Saturday, November 21, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 1144

BREAKING: Luis Robert Jr. Wins First Silver Slugger

Aug 30, 2023; Baltimore, Maryland, USA; Chicago White Sox outfielder Luis Robert Jr. (88) rounds the bases following his solo run home run in the third inning against the Baltimore Orioles at Oriole Park at Camden Yards. Mandatory Credit: Mitch Stringer-USA TODAY Sports

On the heels of a gold glove award snubbing, Luis Robert Jr. finally gets recognition and wins his first major award in the big leagues. After a season where Robert was the best player on the Sox by far, this award is extremely deserving. For the season he had, he should have been in the running for MVP as well, but he will have to settle for the potential of being selected to the all-MLB team instead.

In 2023, Robert showed the potential everyone knew he had. He set a career-high in home runs, RBIS, and stolen bases, en route to his first all-star selection. This was the first season where he played over 100 games, so that is also a benchmark to be proud of. When Robert is healthy, he is a premier bat in the White Sox lineup and would be in any lineup.

Over 148 games, Robert slugged his way to 38 home runs and 80 RBIs. He could have potentially added to that total if he had not gotten hurt at the end of the season. This is exactly what the White Sox were hoping to get out of Robert when they spent a significant amount of money on him in international free agency. Despite the injuries, he has lived up to the hype.

Robert should be a cornerstone of the White Sox for years to come. He is truly the type of player that you can’t replace, as his five-tool skill set is hard to find these days. While Chris Getz says everyone is on the table, I don’t think he would consider a Robert trade just yet.

Robert is still just 26 years old and had one of the best WARs in all of baseball. If there is one player the Sox should build around, it’s him. He and Jake Burger could have formed a great middle-of-the-order duo for the next five years, but the White Sox had to ruin that by trading Burger to the Marlins.

The best part about Robert is his contract. He will be making 12 million next year, 15 the year after that, and has 20 million dollar options in 2026 and 2027. That is extremely cheap for a player of his caliber now, just wait until how cheap that is in a few years. There is no reason to trade him, as the White Sox can’t use the salary cap as an excuse.

Despite the uncertainty with the team, this is a nice win for Robert. He is the latest White Sox to win the award, and the first since 2020 when Tim Anderson, Jose Abreu, and Eloy Jimenez all won silver sluggers. Robert is just entering the prime of his career and will only get better. This will not be the only silver slugger he will put in his trophy case. Congratulations, Luis!

One Overlooked Reason The Bears Might Be Holding Justin Fields Out

tyson bagent

We’ve already covered how odd the situation regarding Justin Fields is. I wrote about whispers of division inside Halas Hall about whether the quarterback should play. Those include a belief Ryan Poles wants to delay his return because he’s ready to move on. Then Adam Hoge of CHGO revealed that some in the building were surprised Fields didn’t return against New Orleans, never mind Carolina. That speaks to a disconnect in the organization about the goal for Fields. There is no cohesive plan, or at least it seems that way.

There is one other possibility that hasn’t been considered. It feels like the Bears might be trying to give Tyson Bagent one more chance to seize the starting job. Some people will scoff at that. They shouldn’t. The undrafted rookie has shown flashes of above-average play since taking over as the starter three weeks ago. He’s completing 67% of his passes, averaging over 200 yards passing and 31 rushing over that span. For three quarters last Sunday in New Orleans, he looked really good. Unfortunately, a turnover-filled 4th ruined it.

There is evidence this young man can play. Now he’s about to face a Carolina Panthers defense that is 31st in points allowed and will be playing without star pass rusher Brian Burns. If Bagent can put together a complete performance, it might give the Bears the excuse to let him keep playing.

Nothing about the Justin Fields situation makes sense.

A month ago, everybody made it sound like the quarterback could return in a few weeks. When he missed the New Orleans game, that was confirmation he’d get back for the home stand against Carolina. Ignoring this one also leads to two possible conclusions. Either the thumb injury is far worse than reported, or some people with heavy sway in the organization would prefer he stay on the sideline for the time being. Based on what Hoge said, it doesn’t sound like the thumb is a huge issue. Fields has been throwing at practice for the past three days with few signs of notable discomfort.

