the media in Arizona on Wednesday.

“I don’t think, in the end, it’s going to matter to people. Back in 1976, the New York Football Giants went across state lines to New Jersey. They have been there ever since. The Jets joined them shortly thereafter. And then 35 years later, both teams had an opportunity to reevaluate their situations and recommitted to New Jersey.

“And somehow, the Republic has survived.”

That is the equivalent of a parent telling a complaining child during a move to a new town that they’ll get over it. Harsh? Sure. It’s also kind of true. Giants fans weren’t happy about leaving New York. They got past it. Hammond is less than 30 minutes from downtown Chicago, just like the Meadowlands is from downtown New York. It will be an adjustment period, but not a huge one in the grand scheme of things. That is before you bring up all the financial assistance Indiana is ready and waiting to throw into the project.

It feels like the Bears are trying to avoid public blowback.

The strategy here is straightforward. If they’d just up and left for Indiana months ago, the public outcry would’ve been intense. By holding off on the decision and continuing to negotiate with Illinois, they’re making it look like they are giving their longtime home a real chance to make a deal. However, they knew how much resistance there would be in Springfield and the limited odds of the bill getting passed. By waiting until the end of the legislature session in May, they can state they gave Illinois every possible opportunity. They just didn’t think the Bears were worth keeping. You can’t blame the organization for not staying where they’re not wanted.

Maybe a little underhanded, but also carrying grains of truth. Illinois has treated the Bears like an inconvenience for a long time, though never too shy to use their immense popularity to further political agendas. Now, when the team pushes to build a new, modern stadium that isn’t a relic decades past, they’re stonewalled. This comes despite a more than fair offer of the Bears paying for the entire stadium construction themselves. Nope, not enough.

It becomes easy to see why Thomas McDermott sounds so confident.

Two Players Considered Overwhelming Favorites To Be Chicago Bears’ 1st Round Pick

chicago bears
Clemson defensive lineman Peter Woods (11) during the second quarter at Memorial Stadium in Clemson, S.C. Saturday, September 6, 2025.

The Chicago Bears won’t tell anybody who they plan to pick with the 25th selection this month. Part of that is because they don’t want people to know who they like. Another part is that they have no idea who will be available. Draft insiders haven’t gotten much information on who they’re even meeting with, let alone who they’re interested in. General manager Ryan Poles and head coach Ben Johnson deserve credit for keeping their intentions locked down from the public eye. So how do we know what they’ll do?

In these situations, math could be of help. The ESPN analytics team released its annual Draft Day Predictor ahead of April 23rd. It is meant to offer the mathematical odds for each prospect in the class and where they are most likely to be selected.

“The underlying model is based on prospect grades from Scouts Inc, expert mock drafts, and team needs along with a few other factors. The Predictor considers these factors in proportion to how accurate they have been in the past.”

This created an interesting question. Which players, if any, are favored to go 25th overall to Chicago? The data charts popped out two names who weren’t just favorites, but heavy favorites to go at that spot: Clemson defensive tackle Peter Woods and Toledo safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren.

Both players make sense for the Chicago Bears.

One of the big issues for them last season was interior pass rush. It was too inconsistent and lacked explosiveness. That is something Woods might bring to the table. He has a great athletic profile and the ideal mix of upper-body strength and lower-body burst. The big concern with him is his sparse production. He never had a true standout season at Clemson, leading many to wonder why. This uncertainty is why there is significant hesitation about taking him early in the draft. Maybe the Bears, with their strong coaching staff, might be willing to take the risk.

McNeil-Warren, on the other hand, is a classic throwback. He’s a big, strong safety with significant hitting power, leaving offensive players wary of crossing the middle. He is athletic enough to make plays in coverage and might be the most gifted forced fumble merchant since Charles Tillman. A creative defensive coordinator can make great use of his versatility. The Chicago Bears do have a starting spot open alongside Coby Bryant. He might be an ideal fit for the new vision for this team.

The Bears won’t reach at positions of need.

