Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2394

Ryan Pace Faces His Darkest Hour. So How Will He Respond?

ryan pace

Super Bowl Sunday was a crowning moment for so many people. However, Ryan Pace was not one of them. The Chicago Bears GM was forced to watch as Patrick Mahomes, a player who’d been in his grasp three short years ago, led the Kansas City Chiefs to their first Super Bowl title in 50 years. A moment that crowned his career with the trifecta of an MVP, a ring, and a Super Bowl MVP before he was even 25-years old. For all the good Pace has done for the Bears franchise, he’s now merely viewed as the guy who passed on Mahomes in favor of Mitch Trubisky.

This leaves an air of uncertainty around the coming offseason. No 1st round pick. Limited salary cap space. People are wondering what Pace will do with the pressure now squarely on his shoulders like never before. His Trubisky mistake reared its head big time this past season. Yet that didn’t stop the GM from doubling down and the end-of-year press conference and declaring the 25-year old would remain the starter in 2020.

It sounded like a man who didn’t fully understand his situation. One characterized by a season wasted because of several key draft failures. Trubisky being one. Adam Shaheen and Leonard Floyd being others. Everything comes back to the quarterback though. Pace has delivered one winning season in five years. Can he honestly survive 2020 if they don’t get back to the playoffs? Ownership has expressed confidence in him but things change fast in the NFL.

Especially when losing is involved.

With Mahomes a champion and the threat of losing his job 11 months away, how will Pace respond?

Ryan Pace is a man who will go down swinging

Under the current conditions, most people might assume what the Bears will do. They’ll spend most of their available cap space on re-signing key players and grabbing a couple of mid tier free agents. Probably a veteran QB on the cheap who can provide depth behind Trubisky. Then they’ll do the best they can to score as many impact players as possible in the draft. Nothing flashy.

While there is a logic to this approach, it’s not one that gives a person optimism the Bears will be in a significantly better position next season. Not with how strong the division and the NFC in general will be. However, this is Pace we’re talking about.

Playing it safe has never really been his style. Don’t forget the note he wrote to himself shortly after drafting Trubisky.

“Maybe we can make status quo decisions and please the pundits, or make decisions that are predictable and easily accepted positions,” Pace wrote. “Or we can (expletive) take chances and be bold and be great. I’m not going to look back with regrets. I can’t do that to myself. I can’t do that to this building. And bottom line is you don’t achieve greatness in this league without great quarterback play.”

Pace has carved a career out of being aggressive.

He’s not afraid to take chances if he feels it makes his team better. Just one year after trading up to secure Trubisky, he engineered the blockbuster deal for Khalil Mack and then moved up from the 4th round all the way to the 2nd to get Anthony Miller. A year later he jumped up the board again to draft David Montgomery. Nothing about Pace’s tenure illustrates a man who’s content at playing it safe.

Already the Bears started the offseason fast with a massive overhaul of their coaching staff. They gave considerable guaranteed money to sign CFL star Tre Roberson ahead of nine other teams. It feels like Pace has no plans to stay mostly quiet this offseason. He’s staying true to who he is, which means fans can expect some interesting maneuvers in the next three months.

How Andy Reid Winning the Super Bowl Could Help the Bears

andy reid

Watching the Kansas City Chiefs win the Super Bowl must’ve felt like torture for Chicago Bears fans. Mostly because the quarterback they did it with in Patrick Mahomes was right in their grasp and Ryan Pace passed on him. That is the cruel reality this fanbase has dealt with for too long. Other organizations enjoy quarterback superstardom but not them. They’re stuck in purgatory with Mitch Trubisky. However, there might be a silver lining to all this, and Chiefs head coach Andy Reid is the key.

It’s no secret that Bears head coach Matt Nagy looks up to Reid like no other. It’s a mentor-student relationship. Nagy gives Reid all the credit for paving his way to the NFL and helping him realize a dream of running his own team. The two text each other all the time, Nagy constantly seeking advice on what he must do to get better. It is this part of the relationship that is key. Nagy wants to get where Reid is now at. On the doorstep of Canton and finally hoisting a Super Bowl trophy.

How did it happen? There are several reasons, but none more key than one decision Reid made in 2017. That was to leave the comfortable waters of Alex Smith at quarterback and take a monumental swing for the fences by trading up to draft Mahomes. The rest is history. Seeing those two realize their mission might just be the final nudge Nagy needs to really press GM Ryan Pace on making a change at quarterback.