Something is going on. Perhaps the flashes Bagent has shown were enough to encourage giving him more playing time. Nobody is saying he’s the second coming of Kurt Warner, but it’s at least apparent the kid isn’t your typical undrafted quarterback. He has abilities that can work in the NFL, at least as a backup. Maybe more experience could help him overcome his turnover issues from the past two weeks. It’s not like the Bears are in the thick of a playoff chase at 2-7. This might be the perfect time to experiment, even if it costs Justin Fields playing time.

Luis Robert Jr. Nominated For 2023 All-MLB Team

Aug 6, 2023; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Chicago White Sox center fielder Luis Robert Jr. (88) rounds the bases after hitting an RBI triple during the first inning against the Cleveland Guardians at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

Luis Robert Jr has been nominated for another honor after his breakout 2023 campaign. On Thursday the MLB announced that Robert is a nominee for the 2023 All-MLB team, which recognizes the best performers of the regular season. 

Robert being up for the All-MLB team should come as no surprise. The 26-year-old got it done on both sides of the ball. Had the White Sox produced a better record Robert would have been a legitimate MVP candidate. 

The White Sox center fielder became the first player in franchise history to hit at least 35 home runs, 35 doubles, and swipe 20 bases in one season. Robert’s 38 home runs were the second most in the AL. He also stole 20 bases, drove in 80 RBIs, and owned the third-highest slugging percentage (.542) among qualified American League hitters. Meanwhile, his expected slugging percentage ranked in the MLB’s top nine percentile. 

His defensive work was equally impressive. Robert was tied with Kevin Kiermaier, who won the Gold Glove Award,  for the highest center field Outs Above Average in the American League at +13. That placed Robert in the MLB’s top 98th percentile. 

Robert recorded 370 putouts, the most by any outfielder in the MLB. His 2.81 Range Factor Per/9 innings, which measures the number of putouts and assists per inning played, was the highest in the MLB. He also produced the most double plays from center field in the league and ranked in the top five in fielding percentage, Range Factor Per Game, and defensive games played in center field. 

Not only did Robert excel on the stat sheet, he also passed the eye test. Robert produced a highlight reel full of jaw-dropping plays which included multiple home run robberies.  One such play included a catch at the wall where Robert had to cover 102 feet of ground in 5.3 seconds to secure an out on a ball with a 5% catch probability. 

A fan vote will decide the award. Fans can vote daily for the best at each position through November 19th.

Bears Insider Hints At Division In Halas Hall On Justin Fields

justin fields
Oct 15, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields (1) passes against the Minnesota Vikings at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Sabau-USA TODAY Sports

Yesterday, I wrote about Matt Eberflus’ weird press conference where he seemed to waffle on the subject of why Justin Fields wasn’t ready to play for Thursday night against Carolina. He stated he wasn’t medically cleared but then seemed to indicate there was still a chance he might play. It was so odd. The man looked like he didn’t have a clear idea of what he was supposed to say. I then revealed a source told me that GM Ryan Poles and others inside Halas Hall were delaying Fields’ return.

It appears there is a desire to move on from the embattled quarterback in 2024. Poles has seen enough. He wants to find his own guy. However, that decision would become complicated if Fields happened to return and play well down the stretch, winning some meaningless games in a lost season. Yes, it sounds way too conspiratorial. However, Adam Hoge of CHGO revealed rumblings of his own. Apparently, some inside the organization are also surprised Fields isn’t playing.

“I’m surprised Justin Fields isn’t playing tonight. And I know some inside Halas Hall are surprised too. One source I spoke with expected Fields to return last week against the Saints. Is Fields 100 percent? No. But he might not be 100 percent in 11 days against the Lions either. Based on what I saw in practice Wednesday — and it’s admittedly a small portion of practice we get to see — I saw a quarterback capable of playing tonight. Coupling this knowledge with Matt Eberflus’ odd “doubtful but out” press conference yesterday — well, something doesn’t add up here.”

Justin Fields will return, but his window is closing.

