Sunday, November 15, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 351

Why Drake Maye Is Outplaying Caleb Williams So Far This Season

caleb williams
Oct 13, 2025; Landover, Maryland, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams (18) passes the ball against the Washington Commanders during the third quarter at Northwest Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Peter Casey-Imagn Images

Caleb Williams entered Year 2 with a hell of a spotlight — and he’s done enough to justify the hype in spurts. But here’s the truth: through five games, he’s smack in the middle of one of the most bizarre, intriguing, and tight-ass QB class races we’ve seen in a while. The kid’s flashing brilliance, sure. But also showing the same damn flaws that made his rookie year so chaotic. And the wild part? His former college rival Jayden Daniels is leading in efficiency in some key metrics, and Drake Maye might already be the most complete passer in the group.

Before y’all come for my neck, understand that I love what Caleb has done this year and the improvements he’s made — but we gotta keep it 100. So let’s break this down. No sugarcoating. Just raw performance, trends, and how these young signal-callers actually stack up now that the NFL has real tape on ’em.


Caleb Williams: Still a Project With a Rocket Arm

What He’s Getting Right

1. Ball Security & Red Zone Killer Instinct

Williams has tightened up the turnover valve. Two picks in five games? That’s a damn miracle after his INT-prone rookie campaign. His 1.3% interception rate is elite, and he’s got 9 TDs already (tied with Bo Nix, of all people). More importantly, he’s finally scoring in the red zone. That was his kryptonite in 2024. Now? He’s converting chances like a vet, and even added two rushing TDs — something he never did last season. Thank Ben Johnson’s play design and Caleb’s willingness to use his legs.

2. Fantasy Boom + Chunk Plays

In fantasy? The kid’s QB6. That’s not fluky either. Williams’ Explosive Play Rating (EPX) sits at 104.6, 13th in the league, and his +9.1 Production Premium (5th overall) tells you he’s outperforming expectations given the talent around him. He’s tied with Maye in fantasy PPG. That’s a real stat, not just nerd fuel.

3. Understanding the Offense

Ben Johnson’s scheme isn’t for simpletons. Yet Caleb’s digesting it like a veteran. He’s pushing the ball (8.32 aDOT, 9th in NFL), using play-action smartly (33.1%, 4th), and commanding the line well. It’s not always pretty, but it’s effective. And it’s night-and-day from the disorganized chaos we saw in 2024.

Where He’s Screwing Up

1. Accuracy Is Still a Disaster

Here’s the ugly truth: he can’t hit the broad side of a barn sometimes. 61.6% completion rate? That’s 33rd in the NFL. Worse: he’s missing from clean pockets. A 67.3% clean-pocket completion rate (23rd in the league) is unacceptable for a top QB. He’s got 52 overthrows through five weeks. Nobody else has more than 37. That’s bad.

  • 15.3% bad throw rate – among the worst
  • Deep ball at 40% – decent, but Maye is at 53.8%
  • His intermediate accuracy? Historically awful. Think 520th out of 530 QBs since 2000. Yeah.

2. Holding the Damn Ball

Williams takes forever to throw (3.07 seconds per dropback – slowest in the league). He’s extending plays, sure, but also killing his line. His 8.8% escape rate leads the NFL, but he still gets sacked 5.49% of the time. Ben Johnson’s scheme needs rhythm and timing, and Williams doesn’t always play on schedule.

3. Supporting Cast Isn’t Helping, But Still…

His receivers rank 17th in Supporting Cast Efficiency. They’re not making his life easier, and his YAC per catch (4.9) is 23rd. Compare that to Bo Nix’s 5.9 and you get the picture: Williams’ throws aren’t letting guys run after the catch. Some of that is scheme. A lot of it is ball placement.


Let’s Talk About the Rest of the Class

Drake Maye: The Dude Is Surgical

Drake Maye might be the best quarterback from this class right now. He’s leading in EPA/play (0.26 vs. Williams’ 0.05), completion % (73.2%), YPA (8.5), clean pocket % (76.7%), pressure % (58.3%), success rate (51.5%), and deep ball accuracy (53.8%).

He’s also doing this behind a bottom-5 receiving corps. But he’s been protected well – the Pats are top-4 in pass-blocking – and he’s making the most of every snap. Don’t get it twisted, Maye’s not just accurate; he’s efficient, calm, and making pro-level throws weekly.

Jayden Daniels: Athletic God, Turnover Machine

Daniels was the golden boy last year. Now? He’s regressed. Completion % is a meh 62.1%, EPA/play barely beats Caleb, and his turnover issues are brutal.