Andy Reid proves one can’t be afraid of change

Reid has always been a guy who doesn’t fear being aggressive at quarterback. He drafted Donovan McNabb in 1999 when few expected him to. Then in 2009, he signed Michael Vick fresh out of prison to guard against McNabb’s possible decline. Upon getting to Kansas City, he trades for Smith then a few years later goes after Mahomes. Whenever he sensed things weren’t progressing at the position, he made a change.

That might be the final lesson Nagy needs to learn. He’s had two years to experience Trubisky at this point. It hasn’t gotten better. It got worse. He’s nowhere close to Mahomes’ level or even Smith’s for that matter. The Bears have a good enough roster to win a Super Bowl, but not good enough to carry an inadequate quarterback to one. This isn’t 1985. The days of dominant defense doing it by themselves are over.

There will be several notable QBs available via free agency or the trade market in March. The Bears have more than enough flexibility to go get one. All they need is the conviction to do so. That will have to come from the top. Nothing will move unless Nagy gives it the needed push.

Thoughts And Observations From Super Bowl LIV

By John McCall / South Florida Sun Sentinel Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes rushes into the end zone for a first quarter touchdown against the San Francisco 49ers during the 2020 Super Bowl at Hard Rock Stadium in Miami Gardens, Sunday, Feb. 2, 2020. (John McCall/South Florida Sun Sentinel)

MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. — The 2019-2020 NFL season came to a close tonight at Hard Rock Stadium, as the Kansas City Chiefs and San Francisco 49ers faced off in Super Bowl LIV. Both teams won convincingly in their respective Divisional and Conference Championship games, setting up tonight’s showdown.

No real preamble this week — just straight up thoughts on a fun and memorable Super Bowl — one that saw the legendary Andy Reid win his first Super Bowl! Follow me on Twitter @DhruvKoul to continue the conversation.

Thoughts and Observations

1. This game had plenty of Chicago Bears connections: Patrick Mahomes, and what could’ve been. Dave Toub. Matt Nagy’s mentor in Andy Reid. Robbie Gould. Raheem Mostert (apparently.) So many storylines to root for. Personally, I was rooting for big ol’ Andy to finally get his first Super Bowl title. Arguably the greatest offensive mastermind in this league’s great history, it wouldn’t be right without him winning a title at some point. Why not tonight?

(P.S. — I’m sorry, Robbie Gould.)

2. Virginia McCaskey, the Bears’ matriarch, made an appearance in the NFL’s Super Bowl commercial! She handed the ball off to a little kid before he ran it onto the field. Great commercial, overall. The NFL does well with these every year; this year was no different.

3. The Chiefs went 3 and out on their opening possession, with Patrick Mahomes missing an easy route in the flat on third down. He just rushed it. After Richie James of SF survived and recovered his own muff on the punt, the 49ers marched down the field with an impressive array of plays from Kyle Shanahan. The drive eventually stalled, but:

4. So far in the first half, Mahomes has been quite bad. He’s been off/late/inaccurate with his throws for the most part, though Reid is scheming them open. But the Chiefs are moving the ball with the running game — something people didn’t expect much of. Reid has even gone for it on two 4th-and-shorts and picked it up with option plays both times. It’s working. The 49ers have no answer for Andy Reid’s scheme right now.

5. The only reason the 49ers are in this game is their running game. Jimmy Garoppolo has been miserable overall, but the running game is the primary source of the 49ers’ drives. Shanahan’s run schemes are FUN.

6. Google with the heart-wrenching ad of the night — advertising an elderly man using Google Assistant to help him remember the finer details of his (presumably late) wife. Ugh.

7. Both coaches seemed like they almost gave up at the end of the first half and were content with a tie game heading to the locker room. The 49ers almost lulled the Chiefs to sleep until the final seconds, when Shanahan called two great plays to get the ball to near midfield and then inside the red zone on back to back plays. But an OPI on George Kittle negated a beautiful throw by Jimmy G (his first of the game) and kept it tied at the half. San Francisco receives the second-half kick.

8. Halftime performance analysis:

J-Lo wasn’t half bad, either. These women are 43 and 50 years old, respectively. Amazing.