The thumb injury might be getting leveraged as a convenient excuse to hold the quarterback out. Maybe they’re hoping Tyson Bagent gives them a reason to keep him in. More likely, they’re trying to narrow Fields’ window to make his case for keeping the job. If he’d returned against New Orleans as many expected, that would’ve given him nine games—more than half of a season. Now he’s looking at seven games, presuming he returns after the mini-bye week against Detroit. Five of those games will be against opponents with top-10 defenses. Fields has averaged 150 yards passing with 11 TDs and 10 interceptions since the start of 2022 against such opponents.

Maybe things are getting blown out of proportion. Still, it feels more and more like the organization is ready to move on from Justin Fields. His health problems persist. The sack numbers haven’t gone down despite improvement on the offensive line. He’s still not protecting the ball well enough. There isn’t enough evidence to justify giving him another season. Plenty of people will disagree with that, but the lack of proof says it all. At some point, a team has to stop betting on potential.

Why Ryan Poles May Divert From Predicted 2024 QB Path

ryan poles
Nov 4, 2023; Los Angeles, California, USA; Washington Huskies quarterback Michael Penix Jr. (9) throws a pass against the USC Trojans during the second quarter at United Airlines Field at Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. Mandatory Credit: Jonathan Hui-USA TODAY Sports

One thing to remember about the NFL draft is that it isn’t always as predictable as people like to believe. What seems like a no-brainer in November becomes unthinkable in April. One thing people agree on is that if the Chicago Bears end up with a top-2 pick in the 2024 draft, GM Ryan Poles is guaranteed to select either Caleb Williams or Drake Maye at quarterback. Justin Fields’ time will be over. Straightforward and simple. Poles has seen enough of Fields. He didn’t draft the quarterback but made sure to give him a fair opportunity to earn the long-term job.

However, it might not be wise to assume outright that Williams or Maye are the unquestioned guys in Poles’ mind. One source informed SM that the Bears GM “really likes” Washington quarterback Michael Penix Jr. While that may shock some, it shouldn’t. After a rough four-year stint in Indiana that involved injury setbacks, Penix has come alive in two seasons with Washington. Across 22 games, he’s thrown for 7,842 yards, 57 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions. As of this moment, he is the current betting favorite to win the Heisman trophy.

Yet many continue to ignore him in favor of Williams and Maye. Poles doesn’t seem to be one of them.

Ryan Poles’ interest in Penix would not be surprising.

While he has yet to draft a quarterback in his stint as Bears GM, he did sign one in Tyson Bagent. The Shepherd product brought good size (6’3), consistent accuracy, poise in the pocket, and lots of starting experience from college. Penix is 6’3, throws with good accuracy at all levels, isn’t flustered in the pocket, and has started 35 games. He checks every single box based on what we know of Poles’ QB preferences. He also has a growing reputation for showing up in big games. Penix beat Texas in the Alamo Bowl last year. This year, he has taken down powerhouse Oregon and outdueled Williams in the Rose Bowl.

None of this means Ryan Poles would take him with one of those high 1st round picks. The general consensus around Penix is that he’s a late-1st, early-2nd round talent. It is possible the Bears might wish to use those early 1sts on top non-QB prospects while trying to wrangle another pick to try nabbing Penix. We already know Poles isn’t afraid to trade down from high picks. He did so last March with #1 overall.

There are so many variables still involved. It’s possible minds will change over the next few months. Plenty of evaluations are still to come. Just Penix in mind once the off-season arrives.

MLB Free Agent Predictions Contest

The Pinwheels And Ivy Podcast is having an MLB free agent predictions contest. To enter, click here.

Prize: $50 Amazon Gift Card
Rules
Predict team and contract of top-20 free agents
Scoring
7 points for correct team
5 points for exact contract value (Total $)
*1 point awarded if you’re within $5 million either way
3 points for correct length of contract

Valid entries must include team, length of contract and total value of contract.

(1 entry per person)
Entries valid until one of the top-20 free agents signs
One winner will be announced and contacted directly through their email once all top-20 free agents have signed.

Subscribe to the Pinwheels And Ivy Podcast on YouTube and enter the contest!

