Friday, November 20, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.
Home Blog Page 1121

Top Insider Drops Bombshell On Chicago Bears Coaching Situation

jim harbaugh
Ohio State coach Ryan Day shakes hands with Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh after their game in xxxxx.

The Chicago Bears found a way to reach 4-8 on Monday night despite some ugly football on the field. It’s never a great sign when your defense forces four turnovers and your offense only musters 12 points. Nothing about that game shifted the conversation on either quarterback Justin Fields or head coach Matt Eberflus. Fields committed two brutal 4th quarter turnovers that would’ve cost them the game if not for Minnesota having their backup quarterback on the field. Eberflus didn’t look much better.

His defense played really well, but it again failed to hold a lead in the 4th quarter. In-game decision-making still seemed too conservative. It felt like he’d learned nothing from the disaster in Detroit the week before. So, while the team celebrated a victory, there is no sense that it was a turning point for Eberflus. His job still appears to be in jeopardy. NFL insider Dianna Russini of The Athletic hammered that home to Colin Cowherd when she revealed she’s been hearing the Bears are having conversations about Jim Harbaugh.

This is the first legitimate rumor connecting Harbaugh and the Chicago Bears.

Before now, there has always been smoke, but most of it came from speculation. Harbaugh covets the Bears job because Mike Ditka was a mentor. He played quarterback in Chicago. It’s a dream position for him. However, since 2015, the Bears have had three opportunities to interview Harbaugh when their head coaching job became available. They passed every time. Why is this time different? Two words.

Kevin Warren.

The new Chicago Bears team president left the job of Big Ten commissioner to take over the franchise. He spent three years running the conference that Harbaugh’s Michigan team calls home. The two were in constant contact over that period and likely have a relationship of some degree. Warren knows the type of person and coach he is. If the Bears are having conversations about Harbaugh, it is likely being broached by the president himself. Whether it leads to anything is uncertain.

Harbaugh is focused on trying to win a national championship. Most believe he’ll leave the program after this season and return to the NFL. Chicago feels like a team that might be a head coach away from playoff contention.

The White Sox Need To Give Braden Shewmake Significant Time At Shortstop This Year

May 5, 2023; Atlanta, Georgia, USA; Atlanta Braves shortstop Braden Shewmake (24) in the field against the Baltimore Orioles in the second inning at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports

The White Sox made a very interesting trade with the Braves about two weeks ago. The White Sox received some interesting high-upside pitchers, as well as Nicky Lopez. But someone who is not getting a lot of attention in this deal is shortstop Braden Shewmake.

Shewmake was a first-round pick in the 2019 draft by Atlanta. They selected him 21st overall out of Texas A&M. In three years at A&M, Shewmake showed off his potential hitting .323 with 22 home runs and an impressive 161 RBIs. He added 32 stolen bases in that timeframe as well. This plus his sure glove at shortstop earned him his first-round selection.

Since then Shewmake has not wowed anyone in the minors, but he has been a very solid contributor. Overall, he has hit .250 with 38 home runs, and 174 RBIs over 346 minor league games. He has also added 53 stolen bases in that same timeframe. While these aren’t world-beating numbers, this shows a glimpse of his potential in the major leagues.

The best tool with Shewmake is his glove. According to MLB, he is one of the better defensive shortstops in all of the minor leagues. Defense is something that new GM Chris Getz has been prioritizing in his free-agent moves, so look no further than Shewmake.

At this point, the options for shortstop are bleak. Paul DeJong used to be good, but now he is more of just a fielder with power potential. He is not going to be a long-term answer at shortstop. Nicky Lopez is a glove-first utility player with little upside at the plate. These aren’t bad players to have on your team, but they should be regulated to more of a utility role for their limited bats.

Shewmake on the other hand has only had four major league at-bats. He is still a question mark as to what he can provide in the major leagues, so why not give him an opportunity to play every single day?

