Putting a quarterback and head coach together isn’t as easy as having a genius play caller combined with an elite talent. Plenty of pairings that looked great on paper wouldn’t have bombed if that were the case. There must be a similarity of mentality between the two. They don’t necessarily have to like each other. However, they must have the same mindset when it comes to winning. That is where the Chicago Bears might be in trouble. Ben Johnson and Caleb Williams sounded like a fun pairing at first, but two games into the regular season, there are signs the two might not be as compatible as people hoped.
First is Williams’ playing style. He still operates with that backyard style of improvisation. It can be a great weapon at times. However, relying on it can often throw off an offense’s timing. Johnson was known for being meticulous in Detroit. He wants plays run a certain way. That usually doesn’t mesh well with a quarterback who likes to make things up on the fly.
Then there is the personality clash. Quarterback expert Tim Jenkins recently said Williams and Johnson remind him a lot of Russell Wilson and Sean Payton. Everybody remembers how that duo fell apart after one season in Denver. New video footage showed an example of why Williams may not be somebody Johnson likes as the season progresses.
Caleb Williams doesn’t seem to take things seriously enough.
That was a major point of contention in some recent news columns. For all his obvious talent, the quarterback didn’t seem to have that laser-focused work ethic you see in great ones. Sure, he puts in work, but doesn’t come across as obsessed with his craft. Look at guys like Brady, Brees, Mahomes, Burrow, and Allen. They’re all built that way. Johnson is also built that way as a coach. He is a perfectionist and a workaholic. Nobody puts in more hours trying to find an edge in everything he does. Try to imagine what it feels like to have a quarterback who sometimes doesn’t seem to care. Smiling on the sideline while you’re down by 17 is not a great look.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
Maybe this is an overreaction. Maybe Williams and Johnson will find common ground as the season goes on. Then again, losing has a way of driving wedges between people. It happened to Wilson and Payton. The Bears’ schedule doesn’t get any easier moving forward. They have four more NFC North games and full swings against the NFC East and AFC North. It could get really bad. Nobody should be surprised if things get frosty between those two.
Reporters make suggestions and critique players and coaches. However, it’s easy for them to play Monday morning quarterbacks and tell the players and coaches what they are doing wrong and how to fix it or replace them. Fans feel the same way but a team needs good leadership, good coaching, not MMQBs, plus cohesiveness as a team instead of coaching from reporters. Chicago in particular gets microscopic criticism from reporters and fans and it probably will continue until they have a winning season again.
Expecting hc Johnson to have everything fixed this season is like taking your car to a mechanic and expecting him to pull the engine and rebuild it and reinstall it in one day. It’s never going to happen.
@Dr. Melhus When you squander opportunities, your odds of success drop very, very quickly when you’re trying to achieve a result that’s above the expected value, as I imagine you know already. So when you say the season is 2/17 over, I say yes, exactly, that’s a huge problem. Chicago is 0-2 and, even if every game were an unconnected event (which they certainly are not), Chicago’s odds of a 10-win season has gone down by more than half. Does the first two weeks of play inspire confidence that this team will be the exception to the general rule that… Read more »
@Dr. Melhus It’s literally how every media outlet that covers the team framed the Johnson hire. It was this humongous coup that was going to turn the franchise around. We were told to be excited about his involvement in this team. We were told to be excited about this draft class because he picked the players, and we were told to believe in QB1 because Johnson fixed Jared Goff and chose to come to Chicago to coach Caleb, etc etc. I am not saying I ever agreed with those predictions; I’m merely recounting what they were. Everybody who said that… Read more »
@Barry: I suspect that most knowledgable fans here expected Johnson to coach better than Flus, but not to step in and fix everything immediately. This year is only 2/17 over for the Bears. @Krisanthony: I hear you. Oh a question. Has anyone ever seen Erik Lambert and Tyler Dunne in the same room? Just asking for a friend. @Everyone: Listen, this is a small sample. @Bears24 said it perfectly: “The back half of the season is what we’re interested in.” Repeat as needed for the next six weeks. He, I, and @Krisanthony (maybe others too) all have predicted here that… Read more »