9. Nice start to the second half for the 49ers — they dominated the third quarter. The running game dominated, Jimmy G was sharp to make some big completions, and they scored 7 points off a brutal INT from Patrick Mahomes. SF is up 20-10 at the end of three quarters. Great play calling from Kyle Shanahan; awful execution by the Chiefs.

Also, Nick Bosa is dominating Eric Fisher. Wow.

10. With the Chiefs near the red zone to begin the fourth quarter, Mahomes rushed another throw (behind his receiver) that was intercepted by SF. A points-removing mistake. Mahomes has been awful tonight.

11. On the ensuing drive, Mahomes chucked a deep ball on 3rd and 15 down the field to a wide open Tyreek Hill, who somehow got wide open for 44 yards. It was underthrown, but still wide open. After a DPI got KC a first-and-goal at the 1, Mahomes found Kelce to bring the Chiefs within three points. This was a very KC-like drive — Mahomes throws a prayer, somehow Hill finds it, and Kelce scores a TD. Mahomes has been terrible tonight overall, but they somehow got a big play to get them back in it.

12. Goodness. After a 3 and out (two incompletions by Garoppolo), Sammy Watkins beat Richard Sherman down the field (beauty of a route and throw) to set up KC in the red zone. And by the literal nose of the football, the Chiefs took the lead. I mean, so close.

It sets up this:

13. YIKES, Jimmy Garoppolo. Holy hell. He missed a potential Super Bowl-winning touchdown pass by five yards on an overthrow.

And on 4th down, he got sacked. Game over. Super Bowl over. Choke complete.

14. All I have to say:

(P.S. — I feel gutted for Kyle Shanahan and Robbie Gould. Man.)

15. In the last three years, we’ve seen an Andy Reid disciple (Doug Pederson) win the Super Bowl, the Patriots win the Super Bowl, and Andy Reid win the Super Bowl. Let’s hope next year is Matt Nagy’s time.

16. And that’s a wrap on the 2019-2020 season. Looking forward to an exciting offseason (for the Chicago Bears) to get back to contention next year. Stay tuned.

Predicting Where Every Free Agent QB Goes and How It Affects the Bears

chicago bears

The 2020 free agent class of quarterbacks is likely the most unique seen in the NFL in easily a decade. Perhaps longer. It’s a class loaded with big names including three future Hall of Famers, a Pro Bowler, and a few other notable starters who’ve played really well in the past but haven’t lately. This creates an interesting situation for the Chicago Bears.

Everybody knows where things stand. Mitch Trubisky regressed a lot this past year, throwing just 17 touchdowns after throwing 24 in 2018. His threat as a runner disappeared for the most part and he just didn’t seem able to handle what defenses were throwing at him. This has led to many an expert to declare him a bust and for the Bears to look for an escape hatch.

Hence the heavy focus on this free agent group. Could one of those big names actually come to Chicago? Here is a breakdown of predictions for every notable name, where they end up and why.

How QB landscape will probably go for the Chicago Bears

Dak Prescott – Stays with Dallas Cowboys

This is an easy one. Word has already filtered out that the Cowboys plan to use the franchise tag on Prescott since negotiations haven’t gone too quickly to this point. He’s not going anywhere.

Drew Brees – Stays with New Orleans Saints

It’s basically retirement or returning for one more year at this point for Brees. After the disappointment of this season, going 13-3 only to get stunned in the wild card opener, one would understand if he walked away. However, Brees is a competitor and the Saints are a good team. He’ll take one more crack at it.

Tom Brady – Stays with New England Patriots

This entire situation feels like it’s setting up for anticlimax. People are wondering what Brady will do as a free agent for the first time in his career. Truth be told he might leave, but the Patriots want him to stay and that’s what will probably end up happening.

Philip Rivers – Signs with Tampa Bay Buccaneers

It’s pretty clear the Chargers and Rivers are done with each other. Rivers though wants to keep playing. Rumors have swirled that the Buccaneers are interested. Adding to this is the fact that the quarterback just moved his family to Florida. Given his reputation for preferring short commutes, this is an easy dot to connect.

Teddy Bridgewater – Signs with Los Angeles Chargers

The Chargers aren’t in a position to rebuild. They have a good roster that is ready to win, so it makes more sense for them to pursue a veteran option. Bridgewater is still young and fresh off a valuable education in New Orleans. He’s ready to start in the NFL again and would be a solid presence for L.A.

