Saturday, November 21, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 2305

Former Bears Still Blame Jim McMahon For Failure To Win More Titles

jim mcmahon
Green Bay Packer Charles Martin (94) checks on Bears quarterback Jim McMahon after slamming him to the ground Sunday, Nov. 23, 1986 at Soldier Field in Chicago. (Edward Wagner/Chicago Tribune/TNS)

While the 1985 Chicago Bears remain one of the most celebrated teams in NFL history, a lot of people lament what could’ve been. How did a roster that featured five eventually Pro Football Hall of Famers only win one Super Bowl? People have tried to find excuses one way or another. Yet it always comes back to the same answer. They were weak at quarterback, and this is because of Jim McMahon.

Make no mistake. The Punky QB was undoubtedly a great leader and talented. He didn’t always throw the prettiest passes but he put the ball where it needed to be. There is no question the Bears don’t win a championship without him in ’85. That said, some players from that team also believe he’s the reason they failed to win another after that.

Dan Pompei of The Athletic conveyed those feelings in a recent article.

Team leaders, especially Hampton, questioned the quarterback’s motivation privately and publicly. “McMahon had essentially become Hitchcock, making cameos every year,” Hampton said recently. “The rest of us were doing the heavy lifting. Nobody felt great, but we played every damn game, every damn down.”…

…“McMahon got hurt the year after the Super Bowl year and was never a factor again,” Hampton said. “Mick Taylor became a rock star not because he was writing all the songs, but because he was one of the Stones. McMahon became a rock star because we had maybe the greatest defense of all time, maybe the greatest running game of all time. I’m not here to diminish his ability. Availability was his problem.”

Jim McMahon was his own worst enemy

McMahon was the toast of the town after that championship win. Unfortunately, it went to his head. Reports surfaced about how out of shape he was when he arrived for training camp in 1986. That inability to take better care of his body ended up leading to loads of soft tissue injuries in addition to other problems brought about by rough hits, clean or dirty. He just seemed so fragile and his reckless playing style didn’t help.

In his final three seasons with the team, he never started more than nine games and had a 76.4 passer rating. The Bears made the playoffs each of those years but were knocked out. Twice by the eventual Super Bowl champions. Every time the primary culprit was bad play at the quarterback position. So yeah, it’s not hard to understand why some of the leaders on that team were bitter about McMahon.

Redskins VP Said Bears Drafted Mitch Trubisky Because He’s White

mitch trubisky

Mitch Trubisky can’t avoid the news these days. Probably his lowest point to date came when the Chicago Bears declined the 5th year option on his rookie contract. A surefire sign that he has failed to meet their expectations up to this point. Meanwhile, Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson, who were taken after him back in 2017, saw their options picked up. Both are expected to secure huge paydays in the near future. Trubisky is left wondering if he’ll even have a job by the end of this year.

This has led to an ongoing question. How in the world did Bears GM Ryan Pace see Trubisky as a better QB than those two? The short answer is he loved the talent and personality. Pace fell in love with Trubisky the person and saw images of Drew Brees when watching him. By the time the draft rolled around, it was pretty much set in stone. There was no going back. The rest is history.

However, is that really it. Author John Feinstein who writes for the Washington Post revealed a conversation he had with Washington Redskins VP Doug Williams about a polarizing topic. Would the Bears have drafted Trubisky if Mahomes and Watson were white? His answer is telling.

Is that true or just revisionist history with Mitch Trubisky?

One must remember that Williams was a black quarterback himself. The first in NFL history to win a Super Bowl. He had to go through so many roadblocks to find success in his career. A lot of it was because of the color of his skin. So it’s only natural he’d take that stance. Is it true though? Many Bears fans have raised the question about whether the McCaskey family might harbor some racist tendencies. This due in large part to them never pushing hard to draft black quarterbacks.

The modern era has seen the team employ just three African-Americans at that position. Vince Evans in the 1980s, Kordell Stewart in the early 2000s, and Jason Campbell in 2012. Whenever they had big opportunities to draft prominent black QBs like Daunte Culpepper, Teddy Bridgewater, Mahomes, or Watson they’ve decided to pass. Hence the conspiracy theories that the organization is run by racists.

Of course, there is zero hard evidence to back this up. The most likely truth is the Bears grew blinded by what Trubisky could be versus what he was. Plenty of draft experts made that same mistake. It’s easy to play armchair GM after the fact. Pace undoubtedly blundered in a big way, but the odds of skin color playing any part in it are remote.

