The Chicago Bears have some tough decisions ahead of them this off-season. It starts with what GM Ryan Poles plans to do about David Montgomery. Barring an unexpected injury, the running back will cross the 1,000-yards-from-scrimmage mark for his fourth year in a row. If he can add another touchdown, it’ll be the fourth straight year with at least seven. That kind of consistency is hard to come by at any position. Still, it’s difficult to say whether he’s been good enough to earn a long-term extension.
Running backs have a short shelf life in the NFL. That is why paying them is difficult for teams. Some have long careers, like Frank Gore or Adrian Peterson. However, most tend to flame out by their 30th birthday. Montgomery turns 26 next year. That means he should have at least three good seasons left, presuming he stays healthy. Sharing the backfield with Khalil Herbert should ease the wear and tear. Still, throwing $8-12 million per year at him isn’t something many teams would do. Not when there are better options available. One NFL executive told Brad Biggs of the Chicago Tribune the Bears would have a chance to upgrade.
Adding any one of these names would make their offense better.
An AFC personnel evaluator listed Jacobs, Barkley and Kareem Hunt of the Cleveland Browns as the top-three pending free agents at the position. He added a caveat with Hunt, explaining some teams might not consider him because of past off-field issues. Hunt was suspended for eight games in 2019 after a disturbing video surfaced showing him attacking a woman.
Pollard has been more productive than Ezekiel Elliott this season but there are questions about whether the 6-foot, 209-pounder can handle the load of a true workhorse back.
“I like Montgomery but he’s not a breakaway speed guy,” the personnel man said. “He’s more quick than fast. I don’t think he has a ton of value on third down. He’s more of a base-down guy with a degree of third-down value.”
The Bears are in a unique spot with David Montgomery.
Unlike most NFL teams, they aren’t pressed for cap space. They should have well over $100 million available going into next March. So if GM Ryan Poles wanted to give Montgomery an extension, nobody would really blink an eye at it. He is overflowing with cash. As long as the deal isn’t north of $10 million per year, it’s a safe bet most people would accept it. The guy is a good player and terrific locker room presence. Rewarding him would go a long way toward winning over other players on the roster.
That said, what the executive brought up was accurate. Josh Jacobs and Saquon Barkley are studs. Genuine three-down threats that can win on the ground and through the air. Poles also has connections with Hunt from their time in Kansas City together. It isn’t crazy to think the Bears might move on from David Montgomery if they believe they can do better. After all, this is a run-first offense. The more they can maximize Justin Fields’ threat as a runner, the better. Answers should be forthcoming by the end of February.
Subscribe to the BFR podcast and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
Wow..first the Cubs now the Bears-we looked hapless most of the season with very few exceptions- Montgomery was 1 of what 3 players to measure up? Keep Montgomery til he’s 30-show some class! Didn’t watch one game on Tv this year.
be. monty is a way better receiver then both Jacob’s and Barkley. neither of those guys line at slot or wide but monty has. he’s also a better blocker. those guys are just name. if they so much better they’d be playing on their 5th year option next year
Pay David. He has earned it.
Montgomery is one of the best and most versatile backs in football. There is over $100m in cap space.
$8m to $10m is not oppressive. He runs well, blocks
well, catches the ball and rarely fumbles. Give him a
2 or 3 yr contract. Every year he has gotten better and
he is not yet in his prime. I can only imagine what he could do behind an improved offensive line. Save the
Cap money and use it to upgrade the O-line, but pay Montgomery.
Why would they pay for someone like Barkley when this system consistently churns out 5th round rbs that are great like the guy on our roster now Herbert. Over paying a fa rb is dumb in todays NFL