Wednesday, November 18, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2628

Bears Mailbag — On What Planet Are The Bears The 18th Best Roster?

mitch trubisky

We’re about two weeks away from training camps starting up around the NFL. That means we’ll be watching intently as the Chicago Bears head down to Bourbonnais, Ill. to get in shape for the upcoming year.

The Bears are coming off a 12-4 season, NFC North title, and a ton of emotional capital built up with the fanbase. But the sting of the double-doink ending their season against Philadelphia in the Wild Card round still hurts.

While the Bears have a lot figured out and set up for the 2019 season, some questions still remain. Can Mitch Trubisky take the next step? Who is the kicker? How will the defense change under Chuck Pagano?

We may start to see some of these answers in Bourbonnais. Can’t wait!

With that, let’s reach into our latest Bears Mailbag. Thank you to everyone who submitted questions!

We’ve been asking this question for years. I assume the motivation for your question is Brad Kelly’s roster ranking article for The Draft Network. For those unfamiliar, Kelly revealed his 17th through 24th best rosters yesterday and ranked the Chicago Bears 18th best in the NFL; in other words, a bottom-half roster in the league. He ranked it below the San Francisco 49ers. He actually asked this question on Twitter before revealing his rankings:

The Green Bay Packers and Minnesota Vikings had not yet been revealed in his rankings, so we can conclude that he views them as stronger rosters.

Here was my reaction to that article:

While the media narrative about the Bears has shifted since they defeated the Vikings and Los Angeles Rams last season, Kelly’s rankings are curious, to put it at its absolute mildest.

His argument centers around the QB. And I understand and agree (to an extent) with the skepticism of Mitch Trubisky. He just hasn’t been consistent enough to warrant complete buy-in. But he’s had stretches where he’s played brilliant football, and it’s certainly fair to believe he can make the leap in Year 3. But Trubisky is nowhere near bad enough, in his current state, to bring the entire team’s ranking down to 18. It’s mind-boggling how someone writing for a prestigious site can evaluate this roster that way.

For a roster that has a strong offensive line, a good mix of running backs and receivers, an elite defensive front, strong linebackers and a strong secondary that tore up opponents last season, even some ‘regression’ does not place this roster in the bottom half of the NFL. With the quarterback, it’s a Top 10 roster. Excluding the quarterback, it’s arguably Top 5.

We’ve seen skepticism and “not really that good” takes from rival NFC North blogging sites, and that’s not surprising. It’s the nature of the rivalry. But Kelly’s take is bad. Very bad. And all the Bears can do about it is continue to prove them wrong.

I really don’t see the Bears trading a lot for Robbie Gould. Keep in mind, San Francisco has the leverage here. They placed the franchise tag on him earlier in the offseason and if he doesn’t sign the tag, he loses out on a salary this season and can’t play for anyone else. Gould has been open about his desire to play closer to his family, who happen to reside in Chicago.

The Bears are arguably a made kick away from playing in the Super Bowl last season. And after releasing Cody Parkey, the competition in OTAs has turned up less than stellar results. After a mini competition saw eight kickers brought in, the Bears are left with Elliot Fry and Eddy Pineiro on their roster at the moment. The Bears will very likely add to the competition in training camp or during the preseason. They have to get this right.

But for a team with leverage like the 49ers, they can demand whatever they want for Gould. And I don’t see the Bears sacrificing a mid-round draft pick for him, even though it would absolutely be defensible. There is no move the Bears could make at kicker that would be better than adding Gould from a good-will / PR perspective. And probably from a football perspective. But it may require either San Francisco to accept something like a seventh-round pick or for them to rescind the tag altogether. Let’s see how it plays out.

Q: What’s your biggest concern going into camp? — Jason B.

I have two concerns as it relates to football: How much will Mitch Trubisky improve and who will kick (and are they any good?). I think those answers are paramount to the Bears’ success this season.

There are others such as how the scheme will differ with Chuck Pagano calling defensive plays instead of Vic Fangio. I think we know they will be much more aggressive with their coverages and rushes and may sacrifice more big plays from time to time in order to wreak havoc. But the Bears have fundamentally sound players on defense where they should be able to minimize those kinds of issues. Hopefully.