Bears Had Reportedly Been Hunting Tashaun Gipson For Over a Year

tashaun gipson

The Chicago Bears caught a lot of people by surprise when they came to terms with veteran safety Tashaun Gipson last week. Not so much because of the player he is but more because of the timing. It took place so quickly after the NFL draft. One had to surmise it had been in the works for some time. Gipson was surprisingly cut after just one year with the Houston Texans on April 27th. Just four days later on May 1st, he was a Bear.

It turns out this wasn’t an accident. Apparently GM Ryan Pace, his scouts, and the coaching staff have had eyes for Gipson longer than people realized. During his first conference call with the Bears media after officially inking his deal, the 30-year old revealed the team had actually expressed interest in him as far back as the spring of 2019.

Unsurprisingly, he took a solid three-year deal from Houston for $22.5 million on March 12th when free agency got started. Two days later, the Bears signed Ha Ha Clinton-Dix to his one-year deal. So it would appear Gipson may have been the guy they wanted but the money didn’t work out. This time it did.

Tashaun Gipson was lured to Chicago by Buster Skrine

One man that Gipson credited for recruiting him to the Bears was starting slot cornerback Buster Skrine. The two were teammates with the Cleveland Browns where they played defense and special teams together. They have a tight relationship. Getting to play with Eddie Jackson was also an obvious bonus. As to who might’ve spearheaded the push to sign him last year? It’s possible defensive coordinator Chuck Pagano and secondary coach Deshea Townsend had hands in that.

Pagano was a defensive backs coach in Cleveland for several years in the 2000s and also worked for the Baltimore Ravens. Townsend was a starting defensive back for the Pittsburgh Steelers most of his career. Both have strong ties to the AFC North. So they likely heard a lot about Gipson when he was a top free safety for the Browns. Pagano also went against him for two seasons as head coach in Indianapolis when he’d signed with Jacksonville.

So there is definite familiarity involved with this move.

2021 #1 APB Announces His Commitment

Notre Dame recruiting took a hit today with the loss of five star Clemson commit Will Shipley.

 

Shipley was highly recruiting by the Irish and has been compared by experts to Christian McCaffery. The logical mind would lead you to believe that if you want to be like CMC, playing for his college RB coach would be a great place to start.

Apparently not. Run Game Coordinator Lance Taylor, McCaffery’s old college coach, may have been the only reason the Irish were even considered this deep into the commitment.

It was believed that the Irish would have been next on his list.

Typically this would sting a little more, but given what is going on in the world today, being close to home proved to be very important to Shipley. And let’s be honest, Clemson is a premier program in College Football.

Revenge Tour

The Irish will get at least two shots at Clemson over the next two seasons. One of them is scheduled to occur in November 2020, while the other is slated for 2021 – Shipley’s freshmen year.

Keep Calm

The Irish will have a strong backfield heading into the future, so let’s try not to get too discouraged. Shipley backing off perhaps shows that Chris Tyree, once a five star APB, is too much competition for another five star back. 

Stay tuned for the latest reaction on the Golden Domers Podcast

Analytics Expert Predicts a Rough Chicago Bears 2020 Season

chicago bears
Chicago Bears' Danny Trevathan (59) and Eddie Goldman (91) celebrate a fumble by Minnesota Vikings quarterback Kirk Cousins and Bears recovery during the second half of an NFL football game Sunday, Sept. 29, 2019, in Chicago. (AP Photo/Matt Marton)

GM Ryan Pace did a ton of work this offseason. Everything within his power to make the Chicago Bears better than the team that finished 2019. No doubt this was the case since failure to win in 2020 could end up costing him his job. What everybody wants to know is was it enough? The NFL schedule is set to come out on May 7th. Chicago will know what exactly they’re up against at that point. However, some people don’t need to wait that long.

Mike Clay is an analyst for ESPN known for his expertise in numbers. He ran full projections for the upcoming season, determining the likely final records of every team, who makes the playoffs, and who are picking high in the 2021 draft. His assessment of the NFC North? A dogfight. Minnesota was predicted to squeak out the title with a 9-7, barely edging out the Packers. The big shocker though was he had the Bears finishing last in the division at 6-10.

Based on this assessment, it’s clear Clay has no faith in the Bears offense. They’re projected to score 309 points, which averages out to 19.31 per game. While that would be an improvement on last season, it won’t be enough to support a defense that Clay thinks will still be good but not great.