He had 3 turnovers in Week 6 alone. His sack rate is the worst in the class (7.1%), and while his 176 rushing yards in 4 games are nice, he fumbled twice against the Bears — including a back-breaking botched handoff. Kingsbury’s offense is built around him, but defenses are catching up.

His weapons? Better than Caleb’s. Deebo, Terry, and Ertz > DJ Moore, Odunze, and Kmet. Yet Daniels has a 52.5 QBR. Caleb? 60.4.

Bo Nix: Sean Payton’s Pet Project

Nix is a game manager to the core. 6.2 YPA is dead last. His EPA/play is barely better than Williams. But here’s what he does have:

  • Lowest sack rate in the class (2.64%)
  • Solid red zone efficiency (36.6%)
  • Safe, accurate short game

He also has the worst average depth of target in the league (7.11 yards). So yeah, he’s efficient, but boring as hell. If Williams is boom-or-bust, Nix is store-brand oatmeal. Effective. Not exciting.

Michael Penix Jr.: Raw But Intriguing

Penix has 4 TDs, 3 INTs, and the worst passer rating of the class (85.6). But his quick release (2.51s time to throw) and 62.4% completion show promise. He’s surrounded by real talent (Bijan, Pitts, London), but hasn’t unlocked the offense yet. Still early.

2024 QB Draft Class EPA per Play, Weeks 1-6 2025 NFL Season.

Team Context: Why It All Matters

Chicago (Williams)

  • 11th in scoring (25.3 PPG), but just 22nd in EPA/play
  • Run game? Absolute trash. 32nd in EPA/rush
  • O-line? 23rd in pass pro, even after big-money upgrades
  • Ben Johnson’s offense is clicking, but Caleb’s delays and pre-snap penalties (7th-worst) are killing flow

New England (Maye)

  • 4th in pass-blocking efficiency
  • 27.6% play-action rate helping Maye stay in rhythm
  • Weak WR group, but Maye still carving up defenses

Washington (Daniels)

  • System relies on Daniels’ legs too much
  • 3rd/4th down QBR: 23.6
  • Turnovers and sacks are crushing their momentum

Where Caleb Williams Lands

Williams is ahead of Penix and Nix, no debate. But Maye has already passed him as a passer, and Daniels is neck-and-neck depending on what you value.

Where Caleb Wins:

  • Ball security (1.3% INT rate is elite)
  • Explosive play production
  • Fantasy relevance
  • Raw physical tools and play-extension ability

Where Caleb Loses:

  • Accuracy (dead last in class)
  • Deep ball inconsistency
  • Pocket presence
  • Holding the damn ball

His Week 3 performance against Dallas (67.9% comp, 4 TDs, 0 sacks, 142.6 rating) was a glimpse at his ceiling. But he’s still too often the reason drives stall or protections break down.

Maye looks like the guy you build your offense around for a decade. Daniels is a wild card with MVP-level athleticism and turnover-prone decision-making. Nix is Kirk Cousins without the fireworks. Penix? To be determined.


Final Verdict

Caleb Williams is still the most talented quarterback from this class. But talent doesn’t win NFL games alone. Timing, accuracy, and decision-making do. Until he speeds up his clock and dials in his mechanics, he’ll be chasing Drake Maye, not leading the race.

But if he gets it all to click? Strap in. Because nobody in this class has his ceiling.

Why Do I Like the Chicago Bears This Week (against the New Orleans Saints)?

Oct 12, 2025; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA; New Orleans Saints quarterback Spencer Rattler (2) throws during the first quarter against the New England Patriots at Caesars Superdome. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Lew-Imagn Images

I always like the Chicago Bears. But here come three additional reasons, and a prediction!

(1) I know the NFL world is enamored with advanced stats, but I still cling to some old school numbers. The Saints have been competitive, even at 1-5, but they have also played four of their first six games at home. They have a -6-point differential in those games. Their differential is -43 in their two road games, and Spencer Rattler struggled in both Buffalo and Seattle. If the Saints deliver a big performance on the road, it will be a surprise.

(2) The Kindness of the Schedule. So often, in this league, momentum is determined by who teams play and when they play them. The Bears are coming off one of their most exuberant road wins in years, and they are rewarded by returning home to face a Saints team that is fending off rumors about trading their best offensive weaponry. I would describe recent Soldier Field crowds as tenuously optimistic. They want to believe. But, in their hearts, they don’t. That tenuousness will disappear on Sunday. Folks believe things are changing. If this were one of the next two games – at Baltimore, at Cincinnati – I could foresee a letdown from this young program. I don’t see one coming on Sunday.