My ultimate concern though? Please, stay healthy. Far too often we see teams get crippled in training camp or the preseason because of a terrible injury to a key player. This team needs to stay healthy. They were granted good health last season and they played excellent football. Availability is just as important as ability.

So please, stay healthy.

Jim McMahon Blamed Michael McCaskey For Bears Falling Apart

jim mcmahon

Jim McMahon is a guy who never shies away from having an opinion. He honestly doesn’t care what other people think. He’ll be heard one way or another. That’s a big reason so many Chicago Bears fans love him to this day. Often his strongest statements have been reserved for people he’s butted head with including his former head coach Mike Ditka. However, people forget how much the “Punky QB” hated Michael McCaskey.

For those who don’t recall, he was the oldest grandchild of George Halas. The man who took over as team president of the Bears when the iconic owner died in 1983. It didn’t take him long to start asserting his authority over the roster. He assumed GM duties in the mid-1980s and began to half frequent disagreements with Ditka for the types of players being acquired.

McMahon sensed the problem with the eventual team Chairman almost right away. Where Halas didn’t mind players with personality and fiery character, McCaskey was the complete opposite.

He ripped Ditka — nicknaming him “Sybil” after a TV character with 16 personalities — and team Chairman Mike McCaskey every chance he got. In his autobiography, he declared that McCaskey would prefer a team of robots: “Then everything would go along peacefully. You might not win many games, but at least there would be no headbands.”

Jim McMahon was proven correct as McCaskey gained more influence

All one has to do is evaluate McCaskey’s draft work in the late 1980s and into the 1990s. More and more the Bears started selecting players who, while physically gifted weren’t always known for their outspokenness. They tended to have more reserved personalities. Guys who could be called good soldiers. They’re quiet and do as they’re told. That can be fine at times, but history shows championship teams can’t be built with those alone.

  • Brad Muster over Thurman Thomas.
  • Stan Thomas over Brett Favre.
  • Dave Wannstedt over Bill Parcells.
  • Curtis Conway over Jerome Bettis.
  • Walt Harris over Ray Lewis.
  • Curtis Enis over Randy Moss.
  • Dick Jauron over Brian Billick.

Whether it was acquiring players or head coaches, McCaskey avoided names that looked like they might talk to the cameras a bit too much or draw unwanted attention like the plague. Even if that meant sacrificing significant potential in terms of talent. It wasn’t until after he was forced to relinquish his power over the roster by his mother Virginia McCaskey that the Bears finally got back on track. The same year that happened, they drafted Brian Urlacher and Mike Brown.

It seems McMahon was right on the money.

Devin Hester Reveals a Secret Technique He Used to Terrorize NFL

devin hester

Most people think they have the return game in the NFL figured out. Put a fast guy back there, let him bring the ball out and hope there are enough blocks to spring an opening for him. That is grossly oversimplified. Believe it or not, like any other position, there’s a science behind it that separates the good from the great. Devin Hester, for the first time since his retirement, revealed one of the key techniques he developed to become the best ever.

Hester had the critical element of speed, quickness, and vision that made him a nightmare to catch. Nevermind the fact he was deceptively strong, which made him that much harder to tackle. Yet his brilliance went even deeper than that. As he played the return man position more and more, he started to create subtle moves to help give him extra bits of space to make something happen.

During a recap with the NFL Network over his rookie season in 2006, he explained the one that worked the most. It involved when he first caught the ball on each of his punt returns. Rather than take off right away, he had a tendency to pause for a split second. He did this for two main reasons. First was to find out where the best lane would be. The second was forcing the coverage unit to slow down, allowing his blockers enough time to catch up.

Devin Hester used that technique time and time again

Go back and watch Hester during that year alone. He used that little trick multiple times including against Arizona, New York, St. Louis, and Indianapolis. He perfected it even more the next season when he broke his own record with six return touchdowns in 2007. The man was an absolute machine but it turns out his greatness wasn’t based on physical ability alone. There was an element of intelligence and instinct as well.

There is no debate that Hester is the greatest return man in NFL history. The question that fans have at this point is whether the voters in Canton will have the common sense to put him in the Hall of Fame. Nobody else comes close to what he accomplished. His records are almost certain to never be broken due to rule changes. There is no way to talk about the 2000s without mentioning his name. That is what a Hall of Famer is. Hester deserves it.

