Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 1006

One Other NFL Draft QB Has Fans Among Chicago Bears Brass

chicago bears
Nov 4, 2023; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Michigan Wolverines quarterback J.J. McCarthy (9) looks to pass in the first half against the Purdue Boilermakers at Michigan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

If you’ve been following all of the breadcrumbs over the past month, one thing has become clear. Caleb Williams is the heavy favorite to go #1 overall in the 2024 draft, and the Chicago Bears are expected to be the team that takes him. The USC star made a lot of positive impressions in his first meeting with the team at the scouting combine. He was also talked up by teammates and coaches leading up to that. Dianna Russini of The Athletic indicated their impressions of him have only improved since. However, there is one thing to remember about the draft evaluation process.

There is rarely a full consensus inside the organization.

It was true in 2017 and 2021. While GM Ryan Pace preferred both Mitch Trubisky and Justin Fields in those respective drafts, it was later revealed there were dissenters in the draft room. Several liked Patrick Mahomes and Mac Jones more. Pace had the final say, so that’s how it went. As it turns out, the same is true for this year. Plenty of key people in Halas Hall have bought into Williams as the guy. Not everybody, though. According to a source, there is a sect of people in the front office and scouting department who have a strong liking for Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy.

While they acknowledge his need for further development as a passer, his talent and excellent intangibles, charisma, leadership, and poise under pressure make for an intriguing prospect.

The Chicago Bears haven’t made a final decision yet.

Williams is the undeniable leader in the clubhouse, but there are still pro days and private visits to get through. A lot can change in that time span. McCarthy might not have the glittering stats Williams does, but he’s 27-1 as a starter with a national championship ring on his finger. He is all about the success of the team, even if that means not putting up stellar stat lines. His job is to be ready whenever his coaches ask him to make a play. That is exactly what he did over and over and over last season.

The problem is McCarthy might not be ready to start immediately. Most experts agree he needs a year of development before he’s ready. That means the Chicago Bears would need a bridge option to buy time. Maybe they hang onto Justin Fields for another year, or they could dip into the free agent quarterback pool. The source said they have checked in on what Kirk Cousins, Baker Mayfield, and Russell Wilson are asking for.

If the Bears do have serious interest in McCarthy, that would fan the flames of a possible trade down from #1 overall. It doesn’t feel likely at this point, but it only takes one person to change that: Poles.

Blackhawks Complete Surprisingly Quiet Trade Deadline, Assign Players To Minors

Feb 19, 2024; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; Chicago Blackhawks center Tyler Johnson (90) celebrates his goal aCarolina Hurricanes during the third period at PNC Arena. Mandatory Credit: James Guillory-USA TODAY Sports

We were told throughout this season that it would be a quiet trade deadline for the Blackhawks, but we didn’t expect things to be this quiet.

The NHL trade deadline came and went Friday afternoon at 2:00 p.m. CST, and the Blackhawks didn’t end up making a single deal throughout the day. Yesterday’s “blockbuster” occurred when GM Kyle Davidson shipped forward Anthony Beauvillier to Nashville in exchange for a fifth-round pick in this year’s draft. When the Blackhawks struggled to field a lineup at the end of November, Beauviller was acquired for a fifth-round pick, so the trade completes an “interest-free loan” of sorts.

Even with potential trade chips like Colin Blackwell and Tyler Johnson on the roster, though, Davidson and his staff didn’t make another move, despite a busy deadline around the league. Household names like Matt Dumba, Adam Henrique, Vladimir Tarasenko, Jake Guentzel, and more were shuffled to new rosters.

After the deadline had passed, Davidson mentioned that he was just as busy this year as in the hectic years past, even if deals never materialized. He and head coach Luke Richardson ensured they weren’t “making a deal just to make a deal”, and the league’s demand for depth forwards never came to fruition. Instead of shipping valuable players like Blackwell and Johnson off for a single late-round pick, it was decided they were better suited playing out the last month of their contracts.

