Every August, football fans and media alike get wrapped up in preseason drama, breathlessly dissecting quarterback play and screaming into the void about who’s destined for greatness and who’s trash. Let’s set the record straight right now: preseason quarterback performances mean about as much as your buddy’s promise to stop playing fantasy football after a bad season. Nada. Zilch. Jack shit.
Why Preseason QB Numbers Don’t Mean a Damn Thing
Look, numbers never lie — except when they’re preseason stats. According to FiveThirtyEight and extensive NFL statistical analysis, there’s practically no correlation (literally a paltry 0.072 correlation coefficient) between preseason quarterback performance and regular-season success. It’s the equivalent of predicting the weather by flipping a coin — you might feel smart occasionally, but mostly you’re just guessing.
And why is that? Because preseason football isn’t real football. Coaches roll out vanilla playbooks, starters barely break a sweat, and defenses play softer than a cover-2 run by your grandpa. Quarterbacks usually get a handful of series at most, and half the time they’re throwing to guys who’ll be delivering your DoorDash in September. Defensive complexity is dialed down, and risk-taking is minimized. Bottom line: it’s a glorified scrimmage.
Preseason Losers Who Became Regular Season Ballers
Still unconvinced? Let’s revisit some recent history.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
C.J. Stroud (2023) was a dumpster fire in the preseason, barely completing 11 of 18 passes for a measly 89 yards and an ugly interception. Fans called him a bust before Week 1. Fast-forward four months: Stroud lit up the league for over 4,100 yards and 23 touchdowns, walking away as NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.
Remember Patrick Mahomes (2018)? He threw more interceptions in training camp than a drunk uncle at Thanksgiving tosses insults. The narrative then: Chiefs fans bracing for heartbreak. Reality: Mahomes dropped 50 touchdowns and casually snagged league MVP honors. Moral of the story: stop overreacting in August.
Even Michael Vick (2010) looked washed in preseason before putting together arguably the best season of his career. And Josh Allen (2018)? He got mauled by preseason defenses, looking more like an insurance salesman than a future Pro Bowler. Fast-forward a couple of years and he’s bullying defenses for a living.
So, What the Hell Do We Do with Caleb Williams This Preseason?
Caleb Williams is the latest golden-boy rookie QB entering the preseason hype machine. He’s already labeled the franchise savior, the heir apparent, and every other cliché fans slap onto talented rookies. But here’s your preseason survival guide for Caleb Williams: ignore the noise.
Williams’ skill set is obvious — big arm, athleticism, poise — but preseason isn’t going to prove jack about his NFL readiness. If he throws four touchdowns in August, chill. If he throws four picks, chill even harder. What matters is how he handles NFL complexity when defenses start disguising coverages, blitz packages get exotic, and every snap truly matters.
Fans should instead watch how Williams processes decisions under pressure. Is he decisive, poised, and in control of the huddle? Does he quickly bounce back from mistakes? Those traits matter infinitely more than his completion percentage against second-string scrubs.
Veterans Aren’t Immune from the Preseason Panic Either
You’d think NFL fans would learn from decades of preseason hysteria, but nope — every year, established stars like Aaron Rodgers and even Tom Brady were thrown under the bus after shaky August performances.
Rodgers, recently in Pittsburgh camp, reportedly struggled with deep-ball accuracy. Cue panic from Steelers fans, claiming he lost his touch. But Rodgers has done this dance before, struggling early only to dominate when games count. Remember, he’s Aaron Freaking Rodgers, not some rookie trying to make the practice squad.
Even Brady wasn’t immune, famously taking “nasty hits” and raising injury red flags in preseason action. Spoiler alert: Brady played another decade and hoisted more Lombardis. Veteran QBs know preseason’s a tune-up, not a performance review.
How Preseason Truly Matters (Hint: It Barely Does)
Sure, there are a few exceptions. Russell Wilson parlayed an electric 2012 preseason into a stellar rookie campaign. But he’s the outlier. The vast majority of preseason studs are forgotten quicker than your buddy’s promise not to draft another kicker in the eighth round.
NFL coaches and GMs already know this. They evaluate preseason with the cold detachment of a Vegas oddsmaker. They’re looking at mechanics, footwork, and mental processing — not QB ratings or yards per attempt. They want to know how their QBs adapt, lead, and make smart choices. Everything else is for fans desperate for football.
Final Verdict
So, as Caleb Williams suits up this August, just remember: preseason games are glorified practices that networks monetize because they know you’re football-starved. Don’t overreact to highlights or Twitter meltdowns. Focus on the process, the decision-making, and the intangibles.
If Caleb Williams struggles, shrug it off and crack open another beer. If he dominates, enjoy the highlights but don’t book those playoff tickets just yet.
Preseason football is a mirage — enticing, deceptive, and ultimately meaningless. The real test begins in September when the games count, defenses bite back, and quarterbacks earn their paycheck. Until then, save your hot takes. Your sanity — and your reputation — will thank you.