They’ve made this clear in the draft last year. Tight end and wide receiver were not at the top of their needs list in 2025, but they took them anyway. It worked out pretty well. There is another layer to this projection. Daniel Jeremiah of NFL.com recently released his updated big board for this 2026 class. Keep in mind, it’s fed by both his tape evaluation and what he’s hearing around the NFL. McNeil-Warren is ranked 16th. Woods is ranked 37th. So if both are on the board, the decision seems pretty obvious.

Then again, there is always the chance that neither player is available. Then you’re looking at guys like Caleb Lomu, Blaker Miller, and Keldric Faulk. The truth is, most of the options when the Chicago Bears go on the clock will have questions about them. They’d go higher if they didn’t. The trick Poles and Johnson will be pinpointing the one guy whose flaws they can live with, or they think are incorrect or overblown.

Why Latest Update On The Detroit Lions Would Be Great News For The Bears

detroit lions
Dec 19, 2025; Norman, OK, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide offensive lineman Kadyn Proctor (74) against the Oklahoma Sooners during the CFP National Playoff First Round at Gaylord Family Oklahoma Memorial Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears are in a rare position: they are the last team in the NFC North to pick in the 1st round this year. It will start with the Minnesota Vikings, then the Detroit Lions, and finally the Green Bay. It’s been a long time since that happened. General manager Ryan Poles and head coach Ben Johnson must hope that their rivals don’t hit any home runs with those picks and make life harder moving forward. However, it won’t be just about that. Whichever players those other teams pick will have a significant impact on who falls to the Bears at #25.

That is where the latest update regarding the Lions is so interesting. Tony Pauline is one of the best draft insiders on the circuit these days. He had some new information that feels pertinent to the 1st round for Chicago. From what he’s hearing, Detroit is zeroed in on Alabama tackle Kadyn Proctor. They don’t feel good before their left tackle options after releasing Taylor Decker. Proctor is the kind of bruising blocker they feel is perfect for their run-heavy attack as they try to regain an identity they lost last season.

“The Detroit Lions have a hole at left tackle, and sources believe they’ve zeroed in on Alabama’s Kadyn Proctor…

…Those I’ve spoken with believe the latest Proctor ends up in the draft is the 17th pick, presently owned by the Detroit Lions. They need a left tackle after releasing Taylor Decker, and Proctor gives them an option, along with Penei Sewell, the 2021 first-round pick who was a star at Oregon on the blind side before moving to right tackle after the Lions drafted him in 2021. More than anything, the Lions want to run the ball and hope to extend Jahmyr Gibbs before the season starts. They believe the combo of Sewell and Proctor would be a dominant run-blocking duo.”

The Detroit Lions going that route is good for the Bears.

There are two reasons for this. We’ll start with the practical. For months, almost every draft expert believed the Lions would target an edge rusher. They lost Al-Quadin Muhammad to free agency and replaced him with D.J. Wonnum and Payton Turner. Not exactly an upgrade. They need somebody who can rush across from Aidan Hutchinson. Taking a top rusher at the 17th pick would make sense. However, if they’re focused on a left tackle, that significantly improves the odds of one of the better edge rushers falling to the Bears at #25.

As of now, projections have around five edge rushers going in the top 24 picks. However, removing the Lions from that equation would improve the odds of that number dropping to four or even three. Right now, most would agree the New York Jets (#2, #16), Tennessee Titans (#4), Kansas City Chiefs (#9), Tampa Bay Buccaneers (#15), Detroit Lions (#17), and Philadelphia Eagles (#23) are believed to view edge rusher as a need in some capacity.

Tampa signed Muhammad as a free agent. Philadelphia signed Arnold Ebiketie. New York signed Joseph Ossai and Kingsley Enigbare. That could dissuade them from attacking the position early, leaving Tennessee and Kansas City as the bigger threats to watch. Obviously, someone unexpected could still draft one, but Detroit leaning away from it is still a break.

Targeting Proctor is a risk in itself.

Talent-wise, the Alabama standout has a rare mix of size, power, and mobility. He has flashes of dominance on his tape. It is easy to fall in love with what he can be. The problem is he never did it consistently. Not only are there concerns about his weight (350+ lbs), but league scouts also have serious misgivings about his passion for the game. Bob McGinn of Go Long found this out recently. They see the talent, as well as somebody not interested in doing the extra work.

