One of the growing discussions about the Chicago Bears quarterback situation is the idea of hedging their bets. This would involve keeping Justin Fields for another year while also taking their top prospect at #1 overall. That player could sit on the bench for a season, transitioning to the NFL landscape and learning the offense. Meanwhile, the Bears could let Fields play another season to keep the locker room happy and maybe make a run at the playoffs. Then in 2025, the Bears can let Fields walk or trade him, or if he breaks through as a franchise guy, they can trade the former #1 pick for a large package.
It is an interesting idea. Teams have done it before. Cincinnati sat Carson Palmer in 2003. Sitting QBs is a proven strategy over the years. However, former Bears personnel director Josh Lucas doesn’t think that would be the best idea. It has nothing to do with whether it might be good for the drafted quarterbacks. He’s all for it. The problem is he doesn’t think Fields would be on board with it. He learned this from how the QB acted during his rookie season in 2021 with veterans Andy Dalton and Nick Foles.
Lucas explained on the Bears Banter podcast with Bill Zimmerman.
This is not a side to Justin Fields people would’ve expected.
Lucas has no reason to go on a smear campaign. That would only make the decision to draft him three years ago look worse. It is more Lucas being honest about the type of competitor Fields was. He felt there was no point in listening to Dalton or Foles because he was the best player in that quarterback room. There was nothing they could teach him. Sadly, that is a mentality several young players often have. They’re so used to being the big man on campus that listening to older guys who aren’t good enough to cut it in the league anymore is beneath them.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
Justin Fields is far from the first one to be that way. Maybe if he’d been more open-minded when he arrived, he would’ve looked better prepared when he finally did become the starter. Dalton and Foles could’ve taught him a lot. Self-confidence is great. Alas, sometimes it comes at the cost of self-awareness. Head coach Matt Nagy knew Fields wasn’t ready to start right away. That proved true after Dalton went down with a knee injury. Maybe things would be different now if he’d sat the whole year and been more open to tips from guys who’d played at a high level in the NFL.
Or, Lucas could be dribbling out these bits and pieces about Fields in order to stay relevant on social media, keep his name out there in NFL circles, and try to explain why JF1 didn’t succeed here and make it seem less like a failure of the regime he was part of.
The point is – we don’t know. And we can’t know.
You, me and half-the-world have said stuff in a stressful moment that could have been used in a piece like this. One bad day telling someone he’d had enough of being treated like he didn’t know anything. The next day, he could have apologized and all was forgiven. Like someone said before Dalton said several times that he was happy with the way JF1 listened and asked questions. Nice try for all of you who like to create massive sandcastles out of a bucket of sand. Too many chefs spoil the soup. They had three strong-willed athletes in camp. Would… Read more »
Does anyone else smell a rat? Three years have passed and all of a sudden an “insider” “former executive” “fired former executive” has to wrestle with his conscience and let the world know the reason Justin Fields was a failure was because they did a shitty job of vetting him before picking him OR JF worked hard as we’ve seen and they created that mess by CYA. Let’s create the most toxic environment possible, I know we can do it. Three years and I never heard this. Someone paid handsomely to get that. Maybe it’s a ploy to make sure… Read more »
When Execs, coaches and former Bears Admin and staff start bad mouthing players, effectively burning bridges, they’re usually getting ready to move the guy.
So, any predictions on what day and what team the Bears trade Justin to?
Let’s see who gets it right or closest…
I’ll say Atlanta makes a deal on March 22nd to get Fields. That’s a week after free agency.
Hey Erik,
You stated, “Self-confidence is great. Alas, sometimes it comes at the cost of self-awareness.”
Truer words never appeared in your articles.
Unfortunately, Halas Hall seems to be a place, brimming with unbreakable, unearned, self-confidence.
Wins and losses tell us all we need to know.