(3) The Bears have now put a dominant run game performance on tape. That will dramatically open up the play action opportunities moving forward, and that is Ben Johnson’s play-calling superpower. The only teams in the NFL allowing a higher passer rating to opposing quarterbacks than the Saints through six weeks are the Miami Dolphins and the Dallas Cowboys. This will be the best performance of the season from Caleb Williams.

Chicago Bears 31, New Orleans Saints 20

Ben Johnson Needed Just 5 Games To Break 30-Year Bears Drought

ben johnson
Aug 22, 2025; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Ben Johnson on field against the Kansas City Chiefs during the second half of the game at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Denny Medley-Imagn Images

Anybody will tell you if you’re not familiar with Chicago Bears history. Offense in this town is about as rare as One-Eyed Willy’s treasure. In an era where franchises seem to have a top 10 offense at least once every few years, the Bears break the mold. They’ve accomplished the feat exactly one team since the turn of the millennium. That was in 2013. Outside of that, it’s been a parade of mediocre or awful. Plenty of coaches were hired to change that. Mike Martz, Marc Trestman, and Matt Nagy were among the most successful, and they weren’t all that good. The Bears hoped Ben Johnson might finally turn their fortunes around.

Five games into his tenure, it is already obvious that hiring him was the right decision. Let’s ignore the cultural impact he’s having in the locker room for the moment. Just focus on his influence on the offense. The Bears have now scored 24, 21, 31, 25, and 25 points in their first five games. That may sound pretty standard for teams these days. Not this one. It marked the first time in 30 years that the Bears have scored at least 21 points in their first five games.

Ben Johnson is living up to his reputation.

He’s renowned as one of the best offensive minds in the game, and it’s proving accurate. While the Bears haven’t set scoreboards on fire, they’re scoring at a much faster clip than we’ve seen in years. The 1995 team was probably the most efficient offense this organization has fielded in the Super Bowl era. They passed and ran with equal success. Erik Kramer claimed the single-season yards and touchdown records that year. Caleb Williams is currently on pace to break both of them.

The scariest part is that those who know Ben Johnson can see he’s holding back so much of his playbook. Allen Robinson said we haven’t even seen a quarter of it yet. He is sticking to the plays he feels the players can execute well. As they grow more comfortable, he will begin adding more and more layers. If the Bears are hard to stop now, try to imagine what it’ll be like in December.

Hall Of Fame Coach Just Delivered A Ben Johnson Mic Drop

ben johnson
Sep 28, 2025; Paradise, Nevada, USA; Chicago Bears head coach Ben Johnson looks on from the sideline during the second half against the Las Vegas Raiders at Allegiant Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kiyoshi Mio-Imagn Images

Bruce Arians was one of the best head coaches in the NFL for a long time. He elevated the Arizona Cardinals and Tampa Bay Buccaneers, two long-suffering franchises, to extended success. That included a Super Bowl championship in 2020. One thing he knows better than most is how to develop quarterbacks. Peyton Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, and Andrew Luck were all mentored by him. Carson Palmer and Tom Brady both had career years under his watch. So it is always worth paying attention when he has something to say about your team. Arians certainly had notable words about Ben Johnson.

The future Hall of Famer watched the Monday night game between the Chicago Bears and Washington Commanders. Johnson was at the forefront of the action, calling a tremendous game that saw Caleb Williams play mistake-free and D’Andre Swift go over 100 yards rushing. Once again, the team rallied from a 4th quarter deficit to take the game in the final seconds. Arians is more convinced than ever that Johnson is one of the great ones in this league. If Williams is smart enough to listen to him, he’ll end up a top quarterback in the NFL before too long.

Ben Johnson is already having a major influence on the team.

Start with the offense. The Bears have now scored at least 21 points in five straight games. This is the first time that has happened since 1995. Thirty years. Ben Johnson barely knew these players when he arrived in January. Getting these kinds of results right out of the gate is impressive. As for Williams, he has eight touchdowns and just two interceptions through five games. That includes two 4th quarter comebacks. At his current pace, the young quarterback will crack 4,000 yards, the first in Bears history to do so. This is why the Bears hired Johnson.