This season is likely to be one to forget for the Chicago White Sox. They are cutting payroll and they are trading their best players away. Why not let the younger guys play? Last year in AAA, Shwemake hit 16 home runs and drove in 70 runs. These are pretty solid numbers, so why not see if they can translate to the pros? He also added 27 stolen bases, which is desperately needed for a slower White Sox team.

I’m not sure what the plan for Shewmake is, but he should at least be given an opportunity to play every day. Worst case scenario, you find out now that he can’t play and you know to move on. Best case, you find out that he can be a solid contributor on a major league roster and now you have another solid player to work with. He clearly has the most upside out of guys like DeJong and Lopez, and at this point, Lenyn Sosa seems to fit in at second base, if anywhere at all.

This is a perfect opportunity for the Sox to find out what they have in their younger players with little to no pressure. See what these guys can do, and if they can’t play, at least you know before you try to compete.

Eddie Jackson Says Too Many People Sleep On Bears Rookie

eddie jackson

The Chicago Bears defense has made a remarkable turnaround since they bottomed out last season, ranking dead last in most categories. While the unit is far from perfect this year, they are significantly better in several areas. They’re 9th in total yards allowed and boast the #1 run defense in the league. They’ve also forced 17 takeaways, including eight in their last two games. Eddie Jackson is thrilled to be part of the resurgence, but much of the credit has to go with several of the young guys GM Ryan Poles brought in.

Gervon Dexter is rapidly becoming a force at defensive tackle. T.J. Edwards looks like a Pro Bowler at linebacker. Kyler Gordon, Jaquan Brisker, and Tyrique Stevenson have all had interceptions in the past two games. The unit is flying all over the field, making plays, delivering hits, and swarming to the ball. However, Jackson believes certain other players aren’t getting enough credit for their contributions. One of them is rookie cornerback Terell Smith, whom he told Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune has a chance to be something special.

“From Day 1, when he stepped out, this guy, he’s kind of special,” free safety Eddie Jackson said of Smith. “You see plays he can make. And it’s just unfortunate because during training camp he got hurt and then he came back and ended up getting sick. Wrong time for that. But he’s a special kid. Smitty is a quiet dude, but he’s very talented.”

Eddie Jackson is right about Smith.

If you’re looking for flashy numbers, you’ll be disappointed. In this case, one must dig a bit deeper to see the value. Opposing quarterbacks have targeted him 25 times this season. He’s allowed only 16 catches for 160 yards, no touchdowns, and two pass deflections for a modest 82.1 passer rating. He also had a big forced fumble in Washington that helped the Bears secure a win. Smith has missed only two tackles while making 10 stops for little or no gain at the line of scrimmage. The 5th round pick out of Minnesota plays far above his draft slot.

It is easy to see why Eddie Jackson and others are so excited. Stevenson is already a starter and playing well for the Bears. If Smith keeps this up, GM Ryan Poles may have nabbed two starting-caliber cornerbacks in the same draft. That is a tremendous stroke of good evaluation and good fortune. It means, presuming the Bears can retain Jaylon Johnson, that they will be one of the deeper cornerback units in the NFL. Few things are more valuable to a defense than that.

White Sox Free Agent Target: Victor Caratini

Sep 21, 2023; St. Louis, Missouri, USA; Milwaukee Brewers catcher Victor Caratini (7) hits a three run home run against the St. Louis Cardinals during the sixth inning at Busch Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports

With free agency in full swing, we look at potential targets of the White Sox in free agency. They have plenty of needs that will need to be filled at some point this offseason, with one of the biggest being the catcher position. They only have two under contract, that being Korey Lee and Carlos Perez. Neither of them have much major league experience.

If the White Sox are serious about developing their young pitching, which they will have plenty of in 2024, they will need an experienced catcher who knows how to handle a pitching staff. In comes Victor Caratini, who is very familiar with the city of Chicago.

Caratini played for the Cubs from 2017 to 2020 before being shipped to San Diego in the Yu Darvish trade, as Darvish liked having Caratini catch for him. He would play for San Diego for just one year before making his way to Milwaukee, where he played the last two years.

