Tuesday, November 17, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 659

Resurfaced Video Puts Ryan Poles Under Fire

Mar 16, 2023; Lake Forest, IL, USA; Chicago Bears general manager Ryan Poles speaks during a press conference at Halas Hall. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears selected wide receiver Rome Odunze with the 9th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, a move widely praised at the time as a steal and excellent value. Odunze’s rookie season has been somewhat inconsistent, but considering the turmoil surrounding the Bears’ offense, his performance has been impressive. He has recorded 52 receptions for 716 yards and 3 touchdowns—a solid rookie campaign.

However, this pick has recently faced scrutiny. Quarterback Caleb Williams has been sacked a league-high 67 times, with one game remaining in the season, highlighting the Bears struggling offensive line. General Manager Ryan Poles is under intense scrutiny due to the line’s poor performance. Adding to the criticism is a resurfaced clip from the day after the draft where Poles was asked about the Atlanta Falcons selecting quarterback Michael Penix Jr. with the 8th pick. Poles laughed in response, a moment that has now drawn attention amid the Bears current struggles.

Hindsight is always 20/20.

Michael Penix Jr. hasn’t had much opportunity to play, with only one start so far this season. Kirk Cousins started most of the year but was benched last week. The criticism surrounding Ryan Poles isn’t necessarily about selecting Rome Odunze at No. 9—most agree that was a solid pick that many would make again.

Instead, the scrutiny stems from Poles perceived arrogance and the fact that he’s currently on the hot seat. His job for next season is uncertain, and every decision he’s made is now under the public microscope. This criticism may not be entirely fair, but it’s a natural consequence when things start to unravel like they have in. It will be fascinating to see how Chicago approaches their GM situation this offseason, as they face a crucial personnel decision and one that will have long lasting implications.

Alarming Details Revealed About Caleb Williams Practice Habits

Dec 26, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) warms up before the game against the Seattle Seahawks at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-Imagn Images

Rookie quarterback Caleb Williams has had a rollercoaster season. While his stats appear solid at first glance, there have been concerning issues throughout the year. Notably, struggles with mid-to-deep throw accuracy and questionable sideline body language have raised eyebrows. However, one aspect that had never been doubted—until recently—was his work ethic.

This changed last week when two NFL voices brought up concerns. First, Barstool Sports’ Will Compton, co-host of the popular podcast Bussin’ with the Boys, shared surprising details with fellow Barstool personality and Bears fan Big Cat. Compton, using unnamed sources, suggested Williams struggles with details in practice.

“Just from what I have heard,” Compton said, “practice, [the] false starts on the quarterback because he doesn’t know the snap count. Not being able to alert when a safety comes down and you have a run play.”

Compton revealed only part of the information, insinuating the rest was better left off-air, leaving fans speculating about what else might be going on with Caleb Williams.

Kirk Herbstreit’s recent remarks add fuel to the fire.

Adding to the intrigue, ESPN’s Kirk Herbstreit chimed in during the Bears-Seahawks Thursday night game. Midway through the third quarter, Herbstreit made an odd remark about Caleb Williams.

“I think the thing that remains to be seen — and only time will tell — is if he understands what it takes to be an NFL quarterback as far as the preparation, as far as first guy there, last guy leaving. And I’m not suggesting he’s not doing those things, but just all of those little things that really make the great quarterbacks special.”

While Herbstreit claimed he wasn’t implying anything negative nor has he heard such rumors, bringing up a topic like this on a national broadcast inevitably plants seeds of doubt. Was this simply filler commentary, or is Herbstreit hearing the same rumors as Compton?

So far, there’s been no indication from Halas Hall that Williams lacks work ethic, but where there’s smoke, there’s often fire. For the Bears sake, let’s hope these claims are baseless rumors. Time will tell whether these comments fade or become a larger narrative around Caleb Williams career. Either way, add this to the growing list of reasons why Bears fans will want to forget the 2024 season in a hurry.

We’ve Learned How Caleb Williams Is Viewed By Upcoming Coach Candidates

caleb williams
Dec 26, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) directs a play prior to the snap during the first quarter against the Seattle Seahawks at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Talia Sprague-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears face a challenge going into the 2025 off-season. Yes, they need to find a new head coach. However, it is slightly more complicated than that. They need to find a coach who is not just willing to work with Caleb Williams but is a staunch believer in what he could be as a quarterback. That is the problem they ran into with Matt Nagy and Mitch Trubisky. Nagy insisted he could work with Trubisky, but after just one season, it became apparent the head coach lost faith in the quarterback, leading to two years of tension and controversy. That can’t happen this time around.