“I didn’t like Evan Neal and this guy is exactly the same,” a second scout said. “I wanted to like him, too. He has a little bit of movement for being so big. But the game against Auburn, he’s just standing around watching. He just teases you and, ultimately, disappoints. Big, good-looking dude but not physical, not a lot of grit. Stands around and watches.”

This would be doubly beneficial to the Bears. Not only would the Lions add a player who may ultimately prove to be a disappointment, but it’ll also ensure Chicago, which does need a left tackle, won’t have to wrestle with the decision to draft him were he to fall to the 25th pick. Sure, there is always a chance Proctor overcomes those questions to achieve his full potential. Based on what most around the league believe, they wouldn’t put money on it.

Kevin Warren Has Finally Set A Hard Deadline For A Bears Stadium Decision

kevin warren
Mar 30, 2026; Phoenix, AZ, USA; Chicago Bears president Kevin Warren during the 2026 NFL Annual League Meeting at the Arizona Biltmore. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears have been slogging their way toward a new stadium, like the Allies during the Battle of the Somme. For every step they take, it feels like they suffer multiple setbacks. Remember, this saga began in 2021 when they placed a bid on the Arlington Park property. In the five years since then, the only thing they’ve managed to accomplish is securing ownership of it and working out property tax issues with Arlington Heights. Everything else has been one ongoing headache. All the while, team president Kevin Warren, the man running this show, has been hesitant to provide anything close to a hard deadline on when a decision will be made.

That finally changed on Wednesday at the NFL owners meetings in Arizona. The Bears have finally reached a point where they seem to have options. Illinois’ state legislature is willing to put the PILOT bill, which would provide the property tax clarity the team needs to start building, on the floor for a vote. On the flip side, the state of Indiana has prepared all the necessary legislation and a prime construction site in Hammond. All the Bears need to do is make a decision. Warren believes the date is almost at hand. Courtney Cronin of ESPN pinpointed it.

“We’re in an excellent position,” Warren said Wednesday at the NFL’s league meetings. “I recently said that the target is to make sure that we have a decision made by springtime here soon. Late spring, early summer would be that from a target.”

The Bears are waiting to see if the PILOT bill passes during the Illinois general assembly’s spring session, which ends on May 31. State lawmakers introduced the proposed legislation, which would freeze property tax assessments on the sites of “megaprojects” and allow developers to negotiate a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) with local governments.

Kevin Warren likely always knew it’d come to this.

Once it became clear that the government wouldn’t reach a decision last October during its fall session, the Bears had a decision to make. Do they go to Indiana immediately, or wait for the spring session, which runs from March through the end of May? After discussions with Governor J.B. Pritzker, it was felt that waiting could produce the results Warren and the McCaskeys hoped for. The family has never wanted to leave Illinois. They merely sought reasonable options on infrastructure and property taxes.

However, there has been persistent resistance in Springfield on this issue. Some of it is people not wanting the Bears to leave Chicago, preferring they stay in the city. Others aren’t eager to give a billion-dollar corporation tax breaks when they should be focused on helping people who actually need it. That has made getting the necessary votes difficult. Two months remain until the legislature adjourns for the summer. If they can’t reach a decision by then, the Bears sound more than comfortable with starting the move to Hammond.

Patience is wearing thin at Halas Hall.

Kevin Warren has been in charge since 2022 and hasn’t had much to show for it in Chicago. He was hired primarily to close the stadium deal, having earned experience in a similar venture with Minnesota. Yet for four years, he hasn’t gained much ground. It wasn’t until he brought Indiana into the situation that Illinois finally started having serious discussions. Even now, though, they are dragging their feet, unable to get over the last hurdle despite what many experts agree is a pretty solid deal for the state.

They’ve been testing the limits of the Bears’ patience for the past several months. If they decide to push their luck by not holding a vote in May, that will be the breaking point. The McCaskeys don’t sound hesitant about going to Indiana. They cited the Giants’ move to New Jersey in 1976. There was an adjustment period, but fans eventually grew to accept it. They believe it will be the same for Bears fans, and they’re probably right.