Ha Ha Clinton-Dix Following a Similar Path of Another Chicago Hero

ha ha clinton-dix

The Chicago Bears feel like they got a steal when they signed safety Ha Ha Clinton-Dix. Here’s a former Pro Bowler who is still in his physical prime as a player that was had for ridiculously cheap ($3.5 million) to fill the void left by Adrian Amos next to Eddie Jackson. There are plenty doing their best to say the Bears downgraded. Clinton-Dix isn’t at the level Amos is. That argument will likely go on for a while.

Instead of getting bogged down in that, a more interesting question was worth raising. Has there ever been a similar set of circumstances that represents his situation? A former budding star who fell on hard times, signed for cheap in Chicago and managed to revive his career? As a matter of fact, there is. One that baseball fans should remember well.

It came in 2005. The White Sox, to minimal fanfare, signed veteran right fielder Jermaine Dye to a two-year deal worth just over $10 million. By today’s standards, that’s chump change. Dye, a former All-Star in Kansas City, had been traded midway through the 2001 season to Oakland. He struggled there most of the way and was allowed to leave in free agency in 2004. Chicago scooped him up, believing he still had good baseball in him if he could stay healthy.

They were correct. Dye hit 31 home runs in 2005 and was the hero in the decisive game of the World Series, going 3-for-4 in Houston with the base hit that drove in the winning run. A move many felt was a gamble had paid off handsomely.

Ha Ha Clinton-Dix journey parallels Dye in many ways

So people will ask what this has to do with Clinton-Dix. That’s a fair question. He’s a football player and Dye is a baseball player. Different sports and what not. Here is a breakdown to help understand:

Starred early in his career with his original team? Check.

Clinton-Dix had 13 interceptions through his first four seasons with the Green Bay Packers and made the Pro Bowl in 2016.

Traded midway through the season? Check.

With frustration mounting in Green Bay midway through the 2017 season, the Packers traded the disgruntled safety to the Washington Redskins for a 4th round pick.

Struggled with the team he was traded to? Check.

In eight games with the Redskins, Clinton-Dix never seemed to find a footing. He failed to record an interception and suffered from a number of on-field mistakes that frustrated people.

Spurned likely bigger money elsewhere to join Chicago? Check that too.

Clinton-Dix may have been struggling at times but he was still a player with standout qualities. There is no question he could’ve gotten more money as a free agent than the one-year deal he signed with the Bears. Same as Dye with the White Sox. His decision is a calculated risk both on himself and the team being as good as it appears.

Now, this is not to say Clinton-Dix suddenly guarantees the Bears will win a championship in 2019. However, the similarities he shares with the former White Sox hero makes it hard not to be excited about what he might do this season.

Khalil Mack Becomes First Bear to Achieve This in 12 Years

khalil mack

Like it or not, Madden NFL is the one and only football video game franchise in town. Even if their titles have been one long series of meh for years now. Bitter complaints aside, one of the most anticipated parts of the game’s release each year is the revelation of the player ratings. This offers an idea of how the game researchers view the hierarchy of the league at that present time. Most importantly, will any of them crack the elusive 99 Overall barrier? Khalil Mack just got his answer.

The Madden 20 makers at EA Sports revealed that only four players will garner a 99 this upcoming season. Thus far Los Angeles Rams defensive tackle Aaron Donald and Seattle Seahawks middle linebacker Bobby Wagner was revealed as two choices. The third revelation? Yep, the Chicago Bears superstar pass rusher. Clearly, his dominating 2018 season with 12.5 sacks, six forced fumbles, and a pick-six left an impression.

Especially considering he did all that in just 14 games. Not only is that a testament to his obvious skill, but it also ends yet another notable drought for the Bears. With it, Mack becomes the first of this team to reach that elusive rating since Brian Urlacher did it way back in 2007 for the Madden 08 release.

Khalil Mack is absolutely at the star level Urlacher was

They may play completely different positions, but don’t be fooled. Mack is every bit the superstar caliber that Urlacher was. His ability to take over games, make big plays in big moments, and force defenses to fashion entire gameplans around stopping him is the same thing Urlacher did for years. He earned every bit of that 99 rating and was also on the cover of the NFL 2K3 game. Hopefully, Mack can avoid that “honor” given its questionable curse history.