If you spoke to certain people on Twitter, they’d have you believe Williams has been terrible this season. Is that view shared by prospective coach candidates going into next month? Not at all. Jeff Hughes of Da Bears Blog made it abundantly clear that Chicago’s young quarterback has plenty of fans.

Caleb Williams has done the Bears a huge favor.

His 2024 season hasn’t been perfect, but it’s been better than it has any right to be. Think about it. The young man lost his offensive coordinator and head coach in the space of a month during the season. He’s been sacked 67 times. Yet despite all of that, he cracked 3,000 yards passing, set the rookie record for consecutive pass attempts without an interception, and has a respectable 87.4 passer rating. Justin Fields’ was 86.3 last season despite taking far fewer sacks and having his coaches in place all year.

Coaches aren’t stupid. They can see the capability Caleb Williams has. The talent isn’t in question. What he needs is a cohesive scheme and better protection. If given those things, there is no reason to think he won’t have a breakout campaign in 2025.

White Sox Should Roll The Dice On A Former Rookie Of The Year Candidate

Aug 18, 2024; St. Petersburg, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Rays outfielder Dylan Carlson (10)singles against the Arizona Diamondbacks during the tenth inning at Tropicana Field. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-USA TODAY Sports

With the White Sox coming off one of the worst major league seasons in the history of baseball, the expectations are low. While this makes for a tough product to watch, it allows the White Sox to get creative with some of their moves, as they aren’t expected to compete for anything meaningful in 2025.

This creates an opportunity for the White Sox to take fliers on former top-100 prospects and allow them to potentially get some significant playing time with no pressure, something that could unlock the potential of prospects who haven’t seemed to figure it out to this point.

The White Sox missed out on the perfect signing earlier in the week, but there are still others out there that could fit that criteria and get some playing time with the White Sox this year. One of those players is Dylan Carlson, the former St. Louis Cardinals and Tampa Bay Rays outfielder.

Carlson, just 26 years old, is a free agent, but has had some success in his short major league career. In 2021, Carlson finished third in the rookie of the year voting with the St. Louis Cardinals. That year, Carlson had 3.1 WAR, as he hit .266, with 18 homeruns and 65 RBIs. Those are some very solid numbers for a 22 year old rookie.

He followed the 2021 season up with another solid showing, as he had 1.9 WAR, but his hitting stats decreased slightly. Since 2022 Carlson has only played in 160 games combined, as he has struggled with injures. Last season the Cardinals sent him in a trade to the Tampa Bay Rays where he would struggle, but played better than he did with the Cardinals earlier in the year.

The White Sox should take a flier on Carlson, as just a few years ago he was a consensus top-20 prospect in all of baseball. On top of that, he had a season in the major leagues where he was very good. If he can get some consistent playing time with the White Sox in a low-stress environment, he may be able to recreate his 2021 season. The White Sox desperately need offense, and Carlson has the potential to hit 15-20 homeruns, so it’s worth it to see if he can figure something out in Chicago.

This is the type of player the White Sox need to take a chance on, as Carlson is clearly a talented player but has dealt with injuries and being traded midseason. The White Sox have nothing to lose by signing Carlson, but if he turns out to be anywhere near where he was in 2021, this would be a huge signing.

Analyst Called Out For Possible Racist Comments About Caleb Williams

caleb williams
Dec 26, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) warms up before the game against the Seattle Seahawks at Soldier Field. Mandatory Credit: Daniel Bartel-Imagn Images

Thursday Night Football was rough for Caleb Williams. He endured another seven sacks in a 6-3 loss to the Seattle Seahawks, bringing his total to 67 for the season. However, the moment that seems to have gained some attention over the past few days came during the broadcast. At one point, color commentator Kirk Herbstreit openly questioned Williams’ preparation and leadership as a quarterback. It was a bizarre moment that he quickly tried to move away from, but many have called him out for it.

“I think the thing that remains to be seen — and only time will tell — is if he understands what it takes to be an NFL quarterback as far as the preparation, as far as first guy there, last guy to leave.”

One person took special umbrage with the comments.

Doug Farrar of Athlon Sports suggested that Herbstreit wouldn’t have said something like that if he were white. Yet because Williams is black, the analyst questioned his intelligence, which is something racially motivated people have said for decades.

“It may not seem like a big deal until you dive into the ways in which Black athletes have been portrayed since they’ve been allowed to play sports. The NFL had a “gentlemen’s agreement” which banned any Black player from the game from 1934 to the mid-1940s, and even when a trickle of players were allowed to participate, it was usually not at the “positions of intelligence” – quarterback, center, middle linebacker, safety…

…So, when we talk about a Black rookie quarterback like Caleb Williams, it behooves us to remember to hold ourselves to the same standards that we would were we talking about white quarterbacks. Again, one paragraph of talk in an unexciting game doesn’t seem like a big deal – Herbstreit was probably trying to create a narrative on the fly to keep people tuned in – but when you look at the history, it’s much more than it seems.”