Ryan Tannehill – Stays with Tennessee Titans

There is a buzz that the Titans might pursue bigger fish on the market such as Brady, but the odds favor them sticking with the guy who got them to the AFC championship in Tannehill. It could be via the franchise tag if they wish to avoid a long-term commitment.

Jameis Winston – Signs with Las Vegas Raiders

Jon Gruden is notoriously fickle at quarterback. Word is hot that he’s ready to move on from Derek Carr. The Raiders want Brady but that is unlikely. There is a small buzz that the head coach is interested in Winston and could probably get him cheap.

Marcus Mariota – Signs with New England Patriots

This probably comes as a shock to Bears fans. That said, think about it. Mariota and Trubisky share the same agent. They also have a number of the same issues. So what would be different? Mariota signing in New England makes sense. The Patriots need depth and the 26-year old could use that time learning under the best with a chance to seize that job down the road.

So what does this mean?

It means if the Chicago Bears are going to make a significant move at quarterback, it will involve either a trade or an unexpected cut. Andy Dalton and Nick Foles spring to mind. Two guys with strong connections to the coaching staff and lots of solid experience. Maybe even Carr if the stars aligned. The truth is the evidence points to the Bears sticking by their word and riding out one more year with Trubisky. They may even decline his 5th year option to pour on some pressure.

Pace still believes in his young quarterback. Enough to gamble his job? It seems so. He always talks about conviction. This is his moment for it.

Tony Dungy Blames the Bible for Convincing Him to Kick to Devin Hester

tony dungy

With the Super Bowl just hours away, Chicago Bears fans are once again forced to lament what could’ve been back in 2006. They came so close to clinching a second Lombardi trophy for the organization only to watch is crumble in the face of Peyton Manning’s legacy. They seemed to do everything right, including the fastest start in the game’s history thanks to the legendary 92-yard kickoff return touchdown by Devin Hester. People couldn’t believe the Indianapolis Colts actually gave him that chance, leading to a simple question. What was head coach Tony Dungy thinking?

The truth is Dungy started out with the obvious intention of avoiding Hester at all costs. Why bother giving the Bears a potential spark? Just avoid him and put the game in the hands of Rex Grossman. It was a no-brainer. Then, somewhere close to when the game arrived the coach had a change of heart. He gave the green light for his coverage unit to kick it away. Hester predictably made him pay for that hubris. So what was the decisive argument that swayed him?

According to Dan Wiederer of the Chicago Tribune, it was a famous passage from the Bible.

While we were in Miami the week of the game, we had a chapel speaker who talked about how David got after Goliath and he wasn’t afraid. Everybody else ran away from Goliath. And David ran right to him. So I started thinking about that and I said to myself, “Gosh, we can’t play scared. We’re kind of playing scared here with Devin Hester and that’s not setting the right tone.” I started to change my mind.

Tony Dungy didn’t play fearless, he played stupid

Emotions had no place in a decision like that. Kicking to Hester was not a question of fear but a question of intelligence. Avoiding him takes away his ability to change the game. Kicking at him does not. The Colts chose the latter option and they paid for it. Only after learning from their mistake did they finally seize control of that game and eventually win. Dungy should consider himself so fortunate the Bears quarterback situation was so bad. He might not have a ring today even somebody even modestly better than Grossman was taking snaps.

In the end, Hester’s big moment was wasted. Chicago let their early lead slip away and fell 29-17. Grossman put the final dagger in the coffin with his pick-six in the second half. Still a crazy story though. Sometimes the inspiration for decisions can come from the unlikeliest of places. Who knew the most exciting first play in Super Bowl history would be born from reading David vs. Goliath?

Raiders Set To Pursue Tom Brady If QB Doesn’t Sign With Pats

It’s Super Bowl Sunday and what would a Super Bowl be without Tom Brady, or in this case, a breaking report about Tom Brady. This time, the news hits close to home as multiple reports have linked the Las Vegas Raiders to the six-time Super Bowl champion and surefire first ballot Hall of Famer.

While the idea has been floated before, never before have the Raiders and Gruden been more linked to Brady, who allegedly purchased a lot of land in The Summit Club, a highly exclusive community in Summerlin outside of Vegas proper. Just weeks ago, it seemed more-than-likely to stick with franchise quarterback Derek Carr but, according to respected NFL reporter Adam Schefter, the Raiders are poised to pursue Brady, fanning flames to the idea that one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever live could be throwing on a silver and black No. 12 jersey in 2020.