Yet it goes beyond that. The head coach is also having a massive impact on the team culture. For the first time in years, the Bears look disciplined, confident, and resilient in tough situations. Those are all things Johnson highlighted as priorities from the beginning. It is something Arians would’ve been proud of. He probably sees a lot of himself in how Johnson coaches. That is a great thing for Chicago.

Turns Out Caleb Williams Knew Exactly Why Troy Aikman Was So Butthurt

caleb williams

Something weird happened on Monday night. Joe Buck and Troy Aikman aren’t always the most complimentary broadcasting duo when it comes to the Chicago Bears, but they’ve at least been fair in previous outings. The game against the Washington Commanders felt different. Aikman seemed abnormally critical of the Bears all night, particularly quarterback Caleb Williams. Every mistake he made was harped on while his nice plays were dismissed as nothing special or just luck. Meanwhile, he had no problems showing Jayden Daniels praise despite two costly turnovers.

It turns out there may have been a reason for this oddly cold behavior. Williams was asked about it during his press conference on Wednesday. Here, he revealed some previously unknown information. He and Aikman were supposed to have a production meeting before the game. However, Williams was working at Halas Hall and lost track of time. When he finished, he called Aikman to meet up. The former quarterback didn’t answer his phone. Based on how things unfolded in the game, it’s a reasonable assumption that Aikman felt disrespected.

Caleb Williams won’t lose sleep over the incident.

People will argue he should’ve been better about communicating that he was running behind schedule. Fair enough, but Caleb Williams is human. He likely lost track of time. It’s not like he just blew Aikman off. He attempted to get in touch to fulfill his obligations. The former Super Bowl champion didn’t bother answering the phone. Instead, he seemed to air his grievances on national television. That isn’t the kind of petty behavior you expect from a 58-year-old Hall of Famer.

Alas, none of it matters. Aikman won’t be calling another Bears game this season. Williams doesn’t have to worry about him until next year. By then, nobody will care about what happened. It will be filed away as another one of those strange incidents that happen from time to time in this league.

We Learned The Real Reason DJ Moore Ended Up In The Hospital

dj moore
Oct 13, 2025; Landover, Maryland, USA; Chicago Bears wide receiver DJ Moore (2) escapes the tackle of Washington Commanders safety Jeremy Reaves (39) during the first quarter at Northwest Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Peter Casey-Imagn Images

The Chicago Bears were all smiles on Monday night. They’d just gotten the sweetest type of victory there is: revenge. After enduring the Hail Mary debacle last season, which sent them into a death spiral, and watching the Washington Commanders reach the NFC championship, this rematch held significant meaning. It would tell everybody, including themselves, whether the Bears had learned anything from that defeat. They proved they had by overcoming a 24-16 deficit in the 4th quarter to win 25-24. The post-game celebration was predictably loud. However, it came with a bittersweet edge. News soon trickled out that star receiver DJ Moore went to the hospital.

Fans weren’t sure what happened. The wide receiver had played the entire game. Nothing about him seemed off. He was even smiling as he walked off the field. Had trainers found something they deemed serious? Head coach Ben Johnson didn’t offer too many details other than that it was a groin issue. This confused NFL doctor David Chao. He couldn’t think of any groin-related issues that would require hospitalization. However, there was one in the same region that would.

Put simply: Moore took a shot to the nuts.

DJ Moore didn’t want to risk further damage without a checkup.

Testicular injuries can get pretty serious if not treated properly. Based on Johnson’s comments, it doesn’t sound like anything serious, hence the day-to-day diagnosis. DJ Moore will likely return to practice whenever he feels the area isn’t tender anymore. Until then, he’ll be limited. Don’t expect him to miss a game, though. One can imagine he may think twice about not wearing a cup in the future. Nut shots can be particularly nasty in any professional sport, but especially in football, where 200-300 lb men fly around at top speed. One wrong angle can lead to no more children.

Moore deserves credit for finishing the game. Most men in that situation would’ve called it a night, looking for the nearest ice bag. DJ gutted it out. That should serve as a reminder to people who question his commitment to the team.

Last Year’s White Sox Trade Is Officially A Bust

Sep 28, 2024; Detroit, Michigan, USA; Chicago White Sox outfielder Dominic Fletcher (7) returns to the dugout after the second inning against the Detroit Tigers at Comerica Park. Mandatory Credit: Brian Bradshaw Sevald-Imagn Images

The White Sox and Arizona Diamondbacks connected on an unexpected trade in February 2024 when the South Siders traded pitching prospect Cristian Mena for outfielder Dominic Fletcher. Over a year and a half later, the deal is now officially a bust from the White Sox side. Fletcher elected free agency earlier today, per Scott Merkin of MLB.com.