Controversial Call Sparks Chicago Cubs Series Win vs. Los Angeles Angels

The Chicago Cubs haven’t exactly been lighting the world on fire against two underwhelming opponents to begin the 2026 season, but a close call on Wednesday sparked a series win over the Los Angeles Angels. This could have gone either way, and luckily for Cubs’ third base coach Quintin Berry, it went in their favor because it was certainly a risky decision.

The Cubs cruised to a 6-2 win, propped up by a fifth-run third inning. The rally began with a Miguel Amaya leadoff walk, and then he scored on a Nico Hoerner double that was hit to left-center field. Amaya, not known for his speed, was given the sign to race home by Berry. It was an aggressive send, considering there were no outs in the inning and the middle of the lineup was due up.

To their credit, the Angels did execute a good relay from the outfield, and the throw did beat Amaya at home. However, the Cubs catcher did a better job with his slide, as he was able to evade the tag from Travis d’Arnaud, who ended up tagging Amaya’s chest, but not before Amaya touched home plate.

The home plate ump called Amaya safe, which, in the past, you could almost guarantee that a throw beating a runner to the plate would have meant an out call, but it created even more frustration for the Angels afterward. First-year manager Kurt Suzuki asked for the play to be reviewed, but it turns out that he took too long to challenge the call.

You can see in the video below how the ump points to his wrist, signaling that the Angels ran out of time before asking for a review. A manager gets 15 seconds to challenge a play, and Suzuki was too slow on Wednesday.

However, it ultimately may not have mattered because the replays shown on Marquee Sports Network didn’t really show any conclusive angles that would have overturned the safe call.

After that, the Cubs added four more runs against left-handed starter Yusei Kikuchi. Alex Bregman singled in Hoerner, Dansby Swanson hit a sac-fly, Matt Shaw drove in another with a single, and Pete Crow-Armstrong capped off the five-run third with another RBI-single.

Shaw had the back-breaker against Kikuchi, as the right-handed hitter fouled off five straight pitches in his at-bat, and then delivered an RBI-single on the eighth pitch with two outs.

Shaw added another RBI in the seventh inning, singling to right field that drove in Carson Kelly.

So, the Cubs wrapped their first home stand of the season with a 3-3 record. The starting pitching was great against the Angels, as Edward Cabrera, Jameson Taillon, and Matthew Boyd combined to give up a total of five hits and two earned runs.

A tough loss on Tuesday, but that was just going up against a very good pitcher in Jose Soriano. Looking back, the series loss against the Washington Nationals was annoying, but at the very least Boyd eased early concerns with his performance against the Angels.

After tomorrow’s day off, the Cubs will begin a six-game road trip on Friday, with a series against the Cleveland Guardians and then the Tampa Bay Rays.

Is It Time For The White Sox To Press The Panic Button On Shane Smith?

Apr 1, 2026; Miami, Florida, USA; Chicago White Sox starting pitcher Shane Smith (64) gets a visit from pitching coach Zach Bove in the first inning against the Miami Marlins at loanDepot Park. Mandatory Credit: Jim Rassol-Imagn Images

After turning in an All-Star season in his first season in the big leagues, the Chicago White Sox named Shane Smith their Opening Day starter, but just two starts into the 2026 season, the former Rule 5 draft pick has looked like anything but an ace.

After getting yanked in the second inning of Opening Day, allowing three runs, three hits, and a pair of walks against the Milwaukee Brewers, Smith followed that with an even uglier outing against the Miami Marlins.

The good news was that Smith made it out of the second inning. The bad news is that he only lasted three innings. With a White Sox bullpen already taxed, pitching 20.2 innings in the first five games, the team desperately needed Smith to eat innings. Instead, Will Venable was forced to turn to his relievers early once again after Smith was pulled, having given up eight runs on seven hits with a pair of walks.

Adding insult to injury, he also committed a costly throwing error in the first inning, which turned what could have been at least the second out of the inning into an early jam he was unable to escape. 

The season is still young, and there’s plenty to like about Smith, but the red flags are hard to ignore. In just 4.2 innings, he has already surrendered 11 hits and four walks vs. just two strikeouts. This comes after he issued nine free passes and was tagged for 13 runs in just 10.2 innings in Spring Training. 