This story may have speedy legs too. On this coming Wednesday, $2.9M of Raiders QB Derek Carr’s $18.9M base salary for 2020 becomes fully guaranteed. If a pursuit of Tom Brady materializes in March, the Raiders could quickly clear $16M in cash by moving on from Carr, using that money towards a potential Brady deal.

Brady has been non-committal about his plans but his social media posts all offseason have been scrutinized with a fine tooth comb.

“I’ll explore those opportunities wherever they are,” Brady told Peter King of NBC Sports. “If it’s the Patriots, great. If that doesn’t work, I don’t know. I just don’t know. I love playing football. I still want to play football. I think I still can play at a championship level. I’ve just got to do it. I’m motivated to get back to work and training.”

Other possible suitors for Brady include the Los Angeles Chargers, Chicago Bears, Tennessee Titans and — as some have heavily speculated —  the Indianapolis Colts.

If Brady were to join the Raiders, this would mean Carr would be moved via trade or by contract maneuvering.

Pro Football Talk broke it down:

“Carr, who has a new house in Las Vegas next door to coach Jon Gruden that Brady could buy, has a contract that pays out $18.9 million in 2020 salary. Of that amount, $2.9 million becomes fully guaranteed on the third day of the waiver period, later this week.

But that’s a small price to pay, especially since the offset language in the contract would generate a dollar-for-dollar credit — and if Carr is cut someone else would pay him far more than that. The bigger question is whether Carr would be traded. Given the current quarterback market, $18.9 million becomes a bargain.

The Raiders would take a $5 million cap charge by trading Carr before June 1. As the salary cap busts through the $200 million mark, it’s also a small paper price to pay in order to upgrade from Carr to Brady.”

In other words, this isn’t a difficult transaction, even if some fans may revolt with anger and molotov cocktails. Regardless, the move makes sense for the future. GM Mike Mayock and Gruden look to the draft to find their next franchise quarterback beyond Brady. Brady could play both mentor to the rookie draft pick as well as franchise QB in the team’s first season in Las Vegas.

Originally, the idea seemed far fetched but so did the prospect of signing Antonio Brown until Mayock shocked the world. While that one didn’t work out, Brady is a leader and an extension of the coaching staff while in the huddle. His leadership for Gruden would mean a great deal of football IQ would be calling the shots.

Social media was aflame prior to the Super Bowl talking about the possible marriage between Brady and the Raider Nation.

While the odds seem slim considering the New England Patriots are reportedly willing to offer Brady $30 million, Brady seems to want more — weapons. If the Patriots aren’t willing to spend on weapons, the legendary quarterback seems happy to cut ties and move one.

While fans seem to love Carr, the 28-year-old quarterback has never even played in a postseason game, let alone a Super Bowl. To add to the intrigue, stranger things have happened and Gruden and Mayock (Gru-yock) have been known to make bold moves (see Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper trades).

I, personally, expect Carr under center when the Las Vegas Raiders make their first appearance at Allegiant Stadium this fall but these new reports have really started fanning the flames around Las Vegas’ newest major league sports franchise.

But Tom Brady and Las Vegas together? It seems like a perfect fit and I’m here for it.

So Remember That Derek Carr Bears Idea? Well It Just Got Serious

derek carr

So remember that piece SM did a few days ago about how Derek Carr might be available to the Chicago Bears via trade and that it wouldn’t cost much? If not, here it is for some clarity. Suffice it to say, there was a growing belief that Las Vegas Raiders head coach Jon Gruden was not satisfied with Carr as his starter and wanted to move in a different direction. These were just rumblings at the time but rumblings that had persisted since early 2019.

Even then, there were many who felt it was ridiculous the Raiders would do this. Carr is a three-time Pro Bowl quarterback in his prime. He threw for 4,000 yards and had a 100.8 passer rating this season with a frankly average group of wide receivers. Unfortunately, the 7-9 finish to the season marked by a disappointing performance in Kansas City likely soured him on Gruden even further. Now things have gotten out in the open when Adam Schefter reported the Raiders were preparing a massive push to sign Tom Brady if the future Hall of Famer hits the open market.