Now 30 years old, Caratini finds himself as a free agent and could be a valuable addition to the Chicago White Sox who are in dire need of a veteran catcher not named Yasmani Grandal.

Caratini would be a nice fit. He is one of the better pitch framers in the league, as Baseball Savant grades him out in the 89th percentile, which is very high. He is a bit below average in terms of blocking and throwing runners out, but his framing can be a very valuable asset to the young pitching staff the White Sox will have. Korey Lee happens to have a great pop time, so he can make up for it when he is catching, as if the Sox sign Caratini it is likely they would split time.

The best part about Caratini is that he is a lot better with the bat than most of the other catchers the Sox could sign in free agency. While some of the other defensive first catchers may make a bit more sense, Caratini is not a significant liability at the plate.

Last year, Caratini hit .259 with seven home runs and 25 RBIs. These would be pretty solid stats out of your backup catcher. This move would not move the needle for the White Sox, but it sure would help the pitching staff and create some completion behind the plate, which they desperately need.

Caratini would add a nice switch-hitting bat to the lineup and a veteran presence to the locker room that the Sox will definitely need this upcoming season. He also is above league average in chase, strikeout, and whiff percentage, which would benefit a White Sox lineup that tends to strike out a lot. Baseball Savant also shows he is well above average in exit velocity and hard-hit percentage, which could be beneficial in the White Sox’s smaller park. According to Baseball Savant, in his career, he would have about five more home runs if every game was played at Guaranteed Rate, which would be the second most out of any other stadium.

Caratini would be a nice veteran presence who is a very good pitch framer. The White Sox should definitely kick the tires on him on a one-year bargain deal.

MLB.com Writer’s Bold Trade Prediction Sends Luis Robert Jr. To The Cubs

Aug 15, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox center fielder Luis Robert Jr. (88) watches his solo home run against the Chicago Cubs during the seventh inning at Wrigley Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

White Sox general manager Chris Getz has said on multiple occasions that nobody on the roster is untouchable. 

But many have assumed that excludes Luis Robert Jr, who is coming off a career year in which he was named to his first All-Star team, took home a Silver Slugger Award and was a Gold Glove finalist. Robert figures to be the face of the franchise that the White Sox built around as they try and climb back toward contention. 

However, MLB.com’s Anthony Castrovince laid out an interesting trade scenario that would send Robert to the North Side of town in a massive four-player package.

The Cubs have a wealth of young talent in their farm system and have not been shy about being aggressive this offseason. They already signed, arguably the best manager in the game in Craig Counsell and are rumored to be in the Shohei Ohtani sweepstakes, as well as being a potential trade partner with the Padres for Juan Soto. 

During a recent appearance on the White Sox Talk Podcast with Chuck Garfein, Castrovince discussed some bold White Sox trade predictions. His boldest prediction was a trade that sent Robert to the Cubs in exchange for Pete Crow-Armstrong, Cade Horton and two “lower-level pieces”. 

Castrovince explained his reasoning for the bold trade prediction. 

“There’s a team across town, that has Cody Bellinger as a free agent and Cody Bellinger is the darling of free agency which from a position player standpoint, not named Ohtani, and that should tell you everything you need to know about the position player market not named Ohtani and should the Cubs lose Cody Bellinger should he get 200 plus million plus from some team, you know silly enough to give Cody Bellinger that kind of money now all of a sudden you’ve got a need on the North Side and a very thin free agent market with which to fill it in,” Castrovice said. 

“So I would propose the Cubs of sending, I don’t have this completely nailed down, but a four I’m thinking a four-player package fronted by Pete Crow-Armstrong and Cade Horton, the Cubs number one and number two prospects. Pete Crow Armstrong debuted in 2023. Very well regarded, especially defensively gifted outfielder. And Cade Horton, a really nice pitching piece drafted seventh overall in the 2022 draft. I’m thinking two other lower-level pieces beyond that, but those are you know, the centerpieces of the deal from the White Sox perspective.” 

