Tuesday, November 17, 2026
EDGE is live. Chicago fans can now access and explore the beta.

Dustin May’s Contract Is A Wake Up Call for All Cubs Fans

-

You probably already knew this, but if Chicago Cubs fans needed another reminder, then Dustin May’s contract with the White Sox was a wake-up call this offseason. The Cubs are expected to be active in the starting-pitching market, whether in free agency or via trades, but May’s new deal proves pitching will once again be more costly than you think.

The Cubs were among the teams in the running to sign May before the right-handed pitcher agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the White Sox, another team that needed to address its starting rotation this offseason. It’s a shocking figure at first glance, especially when you consider how poor May’s performance was with the Milwaukee Brewers following the trade deadline.

However, this is yet another example of an organization paying for potential. At 29, with only two full seasons under his belt, his potential might raise an eyebrow, but this $50 million investment in May is about unlocking his ceiling. May has a good fastball and strong underlying metrics, and the White Sox will be the fifth organization to try to put it all together.

So far, the results don’t reflect a pitcher who consistently excites a fan base, as May has posted a career 4.12 ERA over 469.2 innings. In 2026, the right-hander posted a 4.70 ERA in 31 starts; however, his 3.63 FIP suggests May can get better results. Again, the White Sox are betting on their pitching infrastructure to make the right adjustments to get the most out of May in his prime.

🔥 Subscribe to the Untold Chicago YouTube channel to hear Chicago legends tell stories you’ve never seen in headlines — real moments, real experiences, straight from the athletes themselves.

Here are the contract projections that May had prior to his deal with the White Sox.

Ben Clemens (FanGraphs): 2 Years, $30 Million
MLBTR: 2 Years, $30 Million
Kiley McDaniel (ESPN): 1 Year, $14 Million

The Athletic’s Jim Bowden reported that at least nine teams were showing serious interest in May. So, if this deal is any indication of the future free-agent market for the rest of the offseason, expect to see big totals next to pitchers you may not initially think are worth it.

Looking at this year’s free-agent class, only one clear ace stands out: Tarik Skubal. It’s still a damn shame the Cubs have pretty much told their fans they won’t be in those talks, which means aiming lower and betting on potential, just like they were willing to do with May before the White Sox got a deal done first.

Aldo Soto
Aldo Soto
With a journalism degree from Eastern Illinois University and a decade of Cubs reporting, my work has appeared on 670 The Score, ESPN 1000, and the Pinwheels and Ivy Podcast. I cover Cubs news and analysis for Sports Mockery, including roster moves, game breakdowns, and prospect development.

Chicago SportsNEWS
Recommended for you

← More Chicago Cubs News & Rumors | SportsMockery Home