Although they didn’t make any official trades, the Blackhawks were still busy in the personnel department Friday. The most notable transaction came when the Ottawa Senators claimed bottom-six forward Boris Katchouk off waivers. He had been placed there for the purpose of being sent to Rockford so that he was eligible for the playoffs, but the Atlantic Division bottom feeder had other ideas. It isn’t a huge loss for the Blackhawks, as Katchouk was often a healthy scratch this season and is in the last year of his contract.

The Blackhawks will have to replace Katchouk on the active roster, but that may be more convenient anyway. With the Big Ten Tournament kicking off this weekend, one of Landon Slaggert or Frank Nazar’s seasons is wrapping up, as Notre Dame and Michigan face one another in the first round. The loser of that matchup could be signed as early as next week, and there’s now space on the roster to make that happen.

With Friday being the last day players could be sent to the AHL in order to be eligible for the league’s playoffs, Isaak Phillips, Louis Crevier, and Zach Sanford were all sent down. Davidson said Crevier and Phillips will likely finish out the season with the IceHogs. That’s a direct result of Nikita Zaitsev finally making his return, as the two would likely be healthy scratches anyway.

The Blackhawks weren’t expected to make much noise at the deadline, but making zero external moves was certainly a surprise. Chicago has plenty of assets to work with in the draft, as well as a prospect pool overflowing with talent. The lineup won’t look too different after the trade deadline, but a few internal moves could help spice things up.

More Details Emerge On Bears’ Internal Thoughts Of Caleb Williams

caleb williams
Jan 2, 2023; Arlington, Texas, USA; USC Trojans quarterback Caleb Williams (13) in action during the game between the USC Trojans and the Tulane Green Wave in the 2023 Cotton Bowl at AT&T Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

Everybody has heard the primary rumors regarding the Chicago Bears and Caleb Williams at this point. Guys like Adam Schefter and Ian Rapoport have both indicated GM Ryan Poles and his people have a high opinion of the USC quarterback. High enough to where it is almost a foregone conclusion they are taking him with the #1 pick. However, some wondered if interviews between the player and the team might shift things in a different direction. First meetings took place at the scouting combine, where Poles and company could speak with Williams privately.

It is often hard to gauge a player in only 15-20 minutes, but first impressions can often say a lot about somebody. Certain players have that ability to fill up a room from the moment they step in. Initial updates said Williams handled himself well in front of the Bears, showcasing his intelligence and easy-going nature. Since then, Dianna Russini of The Athletic has heard even more about the meeting. She told the Hoge & Jahns podcast that the Bears are even more sold on Williams now than before the meeting.

The Bears appear set on their path with Caleb Williams.

Either he is cemented as the #1 overall pick or Poles is enacting one of the greatest misdirection campaigns in the history of the NFL. It is possible, but feels unnecessary at this point. All signs have indicated the Bears are ready to move on from Justin Fields. They watched him for two years. He didn’t showcase anything remotely resembling top-10 quarterback play during that time. Most of his highlights came from his phenomenal athletic prowess. Every draft expert worth anything has said with utmost confidence that Williams would be an instant upgrade.

The challenge for the Bears will be crafting an offense scheme that enhances his strengths while curbing his weaknesses. His uncanny improvisational skills and accuracy must be nurtured. At the same time, offensive coordinator Shane Waldron must teach him how to play with better timing and rhythm. Those who know him don’t seem concerned about such things. If given proper support, Caleb Williams has the ability to elevate a franchise. Poles seems prepared to give him that opportunity.

The Dwindling Justin Fields Market Demonstrates Why The Bears Need To Draft A Quarterback

justin fields
Dec 31, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields (1) during the second half against the Atlanta Falcons at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Mike Dinovo-USA TODAY Sports

The NFL free agency period and new league year will begin early next week as the Chicago Bears are still looking for trade partner for quarterback Justin Fields. Over the past few weeks, the trade market for Fields has cooled significantly as the number of potential suitors and compensation level has dissipated as other signal-callers have become viable options. The abrupt decline in a once-promising market should reinforce the desire to utilize the first overall selection on a quarterback in the upcoming NFL Draft, as another year with the team’s current starting quarterback could result in wholesale changes at the end of 2024.