Regardless of who the two lower-level pieces are Horton and Crow-Armstrong would be a massive return to build around for the White Sox. Horton is regarded as the best pitching prospect in the Cubs farm system while Crow-Armstrong has already proved to be an elite defender in center field at the big league level. However, considering Robert is under team control until 2027 the Cubs would likely have to throw in some extra sweeteners for a deal to get done. A lot would depend on who those other two pieces are that Castrovince alluded to.

For a player of Robert’s caliber, this would not be a terrible idea for either team. The Cubs are looking to contend while the White Sox are tearing things back down to the studs. While it is unlikely that Robert would get moved this offseason, Getz would certainly have to consider a trade package like that if the Cubs were willing to part with their two top prospects.

Bears’ Stance On Justin Fields Reportedly Hasn’t Improved. Here’s Why

justin fields
Nov 27, 2023; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Chicago Bears quarterback Justin Fields (1) scrambles against the Minnesota Vikings safety Theo Jackson (25) in the third quarter at U.S. Bank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Brad Rempel-USA TODAY Sports

One thing the Chicago Bears promised this past off-season was they’d give Justin Fields a fair shot to secure the starting quarterback job long-term. However, there were conditions. They needed to see more consistency, better situational awareness, and a legitimate effort to better protect himself from unnecessary hits and sacks. They’ve kept their word, allowing Fields to start every game without any hint of making a change despite backup Tyson Bagent going 2-2 while he was injured.

Over the past five games, Fields seems to have improved. He’s thrown nine touchdowns to only two interceptions while rushing for 291 yards. If not for a pair of brutal 4th quarter collapses by the defense, he might’ve gone 4-1 in those games. Many fans and some in the media believe Fields has done enough to earn another year as the starter, even if the Bears end up with the #1 overall pick. Unfortunately, what matters is the opinions of the people at Halas Hall. According to Jeff Hughes of Da Bears Blog, they still aren’t convinced.

Much of it concerns his ongoing rollercoaster process in the pocket.

“Is the quarterback’s tenure in Chicago officially over? If the season ended Monday night, that answer would surely be yes; the lack of week-to-week consistency would not prohibit the Bears from using one of their high draft picks on a quarterback prospect. Fields has ability; he is a brilliant runner capable of making dynamic plays off-script. But if you listened to Troy Aikman on Monday night, you heard an analyst incredibly skeptical of Fields’ ability to play the position from the pocket. Folks in the building share that skepticism.”

Justin Fields has improved, but not enough.

That may sound unfair, but it’s the harsh reality of the situation. His passer rating is slightly better than last year (92.3) but still below the league average. He’s still averaging less than 200 yards passing per game (198.4). His threat as a runner has also lost a lot of its heat. His average is down by 16.2 yards per game compared to last year, and he’s only scored one touchdown. Fields had eight in 2022. All of this comes despite considerable upgrades to his supporting cast with a bolstered offensive line and a legitimate star wide receiver in D.J. Moore.

His 3.13 seconds of Time To Throw is the highest in the NFL, which means he’s still holding the ball too long. None of this even accounts for his ghastly eight 4th quarter turnovers this year. Nobody disputes Justin Fields is a tremendous physical talent. He is resilient and a respected locker room leader. The harsh truth is all of that isn’t enough. He still doesn’t function at a high enough level where it matters most for an NFL quarterback. If you want to win big games in this league, you have to win from the pocket at some point.

Fields can do it once in a while, but not nearly enough. Five games remain. He is running out of time to make a true statement.

White Sox DFA Former First Round Pick 

May 17, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox right fielder Adam Haseley (51) scores against the Cleveland Guardians during the sixth inning at Guaranteed Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-USA TODAY Sports

On Tuesday the White Sox announced that they had designated outfielder Adam Haseley for assignment to make room on the 40-man roster for Paul DeJong. 