Former scout and current columnist for The Athletic San Francisco John Middlekauf made it clear that this is a very real situation and that Carr is fully aware of it. By the sound of things, he’s tired of all the rumors and might be approaching his own desire to go somewhere else.

Derek Carr certainly gets blamed for a lot. Too much?

The entire situation with Carr is fascinating. Here’s a guy who has thrown for 4,000 yards in back-to-back seasons. He’s gone to three Pro Bowls and was an MVP hopeful in 2015. People talk about him not winning enough and yet the Raiders haven’t had a defense rank higher than 20th in points allowed during his entire career. Not to mention the lack of any true star players being put around him in that time. It truly feels like he’s been unfairly scapegoated for the team’s shortcomings.

So where does this leave the Bears? Nothing is certain yet, but it does feel increasingly likely that Carr is gone from the Raiders this offseason. Will they trade him? One would think that’s the goal even though now that teams are aware Gruden wants him gone, it might be difficult with his expensive contract. That said, it’s much more affordable than anything Chicago would’ve had to pay for guys like Philip Rivers, Teddy Bridgewater or Cam Newton.

Carr would be a good fit in Matt Nagy’s offense. He features a big arm and isn’t afraid to throw it down the field. His experience with Gruden has also prepared him well for how to operate in a West Coast-style offense. This is a good quarterback with 18 career 4th quarter comebacks. He can play above average football, which is all this team needs to win football games.

Whether GM Ryan Pace would snap at that bait, thus abandoned Mitch Trubisky? That’s another story.

Revenge Might Have Pushed New CB Tre Roberson to Sign with Bears

tre roberson

Motivations of why a player signs with one team or another are based around several factors. The biggest, for most anyway, is money. Typically the teams who offer the most get the free agents. That was no different for Tre Roberson. Chicago Bears fans learned of his existence a couple of weeks ago when the CFL standout met with the team for a workout. Roberson was coveted by several NFL franchises. Ten of whom, including the Bears, ended up making contract offers.

Chicago ended up getting their guy thanks to $300,000 in guaranteed money according to Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune. However, that might not have been the only reason Roberson went there. He’s a native of Indianapolis who went to Illinois State in college. So it’s familiar territory. Then there is one other factor. The cornerback might see Chicago as a chance to show a former team he’s got the goods to play in this league.

Some players balk at the idea of taking a career detour to Canada, but Roberson embraced the opportunity. He believed he belonged in the NFL from the start of his season out of football, when he spent long days — and nights — driving delivery trucks.

“I was good enough to be in Minnesota,” Roberson said. “I was good enough to make that 53-man roster. I just had to go prove I was worthy of a roster spot.”

Tre Roberson hasn’t forgotten his Vikings experience

Here’s the thing. Roberson signed with the Vikings as an undrafted free agent in 2016. He did enough to make their practice squad that year. However, the next year he was among the final cuts and not even good enough to make the practice squad again, being cast aside in favor of Horace Richardson who has become a journeyman yet to play a single NFL snap. Roberson took that chance to head for Canada where he became a sensation with 10 interceptions in two years and a Grey Cup title.

Now he’s back and playing for one of the Vikings’ biggest rivals. It’s rather poetic in a way. What better way to remind a team of your existence than by making plays to beat them on Sunday? Roberson will have a chance to compete for extended playing time in 2020. The status of veteran corner Prince Amukamara is up in the air and that boundary starting position could be up for grabs. No doubt Roberson isn’t just content with making the roster.

His goal is to play in the NFL.

Hoping Alex Smith Comes to Rescue the Bears? Don’t Count on It

alex smith

Plenty of names have been mentioned as possibilities for the Chicago Bears in regards to the quarterback issue. Names that might be able to come in and both serve as depth and competition for Mitch Trubisky. Obviously, this would limit the number of options they could go for but the list still had some intriguing ones. Perhaps the most interesting is Alex Smith. The four-time Pro Bowler appears to be nearing the end of an arduous process that started back in 2018.

Everybody remembers what happened. In a game against the Houston Texans, a tackle by J.J. Watt and Kareem Jackson led Smith to contort awkwardly to the ground, resulting in a horrific compound leg fracture. One that required immediate evacuation to a hospital and emergency surgery. It got so bad at one point that the leg became infected and septic. Smith admitted to John Keim of ESPN that he came frighteningly close to having it amputated.