NFL Teams Choosing To Go In A Different Direction Is Really Troubling Given Who They Are Choosing Over Fields

Last month, the potential trade market for Fields was as hot as it could be as many prominent NFL analysts believed that Chicago’s third-year quarterback could be traded in return for a high-round draft pick, even as high as a first-rounder. Bears’ general manager Ryan Poles appeared to have a highly contentious bidding war building between multiple teams rumored to be highly interested in a trade, including the Atlanta Falcons, Pittsburgh Steelers, Las Vegas Raiders, and the New York Giants. Unfortunately, due to several quarterbacks slated to reach free agency now, talks have dropped off significantly.

The decreasing trade market is especially troubling given the alternate options other NFL teams are considering rather than potentially acquiring Fields. Atlanta appears to be heavily focused on signing former Vikings’ quarterback Kirk Cousins. Although one of the best quarterbacks in the league, Cousins is 36 years old and is coming of a torn Achilles injury that ended his 2023 season. The Falcons view the former Pro Bowl signal-caller as a better option than Fields despite being vastly older, less mobile, and more expensive.

Pittsburgh is considering multiple free-agent veteran options to address their starting quarterback position, as they could target Russell Wilson or Ryan Tannehill. Although both quarterbacks are former All-Pros with significant playoff experience, neither have good the past two seasons with their respective teams. The Denver Broncos benched Wilson at the end of the 2023 season to avoid a potential bonus payout and released him two years after one of the largest trades in league history.

Teams looking at other older and costlier options provide perspective on how Fields is seen around the league and how they view him as more of a risk than the other quarterbacks. The Falcons and Steelers are teams needing to make the playoffs in 2024, as the signal-caller position was a glaring issue for both teams in 2023. Trading Fields has been a heated debate in Chicago and across the country as many fans and analysts believe he could reach his full potential with another team, but it appears NFL teams don’t believe he can achieve that potential now.

It is especially concerning as Fields may now buck a long-standing NFL trend of franchises trading for former first-round quarterbacks, believing they could be the one to bring out the best in the player. Over the past few years, former first-round talents, including Deshaun Watson, Sam Darnold, and Baker Mayfield, have been traded for lucrative compensation involving multiple draft picks. If the current market continues, Chicago may only get a mid-round selection in return for Fields.

Declining Fields Market Further Proves Why The Bears Are Right To Draft A Quarterback

Since the end of the 2023 season, the fierce debate on whether the Bears should keep Fields or draft a quarterback with the first of their two first-round selections has engulfed Chicago sports, with fans and analysts believing the team should trade the first overall selection for a haul of top-end draft selections. The contingency believes that Poles’ front office can build an elite roster around their current starting quarterback. The theory is rooted in the belief that Fields will mature into an elite-level passer, something that fans and analysts have been waiting for the past two seasons.

If Chicago decides to forego drafting either Caleb Williams, Drake Maye, or Jayden Daniels in favor of keeping Fields, the franchise risks chasing a replacement in the next few years if their quarterback does not take the next step as a passer. Even if the Bears parlay another trade of the first overall selection and draft several Pro Bowl-level players, the team could have to trade away future draft picks to move up to select a prospect or to acquire a veteran talent at the position. Potentially moving the first overall pick again, along with Fields not developing, would prove to be a historically embarrassing decision, given the talent at the quarterback position in the draft.

The lack of interest should be a reinforcer for Chicago as they have leaned towards drafting a quarterback throughout this offseason. If the Bears can’t get high-end compensation, it isn’t their fault, as opposing NFL teams may view Fields as a risk rather than a reward despite his youth, mobility, and cost-friendly rookie contract. Teams choosing older and declining quarterbacks as safer options demonstrate how Chicago’s quarterback and his passing ability are realistically thought of around the league.