Caleb Williams deserves more respect.

This is another in a long line of pointless crap Williams has to deal with. He already has people calling him out for not being efficient enough because of his lower completion percentage and tendency to take unnecessary sacks. Never mind the fact he has broken several rookie passing records despite both his offensive coordinator and head coach getting fired in the middle of a season. What exactly is he supposed to do with such a chaotic situation around him? There is no pleasing some people.

Is Herbstreit racist? Unlikely. Still, that doesn’t make his comments any less dumb, insensitive, and backward. There have been indications for years that Caleb Williams has a stellar work ethic and leadership qualities. Surviving this season with a positive passing stat line would’ve been impossible otherwise. There is a fine line between fair critique and useless criticism.

If nothing else, this is another reason for Bears fans to rally around their quarterback. Williams is putting his body on the line to help this team win and getting hate for it. Time to show him the city has his back.

A Big Twist Has Surfaced In The Ben Johnson Sweepstakes

liam coen
Aug 23, 2024; Tampa, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive coordinator Liam Coen against the Miami Dolphins during the second quarter at Raymond James Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-USA TODAY Sports

It isn’t a secret by now that the Chicago Bears and Ben Johnson have mutual interest. The Detroit Lions offensive coordinator has eyed the job since last January, driven by the idea of working with likely #1 overall pick Caleb Williams. There are no indications that interest has died. The Bears are already hoping to line up an interview. It seems as if things are coming together. Unfortunately, nothing is ever simple with this team. There is still the issue of Ryan Poles.

The Bears GM is in serious trouble as his team is on a ten-game losing streak. He hired this coaching staff and put together this roster. Why should he keep his job when others won’t? Any coach worth his salt would be hesitant to work with somebody who is clearly on a short leash. It seems that is the case with Johnson. Jeff Hughes of Da Bears Blog provided a telling update. From what he understands, the Lions coordinator would prefer to work with a GM he knows.

Meanwhile, another name might be gaining traction inside Halas Hall.

The Ben Johnson decision may come down to interviews.

If he nails the process, it could force Kevin Warren’s hand, choosing to fire Poles in an effort to get the right coach. One can safely assume the GM might be pushing for Coen since he wouldn’t have any issues working with him. Chicago met with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive coordinator in January for their own OC position before giving it to Shane Waldron. Coen somehow improved on what Dave Canales managed last year, producing the #3 offense in the NFL despite Mike Evans and Chris Godwin missing significant time with injuries. Baker Mayfield set a new career high with 34 touchdown passes and will likely cross 4,000 yards this weekend.

The problem with Coen is his lack of experience. He’s only been a coordinator for two years at the NFL level, and one of them didn’t involve him calling plays. Two others were spent in college with Kentucky. It is hard to know how much of his success comes from being unfamiliar to pro defenses and having a solid veteran quarterback to work with. He just doesn’t have the same reputation as Ben Johnson does. It would be so like the Bears to compromise at head coach because they want to keep the GM they have.

ESPN Reveals How Many Coaches Chicago Bears Plan To Interview

chicago bears

The Chicago Bears are under no illusions. Those people in charge understand the next 3-4 weeks may well determine the next decade of football in this town. It has been several years since the Bears landed on an actual good head coach. Since Lovie Smith departed, it’s been an array of horrible mixed with mediocre. Matt Eberflus has a case for being the worst of the lot. Now, team president Kevin Warren and GM Ryan Poles must try to learn from that mistake and somehow find the right guy for the first time in over a decade.

Plenty of rumors have bounced back and forth around the team. Some indicate they’re looking for an offensive specialist to help Caleb Williams. Others hear they’d prefer somebody with experience who can fix the culture of losing that has permeated Halas Hall. Jeremy Fowler of ESPN shed some light on the subject during an appearance on the This Is Football podcast. From what he understands, the Bears aren’t going to pigeonhole themselves. They’re planning a thorough and extensive search.

The Chicago Bears are correct in taking this approach.

One can understand eyeing a specific type of coach, but the right person for the job can sometimes pop up in unlikely places. Smith wasn’t the first choice for the Bears in 2004. GM Jim Finks didn’t even want Mike Ditka in 1982. It is always about getting to know every candidate possible and assessing which of them has the traits you’re looking for. A big criticism of Poles was that he only took 48 hours after getting the GM job to make a decision in 2022, opting for Eberflus. He went with his gut rather than taking time to truly evaluate his options. It appears he won’t make that mistake again.