Now almost two years removed from playing a snap of football, the quarterback appears close to a possible return. This opens the door for questions. Most important is where will he end up trying to make it. Many Bears fans are hoping the Redskins cut ties with him so Chicago can swoop in. It makes perfect sense on paper. Matt Nagy was offensive coordinator for Smith’s career-best year in 2017. The connection is easy.

However, people might be a little too optimistic in this regard.

Alex Smith remains in high standing with the Redskins

While it’s true Smith hasn’t played football in a long time, the reality is his status in Washington is not nearly as modest as people might think. Keim reports the quarterback has remained close with ownership during the process and he’s also held in high regard by new head coach Ron Rivera.

“The Redskins haven’t ruled out a possible return for Smith, 35, who spent this season watching games in owner Dan Snyder’s box and was often seen with him before and after games.

Smith, who is under contract through the 2022 season, will count $21.4 million against the salary cap in 2020. First-year Redskins coach Ron Rivera has consistently mentioned him when discussing the Redskins’ quarterback situation. Smith also has become a mentor to Dwayne Haskins Jr., who just completed his rookie season.”

While there is no denying his contract is expensive, the Redskins have held onto it this long. Besides, as a team that is in the process of rebuilding their salary cap situation isn’t in any real danger. They can afford to hang onto him with Haskins still playing on his rookie deal. If the former 1st round pick falters this year, having Smith in place would make for a nice safety net.

All of this translates to a clear reality. The odds of him coming to Chicago are low. That means the Bears will have to find their savior elsewhere.

Matt Nagy Gets No Love Among Coaches Players Want to Play For

matt nagy
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS - OCTOBER 20: Head coach Matt Nagy of the Chicago Bears watches the action during the second half against the New Orleans Saints at Soldier Field on October 20, 2019 in Chicago, Illinois. (Photo by Nuccio DiNuzzo/Getty Images)

Matt Nagy supposedly has a reputation for being a players coach. His ability to connect with his players and motivate them is well-documented. Several free agents they signed in 2018 admitted Nagy’s presence was a reason they decided to join the Chicago Bears. Even after the struggles of 2019, almost everybody in the locker room defended Nagy against criticism. They stated without his presence that the season would’ve gone far worse than just 8-8.

That said, it would appear his reputation isn’t quite as ringing around the league as some might think. Greg Auman of The Athletic was at the Pro Bowl last week and talked to several players, asking various questions from who the most underrated names in the league were to the best and worst NFL cities to travel to. Perhaps the most telling was when they were asked which head coach (besides their own) would they love to play for.

Of the 23 anonymous names who gave an answer, not a single one of them mentioned Nagy.

  • Andy Reid, Chiefs (4)
  • Pete Carroll, Seahawks (4)
  • John Harbaugh, Ravens (2)
  • Kyle Shanahan, 49ers (2)
  • Mike Tomlin, Steelers (2)
  • Mike Vrabel, Titans (2)
  • Bill Belichick, Patriots
  • Joe Judge, Giants
  • Kliff Kingsbury, Cardinals
  • Sean McVay, Rams
  • Bill O’Brien, Texans
  • Sean Payton, Saints
  • Frank Reich, Colts
Now one can understand the top half of that list.

Carroll, Harbaugh, Tomlin, Payton, and Belichick have Super Bowl rings. Reid and Shanahan are in the Super Bowl. Vrabel reached the AFC championship, as has Sean McVay. Where it gets interesting is the fact that Kingsbury, Reich, and Judge all got votes instead of Nagy. One coach who had a losing record. One who didn’t make the playoffs just like Nagy this year and one who hasn’t even coached a game yet.

Matt Nagy is about to show who he really is

Head coaches often show who they are less after a winning season and more after a losing one. How do they handle failure? Do they start to press and lose sight of what made them a success or do they embrace change and work hard to get things turned around? This is the test that Nagy is about to take. He goes into 2020 with a lot of people starting to question whether he’s truly up to the task of getting the Bears where they need to go. Was 2018 simply a fluke?

Many coaches in the past failed to meet that challenge, including a number of familiar names like Neill Armstrong, Dave Wannstedt, and Dick Jauron. One winning season is easy. Sustained success is what separates the good coaches. If Nagy wants to raise his star in NFL circles, he’ll have to prove he can do that and he wasn’t just a one-year wonder.