Unfortunately, teams aren’t more interested in Fields, but potentially giving up top-end draft selections for a signal-caller lacking consistency as a passer can be an intimidating scenario. The franchises that were initially interested are in a must-win situation and can’t afford to miss out on the playoffs because the third-year quarterback never matured during his fourth season in the league. The Bears may not get the return they expected for Fields, but the declining desire to acquire him should be peace that the franchise should draft a quarterback with their first pick.

3 Demoted Players That Will Still Impact The Cubs’ 2024 Season

Feb 23, 2024; Mesa, Arizona, USA; Chicago Cubs center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong (52) reacts after hitting a single against the Chicago White Sox in the first inning at Sloan Park. Mandatory Credit: Rick Scuteri-USA TODAY Sports

Time flies when you’re having fun, and that’s what the Chicago Cubs are doing in spring training. We are under three weeks from the 2024 Cubs kicking off the regular season in Arlington, Texas. As the days left in camp dwindle, so must the number of players on the Cubs roster.

Eventually, 26 players will be named to the Opening Day roster, and the others will be distributed to the minor league affiliates or cut. On Friday, the Cubs announced they have reduced the number of rostered players from 62 to 50. The roster now consists of 27 pitchers, 5 catchers, 11 infielders, 6 outfielders, and 1 infield/outfielder. This includes 16 non-roster invitees.

We have seen a youth movement in Mesa so far this spring. The Cubs have several top prospects on display and are performing at a high level. This made some of these decisions difficult to make. But the Cubs roster has a beautiful problem – an overflow of talent. Although they have been optioned or assigned to minor league camps, keep an eye on these five players to impact the Cubs in 2024.

Pete Crow-Armstrong Will Impact the Cubs’ 2024

The top prospect in the Cubs organization, Pete Crow-Armstrong, had his eyes set on a roster spot at the beginning of spring training, especially with the Cubs’ offseason activity. But those chances became less likely after the Cubs re-signed Cody Bellinger and stated their commitment to Michael Busch at first base. PCA was optioned to AAA Iowa on Friday.

If he were to make the major league roster, PCA would not get nearly as many opportunities as he will starting in Des Moines. When he was a September call-up in 2024, we saw how much the lack of consistency impacted his flow and effectiveness at the plate. It would be the same story if he broke camp with the Cubs because he would not be a starter.

But PCA will be called up in 2024 and have a second chance to shine in the bigs. Whether it is due to injury, due to trade, or to add depth, PCA will be back on the North Side of Chicago at some point. He will stay active and ready with Iowa until his number is called, which might be the last time he’s ever called up. He might stick around.

Ben Brown Could Provide Eventual Pitching Depth In The Majors

Big Ben Brown came to the Cubs organization through the trade that sent reliever David Robertson to the Philadelphia Phillies in 2022. After an oblique injury kept him out for a while in 2023, his focus shifted from starting games to coming out of the bullpen. It didn’t improve anything for him, but hope was high entering camp this year.

Brown has pitched six innings for the Cubs this spring. He has five strikeouts but has given up three walks and three hits, resulting in one earned run. Still, this is a vast improvement and exactly what the Cubs wanted to see out of him in camp. He’ll build on this momentum as he begins his 2024 with AAA Iowa.

Manager Craig Counsell specifically named Brown as a player who he sees being on the major league roster at some point in 2024. Brown will continue working in Iowa and wait for his turn to make his major league debut. We could see him after the All-Star break, but an unexpected injury could bring him up to the Cubs in 2024 sooner than that.

Matt Shaw Is On A Quick Path To The Bigs

The Cubs drafted Matt Shaw in the first round of the 2023 draft out of Maryland. He immediately went to work with high-A South Bend but ended the year with AA Tennessee, pulverizing opposing pitching in both spots. He was assigned to minor league camp on Friday.