Chicago Bears just seem too talented to finish that poorly

What’s frustrating about this is the projections don’t provide any details. He doesn’t back up his numbers with an explanation. The truth is it’s hard to imagine this Bears team being 6-10 bad. There is just too much talent on the roster to accept that. Khalil Mack, Eddie Jackson, and Kyle Fuller remain in place on defense. Roquan Smith, Danny Trevathan, and Akiem Hicks will all be healthy. They’ll be joined by Robert Quinn who had 11.5 sacks last season. One could argue this defense looks better on paper than the one from last year.

Offensively? One can understand a certain degree of skepticism. Still, they added Nick Foles at quarterback. While not having the most consistent NFL career, the 31-year old has a history of playing some really strong football. Especially in this type of offensive system under Matt Nagy. Pace also upgraded the tight end position with Jimmy Graham and Cole Kmet. An area that severely hampered the team in 2019. Last but not least, rookie Darnell Mooney and veteran Ted Ginn Jr. add much-needed speed at wide receiver.

Nobody is saying this offense will suddenly set the world on fire, but it should be better. Enough to crack the playoffs? Sure, if the roster can stay healthy but 8-8 feels like their floor.

The New, Insane Story of Why The Bears Passed on Joe Montana

joe montana

Few teams have a longer track record of missing out on great quarterbacks than the Chicago Bears. Most remember their appalling decision to pass on Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson. There was also passing on Aaron Rodgers in 2005. They didn’t sign Kurt Warner that same year because they didn’t want to let him compete with Rex Grossman. They bypassed Daunte Culpepper for Cade McNown in 1999. The list goes on. Yet no decision probably haunts the franchise to this day more than passing on Joe Montana in 1979.

Now some people will argue that a lot of teams passed on Montana. He didn’t go until the 3rd round of that draft. Those people don’t know the backstory. The Bears had eyes on the Notre Dame standout for over a month as the draft approached. They felt he was the only option worth where they were picking at #66. Sure enough, Montana fell to them. It got so close to where they literally had his name written out on the card. All they had to do was turn it in according to Dan Pompei of The Athletic.

Then GM Jim Finks committed his greatest career blunder.

Bob Avellini had taken the Bears to the playoffs two years before. Finks thought Vince Evans had potential. And the general manager had not given up on Mike Phipps, for whom he had traded a first-round pick. “We would be muddying the waters with another quarterback,” Finks told the others.

Then Finks expressed concern about the depth at running back behind Walter Payton. “Who’s the best running back left?” he asked. Their highest-rated remaining back was Willie McClendon from Georgia.

After some deliberation, Finks announced the Bears were taking McClendon. “Bill Tobin almost had apoplexy,” McGrane said before his death in 2015. “He was beside himself, sick he didn’t get Montana.”

Finks became a Hall of Famer, but it was not a Hall of Fame moment.

“Finks liked Montana, but he was human, too,” said McGrane, who also worked with Finks in Minnesota. “Finks would make picks out of his back pocket sometimes. He’d call it a hunch play.”

Joe Montana wasn’t a Bear because of a hunch

This is a cold reminder of how inexact and human the NFL draft truly is. Hindsight tells us that Montana was the obvious pick. The Bears cost themselves more Super Bowls in the 1980s for not making it. He ended up going to San Francisco and defeated Chicago in the NFC championship game twice. First in 1984 and again in 1988. How different would it have been had he sat on the opposite sideline?

He’d have played with an all-time great running back in Walter Payton and been able to lean on an all-time great defense. Yet because Finks had muddied the waters so much with other bad QB decisions, his psyched himself out to where he didn’t want to do it anymore. He felt the Bears had “enough” quarterbacks already. Just like many experts felt they had “enough” tight ends when Ryan Pace drafted Cole Kmet.

Insider Says Packers Will Trade Aaron Rodgers After 2020 Season

aaron rodgers

It seems like every offseason for some time now the Green Bay Packers and quarterback Aaron Rodgers are embroiled in some sort of dispute. That took a major step forward last month. GM Brian Gutekunst heralded the beginning of the doomsday clock for Rodgers when he traded up in the 1st round to select Utah State quarterback Jordan Love. Anybody with common sense could tell this was a clear power play meant to send a message.

Gutekunst is tired of beholding himself to the future Hall of Famer and wants to carve out his own legacy. He insists this move was only about protecting the future of the Packers organization. A lot of people aren’t buying that. Insider Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk is one of them. He spoke to David Kaplan of SportsTalk Live about it and made it clear he thinks 2020 could be Rodgers’ swan song in Green Bay.