The bigger question is whether the Chicago Bears are willing to take their time. If they plan to meet with 12-14 candidates, they can’t possibly expect to do so in the span of one or two weeks. It is almost impossible to glean any good information from a frantic pace like that. This process must be spread out over most of January and even into February if needed. Will Poles and Warren have that kind of patience? Nobody can say.

The White Sox Could Regret Passing On This Underrated Outfielder

Jul 11, 2021; Denver, CO, USA; National League right fielder Brennen Davis (21) rounds the bases after hitting a solo home run in the fifth inning against the American League of the 2021 MLB All Star Futures Game at Coors Field. Mandatory Credit: Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

Since the White Sox are not expected to be good next season, they have no expectations. Knowing that, they should take advantage and allow as many players as they can to get an extended look at the major league level, to see if they could be around when the White Sox are eventually good.

The White Sox just missed a golden opportunity, as the New York Yankees just scooped up a player that the White Sox should have taken a flier on.

According to Adam Leighton, the Yankees signed outfielder Brennen Davis to a minor league deal.

Davis was formerly a top-100 prospect for the Chicago Cubs, but injuries have derailed his career to this point. However, he is still a very talented player that could have played some meaningful innings for the White Sox this year.

Davis hasn’t made it to the major leagues yet, but he had a decent showing in AAA last year for the Iowa Cubs, as his power was on display.

In 47 games, Davis hit 11 homers and had 28 RBIs. He also walked 23 times while striking out 42, which contributed to a very solid .359 OBP. His average was low, as he hit .214, but he showed flashes of his potential to be a very good power hitter in the major leagues.

Davis is still just 25 so he is still pretty young. He is the exact type of player that the White Sox should take a filer on, as if he turns out to be a solid major leaguer, Chris Getz looks like a genius, but if he doesn’t pan out, you lose nothing, as the team wasn’t expected to be any good in 2025.

The White Sox have been searching for answers in their outfield for years now and with rumors swirling around Andrew Benintendi and Luis Robert Jr., there could be a few spots up for grabs this year, as the White Sox don’t have any top outfield prospects that are close to making their debuts. Newly acquired Braden Montgomery could fly through the minor leagues, but he still hasn’t played in a minor league game.

Currently in the outfield, besides Benintendi and Robert, the White Sox have Mike Tauchman, Austin Slater, Dominic Fletcher, and Zach DeLoach. While that list includes some average MLB players, the White Sox should be swinging for the fences and trying to find as much upside as they can this year. Davis would have been the perfect signing to compete for at-bats in the outfield, especially if the White Sox make a trade in the outfield.

Sometimes all a prospect needs is a change of scenery for them to figure things out, and the White Sox should be the top destination for many of those former top prospects looking for a new home. While the White Sox don’t have a great track record of getting the most out of their prospects, they have made sweeping changes to fix that.

Chicago Bears Just Got More Good News On The Draft Front

chicago bears
Ohio State Buckeyes offensive lineman Donovan Jackson (74) celebrates a touchdown by TreVeyon Henderson during the NCAA football game against the Indiana Hoosiers at Ohio Stadium in Columbus on Monday, Nov. 25, 2024. Ohio State won 38-15.

The season is over. The only thing left for the Chicago Bears is to march into Lambeau Field next Sunday and accept another beating from the Green Bay Packers as they prepare for yet another playoff run. From there, the real action begins. Team brass will begin their search for a new head coach and maybe a new GM, depending on what fate awaits Ryan Poles. Once that is done, they must prepare for an incredibly important off-season that could make or break the development of quarterback Caleb Williams.

That means heavy investments in the offensive line, which has allowed 67 sacks this season. Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune reached out to a top front office executive to get a feel for what the 2025 draft class could look like. His response feels like a major positive from the Bears’ perspective.

“It’s shaping up to be a better offensive-line class than we originally expected, but it’s still not what it was last year,” the front-office man said. “There’s not any real slam-dunk, top-half-of-the-first-round players. A lot of the top guys in this class on the line are Day 2-graded players…

…The Bears will have two picks early in Round 2, with one coming from the Carolina Panthers, and the evaluator said that might be a sweet spot to target a lineman or even two.

“They would be in a good spot there,” the front-office man said. “Where it’s the thinnest is at center. Not a good draft class for that position.”

The Chicago Bears can get this fixed if they’re smart about it.