Shaw has had a spring that has had Cubs fans remembering his name. Drafted as a second baseman, Shaw has seen time all over the infield while ripping extra-base hits at the plate. He spent his offseason working on his defense at third base, a position Craig Counsell has deemed “fluid” going into the regular season. If he makes it to the bigs, he may come to play third.

The Cubs drafted Nico Hoerner in 2018, and he made his major league debut in 2019. The weird 2020 season prevented him from joining a roster, but he returned to the club in 2021. This is the last time we have seen the Cubs draft a player and have him in the majors just a year later. If Shaw continues his path of destruction at his next assignment, we may see him follow Hoerner’s quick path to the top.

Honorable Mentions To Play For The Cubs In 2024

We have seen a lot of raved reviews on Owen Caissie so far this spring. He was designated to minor league camp on Friday but could move around quickly. If Pete Crow-Armstrong is called up to Chicago, there is a good chance he does not go back down. If Caissie is starting in AA Tennessee, he could see a quick jump to AAA Iowa to fill PCA’s void. But he could also stay and be a candidate to leapfrog to Chicago and play for the Cubs in 2024.

We have seen a lot of movement with Kevin Alcantara ever since he came to the Cubs organization. He has previously spent a small amount of time at the major league level at times of need. With his experience there, he is someone the Cubs may rely on in a pinch. But he is always someone they have in the back pocket.

Brennen Davis had an excellent spring training until he got hit in the head during an at-bat. The Cubs placed him in concussion protocol, and he has been out of the lineup for over a week. This is a big year for Davis as the one-time top prospect is battling back from injuries that have kept him down the last couple of seasons. If he comes back and continues what he was doing in the spring, he could be in contention for a September call-up.

ESPN Gives Mediocre Grade To Cubs’ Offseason

Jan 12, 2024; Chicago, IL, USA; Chicago Cubs president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer (right) shakes hands with newly signed pitcher Shota Imanaga during a press conference at Loews Chicago Hotel. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

After starting with the bombshell of signing Craig Counsell as their manager, replacing David Ross, the Chicago Cubs‘ offseason started as hot as ever. Many believed the Cubs would not begin with a move like Counsell to fizzle off and stand pat. Eyes got big, and rumors swirled quickly.

However, as the calendar turned to 2024, nothing significant changed for the Cubs. They fell short in the races for Shohei Ohtani, Yoshinobu Yamamoto, and a trade for Tyler Glasnow, who all went to the Los Angeles Dodgers on historically lucrative contracts. They had also not yet signed outfielder Cody Bellinger as expected. National writers were beginning to doubt what the Cubs were doing.

Then, things finally started to heat up. The Cubs’ offseason kicked off when they signed Japanese left-handed pitcher Shota Imanaga to an MLB contract. Immediately following, they traded with the Dodgers to acquire their top prospect, Michael Busch. Presumably, this was to help answer the lingering questions at the first base position. They also agreed to terms with reliever Hector Neris to add to the bullpen.

Those two excellent moves, but the talk of the Cubs Convention the weekend that followed was re-signing Bellinger. Cubs fans would not accept the offseason completed until that job was done. After signing veterans David Peralta and Dominic Smith, they finally got what they wanted. Bellinger signed a three-year deal. They also added veteran Garrett Cooper for some extra depth at first base and in right field.

Retaining Bellinger, adding Imanaga and Neris to the pitching staff, and adding Busch and Cooper to address first base was not on the level an Ohtani deal would have taken them. Still, the Cubs’ offseason is precisely what the doctor would have ordered to compete in 2024. However, one writer would label the work done as unimpressive.

Schoenfield Gives Gubs A C+ For Cubs’ Offseason

ESPN’s Senior Writer David Schoenfield gave the Cubs’ Offseason a grade of C+ going into the 2024 regular season. He states that no signing was “exciting,” but the Cubs did avoid disaster by getting the Cody Bellinger deal done. Schoenfield is also not sold on Shota Imanaga as a starter in MLB. He calls Imanaga “homer-prone” and a downgrade from former Cub Marcus Stroman. In comparison, he gave the same C+ grade to the St. Louis Cardinals.