“For a team that was a step away from the Super Bowl, this does nothing to help the Aaron Rodgers Packers get any better. I think that when you combine that with the fact they didn’t draft a single receiver in one of the deepest receiver drafts we’ve ever seen, it sets the stage for awkwardness, acrimony and I think potentially a divorce after the 2020 season.”

“I think, right now, if I had to pick one or the other. I’d say after this season they’re gonna end up trading him.”

With Aaron Rodgers, it’s best to follow the money

Contracts help dictate what is likely to happen here. The Packers have put themselves on a timeline by drafting Love. Typically teams want to do all they can to exploit a young quarterback while still on his cheap rookie contract. See Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs for an example. This is because it’s difficult to build a roster through free agency or trades once that quarterback reaches his second contract.

The longer the Packers wait on Love, the less time they’ll have to take advantage of his rookie deal. If they wait until 2022 for example, that would leave them just two seasons of cheap play before they’re forced to decide whether to use his 5th-year option, which gets expensive. Not a lot of time to evaluate whether he is truly “the guy” they’re hoping he is. This is likely why Florio expects a breakup with Rodgers to happen after 2020.

It would give Green Bay three years to evaluate Love and likely net a strong return via trade while the Hall of Famer is still not too old. That would be the plan anyway. Odds are the Packers would aim for a post-June 1st deal. One that would clear up $22 million in cap space rather than less than $5 million otherwise.

Patrick Kane Thinks This Former Teammate Would Be A Good Front Office Fit

Kane spoke highly of the three-time Stanley Cup champion during an interview with NBC Sports Chicago.

Former Chicago Blackhawks forward Patrick Sharp has flourished in his first two years as a broadcaster for NBC Sports since officially retiring from the NHL after the 2017-18 season. The former All-Star Game MVP and Most Beautiful Chicagoans’ Cover Boy has smoothly transitioned into one of the top television analysts in hockey. What can’t this guy do?

Well, according to Blackhawks superstar and former teammate Patrick Kane, Sharp has the proficiency to succeed in a front-office role as well. Kane talked about Sharp and his potential as a scout or advisor with NBC Sports Chicago back in January.

“I don’t know if we really expected him to [become a broadcaster] to be honest with you,” Kane said. “I thought maybe he’d be trying to get in with the team somewhere whether it was scouting or trying to get into the front office. I could see him doing that even to this day. Maybe that’s a stepping stone for him maybe in the future. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him in the front office at some point because I think he’s pretty good at scouting players and knowing a lot about the league too.”

Sharp hasn’t made any comments to suggest that he wants to leave NBC Sports, but after John McDonough, Blackhawks team president was fired on Apr. 27, there have been rumors swirling around about the possibility of yet another reunion.

If Sharp were to take on a front-office role with the Blackhawks, he would join former teammates Colin Fraser (amateur scout), Brian Campbell (development coach), Sheldon Brookbank (assistant coach), and Chris Kunitz (player development advisor) in the organization.

For more Blackhawks news and updates, follow the author (@JackBushman2) on Twitter. Make sure to check out the author’s podcast, Talkin’ Hawkey, which can be found on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Twitter (@TalkinHawkey).

Are The Chicago Bears Quietly Courting Peyton Manning?

peyton manning

It seems conspiracy theories are a popular topic these days, be it in politics or sports. With free agency and the draft in the rearview mirror, there is time to stop and examine the Chicago Bears situation. One topic that seems to come up a lot is the future of GM Ryan Pace. Could 2020 be his last stand? Most seem to think unless the Bears deliver a winning season, that is the case. Hence why speculation is ongoing on who possible replacements could be. One name that isn’t discussed but should be? Peyton Manning.

The wider NFL views the Hall of Fame quarterback as the white whale. Somebody teams desperately want to lead their organization. It’s not hard to understand why. Manning has one of the best football minds ever witnessed. He’d bring instant credibility to a franchise and would likely do whatever it took to create a winner. Kalyn Kahler of Bleacher Report just did an excellent close-up on the retired QB.

Many seem to think it’s only a matter of time before he is running his own team.

Three sources who have spent time with Manning say that what he really wants to do is run a team with an ownership stake. Call it the Michael Jordan model.

“I could see him running an organization,” former NFL head coach and three-time Super Bowl champion Mike Shanahan says. “He is so on top of every area because he has been working at it his whole life.”…

…While Manning says making the shift into a front office is “just not something that I have moved on yet,” multiple sources interviewed for this story agree his ultra-competitive nature will probably make him more likely to run a team than become a broadcaster.