They have more than enough resources to address the problem. As of now, it is evident the offensive line needs at least three new starters, all of them along the interior. Teven Jenkins and Coleman Shelton are both free agents. Nate Davis was already cut a few weeks ago. An argument can be made that Braxton Jones shouldn’t remain left tackle, but this class isn’t strong at tackle. The logical course, at least at this stage, is keeping him in place while focusing the money and draft capital on finding two new guards and a center.

The latter doesn’t seem like an option in the draft, so free agency could be where the Chicago Bears decide to pounce. Drew Dalman, Ryan Kelly, and Josh Myers are all possibilities to consider. They could then shift to the draft for their guard help. Plenty of options will be available between the 1st and 2nd rounds. The tougher question is whether the Bears can find them, given their poor hit rate in recent years.

Arizona Diamondbacks Pitching Surplus Could Benefit White Sox

Sep 11, 2024; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Jordan Montgomery (52) throws against the Texas Rangers in the seventh inning at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Rick Scuteri-Imagn Images

The Arizona Diamondbacks shocked the baseball world last night by signing star free agent pitcher Corbin Burnes to a 6 year/$210 million contract. Arizona’s big splash will have significant ramifications across baseball. The NL West is now even more competitive, and a rebuilding team like the White Sox can take advantage of a newly formed logjam on the Diamondbacks pitching staff.

Diamondbacks Crowded Starting Rotation

The Diamondbacks starting rotation is very crowded. Burnes and fellow right-handers Zac Gallen and Merrill Kelly are their newly formed top three. They also have former prized free agent signing Eduardo Rodríguez from the left side. Promising young right-handers Brandon Pfaadt and Ryne Nelson round out their starting staff. They have no shortage of starting pitchers and are six deep without even including disgruntled lefty Jordan Montgomery. He seemingly lacks a spot now, and their pitching surplus could work to the White Sox benefit.

Jordan Montgomery’s Track Record

A veteran of 8 MLB seasons, Montgomery has generally been a quality pitcher in the major leagues. He made 32 starts with the Cardinals and Rangers in 2023, pitching to a respectable 3.20 ERA and 1.19 WHIP. He was also integral to the Rangers World Series run. It was arguably the best season of his MLB career.

Fractured Relationship In Arizona

Montgomery parlayed his 2023 success into a one year/$25 million contract with the Diamondbacks with a team option for 2025. Unfortunately for both parties, 2024 was the worst season of Montgomery’s MLB career. His ERA was over 6.00 and he was so bad that he was demoted to the bullpen towards the end of the season. Diamondbacks owner Ken Kendrick publicly called the signing of Montgomery “a horrible decision” and their “biggest mistake this season from a talent standpoint.” Montgomery exercised his $22.5 million player option for 2025, but the relationship between both parties is shaky at best because of his poor performance and Kendrick’s comments.

Interesting Opportunity For White Sox

While the Diamondbacks no longer have the space or desire to roster Montgomery, the White Sox might. Even after the signing of veteran pitcher Bryse Wilson, the White Sox could use another innings eater. The 2025 rotation will be very young. It is fair to assume that all of Davis Martin, Drew Thorpe, Sean Burke, and Jonathan Cannon will be under workload limitations to an extent. The White Sox need bodies and guys who can eat innings. Montgomery fits that category. He has pitched over 150 innings four times and has three seasons of over 30 starts each. He is durable and a proven winner. That is the type of pitcher the White Sox need to get through 2025. His veteran presence could guide a young rotation.

Montgomery’s Bounce-Back Potential

There is also bounce-back potential with Montgomery. Even during his career-worst 2024 season, he was still elite in categories like chase% and barrel%. He has also historically been a good pitcher and is not far removed from MLB success. It isn’t unreasonable to think that a change of scenery could revitalize his career. He is also under contract for just 2025. It would be a minimal commitment from the White Sox perspective. If Montgomery is bad again, he will be gone after the season. However, he could become a trade chip with a strong first half.

Outside-The-Box Idea

Given Montgomery’s current status, he is a pure salary dump. As a result, the White Sox could likely ask for a prospect along with Montgomery in exchange for taking his salary off the Diamondbacks’ hands. There is also a version of this scenario where the White Sox could send Andrew Benintendi to Arizona as part of the deal to even out the contracts a bit. Exploring the salary dump route to acquire a pitcher and potentially more prospects is an avenue worth taking for the White Sox.

While taking on Jordan Montgomery from the Arizona Diamondbacks in a salary dump is logical given where the 2025 White Sox stand, it likely won’t happen. It would involve taking on payroll, which is seemingly a no-no for Chris Getz. The White Sox will have one of the lowest payrolls in MLB next season and aren’t likely to spend much more money this winter. That said, trading for Montgomery would represent an outside-the-box way to get another innings eater and potentially accumulate more assets for the future.