This is about what I would expect a national baseball writer to give the Cubs. With all the talk of them being in the mix for Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinobu Yamamoto but not getting a deal done, plus the time it took to retain Bellinger, the Cubs were very close to a failing grade. But signing Bellinger changed all perspectives locally to a feeling of confidence. As discussed on the Pinwheels & Ivy podcast (like and subscribe), Bellinger provides the depth, versatility, and veteran leadership missing from the roster the Cubs needed.

As for Imanaga, he looked great in his first start while giving up a home run. One pitch can change everything, sure. But he also struck out five. Time will tell how prone he is to the deep ball, especially in the summer. Neris stabilizes a bullpen that lacked stability down the stretch in 2023. If Busch pans out at first, the only question left to answer is the defense at third base.

This Cubs’ offseason grade also didn’t consider the young talent ready to take on MLB at any moment. Pete Crow-Armstrong, Ben Brown, and Matt Shaw (to name a couple) are all on the doorstep and ready to impact the Cubs in 2024. Grade as you will, but the Cubs have their eyes set on a fun summer at Wrigley.

White Sox Sign Arch-Enemy From The Royals

May 15, 2023; San Diego, California, USA; Kansas City Royals starting pitcher Brad Keller (56) throws a pitch against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Kiyoshi Mio-USA TODAY Sports

Well, well, well, how the tables have turned. The White Sox have announced that they have signed Brad Keller to a minor league deal with an invitation to major league Spring Training.

Before we dive into the obvious baggage associated with this move, let’s take a look at his on the field performance.

Keller has spent his entire six year major league career, with the Kansas City Royals, now adding to the list of former Kansas City Royals signed by Chris Getz this off-season. In his career, he has a 4.27 ERA over 679 innings pitched. His career WHIP is a little high, sitting at 1.446. He has had some problems with walks as of late, as he averages four walks per nine innings, while striking out six in that timeframe.

Last year, he started nine games for the Royals, pitching in 11 games total. He threw 45 innings, pitching to a 4.57 ERA, which isn’t terrible. However, his control was, as he was averaging a horrible 8.9 walks per nine innings. That simply will not cut it in the major leagues, as if you give up that many free passes, you are toast.

Beyond that, he has struggled the last few years with the Royals, as he posted a 5 ERA+ in 2022 and in 2021. He played some of his best baseball in the Covid shortened season, as he pitched to a 2.47 ERA over nine starts. Prior to that, he was pretty solid in 2018, posting a 3.08 ERA. 2019 was just an okay year for him, as he posted a 4.19 ERA over 28 starts.

Needless to say he has not been as great since 2020, but he has shown in the past that he can be an effective major league starter. However, that is not why most White Sox fans are familiar with him.

He is most known for his on the field beef with former White Sox shortstop, Tim Anderson. This breakdown by Jomboy will remind a lot of fans of this famous rivalry. This situation also features a new White Sox player, Martin Maldonado.

This started a rivalry between Tim Anderson and Brad Keller, as it took over the MLB for a while. It also turned into a plethora of media appearances for Tim Anderson, like this one here:

Luckily for all the parties involved, Tim Anderson is no longer on the team, so there should not be as much tension in the clubhouse as there could have been if Anderson was still around. I’m sure there are guys that were around for all this that might have some negative feelings towards Keller because of this situation, but most people get over that once they become teammates.

Keller will now join Spring Training almost a month late and try to make a push for one of the last rotation or bullpen spots. At this point, I’m not sure how likely it is he will make the team, but he could accept an assignment to AAA and come up if there in an injury.

The battle for the last few pitcher roster spots will be a fun one as camp winds down, as there are a number of combinations the White Sox can have on Opening Day.