Fletcher was on the Diamondbacks’ top 30 prospect list every year from 2020 to 2023 and put up strong numbers in the minor leagues over that span. He also impressed in a cup of coffee at the MLB level with Arizona in 2023, but was the odd man out in a Diamondbacks outfield that featured Corbin Carroll, Lourdes Gurriel Jr., Alek Thomas, Jake McCarthy, and others. 

Fletcher’s Struggles in Chicago

At the time of the trade, the hope was that he would rejuvenate the White Sox outfield as a young player who needed consistent at-bats. It didn’t play out that way. In 275 plate appearances across 84 games in two seasons with the White Sox, he slashed just .208/.254/.282. He gradually fell down the depth chart as time went on, even during the heart of a rebuild. 

The now 28-year-old outfielder did put up a respectable .260/.317/.453 line with 17 home runs in 105 games with the Triple-A Charlotte Knights this season, but he only appeared in 12 games for the White Sox big league team. His inability to earn playing time on a rebuilding team that lost 102 games felt like a good indicator that the organization no longer held him in high regard. The team recently outrighted him to Triple-A Charlotte in hopes of keeping him around as a depth option, but he will now look to continue his career elsewhere.

Cristian Mena

Mena hasn’t been as hoped for the Diamondbacks either to this point. He has only appeared in four MLB games since the trade, spending most of his time in Triple-A. Across 44.2 innings at that level in 2025, he recorded an elevated 4.84 ERA and 1.38 WHIP, though he did strike out 52 over that span and improved from his 2024 Triple-A numbers. He is still just 22 years old, so time is on his side.

Another Failed White Sox Trade

Corey Julks also elected free agency in this set of roster moves. Acquired from the Astros in May 2024 for pitching prospect Luis Rodriguez, Julks did not make the most of his chances in a White Sox uniform. In 202 plate appearances across 72 games in two seasons on the South Side, he hit just .216/.272/.314. He will now look for another opportunity elsewhere.

Improved Talent Evaluation Is Essential

The White Sox have held auditions for numerous players over the past few years. Some have shown enough promise to get continued opportunities. Others, like Dominic Fletcher and Corey Julks, did not. For a team that doesn’t figure to spend significant money in free agency any time soon, they will have to become better at evaluating talent in trades to build a winning roster again.

Watch: Pope Leo XIV Teases Cubs Fans After NLDS Loss

Jun 14, 2025; Chicago, Illinois, US; Pope Leo XIV delivers his video message to churchgoers prior to the Archdiocese of Chicago’s Catholic mass hosted at Rate Field, home of the Chicago White Sox. Mandatory Credit: Patrick Gorski-USA TODAY NETWORK

The world’s most famous White Sox fan has made headlines once again. 

Pope Leo XIV, a Chicagoland native from Dolton who first caught the baseball world’s attention when a clip of him in the crowd at Game 1 of the 2005 World Series resurfaced, is back in the headlines — this time for poking a little fun at Chicago’s crosstown rivals.

During an appearance at the Vatican on Wednesday, someone in the crowd shouted out “Go Cubs!” to him. Pope Leo XIV responded with a smile and a wave before shouting back: “Han perdido! They lost!” 

The Cubs were eliminated from the NLDS over the weekend after a tense, five-game series against the Brewers.

This comes after Pope Leo XIV joined in on a White Sox chant as the popemobile passed a group of hometown fans at the Vatican in June. He was also spotted wearing a White Sox cap in St. Peter’s Square, gifted to him by a pair of Red Sox fans.

The White Sox, meanwhile, have been quick to embrace the new pontiff. In June, the team hosted a celebration at Guaranteed Rate Field honoring the Chicago-born pope, an event organized by the Archdiocese of Chicago that even featured a video message from Pope Leo himself. Earlier this year, the ballpark also unveiled a mural paying tribute to the South Side’s most famous fan in the Vatican.

Sounds Like Ryan Poles Keeps Getting Good News On Trade Market

chicago bears
Dec 3, 2023; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; New York Jets linebacker Jermaine Johnson (11) reacts during the fourth quarter against the Atlanta Falcons at MetLife Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears won their third game in a row on Monday night. Suddenly, they’ve gone from 0-2 to 3-2. Now their schedule might be entering its softest period. New Orleans (1-5), Baltimore (1-5), Cincinnati (2-4), and New York (2-4) are their next four games. Nothing is a gimme in the NFL, but this stretch could catapult the Bears straight into playoff contention. There has been obvious improvement since the season began across the roster, but this team still has certain areas that don’t look strong enough. GM Ryan Poles has one last opportunity to address them with the November 4th trade deadline approaching.