Smith’s struggles to pitch deep into games are nothing new. Even during his All-Star season, when he posted a 3.81 ERA, he walked 9.1% of batters and allowed plenty of hard contact, ranking in the bottom third of the league in average exit velocity. As a result, he averaged just five innings per start across his 29 outings last season.

Consistency also emerged as an issue for the 25-year-old right-hander last season. After starting the season allowing three runs or less in his first eight starts, he got tagged for 22 earned runs in a four-game stretch between June 17 and July 6. 

None of this is to say that Smith can’t be a piece of the rotation moving forward. But at this point, he looks more like a third or fourth starter than an ace. His early struggles have not only strained the bullpen, but they have also taken the White Sox out of two games that should have at least been competitive with the No. 1 starter on the bump. 

In an organization that has four pitchers on its top 10 prospect list, including two arms ranked among MLB Pipeline’s top-100 prospects, it will be interesting to see how long a leash Smith will get. 

The Charlotte Knights alone boast a rotation of Hagen Smith, Noah Schultz, Tanner McDougal, David Sandlin, and Jonathan Cannon, who all, in theory, could get starts in the big league rotation this year. 

Smith still has minor league options and could benefit from a reset in Triple-A. The White Sox found success with a similar approach last season, sending Colson Montgomery, who was struggling in Triple-A, to Arizona to work on his swing with hitting director Ryan Fuller.

It’s a strategy that the White Sox couldn’t use last season when Smith hit a rough patch, because as a Rule 5 pick, he was required to stay on the big-league roster all year, or risk being offered back to the Milwaukee Brewers.

Smith is an easy guy to root for. After being a relative unknown minor leaguer, he emerged as one of the best breakout storylines of 2025. But it’s fair to wonder if he was a one-year wonder, now that teams have a large sample size of tape to work off of. 

It’s still too early for a drastic reset in the minor leagues, but the cracks in Smith’s game are glaring. If he continues at this current rate, difficult questions are going to have to be asked.

White Sox Luis Robert Trade Nearly Took Another Direction

Mar 31, 2026; Miami, Florida, USA; Chicago White Sox center fielder Luisangel Acuna (0) celebrates with teammates after scoring against the Miami Marlins during the third inning at loanDepot Park. Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images

New details from Chris Getz’s trade talks with the New York Mets reveal the Chicago White Sox return for Luis Robert Jr. could have looked drastically different.

According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the two sides were engaged in trade talks centered around Robert since June, with “ a thousand iterations” of trade packages for Robert thrown around. 

After failing to strike a deal at last year’s trade deadline, the White Sox picked Robert’s $20 million player option at the end of the season, before ultimately trading their All-Star center fielder for Luisangel Acuna and minor league right-hander Truman Pauley. 

While Acuna’s name had been thrown around in trade rumors, he reportedly wasn’t the White Sox first choice. According to Heyman, the White Sox were initially interested in former first-round pick Brett Bady. 

It’s easy to see why the White Sox were interested in Bady. The 26-year-old infielder hit 18 homers and posted a .748 OPS after playing in a career high 130 games last season. Given the crowded Mets infield, the White Sox had assumed he would be the odd man out in New York. 

However, per Heyman, the Mets quickly shot that proposal down and instead offered Mark Vientos before last year’s trade deadline, a 26-year-old corner infielder, who Mets brass believed was going to have a diminishing role on the team. 

But Getz reportedly preferred Acuna, which raises the question: Did Getz make the right decision? 

Vientos, who has slugged a combined 44 home runs over the past two seasons, offers a much higher offensive floor than Acuña. Across five MLB seasons, he owns a .732 OPS, hitting .239 with a strikeout rate near 28 percent. But he made up for the swing and miss concerns by launching a career-high 27 home runs and driving in 71 RBIs in 2024. He has also proven that he can draw hard contact consistently, with an average exit velocity of 91.4 mph last season, which ranked in the MLB’s 82nd percentile. 

Meanwhile, Acuna, who entered the season with just 109 games of MLB experience, had posted a .248/.299/.341 slash line with three home runs and 14 RBIs during his two seasons in Queens. However, given Acuña’s skill set, he offers a higher ceiling than Vientos, albeit with more risk attached.