White Sox Make A Flurry Of Surprising Roster Moves

Aug 25, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox right fielder Oscar Colas (22) grounds into force out against the Oakland Athletics during the second inning at Guaranteed Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

Well, it is about that time. The White Sox have officially announced their first set of Spring Training roster moves, and some of the names on here are a bit surprising, all things considered.

According to the White Sox Twitter page, these are the moves they made:

They optioned four players to Class AAA Charlotte: OF Oscar Colás, RHP Davis Martin, LHP Sammy Peralta and INF José Rodríguez;

Two more to Class AA Birmingham: RHP Josimar Cousin and LHP Jake Eder;

And six players to minor-league camp: LHP Ky Bush, LHP Fraser Ellard, C Adam Hackenberg, RHP Edgar Navarro, C Edgar Quero and RHP Lane Ramsey.

With these moves, the White Sox now have 58 players remaining in major league camp. It is broken down with: 30 pitchers, five catchers, 12 infielders and 11 outfielders.

The most surprising out of these moves is Oscar Colas. It was expected that he would likely start the season in the minors, but for him to be in the first round of cuts is kind of crazy. Chris Getz must really not be a fan of him, as he was the only outfielder to be taken out of major league camp.

So far in Spring Training, Colas is hitting .188 with just one extra base hit and one RBI. These aren’t great stats, but one would think that a top-100 prospect from last year would get an extended look. Chris Getz clearly does not think so, as he has Dominic Fletcher, Zach DeLoach, Kevin Pillar, and Brett Phillips, among others ranked ahead of him. At this point, you wonder if it is worth trading Colas, as teams could be interested in revitalizing a former top-100 prospect. I don’t know how much value he would have, but it is worth exploring at this point to let him get a chance at significant playing time.

The other surprising move is Jose Rodriguez. He was only able to get five at-bats in Spring Training so far, going one for five. I thought he would stick around and fight for the UTL infielder spot, as he has great speed, so he could be a solid bench player, but it looks like he will start the season at Charlotte. It seems that the UTL infielder battle is down to Braden Shewmake and Danny Mendick.

Davis Martin still needs time to recover from his Tommy John surgery so it was likely he wasn’t making the team out of camp, but I would expect to see him in Chicago at some point.

Cousin, Eder, Bush, and Quero are all interesting arms to monitor, as they could be in the big leagues contributing sooner rather than later. At this point however, they are just not ready for the major leagues. There is a good chance we could see some of them in Chicago in 2024 though.

Now, the fight for the rest of the roster spots just got so much more interesting. On the hitting side, keep a look out on the right field, catching, and utility infield competition, as well as one of the last bench spots.

On the pitching side, the last rotation spot and about half the bullpen is up for grabs, so this will be an interesting last few weeks of Spring Training.

Top Expert Has Caleb Williams Ranked Over Some Legendary QB Prospects

caleb williams
Nov 18, 2023; Los Angeles, California, USA; USC Trojans quarterback Caleb Williams (13) drops to pass during the third quarter against the UCLA Bruins at United Airlines Field at Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. Mandatory Credit: Jason Parkhurst-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears got some great fortune when they landed the #1 overall pick for the second time this off-season. After passing on a quarterback last year, everybody is convinced GM Ryan Poles is prepared to move on from Justin Fields. The only question is who it will be for. If you ask almost every national insider with credible connections, they’ll tell you the same thing. It is Caleb Williams of USC. Chicago has been zeroed in on him since the off-season began in January, or at least it seems that way. Such conviction makes some Bears fans nervous. This might be another Mitch Trubisky situation where the GM falls in love with a prospect without seriously considering others.

All signs point to that not being the case. The Bears have done their due diligence throughout the process, meeting with every potential top-10 quarterback. Yet nothing has changed. Williams remains the heavy favorite to go #1 to Chicago. Is this a case of a player being way overhyped thanks to his fun highlights, or is this serious? Matt Miller of ESPN is widely considered one of the top draft evaluators in the field. He made one thing abundantly clear on 670 The Score.