Haseley played in 28 games for the White Sox last season hitting .222/.282/.278 with no home runs and two RBIs in 38 at-bats. The 27-year-old played all three outfield positions during his time with the White Sox and posted solid defensive numbers. His Defensive Runs Saved (11), Ultimate Zone Rating (3.6), and Outs Above Average (1) all graded above league average according to Baseball Savant. 

The bulk of his 2023 season was spent in Triple-A Charlotte where he slashed .264/.338/.386.  Haseley was out of minor league options and was likely going to be DFA’d anyway if he did not make the White Sox Opening Day roster. 

The Phillies selected Haseley with the No. 8 overall pick in the 2017 First-Year Player Draft. He made his professional debut with the Gulf Coast League Phillies and was named Philideplhia’s No. 5 minor league prospect by Baseball America at the end of the year. 

In 2018 he was named Philadephlia’s Minor League Hitting Prospect of the Year by MLB Pipeline after batting .305/.361/.434 with 11 home runs, 55 RBIs, 77 runs scored, and 33 extra-base hits. He earned his first crack in the big leagues the following season playing in 67 games over three separate stints. He hit the only five home runs of his MLB career that season. 

In 2020 he made his first Opening Day start with the Phillies playing in 24 games. He hit .278 with a .690 OPS but a left wrist sprain landed him on the ten-day IL. Haseley was once again named the Opening Day center fielder in 2021 but struggled to find a rhythm offensively. He slashed just .190/.190/.238 in April before getting sent down to Triple-A where he spent the remainder of the season. 

The White Sox acquired him in exchange for right-handed pitcher McKinely Moore. At the time of the trade, Rick Hahn was hoping to find another left-handed bat who could also serve as a fourth outfielder. It was a low-risk roll of the dice considering his draft pedigree. 

Haseley began the 2022 season in Triple-A Charlotte but was recalled as the 29th player for a doubleheader on April 20th in Cleveland. Tony La Russa called on him to be a defensive replacement in Game 1 and then started him in center field during Game 2 where he went 0-3 in his first at-bats in a White Sox uniform. 

He proceeded to bounce around between Charlotte and the big league club, making three separate occasions but only played in 14 games with the White Sox. That season he ranked second on Charlotte Knights leaders in triples (4) and stolen bases (18) and finished third on the team in doubles (19), RBIs (63) runs scored (59), and home runs (15). 

Since he has been DFA’d, Haseley will now either be traded or run through outright waivers. Haseley cleared waivers last offseason which means there is likely going to be little to no trade market for him. If he is not traded and then goes unclaimed he will have the option to elect free agency.

Ryan Poles Draft Pick Named One Of NFL’s Top Young Players

ryan poles
Oct 29, 2023; Inglewood, California, USA; Chicago Bears offensive tackle Darnell Wright (58) blocks against Los Angeles Chargers linebacker Tuli Tuipulotu (45) during the fourth quarter at SoFi Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jonathan Hui-USA TODAY Sports

The Chicago Bears can’t hope to get back into the thick of NFL contention until they start drafting well again. It has been a persistent issue for the past decade as guys like Jerry Angelo, Phil Emery, and Ryan Pace routinely failed to put strong classes together. It is hoped that GM Ryan Poles might be able to reverse the trend. Recent signs indicate that could be the case. Several of his recent additions were big contributors to the Bears’ latest win in Minnesota over the Vikings. Jaquan Brisker and Kyler Gordon had interceptions. Roschon Johnson was an offensive focal point.

Trade additions D.J. Moore and Montez Sweat were studs all night as well. However, the name that has caught the attention of Matt Bowen and others at ESPN was different. They put together a list of the top 44 players in the NFL under the age of 24. Players they believe represent the future of the league. To them, the name to watch in Chicago is Darnell Wright. The 10th overall pick is their first-team right tackle and somebody believed to have legitimate star potential once he cleans up some pass protection issues.

“First team: Darnell Wright, Chicago Bears

Current age: 22

Wright has started 11 games at right tackle for the struggling Bears. The rookie’s tape has been hot and cold — he has allowed nine sacks — but his flashes in the run game are dominant with a win rate of 77%. That’s top-20 among all tackles. Wright has to develop, as this is his second season playing right tackle, but the traits are there for him to become a star.”