The crazy part is that the Bears outside linebacker reached that height in spite of some huge obstacles last year. He didn’t arrive in Chicago until the beginning of September, just days before the regular season was set to begin. He’d had no training camp to prepare and zero knowledge of the defense. Then he dealt with a rough ankle injury midway through the season that hobbled him for two games and forced him to miss two others.

It didn’t matter. He dominated anyway. Now he’s healthy and will have a full offseason of preparation. It’s scary to think he might actually top what he did last year.

John Paxson Makes Statement on Russell Westbrook Rumor

Westbrook unhappy

The idea of adding Russell Westbrook has caught the imagination of many Chicago Bulls fans lately. Oklahoma City has made the 8-time All-Star available via trade. The organization is looking to rebuild and shed salary. Already they dealt Paul George to the Clippers in a blockbuster deal. Now removing Westbrook’s $38.5 million cap hit in 2019-2020 is their next objective. Chicago has ways they could make a deal work, but that would depend on how interest John Paxson and Gar Foreman are in such an idea.

Knowing their history, the answer wasn’t hard to surmise. Chicago has never been aggressive in pursuing big trades for veteran players, even if they are stars. They’re much more about grabbing talent in the draft and supplementing it with the hopeful addition of a star in free agency. The only problem is their record in the latter has been pitiful for years. Hence the frustration of fans and desire to try this different approach.

Paxson though has never been a man known for bowing to public pressure. It served him well as a player and remains something that carries him through in the Bulls front office. So when asked about the Westbrook Question on 670 The Score, his answer was long-winded but hardly surprising.

John Paxson says Bulls will avoid any Westbrook entanglements

There were a number of reasons Paxson listed, but two were primarily referenced multiple times. The fact that Westbrook costs what he does at 30-years old and the fact the team brass believes strongly in the potential of their young core. Especially Lauri Markannen and Zach Lavine. If they develop properly, the team may turn into a hot destination in the near future.

“When you look at the financial aspect of a player that’s 30 going out four years (on his contract) and the amount of money that’s going to be made, those things can tie your hands up and put your organization in a tough position…

…You want the superstars. You want to do what the Clippers are doing and the Lakers are doing, but we’re realistic right now. We’re not in that position. We hope that in a couple years with the development of these young guys, players around the league view us as a destination point where they can win at the highest level. I believe we’ll be there if our young guys perform the way we hope they will.”

It’s not a bad plan in terms of its logic. The Bulls have a host of young talent on their roster. Several names with high upside. Not just Markannen and Lavine but also Wendell Carter, Otto Porter, and now Coby White. None of them may be superstars, but they could forge the kind of lineup that would entice a superstar to come to Chicago and complete the puzzle. Sort of like what the Cavaliers did with LeBron James back in 2014.

This Chicago Bears Position Group is Ranked Deepest in the NFL

chicago bears

Star power is important in the NFL. Then again it’s important in every sport. Teams won’t win a lot of games without it. However, football tends to favor one other aspect of roster building than just a core of great players. That being depth. Due to the nature of football and its physicality, attrition is the biggest issue facing teams. Players lost to injury. That is why having a deeper roster can often be the decisive advantage. Something the Chicago Bears haven’t known for a long time.

Not until now that is.

Experts everywhere tend to agree that this might be the most talented roster the franchise has put together in years. Not since their peak in 2005-2006. Some would even argue this team is better than that one because of its significant improvements on offense in regards to wide receiver and quarterback. It certainly provides hope this team might finish what that one wasn’t able to 13 years ago.

Yet there is one area of this roster that is getting significant attention. Not just for being the deepest on the team but the deepest in the entire NFL. Chris Wesseling of NFL.com broke down which one it is and what makes it so scary on paper.

Chicago Bears front seven is peerless in the NFL today

The Los Angeles Rams may have the best defensive front seven player in Aaron Donald, but their overall unit can’t even touch what the Bears have built. Not only do they have a comparable star in Khalil Mack, but the talent spreads to multiple other positions and goes even to the #2 guys at several of them. That’s why the Bears front seven was ranked the second deepest position group in the entire league.