The gap between Williams and everybody else, including Justin Fields, is massive.

“I would take Caleb Williams over Justin Fields every day and twice on Sunday. This is not a hard conversation, guys. I will say two things about this. Number one, let’s talk about the trade market for Justin Fields or the fact that there really isn’t one right now. That should tell you what he’s done at the quarterback (position). What he’s done at quarterback in three years as a starter, the fact the Atlanta Falcons would rather have 36-year-old Kirk Cousins coming off a busted right Achilles, the fact Pittsburgh would rather have Russell Wilson, who’s as washed as washed could be…the lack of a trade market for him should tell those Bears fans that are holding out…it’s been three years. I would argue he has regressed in those three years.

As an evaluation standpoint, Caleb Williams has the highest grade I’ve given a quarterback since I started doing this professionally in 2011. That includes Andrew Luck, that includes Joe Burrow, that includes Trevor Lawrence. Whoever you want to say in that time span. He’s the guy for me.”

Caleb Williams’ question marks aren’t about ability.

Almost every evaluator worth anything has said he has all the tools necessary to thrive in the NFL. What concerns them is the off-the-field stuff. His father is sometimes known for being a distraction, basically acting as Williams’ agent and business manager. Some wonder how hard the quarterback is prepared to work and whether he can handle the pressures of playing in a town like Chicago. Fans won’t give him the same royal treatment as Oklahoma and USC did in college. They will have high expectations from the jump and won’t let it slide if he struggles.

Poles said his primary goal was to find a quarterback that can handle playing in this city. He knows it can be unforgiving. Players need mental toughness above everything else. Based on all the rumors lately, there don’t seem to be any red flags about Caleb Williams in that regard. Yes, he is a different personality but that doesn’t mean he loves football any less. Teammates and coaches alike have described him as a fierce competitor. If he is willing to put in the work, then Miller could be proven correct. Chicago might finally get that elusive franchise quarterback they’ve yearned for.

Will A Quarterback Break The Heisman Jinx?

Jan 7, 2024; Houston, TX, USA; A Heisman Trophy at the College Football Playoff Fan Central at the George R. Brown Convention Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The Heisman Trophy has been awarded to the nation’s top college player since the 1930s. Throughout history, the honor has been bestowed upon QBs on 38 occasions. The first QB Heisman winner was Davey O’Brien from TCU in 1938.

Since 1966, the beginning of the Super Bowl era, quarterbacks have won the award 31 times. Here is a list of the last ten:

  • Johnny Manziel 2012
  • Jameis Winston 2013
  • Marcus Mariota 2014
  • Lamar Jackson 2016
  • Baker Mayfield 2017
  • Kyler Murray 2018
  • Joe Burrow 2019
  • Bryce Young 2021
  • Caleb Williams 2022
  • Jayden Daniels 2023

The Heisman Jinx

With more than 30 Heisman-winning QBs since the Super Bowl era began, a quarterback has never won the Heisman and the Lombardi Trophy for the team that originally drafted him.

Three Heisman winners have led a team to a Super Bowl Championship. Roger Staubach did win the NFL Championship with Dallas, but he won the Heisman in 1963, three years before the Super Bowl era began. The only other QB to have both a Heisman and an NFL Championship is Jim Plunkett. Plunkett won two Super Bowls with the Raiders, but he was originally drafted by the Patriots in 1971.

When the 2024 season begins, six QBs will have a shot to break the 58-year drought. Lamar Jackson (Baltimore), Kyler Murray (Arizona), Joe Burrow (Cincinnati), Bryce Young (Carolina), Caleb Williams, and Jayden Daniels.

Can Caleb Williams lead Chicago to their first title since 1985? No rookie QB draft first overall would have a better chance in recent years. The Bears have improved greatly since Ryan Poles became the GM just two years ago. The defense is loaded with talent. They have key players locked up for 3-4 years.

Offensively, they are a few key pieces away. Free agency and the draft will play critical roles this year to push the Bears into annual playoff contenders.