Ryan Poles deserves credit for what he’s done.

That is especially true on the offensive line. It started with plucking Braxton Jones out of the 5th round last year. He quickly developed into a legitimate starter who has played some of his best football in the past few weeks. Nate Davis is finally healthy and fitting in at right guard after the Bears signed him as a free agent. Yet the arrival of Wright seems to have brought everything together. Pass protection has improved considerably since last season, and the Bears still have one of the best rushing offenses in the league.

Wright has allowed only two sacks and no QB hits in over 200 one-on-one pass blocks. This was despite facing top NFL studs like Danielle Hunter, Aidan Hutchinson, Joey Bosa, Maxx Crosby, and others. He’s endured a real trial by fire and not backed down. It is easy to see why Ryan Poles liked him so much coming out of Tennessee. If he’s this effective as a rookie, there is no telling how much better he will get as he keeps gaining experience. It also offers hope that Poles is piecing together a roster that can compete with the NFL’s elite.

A Look At Potential Eloy Jimenez Trades

Sep 26, 2023; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago White Sox designated hitter Eloy Jimenez (74) celebrates after hitting a three-run home run against the Arizona Diamondbacks during the first inning at Guaranteed Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Kamil Krzaczynski-USA TODAY Sports

It seems that the consensus among insiders is that two notable players will likely not be on the roster to start the 2024 season. One of those is Dylan Cease, who has a plethora of suitors for a potential trade. The other player that seems to be as good as gone is Eloy Jimenez. This one may surprise Sox fans, but this may be in the team’s best interest.

Eloy has been a solid contributor for the White Sox when healthy, but that is just the point, he is rarely ever healthy. The most games he has played in a season was in 2019, his rookie year. That year he still only played 122 games. That was his best year by far.

In 2023, Eloy was a bit healthier, as he managed his second-most games played, 120. He just simply has not been as productive since his rookie year. In 2019, he hit 31 home runs and had 79 RBIs. The most in any year since then has been 18 home runs and 64 RBIs. That is not great for a guy who has so much potential.

But, despite the lower numbers, there should be a number of suitors for Eloy’s services, who is still just 27 and has up to three more years of team control.

I can see both the Marlins and Red Sox as potential landing spots for Eloy, as there have been rumors of both of those teams being interested. There were rumblings that the Brewers were interested in Eloy at the deadline, but they might be heading in a rebuild direction at this point.

Let’s take a look at what potential trades to Miami and Boston could look like.

Another Trade With Miami

Miami Receives: Eloy Jimenez

White Sox Recieve: Noble Meyer(MLB #55), Jacob Berry(MIA #4)

The Marlins would be trading out of a position of depth, that being young starting pitching. Miami made a late playoff push and they could use another middle-of-the-order bat. There aren’t that many available in free agency, so they could use some of their pitching depth to get a guy like Eloy.

Getting a guy like Meyer for the Sox would be huge, as he is Miami’s only top-100 prospect. I would imagine at this point in the offseason Eloy can get at least one top 100 guy with another solid piece on top.

Meyer was Miami’s first-round pick in the 2023 draft as a high school pitcher. He is just 18, so is far away from contributing to the big league club. This could be a reason why they would part with him, as Miami looks to enter a window of contention as soon as this season. Scouts love his fastball and slider and he can develop into a frontline starter for the White Sox to pair with Noah Schultz.

Berry was Miami’s first-round pick in 2022, but he has not lived up to his hype to this point. As a likely DH/Corner Infielder/Outfielder, he has only hit 12 home runs in 144 games to go with a .236 average and a .300 OBP. The Sox would be buying low on his potential and he could potentially turn it around with a change of scenery.

This would be a very solid return for Eloy, as he simply has not gotten the job done in Chicago. These moves would not help the Sox in 2024, but they could help them in ’25 and beyond.