“Led by perennial Defensive Player of the Year candidate Khalil Mack, the latest iteration of the Monsters of the Midway finished first in Football Outsiders’ defensive efficiency metrics and opponents’ passer rating, while falling just two sacks shy of the NFL lead.

The entire front-seven cast returns intact, with Pro Bowl behemoth Akiem Hicks stonewalling the ground attack and nose tackle Eddie Goldman emerging as a disruptive force in his own right. Not to be overlooked, veteran Danny Trevathan and up-and-comer Roquan Smith comprise one of the league’s most productive inside linebacker tandems, with the latter improving throughout last season.

Headlining the second unit, edge rusher Aaron Lynch and second-year interior lineman Bilal Nichols flashed big-play potential in limited playing time. If this unit stays healthy, the only question is whether former Colts head coach Chuck Pagano can fill the sizable shoes of Vic Fangio, a master button-pusher in recent years.”

It’s hard to argue those points. The Bears devastated offenses with that front seven last year. Not only did they finish with 50 sacks, but they also boasted the #1 run defense in the league. There was no escaping them. Perhaps the scariest part is that it is a group that is still young. Hicks and Trevathan are the oldest members and are still just 29. Mack is 28 and Leonard Floyd is 26. Everybody else including Smith and Goldman are 25 or younger.

Eddie Jackson Says This Bears Rookie is Already Hard to Ignore

eddie jackson

Not too long ago, Eddie Jackson was a rookie himself in 2017. He understood the trial and challenges needed to overcome in order to become part of the Chicago Bears starting defense. He achieved that goal and has since become one of the focal points of the unit, earning All-Pro honors in 2018. So he has a unique perspective in terms of watching this latest Bears draft class embark on their own quests to crack the top 22.

Continuing his offseason campaign of talking with various media outlets, the accessible Jackson appeared on the Bears Banter podcast with Bill Zimmerman to discuss various topics. Things started with the transition from Vic Fangio to Chuck Pagano, then covered his comments regarding the pursuit of the ’85 Bears. His most interesting statement though came when asked about which rookie has stood out to him the most at this point.

There wasn’t must hesitation in his answer. Jackson is becoming a big fan of 6th round pick Duke Shelley.

“Duke, man. Duke has stood out the most to me, to be honest. To see the energy he brings. He has a dog. We call it ‘He has that dog inside of him.’ He wants to come out and compete. You know he’s lined up against Turbo (Taylor Gabriel), Riley Ridley, or any other guy, he’s going to feel like he’s going to win that matchup.

When you tell him something, you see him take the coaching and actually put it into his game. For us? Having a young guy like that? We can trust him.”

Eddie Jackson is the latest to heap praise on Shelley

The buzz around Shelley has been persisting since rookie minicamps back in May. A cornerback out of Kansas State, he arrived to little fanfare in April. Few people even knew his name. When they found out he was cornerback who is only 5’8, their reservations intensified. However, upon evaluating his tape it started to become clear the Bears may have gotten themselves a football player.

For what he lacks in height, Shelley makes up for it in athleticism and toughness. He can play the physical game against wide receivers and won his share of battles for the football. The man himself believes if he hadn’t suffered an untimely injury last season he would’ve been a higher draft choice. Seeing the film and hearing the whispers thus far? It’s hard not to take him at his word.

Now with Jackson throwing his own assessment into the mix, it’s clear the Bears may have gotten a steal with that pick.

Mitch Trubisky Finally Gets Credit For Overlooked Part of His Game

mitch trubisky

Experts and armchair GMs have done everything in their power to attack Mitch Trubisky since his rookie season. People have searched for reasons why the fervor against him is so strong. The running belief is it’s because he had the audacity to be chosen ahead of Deshaun Watson and Patrick Mahomes. Two guys who had rabid fan bases in college that carried over into the NFL. To see this intruder with only one year of starting experience get picked first? It was an insult to them.

The fact Watson and Mahomes have had outstanding bursts of production over the past two years while Trubisky has only improved steadily doesn’t help. For every outstanding play he’s made in the past two years, there has been one that can make you cringe. Yet rather than chalk it up to a young quarterback learning the speed and complexities of the NFL, many have leaped right to the conclusion that he’s a bust.