After the performance D'Andre Swift had in Washington, it feels like running back won’t be an area they look at. However, the market seems considerably different for pass rushers. ESPN revealed its latest intel on where things stand. The list of names that could be available couldn’t set up any better for Poles if he wants to be aggressive.

Fowler: Other potential options I suspect the 49ers will check on include edge rushers Rashan Gary (Packers), Jaelan Phillips (Dolphins), Bradley Chubb (Dolphins), Jermaine Johnson (Jets), Will McDonald IV (Jets) and Arden Key (Titans). If the Packers won’t part with Gary — and I don’t think they would — they have pass rusher Kingsley Enagbare, a former starter who’s relegated to a reserve role in a contract year. Pass rusher could elicit the most movement on the trade market overall, and I suspect San Francisco will be involved to some extent.

This is good news for the Bears.

Keep this in mind. Dayo Odeyingbo has eight total pressures on the quarterback this season. Phillips (20), Chubb (13), McDonald (13), and Johnson (9) all have more. Johnson has played two fewer games because of injuries.

Ryan Poles’ likeliest targets aren’t difficult to pinpoint.

Currently, the Bears are limited in terms of cap space. That means pursuing a player with a large contract isn’t really feasible. That means if Ryan Poles does want to make a move, the two names to watch are McDonald, Johnson, and Phillips. All three are still on their rookie contracts with cap numbers hovering between $3-4 million. Knowing how Poles operates, he’d be more inclined to target McDonald or Johnson because both have one more year on their respective deals through 2026.

It would give the Bears some much-needed flexibility since cutting Odeyingbo or Montez Sweat isn’t likely until 2027. If one of those two came over and excelled, Poles would be able to extend them right as the big contracts for Sweat and Dayo become movable.

As to compensation? The New York Jets and Miami Dolphins will likely be seeking high draft picks in return for these pass rushers. A 1st rounder is out of the question due to their contract situations. Smart money says it will hover around a 2nd round pick.

Caught Off Guard: White Sox Turn Pickoffs Into a Secret Weapon

May 26, 2025; New York City, New York, USA; Chicago White Sox catcher Edgar Quero (7) makes a catch for an out while wearing gear honoring the military during the second inning against the New York Mets at Citi Field. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

The 2025 White Sox season had its share of bright spots and growing pains. But there was one play the White Sox executed better than any team in baseball: the catcher pickoff. 

Chicago led the majors with eight catcher pickoffs this season, well above the MLB average of just two. The Red Sox, Orioles, and Tigers tied for second place with six apiece.

No one was more effective in this area than rookie catcher Edgar Quero. In just 579 innings across 72 games behind the plate, Quero recorded an MLB-best five catcher pickoffs, tying Bill Nahorodny’s 1978 mark for the most in a single season in White Sox history. Matt Thaiss, who was traded to Tampa Bay early in the season, was responsible for the White Sox other three pickoffs.

It’s an impressive feat for the rookie, considering there were just 58 catcher pickoffs in the MLB.  However, it’s also a high-risk play. A catcher pickoff carries a much greater chance of error than a throw from the mound, as a single misfire can sail into the outfield and turn an aggressive decision into an extra-base mistake. 

So why the sudden aggressive approach from White Sox catchers? 

The White Sox have historically struggled to hold on baserunners. This past season, they allowed 147 stolen bases, the fifth-most in Major League Baseball. It marked the fifth consecutive year Chicago has ranked among the top ten teams in stolen bases allowed.

Some of that can be attributed to slightly below-average pop times from Quero and Teel. However, much of the responsibility falls on the pitching staff, which struggled to hold runners — a challenge made even tougher by MLB’s disengagement limits. In that context, the catcher’s back pick has become a valuable weapon for keeping baserunners honest.

Quero’s pitch framing was well below league average, posting a Called Strike Above Average of -3. Catchers often set up with one knee in the dirt when trying to steal strikes, a stance that can limit their throwing ability. Executing a back pick is challenging enough from the catcher position, but adding the task of framing a pitch makes throwing out a runner even more difficult.

However, despite Quero’s poor pitch framing, he still had at least one knee down 97% of the time, which was higher than the league average of 95%. This made his five pickoffs even more impressive as he continues to refine his pitch framing.