Check out the latest episode of the Pinwheels And Ivy Podcast, where we discuss the Cubs being in on every free agent and major trade targets, while Chris Getz begins his goal of establishing a new identity for the White Sox.

3 Bold Predictions For Bears vs Panthers Game

Oct 5, 2023; Landover, Maryland, USA; Chicago Bears wide receiver DJ Moore (2) reacts against the Washington Commanders during the second half at FedExField. Mandatory Credit: Brad Mills-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears are getting ready for a Thursday night matchup against the Carolina Panthers. Justin Fields remains sidelined due to a thumb injury, so rookie quarterback Tyson Bagent will continue to start. Despite the setback, here are my three bold predictions for the game.

DJ Moore goes for 200 yards

Let’s dub it the DJ Moore revenge game. It would be even sweeter with Justin Fields as the quarterback, but the Bears are up against a seriously depleted and weak Panthers defense. Looks like a winning formula to me.

Bears defense gets 3 turnovers

Panthers rookie quarterback Bryce Young has struggled with turnovers, experiencing two pick-sixes in a single game this season. However, the Bears defense, led by Matt Eberflus, has shown improvement. Additionally, Jaquan Brisker’s return from a concussion adds strength to the defense this week. With Montez Sweat having been present for more than a week now, this matchup has the potential to be a fun game on the defensive side.

Bears win by 10+ points

Picking the Bears to win might seem like taking the easy route, especially since they’re 3-point favorites. However, considering the factors I highlighted earlier, and the fact that they’re up against one of the worst teams in football, the Bears should snag a comfortable victory. Now, if by some twist of fate the Bears lose to the Panthers, Ryan Poles has to fire Matt Eberflus. He can promote Luke Getsy to head coach and then fire him too. Let another assistant take over. I am halfway joking here but if the Bears do lose changes should be made the next morning.

Bears vs Panthers Preview

Make sure to watch the video below for a great breakdown of the Bears vs Panthers game.

Jason Benetti Stuns Everyone, Leaves White Sox for Division Rival

Holy shit, who saw this coming? Chicago White Sox play-by-play man Jason Benetti has left the south side and is now the new announcer for the Detroit Tigers.

The news of this stunning move came out on Thursday morning. The White Sox said they are now looking for a replacement in their TV booth, as Len Kasper is committed to his radio role.

This seemingly came out of left field, as Benetti signed a multi-year contract with the White Sox back in January. Yet, despite getting a new deal with his hometown team, Benetti did admit the negotiations were annoying with the White Sox.

Via the Chicago Sun-Times.

“The really good news is we got somewhere good,” Benetti said. “It was kind of a pain, really. There were some things that we had to get through that I thought were silly, and I’m sure they thought some of the stuff that I was talking about might’ve been silly. But we got there in the end.”

Now, after the White Sox lost 101 games in 2023, Benetti is off to Detroit, where he will call at least 127 Tigers games each season according to the team’s press release. Benetti will also continue to fulfill his other broadcasting duties that include national MLB games, college football and college basketball games.

Benetti’s first regular season game with the Tigers will be against the White Sox on Opening Day in 2024 in Detroit.

The Tigers have announced a multi-year deal with Benetti.

It does seem like the White Sox were unhappy that Benetti was not committed to their team for all 162 regular season games.

The following is from Jon Greenberg’s story on Benetti from March.

Via The Athletic.

The big issue between the Sox and Benetti was his schedule.

During the season, some people with the White Sox weren’t so keen on Benetti being gone so much for his other jobs — though they have radio guy Len Kasper as perhaps the most overqualified fill-in in sports — and they let him know about it. This is the first year he’ll do weekly Saturday national baseball games for Fox.

After some negotiation, his new contract spells out how many Sox games he can miss — he said it’ll be 35, max — and that should go a long way to smoothing any rough patches with the team, at least for the next two years.

So, after eight years, Benetti, who is a lifelong White Sox fan, is leaving the team he’s loved for the Tigers.