So what does Peyton Manning have to do with the Bears?

Now there is no hard evidence to support the idea that Bears ownership is biding their time for a chance to nab Manning. However, there have been certain indications over the past few years that makes one wonder if the McCaskey family are among those most interested in reeling him in somehow.

Manning visited the Bears facility multiple times after he retired. He attended practices in both 2016 and 2017. He did an outstanding episode of Peyton’s Place for ESPN+ where he was baptized as an official Bears fan. Where it really gets interesting is his connection to the franchise’s legacy.

One thing Manning has a clear appreciation for is football history. That’s not a surprise given his father Archie was a star quarterback in his era of the 1970s. What many may not know is Archie Manning had a relationship with legendary Bears running back Walter Payton. The two worked together in Jackson, Mississippi.

The future icon always jokes the Mannings named Peyton after him.

There’s even a story where Payton basically kidnapped a four-year-old Manning at the 1979 Pro Bowl. They spent an hour together having fun at the beach while Archie nervously searched for his son. Is it so hard to think that the young Manning might’ve developed a love for the Bears thanks to experiences like that?

There are other interesting comments. During an interview with Bears matriarch Virginia McCaskey, Manning lamented how he felt Chicago was where the quarterback position was truly born.

“In a lot of ways, this is kind of where my position sort of was born, right here. The quarterback position with [Sid] Luckman and the T-formation… Halas got that started.”

Clearly the franchise holds a sentimental place in his heart.

Then there is the last key to all of this. Age. Virginia is 97-years old. Her time is running short. Also is the situation with team president Ted Phillips. He is set to turn 63 in June this year. He’s held his title since way back in 1999. While the McCaskeys have remained loyal to him, they might feel the time is approaching for a change. Manning, who is 44-years old and a far more proven football mind, would be the ideal heir apparent.

Virginia could rest easy knowing her father’s beloved franchise would be left in the most capable of hands. Manning would get the complete autonomy he’s likely seeking. It makes sense on a number of levels.

Obviously this is all speculation. Still, it’s hard not to see such a strange sequence of events over the years and not at least wonder.

Former Player Details Why Cole Kmet and Bears Are a Perfect Match

cole kmet

The Chicago Bears offense was not good last season. It wasn’t even mediocre. They were 25th in passing, 27th in rushing, and 29th in scoring. The fast the team finished 8-8 is a testament to how great their defense was. GM Ryan Pace and head coach Matt Nagy believe they have a good enough team to make a deep playoff run. They just had to make some tweaks to perform better offensively. One area deemed vital to this was the tight end position. That is why they signed Jimmy Graham and why they drafted Cole Kmet.

Both decisions were ridiculed. Graham because the Bears overpaid for him. Kmet because the team already had nine tight ends on the roster. What was the point of another? Matt Bowen of ESPN understood the decision. The former safety is widely respected as one of the best tape analysts in the business today. He feels Kmet couldn’t have gone to a better situation than Chicago.

“The Bears added veteran Jimmy Graham in free agency, but Kmet gives Matt Nagy’s offense a true inline tight end with the pass-catching skills to fit in his system. In addition to giving Chicago an extra gap in the run game as a blocker, Kmet can stretch the seams, run crossers/pops off play-action and RPOs, while also seeing the ball on inside sit routes to move the chains.

With a 6-foot-6, 262-pound frame and 4.7 40 speed, Kmet can rumble after the catch. I like what I see on tape there. The Bears already had an overcrowded tight end room, but I see Kmet as an instant contributor as a rookie because of his pro-style traits. They didn’t have a single tight end gain 100 yards last season, but that’s going to change in 2020.”

Cole Kmet is in a system made for tight ends

The Bears really wanted to run a lot of “12” personnel in 2019. That is an offensive alignment that features two tight ends, a running back, and two wide receivers. This formation can create a lot of options both in the running and passing games. However, as the season went on they started to do it less and less because they just didn’t have the horses at tight end to make it work. Trey Burton and Adam Shaheen were both injured. Nobody else could step up.

That’s unfortunate because this offense is made to feature the tight end position. Just look at Philadelphia and Kansas City as shining examples. They run similar schemes. Travis Kelce and Zach Ertz are among the most productive at their position in the NFL. This is where the Bears are trying to get. By drafting Kmet, it’s believed they took a step in that direction. Throw in Nick Foles, who loves using tight ends based on track record and it’s understandable why Bowen has high expectations for the rookie.