The White Sox already have a crowded infield, with Miguel Vargas and Munetaka Murakami holding down the corner infield positions, and Andrew Benintendi expected to handle the bulk of the DH duties, leaving Vientos without a clear path to everyday at-bats. Had the White Sox agreed to that deal before the deadline, there’s a strong chance they wouldn’t have later signed Murakami to a two-year, $34 million contract.

Acuna, meanwhile, offers far more versatility. While he has spent most of his time in the infield, the White Sox believed his speed and athleticism could make him an intriguing candidate to play centerfield, despite logging just three innings at the position before getting traded. On top of that, Acuna also had two more years of club control than Vientos. 

Vientos is also a sub-par defender, owning a -6 defensive Run Value in each of the last two seasons, which would have been hard to justify swapping a Gold Glove-winning centerfielder for. 

While Acuña comes with more risk, he also remains largely unproven, having yet to receive an extended opportunity to show what he can do. While Vientos is a solid bat, he has done nothing to suggest he can be a long-term piece to build around. Acuna might not get to that point either, but his wide-ranging skill set makes Chris Getz’s bet on him a worthwhile one.

George McCaskey Has Joined The War For The Bears’ Comp Picks — Here Are The Details

chicago bears
Oct 13, 2024; London, United Kingdom; Chicago Bears chairman George McCaskey. (left) and NFL commissioner Roger Goodell embrace during an NFL International Series game at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images

The NFL made its ruling at the start of the new league year. Despite significant evidence showing Ian Cunningham was the primary football decision-maker for the Atlanta Falcons, the Chicago Bears would not receive two compensatory draft picks per the Rooney Rule. It was a baffling decision. Everybody involved in the situation believes the Bears were entitled to compensation. Even the national media couldn’t understand the NFL’s stubbornness regarding such a technicality. It felt like they were trying to avoid admitting they were wrong and didn’t mind screwing the Bears in the process. One would think that would be the end of it, right? Not if George McCaskey has anything to say about it.

The team chairman and owner has never been known for being overly meddlesome in league affairs. That said, he can be pretty active when he feels the cause is worthy. This is one of those cases. McCaskey, along with team president Kevin Warre and general manager Ryan Poles, flew to New York for a meeting with commissioner Roger Goodell to reinforce their appeal over the comp picks. It is hoped that this added pressure from an actual owner might sway the decision.

George McCaskey is in uncharted territory.

The NFL has made adjustments to compensatory picks before, but never this close to the draft. As of now, the closest it has happened is 44 days before opening night. There are only 23 days now until the 2026 draft begins. Chicago would shatter that record if they somehow convinced the NFL to reverse its decision. Knowing how the league has operated for years, it is hard to imagine it will be willing to rock the boat that much. Then again, they are the ones who created this mess with the funky language in the Rooney Rule. They are duty-bound to clean it up.

Making this matter even messier is an ongoing dispute with Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, who is attacking the Rooney Rule. He states it constitutes blatant race and sex discrimination and not hiring based on merit. Most see it as the highly conservative state’s way of further curbing diversity hiring policies in the state. If Goodell were to admit the NFL made a mistake with the Bears’ decision, it wouldn’t be a great look. That makes it more difficult to get it overturned.

McCaskey is doing the right thing.

What has happened to his franchise is an injustice. They followed the spirit of the Rooney Rule, helping Cunningham elevate his profile to a point where he was hired to run his own NFL franchise. According to the rule, any minority hire in that situation earns his former team two 3rd round compensatory picks. Yet the NFL is holding out because the Falcons chose to give Matt Ryan the title of director of football operations, even though he was never going to actually run the scouting operation and pick players.

The league basically looked at his title and didn’t bother gathering any further information. He’s the primary football guy, so no picks for you. George McCaskey may not be the sharpest owner around, but he knows an injustice when he sees one. His presence in the appeal process might give Goodell pause on the matter since this isn’t something McCaskey does often. Maybe it’s a losing effort, but it wasn’t a fight the Bears were ready to abandon. They were cheated and intend to make their displeasure known.