ESPN’s Latest Update On Matt Eberflus’ Job Status Is Telling

matt eberflus
Oct 1, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Matt Eberflus looks up at the scoreboard in the fourth quarter during a game against the Denver Broncos at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Jamie Sabau-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears are in the midst of another rough season. Since the start of 2022, it has arguably been the worst stretch in franchise history. They are 5-21 in that span. At the center of the mess is head coach Matt Eberflus. He was brought in because it was felt he could reestablish a winning culture, cut down on the constant self-inflicted wounds, and bring back many of the qualities that were present during the Lovie Smith days. Instead, he’s produced the worst winning percentage of any coach in franchise history. The team is near the top of the league in both penalties and giveaways. The defense, his supposed area of expertise, is also bad.

Nothing about the Bears can be sold as a positive development under Eberflus’ watch. He’s insisted up and down that things are getting better. The team was competitive in New Orleans against a good Saints team. That glosses over the fact they were blasted 30-13 the week before in Los Angeles. Eberflus is grasping at straws. He knows the pressure on him is mounting. That said, his seat might not be as scalding as many think it is. Adam Jahns of The Athletic predicted he would stick around another year. Now, an update from Jeremy Fowler of ESPN suggests there isn’t nearly as much heat on him as one might expect

“The Bears’ Matt Eberflus is now 5-21. To be fair, he inherited a tough situation and has worked admirably to keep things together there. I don’t sense much friction in Chicago. Still, that record could be tough to overcome.”

Selling Matt Eberflus will be impossible without more wins.

That is the simple fact. Five wins in one and a half seasons is unacceptable for any franchise, especially the Bears. Yes, it’s acknowledged the team embraced full rebuild mode when they gutted the roster of proven veterans last year. Even so, improvement should be expected going into the second season. There hasn’t been much of that on either side of the ball. Unless Eberflus can produce a modestly better record than his 3-14 campaign from last season, it will be impossible to sell another year of him to the fans.

There are eight games left. Three of them are against opponents in the thick of the playoff chase, and another two are against teams that have already beaten them once this year. One of the easiest games is tonight on Thursday Night Football against a one-win Carolina Panthers team. If Matt Eberflus can’t pull off a victory against them, that will be a potential death blow to any idea of him getting a third season. There is no way the organization can convince people he should stick around to oversee the potential development of a new quarterback.

Bizarre Matt Eberflus Presser Exposed Potential Justin Fields Conflict

matt eberflus

Nobody wants to lean too much into conspiracy theories. Still, it’s hard not to feel like something odd is happening with Justin Fields. The quarterback suffered a dislocated thumb against Minnesota last month. Tests revealed no break—initial projections offered hope that he might be able to return by the game in New Orleans. In fact, there were rumblings that game was the target. Well, the game came and went. Fields didn’t play. So that clearly meant he was getting four extra days to get right for Thursday night at home against the Carolina Panthers. Then the news dropped. Fields was doubtful to play. What made it all the more bizarre was Matt Eberflus.

The Bears head coach was more evasive than usual about the situation. While he said backup Tyson Bagent would start, he also suggested an outside possibility Fields could still play. The only thing he kept saying was that the quarterback wasn’t cleared yet. It was a befuddling two minutes of audio that suggested Eberflus didn’t have a clear answer on what Fields’ status is. Either the thumb was worse than they expected, or something else was going on.

Matt Eberflus may not have a say on if Fields can play.

Rumors on these situations can always be shaky. That said, one source informed SM that Fields still isn’t back because of resistance from GM Ryan Poles. He is delaying the quarterback’s return as long as possible because he wants to make a change at the position. Poles is cognizant of what happened four years ago in 2019. Mitch Trubisky looked like he had lost control of the starting job. Then he won four out of five games down the stretch, playing well against some weak competition. Chicago snuck into the playoffs as a wild card. That saved his job, prompting the Bears to pursue Nick Foles as competition rather than starting over.

Maybe they would’ve drafted Jalen Hurts that subsequent off-season if they’d pulled the plug. Poles doesn’t want to give Fields that opportunity to save himself at the last second. He’s ready to move on. We’ve already heard scattered reports of this for the past month.

It might explain why Matt Eberflus had no straight answer on what’s going on. Either that or the simpler answer is that the head coach still has no grasp on handling the media. The bottom line is Bagent will start at least one more game, and Fields is running out of time to rescue a sinking ship.