Few wanted the narrative to surface. Sadly, it’s out there and isn’t likely to go away. Justin Fields was the best offensive player the Chicago Bears had in 2022. Nobody can argue that. He accounted for over 3400 yards of total offense and 25 touchdowns. Given the weak supporting cast, one would think that he’s done enough to earn another year on the job. However, circumstances make that decision complicated. Some feel the Bears possessing the #1 overall pick gives them an ultra-rare opportunity to find a true franchise quarterback.
Former Jets and Dolphins GM Mike Tannenbaum is already on record saying Ryan Poles should trade Fields and use the pick on his quarterback of choice. Opportunities like this don’t come around often. Tannenbaum felt like a man alone in that assessment. Not anymore. Another former executive supported the idea. Joe Banner spent two decades working in the front offices of Philadelphia, Cleveland, and Atlanta. He’s seen what franchise QBs look like, from Donovan McNabb to Matt Ryan. He explained on The 33rd Team why the Bears must make a change.
His argument follows the same beats as Tannenbaum’s.
“Why? Simple. I like to play the odds. I don’t like swimming upstream. And the odds tell me that a difference-making quarterback changes everything. At the very least, he guarantees you’re good and gives you the opportunity to be great.
Which is where Fields comes in. I don’t see him as having the ability to be a great quarterback.
When you watched him this season, what do you remember? A lot of spectacular runs, right? But he wasn’t an accurate passer. There were four games where he completed 50 percent or fewer of his attempts. Nor was he productive with his arm. He had 17 TD passes, never threw for 300 yards, 12 times threw for under 200 and had 75 in his last start.
Granted, he wasn’t surrounded by an abundance of talent, but I look at him and see limitations.”
Justin Fields did show signs of improvement.
What Banner says is harsh. Still, the facts are undeniable. Fields averaged 149.46 yards passing per game in 2022. The only other player remotely close to that is Brock Purdy at 152.7, and he’s a third-string backup. Everybody who started at least 15 games this season averaged at least 200 yards or more. Yes, Fields made up for that with the second-most rushing yards in a season in NFL history. Even so, everybody knows that kind of quarterbacking doesn’t win in the playoffs. Lamar Jackson and Michael Vick are living proof. Vick was 2-3 in the postseason. Jackson is 1-3. To reach a Super Bowl, you must be able to throw the football.
The pressing question is this. Is Poles confident a strong supporting cast can unlock Justin Fields as a passer? He did show flashes of progress down the stretch. His processing improved. The accuracy was there. Maybe better protection and receivers that can get open consistently allow him to thrive. Banner doesn’t see that happening. Fields has had two years to show he’s capable of being something special. There hasn’t been enough evidence. Chicago needs to hit the reset button while the opportunity is there.
Subscribe to the BFR podcast and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
We’ll soon find out whether Poles agrees or not.
Former executive should tell you already his opinion is worthless or else he would still have a job somewhere
What makes everyone so sure Young will even be a NFL Quarterback? many have done well on the colledge level and fell on the face in the NFL.Fields deserves another full season with abetter team around him.Just don’t get it? The man runs like a deer,has the heart of a Lion,Get him some help and this team will shine!!Yes he ran alot this past year,he was also running for his life?Fix the O line,Trade smart,Ya’ll knew this was a rebuilding year,and yet your looking at Fields trying to blame him? really sit down and look at this past year.for a… Read more »
The Bears should trade their no. 1 pick because probably none of the top quarterbacks are likely to become NFL stars, but some teams may be desperate enough to move up to get one and the Bears need all the good players they can get because they don’t have many good ones now.. I don’t think Fields is the long-term answer either. He and the Bears have done their best to hide his passing problems by running, but that’s what running backs, are for. They are usually faster than him and less worried about injury so they can struggle for… Read more »
The 2023 Justin Fields discourse is the recycled 2022 Jalen Hurts discourse which was the same as the 2021 Lamar Jackson discourse which was really just the 2020 Josh Allen discourse which sounded a lot like the 2018 Deshaun Watson discourse.
Trading Fields would be the 2023 version of the Cubs trading Lou Brock.