This has made it beyond easy to miss something that has already begun to emerge about Trubisky. Something that can make him truly special if the rest of his game continues to blossom. Brett Kollmann of SB Nation discovered it during some intensive tape study. For all his maddening inconsistencies, Trubisky always seems to step up right when the Bears need him most.

Mitch Trubisky has proven ice cold in high-pressure situations

This is something that began to appear as far back as his rookie season. There were constant flashes that Trubisky just had this switch. When he flipped it late in games, he’d often produce a money play to give his team a chance to win. People just don’t remember a lot of them because they’re often been ruined but the utter dumpster fire that is the Bears kicking games. Shall we review?

  • The 4th and 16 scramble against Detroit. Connor Barth missed the tying field goal.
  • A 6:21 drive in the 4th quarter against Green Bay to make it 23-17 with just 2:39 left. Kyle Fuller drops the clinching INT and defense gives up a 75-yard TD on the next play.
  • Hit Anthony Miller for a 29-yard TD with 3:17 left in Miami to take a 28-21 lead. Defense gives up a 75-yard tying score on the next play.
  • Came one yard from forcing overtime on a 54-yard strike to Kevin White against the Patriots.
  • Accounted for all but 6 of the 45 yards on the TD drive that clinched the division title against Green Bay (in the 4th quarter).
  • Engineered a 5:37 late drive to drain the clock against San Francisco. Allen Robinson kills it with a bad fumble.
  • Hits two huge passes for 33 yards with 44 seconds left in the playoff game against Philadelphia. Cody Parkey misses the winning 43-yard field goal.

Rather than kill Trubisky for his apparent shortcomings, maybe it’s time to get on his teammates for constantly ruining what should’ve been spectacular clutch moments with their own mind-numbing mistakes. This kid can play, and he can do it under pressure. That is something worth having when a team is thinking Super Bowl.

New Info on Russell Westbrook Issue Opens Door a Bit Wider for Bulls

russell westbrook

The Russell Westbrook situation has many NBA fans captivated. An 8-time All-Star who is still on the later end of his physical prime could be dealt by the Oklahoma City Thunder. It’s clear they intend to do so, wanting to shed as much salary as possible while collecting future assets. They already raked in a ton of wiggle room and draft picks in the blockbuster deal that sent Paul George to the Clippers. Most feel it’s only a matter of time before Westbrook is next.

As things stand, the heavy favorite in any speculation for a trade is the Miami Heat. It seems like a move Pat Riley would make. The team just signed Jimmy Butler. Adding Westbrook would launch the team right back into the thick of the Eastern Conference picture. There’s one problem though. Their money situation is tight. In order to work a deal, they’d have to shed a ton of salary to fit Westbrook’s massive $38.5 million cap hit.

Difficult, but not impossible. However, a seemingly innocent development in the past few hours has made any deal harder. Their rookie 1st round pick Tyler Herro was viewed by many as a logical part of any trade package Miami could put together. That idea became problematic when it was reported Herro signed his rookie contract. This means he is now untradeable for the next 30 days.

To say nothing of the fact the Heat have hinted strongly they have no desire to move him. For those who are hoping the Chicago Bulls might take a shot at landing the star point guard, this is significant.

Bulls now have a 30-day window to scoop Russell Westbrook

It still isn’t clear where the Bulls stand on the Westbrook question. Their silence would seem to indicate a lack of interest. Then again silence can mean anything. The reality is Westbrook would instantly become the best player on the roster by a comfortable margin. His 22 points/10 assists/11 rebounds stat line from last season is something that few players in the NBA could ever hope to accomplish.

People may accuse the man of being selfish and not focused on making the team better. If that were true though, he’d be focused on scoring and wouldn’t even bother passing. It’s also important to remember he was brilliant in the NBA Finals against Miami back in 2012. He scored at least 27 points in three of the five games played including 43 in Game 4. The man had a triple-double twice in the series loss to Portland last season.

He can elevate his game in May and June. Given the state of the Eastern Conference, there is no reason to think his addition can’t make the Bulls a dark horse contender depending on who they’re able to keep in any trade with the Thunder. As always it comes down to what Gar Forman and John Paxson believe.