A Sox Swap

Red Sox Recieve: Eloy Jimenez

White Sox Receive: Ceddanne Rafaela (MLB #72), Miguel Bleis (BOS #5)

This would be a very interesting swap. Rafaela is a major league-ready player who is just 23. He got some time up with the major league club, showing promise in just 83 at-bats. He is a potential 20 homerun hitter up the middle as he has hit 20+ home runs in the last 2 years in the minors. He can play 2B, SS, and CF. This versatility is nice, as it can move Nicky Lopez or Paul DeJong to UTL roles and you can get some upside out of the middle infield this season.

Bleis is a high-upside lottery ticket, as he is Boston’s first prospect on their list that is not in the top 100, which means he could be on the list in a year or so. He is a 19-year-old outfielder who has a good power and speed combination. He is more of a gamble than a surefire thing here, but he has the tools to become a very good major leaguer. He would be a few years away from the pros, but it is nice to stagger the talent in the farm system.

Alex Verdugo could be a target here, as there have been rumors that Boston is looking to trade him, but unless he is an add-on in the trade, I can’t imagine the Sox would want him as a main piece, as he is the same age as Eloy and will be a free agent next year. He could be a nice piece to have for the 2024 Sox, but not as a main part of an Eloy trade.

Either of these trades would be nice returns for Eloy at this point. He could get more if there is bidding for his services, but his trade value is hard to determine at this point.

Multiple NFL Scouts Say Caleb Williams Vs. Justin Fields Is No Contest

caleb williams

Two camps have formed among Chicago Bears fans. With five games left, the team is 4-8. The biggest lingering question is whether Justin Fields deserves another season as the starting quarterback. His numbers over the past five games have become less erratic. Nobody can definitively say he has turned a corner, either. This is where the debate comes in. Several fans believe this is who Fields is and he’s not likely to change even if the Bears bring in a new coaching staff. It is time to start thinking about Caleb Williams or Drake Maye in the draft. Others believe the coaches are holding Fields back.

Five games remain. There is still time for the young starter to sway people in his direction. He managed a last-second rally to beat Minnesota. It wasn’t pretty, but a win is never a bad thing. Still, he needs sharper performances than 217 yards and two 4th quarter fumbles to make a strong enough case. Meanwhile, Courtney Cronin of ESPN contacted several people around the NFL to ask about the top 2024 prospects. The answers she got were telling.

In their minds, the decision is an easy one for the Bears.

ESPN contacted eight NFL scouts and executives who said Williams is the can’t-miss prospect.

“I thought from last year’s film, he would be top 10 the day he showed up,” an AFC executive said on the condition of anonymity.

A top 10 draft pick? Or top 10 quarterback when he gets to the NFL?

“The latter,” he clarified.

“A lot of the things they’re asking Fields to do, Caleb does better,” an NFC national scout said. “This guy thrives on his ability to improv, create on his own and turn a dead play into a highlight.”

Caleb Williams is a risk but one worth taking.

While there is an obvious possibility he will flame out in the NFL, the fact so many respected NFL evaluators are going to bat for him with such passion is important to note. While it’s true he’s a bit undersized and can hold the ball at times, the kid is a playmaker. He’s accounted for 120 touchdowns over the past three seasons for two of the top programs in the country. His accuracy and improvisational skills are elite. While not great in the pocket, he has capability there as well. It isn’t crazy to think he can get better there, provided the Bears find him the right coaching.

Everything hinges on what GM Ryan Poles wants to do. He’s remained a firm supporter of Fields throughout the season. However, many of the things he wanted to see from the Bears quarterback haven’t improved. He still takes unnecessary sacks, doesn’t operate well in the 4th quarter, and hasn’t drastically improved his consistency. Next year will be the last of his rookie contract. Poles needs answers on whether to think about exercising his 5th-year option, which will be over $23 million.

It becomes easier to understand why he might prefer starting over with Caleb Williams. It gives the organization a fresh start at quarterback with four years of a cheap rookie contract to keep building the roster.